< Back to IRS

Mila Walker

How can I stop my parents from claiming me as a dependent on their taxes?

I'm in a bit of a tax mess right now and could use some advice. I'm 24, a full-time college student, and I work about 30 hours weekly at my regular job. The issue started when I sent my 1098-T forms from my university to my mom (who does pay for my tuition) instead of my dad (who I'm currently living with). Now my dad wants to claim me as a dependent on his taxes. Here's my situation: I pay my dad $175 cash every week for rent (no receipts unfortunately), I buy all my own groceries, pay my own car insurance, and pretty much cover all my personal expenses. My bank statements show my grocery purchases and insurance payments. I'm pretty sure my parents don't provide over half of my support, except for my mom paying tuition. I honestly don't think either of them should be claiming me as a dependent at this point. Is there anything I can do to prevent this? Do I have any options since I can't exactly prove the cash rent payments? I'm filing my own taxes and want to do this correctly.

You're right to be concerned about this situation. The key factor here isn't where you live, but rather who provides more than half of your support throughout the year. This is called the "support test" for dependency. Since you're a full-time student under 24, you could potentially qualify as a dependent, but only if someone else provides more than half your total support. Support includes housing, food, clothing, education, medical expenses, transportation, and other necessities. My suggestion would be to create a "support worksheet" listing all your annual expenses and who pays for what. Include estimated values for rent ($175 × 52 weeks = $9,100/year), all groceries, utilities, tuition, books, car expenses, insurance, clothing, etc. This will give you a clear picture of whether you truly provide more than half your own support. Going forward, I'd recommend paying rent with something traceable - Venmo, check, or bank transfer - anything that creates a record. Even a simple signed receipt each month would help. If you find you provide more than half your support, you should file your return claiming yourself. The IRS may flag the duplicate claim, and both returns may be audited, but your worksheet will help support your position.

0 coins

What happens if both returns get flagged? Will the IRS automatically side with the parents since I can't prove the cash payments? And does my mom paying tuition automatically make me her dependent even if I pay for everything else?

0 coins

If both returns get flagged, the IRS will likely send notices to all parties asking for documentation to support the dependency claim. They don't automatically side with anyone - they follow the evidence. While you can't prove past cash payments, your bank statements showing regular cash withdrawals that align with rent amounts could be supportive evidence, along with your comprehensive support worksheet. Your mom paying tuition doesn't automatically make you her dependent. Tuition is just one factor in the total support calculation. If your combined personal expenses (rent, food, transportation, etc.) exceed the tuition amount, and you're paying those expenses yourself, you might still provide more than half of your own support. Remember that scholarships and grants don't count as support provided by either you or your parents.

0 coins

I was in a similar situation last year with my complicated family tax situation. I found this site called taxr.ai (https://taxr.ai) that really helped me figure out my dependency status. They analyzed my specific situation and helped me understand exactly who could claim me based on the IRS rules. You upload your documents and they break down all the support tests and requirements. In my case, they showed me that even though I lived with my dad, my mom couldn't claim me because I provided more than half my support overall. The dependency rules are really specific and the support test calculations can get confusing. What I liked is they gave me a detailed report I could use if the IRS ever questioned my filing status. That gave me peace of mind to confidently file my own return.

0 coins

How long did it take to get your results back? I'm kinda in a rush since the filing deadline is coming up soon. Also, do they help with the support worksheet the other commenter mentioned?

0 coins

Sounds interesting but did you actually have to prove anything to the IRS? My concern is how much this would actually help if there's an audit since OP doesn't have receipts for rent payments.

0 coins

I got my results pretty quickly - I think it was within 24 hours after I uploaded everything. They definitely helped with the support worksheet - that was actually the most valuable part. They have a section where you can input all your expenses and who paid for what, and it calculates whether you meet the support test. I didn't end up having to prove anything to the IRS because my parents decided not to claim me once they saw the detailed analysis. But the report they provided would have been good documentation if I needed it. For your rent payment situation, they suggested documenting everything going forward, but they also showed how bank withdrawals matching your rent amount could be used as supporting evidence.

0 coins

Just wanted to update that I ended up using taxr.ai after posting my question here. It was extremely helpful for my situation! The site helped me calculate that I actually provide about 68% of my own support when I included everything (even with my mom paying tuition). The detailed support worksheet was exactly what I needed. It showed that my rent, groceries, car expenses, and other costs I pay myself add up to way more than what my parents contribute. I was able to use this to talk to my parents with actual numbers rather than just arguing about it. My dad was still skeptical but changed his mind when I showed him the IRS guidelines the site provided. Now I'm filing my own return and claiming my education credits myself! They also gave me tips on how to document everything better for next year so I won't have this problem again.

