Back to Nevada Unemployment

Alice Pierce

How to appeal DETR unemployment overpayment furlough mutual agreement - my situation

So I'm about six weeks into this whole mess and just got a letter in the mail yesterday that completely blindsided me. Nevada DETR is saying I owe back $4,100 in unemployment benefits from when I was furloughed earlier this year. The thing is, my furlough was a mutual agreement situation - my employer and I both signed paperwork saying it was a temporary layoff with the expectation I'd return. I filed for UI benefits during that period because I genuinely had no income coming in and my employer told me to. Now DETR is saying I wasn't actually separated from work in a way that qualifies and they want their money back. I don't even fully understand what I did wrong here. I reported everything honestly - my furlough start date, the fact that I expected to return, all of it. How does someone even start to appeal this? Do I have to pay the money while the appeal is processing or can I hold off? Any guidance would be really appreciated because I'm honestly kind of panicking right now.

Week two of my own overpayment fight here, so I feel this post in my bones. The mutual agreement furlough situation is actually a really specific kind of case and you have more ground to stand on than you might think. The key thing DETR is probably tripping over is whether your separation was considered 'voluntary' because you agreed to it. But a mutual agreement furlough where you had no real choice - like it was either agree or lose the job entirely - is very different from voluntarily quitting. You need to get your appeal in writing within 11 calendar days of the date on that overpayment notice. That date matters more than when you actually received the letter, so look at the notice date carefully. Send your appeal to the address on the notice itself, not just any DETR address.

0 coins

Eleven days sounds really short - does that clock start from when they mailed it or when it's dated at the top of the letter? Because mail takes like 3-4 days sometimes and that could eat up almost half your window right there.

0 coins

The postmark or date on the letter itself is what starts the clock unfortunately. So yes, if they mailed it on a Monday and you got it Thursday, you've already burned four days. This is why opening any DETR mail the day it arrives is so important - I learned that the hard way with a different issue last year.

0 coins

I went through a furlough overpayment appeal last spring and the timeline stress is real. File the appeal first with whatever information you have - you can add documentation later. Getting the appeal in before that window closes is the only thing that matters in those first days.

0 coins

Three months into my adjudication nightmare and just now getting to the other side of it - so I've been lurking this forum a lot. What you're describing with the mutual agreement piece is going to come down to your employer's paperwork more than anything. When you go into your appeal, you want to get a written statement from your employer confirming that the furlough was employer-initiated and that returning was contingent on business conditions, not your personal choice. That document alone can flip how DETR characterizes your separation. Also dig up any emails or texts from your employer directing you to file for UI during the furlough period. Those are gold.

0 coins

My employer actually sent us all an email saying to file for unemployment during the furlough - is that the kind of thing you mean? I saved it but wasn't sure if it mattered.

0 coins

That email is exactly what I mean and honestly that might be the most important document in your entire appeal. An employer actively directing employees to file UI shows this wasn't some gray area situation - they knew the furlough qualified and told you to file. Attach it to your appeal and reference it specifically in your written statement.

0 coins

Saving every email from an employer during a furlough is so underrated. I didn't do that during mine and had to reconstruct a whole timeline from memory which the appeals referee definitely noticed.

0 coins

Just got my overpayment appeal decision back last week - finally - and wanted to share what helped me actually reach a human at DETR during the process. I was going in circles for weeks trying to get through on the phone to ask a specific question about whether my appeal was received. Someone on another thread mentioned Claimyr and I tried it. You go to claimyr.com, there's a video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY that shows exactly how it works. Basically it handles the hold time and connects you when an agent is available. Got through to someone who confirmed my appeal was in the system and actually told me what documents they still needed. For an overpayment appeal situation where timing is everything, being able to actually talk to someone made a real difference.

0 coins

How long did it take before you actually got connected to someone through that? I've been calling the main DETR line and getting disconnected after 45 minutes on hold.