0 coins

My sister went through something similar with our parents. We couldn't reach anyone at the IRS for weeks to get clarification. Then she found this service called Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) that got her through to an actual IRS agent in under 20 minutes. They have this demo video that explains how it works: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c The IRS agent was able to explain exactly what documentation she needed to prove she was providing her own support and couldn't be claimed as a dependent. It saved her from making a costly mistake on her taxes. The agent even sent her an official document explaining the support test that she could show our parents. Before that, she was on hold for literally hours trying to reach someone at the IRS directly. This service basically holds your place in line and calls you when an agent is about to answer.

0 coins

Wait, so they just wait on hold for you? How does that actually work? Seems too good to be true with how impossible it is to reach the IRS.

0 coins

I'm pretty skeptical about this. The IRS phone system is notoriously bad. How is some service going to magically get through when millions of people can't? And would they even have answers about this specific dependency situation?

0 coins

They use an automated system that basically waits on hold for you, and then calls you when an IRS agent picks up. So you don't have to sit there listening to hold music for hours. It's not about "magically" getting through - they're just waiting in the queue like everyone else, but you don't have to waste your day doing it. Regarding the dependency situation, yes, IRS agents are specifically trained to answer these types of questions. My sister spoke to someone in the Individual Taxpayer Advisory department who specializes in filing status and dependency issues. The agent walked her through all the tests for qualifying as a dependent and explained exactly what documentation would be needed if there was ever a dispute.

0 coins

I have to admit I was completely wrong about Claimyr. After posting my skeptical comment, I decided to try it myself since I had my own tax questions that I'd been avoiding dealing with. It actually worked exactly as advertised. I got a call back in about 35 minutes, and was connected to an IRS representative who answered all my questions about dependency status. They confirmed that as a student who provides more than half of my own support, I couldn't be claimed as a dependent regardless of what my parents wanted. The agent even explained that in case of conflicting returns, the IRS would request documentation from both parties and make a determination based on the evidence. She suggested keeping a support worksheet (like others mentioned here) and said bank statements showing regular cash withdrawals would be considered supporting evidence for rent payments. Definitely worth it instead of spending half a day on hold!

0 coins

Have you considered just talking to your parents directly about this? My son and I had a similar issue last year. We sat down together, looked at the IRS rules (Publication 501 has all the tests for dependency), and worked out who could actually claim him. The support test is really what matters here. If you truly provide more than 50% of your own support, your parents CAN'T legally claim you, regardless of what they want. And if you file first claiming yourself, they'll get rejected when they try to e-file with you as a dependent. I'd suggest having a calm conversation showing them the actual numbers - how much you earn, how much you spend on yourself (including that rent), and compare it to what they provide.

0 coins

I've tried talking to them, but my dad is pretty stubborn about this. He insists that since I live in his house, he gets to claim me. My mom thinks she should get to claim me since she pays my tuition. Neither seems to understand that it's not their choice - it's based on the actual support test. I think I'll try creating that support worksheet everyone's mentioned and show them the actual numbers. How detailed does it need to be to convince the IRS if they both still try to claim me?

0 coins

Your worksheet should be as detailed as possible. List everything - monthly rent, food costs, utilities (your share), car expenses (payments, insurance, gas, maintenance), phone bill, clothing, entertainment, personal items, medical expenses, and of course, education costs including tuition, books, and supplies. For each expense, note who pays it. For shared expenses like utilities in your dad's house, make a reasonable estimate of your portion. Include your annual income from all sources so you can demonstrate what percentage of your total support you provide. If your parents still insist on claiming you after seeing the numbers, file your return first claiming yourself. The IRS might contact all of you to resolve the conflict, and having this detailed worksheet ready will put you in a much stronger position. Also, start documenting your rent payments immediately - even if it's just a signed receipt each time you pay.

0 coins

Has anyone mentioned the education credits yet? One big reason parents fight over claiming college students is because of the American Opportunity Credit or Lifetime Learning Credit. These can be worth up to $2,500 in tax benefits. If you're not claimed as a dependent, YOU can claim these credits for the tuition YOU paid. But if someone else paid your tuition (like your mom), they generally get to claim the credit even if you're not their dependent. This might be a compromise - if your mom wants the education credit for the tuition she paid, she can still get that without claiming you as a dependent. Then you can claim yourself, get your standard deduction, and potentially other credits you qualify for.

0 coins

This is actually incorrect. The education credits go to whoever claims the student as a dependent. If you claim yourself, you get the credits even if someone else paid the tuition. The IRS looks at who claims the student, not who paid.