0 coins

Honestly way faster than I expected given how brutal the regular phone line is. The main thing for me was that I didn't have to sit there with the phone glued to my ear - it called me back when someone was available. For an overpayment appeal specifically it was worth it just to confirm my paperwork landed correctly.

0 coins

I've been afraid to call DETR at all after getting disconnected four times in a row. Good to know there's something that actually helps with that.

0 coins

Somewhere around day 30 of waiting for my adjudication result when I stumbled on this forum and it's been a lifesaver. The furlough-as-mutual-agreement thing is legitimately complicated and I want to add something nobody's mentioned yet - DETR distinguishes between a furlough where both parties agreed because the employer needed to cut costs temporarily versus one where the employee had a real say in whether it happened at all. If you had no meaningful choice but to agree, that's not really 'mutual' in the legal sense DETR uses. Your appeal should address that head-on. Write a paragraph explaining the circumstances of that agreement - who initiated the conversation, what alternatives were presented to you (if any), and what would have happened if you had refused.

0 coins

What counts as 'no meaningful choice' though? Like is it enough to say I would have been let go anyway or do you have to prove that somehow?

0 coins

You can't always prove it with a document but you can make the case in your written statement. If your employer said something like 'we're doing furloughs and we need everyone to sign' versus 'do you want to take a furlough or stay on reduced hours,' those are very different situations. The more you can describe the specific conversation and the lack of real alternatives, the stronger your position.

0 coins

My appeal referee specifically asked me about this - whether I felt I had a genuine option to decline the furlough. The way you describe the conversation when it was offered to you matters a lot in the hearing.

0 coins

Got my overpayment notice exactly four weeks before you posted this and I'm deep in the appeal process right now. One thing I haven't seen mentioned - when you file your appeal, explicitly request a hearing. Some people just submit their documents and hope for a paper review, but requesting an in-person or phone hearing gives you a chance to explain the nuance of a mutual agreement furlough that just doesn't come across in paperwork. The appeals referee can ask clarifying questions and you can answer them in real time. For complicated cases like yours this matters a lot.

0 coins

Do most people request the hearing or just go with the document review? I'm kind of nervous about having to explain everything live.

0 coins

Honestly most people go with documents only and I think that's a mistake for cases like yours. A furlough where both parties signed something looks ambiguous on paper. In a hearing you can explain the whole context - your industry, what your employer said, why you had no real alternative. The referee can ask you to clarify things in ways that actually help your case.

0 coins

The hearing is intimidating but it's not like a court. The referee is just trying to understand what happened. I did mine over the phone and it was actually pretty low-pressure compared to what I expected.

0 coins

Is there a deadline for requesting the hearing or can you add that request after you've already submitted your initial appeal?

0 coins

About two weeks after my employer-initiated furlough ended and I got hit with an overpayment notice too - different circumstances but similar enough that I've been following this thread. Something that helped me understand my situation was actually pulling up Nevada's UI statute on what counts as a disqualifying separation versus a qualifying one. The furlough itself isn't the issue - it's how DETR classified your separation at the initial determination. If they're calling it a voluntary quit now when they originally approved you, that's a different situation than if they're saying you never qualified in the first place. Do you know which one your overpayment notice is actually claiming?

0 coins

The letter says something about 'benefits paid for weeks not covered under qualifying separation' - does that tell you which category it is?

0 coins

That phrasing suggests they're challenging whether your separation type qualified at all, not necessarily calling it a voluntary quit. That's actually useful to know going into your appeal because you can focus on proving the furlough was employer-driven rather than getting into the voluntariness question. Your employer's documentation about initiating the furlough is your most important evidence in that case.

0 coins

Spent week eight of my claim on the phone trying to understand my own adjudication when I figured out the trick about DETR's appeals unit specifically. They have a separate phone queue from general claims and the hold times are different. If you call in the first 20 minutes they open (8am sharp) and dial through directly to appeals, you get through faster than calling the general line. This helped me get confirmation that my appeal was received without waiting three weeks for a written acknowledgment.

0 coins

What number specifically gets you to the appeals unit? I've only ever called the main UI line and it always dumps me into the general queue.

0 coins

It's still the main DETR number but when you get through the automated menu there's usually an option specifically for 'appeals and overpayment hearings' - listen carefully because it's not the first option. A lot of people hit 1 for claims status and end up in the wrong queue.

0 coins

The 8am tip is real - I tried Claimyr for a couple of my calls during my adjudication and it worked well, but I also noticed that when I did get through on my own it was always early morning. The queue fills up incredibly fast after about 8:30. For overpayment appeals specifically, being able to actually confirm receipt of paperwork with a live person gave me so much more peace of mind than waiting for a letter back.

0 coins

I had no idea there was a specific appeals queue - I've been calling general claims and getting nowhere for two weeks.

0 coins

Got hit with my notice at the end of my second furlough week back in March - yes I went through two furloughs with the same employer - and the mutual agreement framing was central to both my cases. Here's something that took me too long to figure out: the written appeal itself should not just be a complaint that the decision is wrong. It should read like you're telling a story with a beginning, middle, and end. Start with when the furlough was offered, describe exactly how that conversation went, then explain your actions during the furlough and why you believed you qualified. DETR referees review a lot of appeals and a clear narrative is much easier to rule in favor of than a list of objections.

0 coins

How long should the written appeal statement actually be? I keep starting and stopping because I don't know if I'm including too much or too little.

0 coins

Mine ended up being about two pages for a pretty complicated situation. Clear paragraphs covering each key moment - furlough offer, your response, your understanding of the situation, your actions in filing. Don't pad it with emotions or grievances about the system. Just tell what happened factually and let the facts make your case.

0 coins

Two pages sounds right based on what I've seen. I want to add - when I was trying to reach DETR to ask about formatting requirements for my appeal documents, I ended up using Claimyr because I'd been getting disconnected all week. The agent I spoke to was actually helpful about what format they prefer for written statements and confirmed they accept email attachments for supporting documents. Worth knowing if you want to verify that kind of detail directly rather than guessing.

0 coins

The narrative format advice is really underrated. I submitted mine as bullet points initially and my referee actually asked me to resubmit as a written statement before the hearing.

0 coins

Somewhere in week five of my own overpayment dispute, still waiting on a hearing date, but I wanted to flag something for anyone reading this thread about the 'do I have to pay while appealing' question from the original post. No - you don't have to repay the overpayment while your appeal is actively pending. The collection process is supposed to pause during the appeal period. However, if your appeal is denied and you don't further appeal, that's when repayment becomes required. DETR can arrange a repayment plan if you can't pay it all at once, so the full amount isn't necessarily due as a lump sum.

0 coins

That's genuinely one of the biggest things I was worried about - thank you. Does DETR notify you in writing that the collection is paused or do you just have to trust that it's happening?

0 coins

In my experience you don't get a specific 'collection paused' letter - it just stops. If you're worried, calling to confirm is worth doing. You can ask the agent to note in your file that you're in active appeal status so there's a record.

0 coins

This is the thing that stressed me out most when I got my notice too. The thought of owing thousands while also fighting the determination felt impossible. Good to know the process has at least that protection built in.

0 coins

About three days after getting my overpayment letter I went down a research rabbit hole and found something that I think matters for the mutual agreement furlough angle specifically. There's a difference between how DETR treats furloughs that were documented in advance with a return date versus open-ended ones. If your employer had a specific return date in the furlough paperwork - like 'you'll return on X date barring business conditions' - that actually strengthens the argument that this was a temporary employer-initiated separation rather than any kind of voluntary or indefinite arrangement. Did your original furlough agreement have a return date or was it open-ended?

0 coins

Ours had language saying 'expected return within 90 days pending operational conditions' - would that count as specific enough?

0 coins

That's actually solid language for your appeal. It shows a defined timeframe and conditional return, which is exactly what distinguishes a furlough from an indefinite layoff or a voluntary separation. Quote that exact language from the agreement in your appeal statement and attach a copy of the document.