0 coins

Actually, I need to clarify something about the education credits - there's some confusion in the thread. The education credits (American Opportunity Credit and Lifetime Learning Credit) can only be claimed by the person who claims the student as a dependent OR by the student themselves if they're not claimed as a dependent by anyone else. If your mom pays your tuition but you're not claimed as her dependent (because you provide more than half your own support), then YOU would be eligible to claim the education credits on your own return, not your mom. The IRS doesn't care who actually paid the tuition - they only care about the dependency status when determining who can claim the credits. This is actually another reason why it's important to get your dependency status correct. If you truly provide more than half your own support, you should claim yourself AND you'll be eligible for the education credits worth up to $2,500. That's a significant tax benefit that you'd lose if your parents incorrectly claim you as a dependent. I'd recommend looking at IRS Publication 970 for the specific rules on education credits, in addition to Publication 501 for dependency tests that others have mentioned.

0 coins

Thanks for that clarification - that's a really important point about the education credits! I had no idea that if I'm not claimed as a dependent, I could still get the education credits even though my mom pays tuition. That $2,500 credit would definitely make a huge difference for me. So just to make sure I understand correctly: if I can prove I provide more than half my own support (through that detailed worksheet everyone's mentioned), then I should file claiming myself AND I'd be eligible for the American Opportunity Credit? That seems like it would be worth way more than whatever tax benefit my parents would get from claiming me as a dependent. I'm definitely going to check out Publication 970 along with 501. This whole situation is way more complicated than I thought, but at least now I feel like I have a clear path forward. Create the support worksheet, document everything properly, and if the numbers show I support myself, file my own return with the education credits.

0 coins

One thing that hasn't been mentioned yet is the timing aspect of all this. Since you're working 30 hours a week and paying your own expenses, you might want to consider opening a separate checking account specifically for documenting your support payments going forward. This would create a clear paper trail for future tax years. For this year, even though you paid rent in cash, you can still build a strong case. The IRS accepts reasonable estimates backed by evidence. Your regular bank withdrawals that align with your rent payments, combined with your documented grocery purchases and insurance payments, paint a clear picture of self-support. Also, don't forget to include the fair market value of room and board when calculating total support. If your dad would charge a stranger $175/week for that room, that's legitimate support you're providing for yourself - about $9,100 annually. When you add your groceries, car expenses, insurance, and other personal costs, you'll likely find you're well over the 50% threshold for self-support. The key is being thorough and honest in your calculations. The IRS wants to see that you've made a good-faith effort to determine the correct filing status based on actual facts, not just family preferences.

0 coins

This is really helpful advice about setting up a separate checking account! I wish I had thought of that earlier in the year. The point about fair market value for room and board is especially important - I hadn't considered that the $175/week I'm paying my dad ($9,100/year) should be valued at what he'd charge anyone else for that room. When I add up my annual expenses, it's looking like: rent $9,100, groceries probably around $3,600/year, car insurance $1,200, gas and car maintenance maybe $2,000, plus personal expenses, clothing, etc. Even if my mom's tuition payment is $8,000, I'm definitely providing way more than half my total support. I'm going to start that separate checking account right away for next year. For now, I'll document everything I can find in my bank statements and create that detailed worksheet. Thanks for the tip about being thorough - I want to make sure I do this right and have solid documentation if the IRS ever questions it.

0 coins

I've been following this thread and want to add some practical advice from my experience working in tax preparation. The support test calculations can seem overwhelming, but there's a systematic way to approach this. Create a simple monthly budget tracking sheet with two columns: "I pay" and "Parents pay." Include everything - rent, utilities (your estimated share), food, transportation, insurance, medical, education, clothing, entertainment, phone, etc. Multiply by 12 for annual totals. For your situation with cash rent payments, the IRS Publication 17 specifically mentions that you can use "reasonable estimates" when exact records aren't available. Your regular ATM withdrawals that match your rent amount, combined with a simple written statement from your dad acknowledging the arrangement, would be considered reasonable documentation. One often overlooked factor: if you're paying your dad $175/week for rent, that's actually market-rate documentation that you're providing your own housing support. Most parents charging a dependent child would charge much less or nothing at all. Also, don't forget that any financial aid or scholarships you receive don't count as support from your parents - they count as support you provided for yourself. This can significantly tip the scales in your favor. The bottom line: if your calculations show you provide more than 50% of your total support, file your return claiming yourself. The education credits alone could be worth $2,500, which likely exceeds any benefit your parents would get from claiming you.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
20,087 users helped today