0 coins

This detail about return dates is something I wish someone had told me when I filed my own appeal. My furlough agreement had similar language and I didn't think to include it. My referee actually asked me about it during the hearing and I had to scramble to find the document.

0 coins

I'm in week one of trying to understand my options after getting a determination I disagree with - not an overpayment exactly but a disqualification - and I want to make sure I understand the appeals process correctly before I do anything. Is the overpayment appeal and a disqualification appeal the same process? Or are they separate systems at DETR?

0 coins

They're related but not identical. A disqualification appeal challenges whether you were eligible to receive benefits in the first place. An overpayment appeal is usually triggered after a disqualification is found and says you owe back what you received during that period. Sometimes fixing the disqualification appeal automatically resolves the overpayment issue. If you're appealing a disqualification, winning that appeal can wipe out the overpayment too.

0 coins

So if I appeal the disqualification and win, I might not even have an overpayment anymore? That changes my whole approach to this.

0 coins

Exactly - tackle the underlying determination first. The overpayment is essentially a consequence of the disqualification. Address the root cause in your appeal rather than fighting the dollar amount.

0 coins

Closing out week twelve of my UI journey - finally got my overpayment appeal resolved in my favor last Thursday. Looking back at the whole process, I want to share what I think actually made the difference. For anyone still trying to get through to DETR while dealing with an active appeal, I had good results with Claimyr at claimyr.com - there's a demo video at https://youtu.be/Mc9FNfOF_yY that explains the concept. I used it twice during my appeal process when I needed to ask about specific documents DETR was requesting. Getting live answers instead of waiting for a callback or letter sped things up considerably when I was trying to meet response deadlines.

0 coins

Congrats on the resolution - what was the actual deciding factor in your case if you don't mind sharing?

0 coins

My employer submitted a written statement confirming the furlough was initiated by them due to revenue shortfall and that all employees were asked to sign the same agreement. The referee specifically noted that in the decision. Employer documentation was everything.

0 coins

Twelve weeks sounds exhausting. I'm only three weeks in and already feeling like this will never end.

0 coins

This is genuinely encouraging to read. Feels like the system is designed to make you give up before you get to the resolution.

0 coins

Just got my hearing scheduled - finally - after submitting my appeal six weeks ago. For people newer to this thread, the wait time between filing your appeal and getting a hearing date has been running long. Mine was about five and a half weeks from submission to scheduled date. During that wait, definitely keep filing your weekly claims if you're still unemployed - stopping those while your appeal is pending is a mistake a lot of people make.

0 coins

Wait, do I still need to file weekly claims even while an overpayment appeal is in process? I kind of assumed that was separate.

0 coins

Yes, weekly claims and the overpayment appeal are completely separate processes. The weekly claim is what maintains your benefit eligibility going forward. The overpayment appeal is about past weeks. If you stop filing weeklies you could create a whole new problem on top of your existing one.

0 coins

This is such an important point that gets missed. I know two people who stopped filing weeklies during their appeal and then had to go back and explain the gap, which created additional adjudication issues.

0 coins

My situation going into this was a furlough with a mutual agreement document that my employer had drawn up themselves - not a standard DETR form. At my hearing the referee asked whether I had seen the specific furlough language before signing and whether I had any ability to negotiate the terms. Those questions caught me off guard. So if your furlough agreement was employer-drafted, be ready to explain how the signing process worked and whether you had any real input.

0 coins

Our agreement was definitely employer-drafted, it wasn't any kind of DETR form. We were basically given it and told to sign. Should I be worried that this looks like I agreed to something voluntarily?

0 coins

Not necessarily - being presented with something and told to sign it is evidence that you didn't initiate the arrangement. The key framing is that you signed because you had to, not because you wanted to take time off. Make sure your appeal statement reflects that you were presented with the furlough as a business decision already made, not as an option you chose.

0 coins

Employer-drafted agreements are actually pretty common and referees know that. What matters is the substance of the arrangement, not which party prepared the document.

0 coins

About to enter my third week of holding onto the overpayment letter while I try to figure out what to do - yes I know I should have already filed, I've been paralyzed by the whole thing. Reading this thread is helping me get unstuck. Question for anyone who's been through this: does the quality of your written appeal statement matter more than the documentation you attach, or is it the other way around?

0 coins

They work together but honestly the documentation is what a referee can point to in the written decision. A great statement with no documentation is a lot weaker than a solid statement supported by an employer letter, the original furlough agreement, and any emails directing you to file. Lead with the narrative but back every claim with a document.

0 coins

If I had to rank them - documentation first, then statement. The statement frames what the documents mean. Without the frame the documents are just papers. Without the documents the frame has nothing to hold.

0 coins

This is really helpful - I've been so focused on what to write that I haven't even started collecting the actual documents. Reversing my approach now.

0 coins

Wrapping up week nine with an appeal decision finally in hand - mine was denied on the first round but I'm going to the Board of Review next. The thing nobody tells you is there's a second level of appeal beyond the initial hearing. If your first appeal doesn't go your way, you have 11 days from that decision to request Board of Review review. So losing round one isn't necessarily the end. Knowing this earlier would have saved me a lot of despair during those weeks of waiting.

0 coins

Is the Board of Review appeal much harder than the first level hearing, or is it basically the same kind of process?

0 coins

It's more of a document review than a live hearing at the Board of Review level. They look at the record from your first hearing - the transcript, the evidence, the decision - and determine if the referee made a legal or factual error. You're not usually presenting new evidence at that stage, so winning your first hearing is still the main goal.

0 coins

The Board of Review step is real and I'm glad you mentioned it. Most people think the first hearing is their only shot and give up if it goes against them.

0 coins

Eleven days at the Board of Review level too? The 11-day deadline keeps coming up - that number is clearly really important throughout this whole process.

0 coins

In the middle of month two of my claim and wanted to come back to the original question about whether the furlough-as-mutual-agreement situation is a winnable case. Based on what I've seen in this forum and in my own experience: yes, it is, but only if you document the employer-initiated nature carefully. The cases where people lose these appeals almost always involve situations where they couldn't demonstrate that the employer made the decision and the employee had no real alternative. If you have paperwork showing employer initiation and especially any communication directing employees to file UI, your odds are genuinely good.

0 coins

This is reassuring - I've been feeling like I already lost before even filing. The email from my employer directing us to file UI is real and I still have it. That feels more concrete than I realized.

0 coins

That email is not a small thing. Keep it front and center in your appeal. Document it, reference it in your statement, and attach it clearly labeled. That single piece of evidence shows your employer understood the situation was UI-qualifying. It's hard to argue you weren't entitled when your employer was telling you to file.

0 coins

Just filed my appeal yesterday after sitting on the overpayment notice for eight days - cut it close, I know. For anyone who hasn't filed yet: the appeal form itself is simpler than you might expect. It's basically a statement saying you disagree with the determination and why. You don't need to submit your full case in the initial appeal - just get that appeal on record before the deadline and then build your documentation for the actual hearing. The appeal form and the hearing are two separate steps.

0 coins

Wait, so you can file the appeal now and then submit all the documentation separately before the hearing? I didn't realize you could split those two parts.

0 coins

Yes, the appeal establishes that you're contesting the decision. After it's filed, DETR schedules a hearing and gives you a date. You have time between filing and the hearing date to gather and submit documentation. For complicated cases like a mutual agreement furlough dispute, this matters a lot because you may need time to get statements from your employer.

0 coins

This is accurate. I filed my appeal with just a one-paragraph statement saying I disagreed with the overpayment determination and why. The detailed documentation came later. Getting the appeal in on time was the only critical step in those first days.

0 coins

Filing with minimal info now and building the case later sounds much less overwhelming than trying to put together a perfect appeal in 11 days.

0 coins

Nevada Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure