Do I need to fill out Form 8949 for stocks sold if basis was reported to IRS?
I'm kinda freaking out about my taxes right now. I used one of those tax software programs and when I got to the part about reporting stock sales, it gave me the option to just submit a summary instead of listing every single transaction. So I picked the summary option because who wants to enter all that info manually, right? But now after I submitted everything, the software gave me this Form 8453 and is saying I need to fill out Form 8949 to list all my individual stock transactions. I'm confused because I thought picking the "summary" option meant I wouldn't have to do this extra step? From what I read online, you don't actually need to include sales where the basis was reported to the IRS. In my situation, all my stock sales were handled by my brokerage who reported everything to the IRS. So do I really need to do anything with this Form 8949? Or can I just ignore it since everything was already reported? This is my first year with significant trading activity and I just want to make sure I'm not missing something important!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Kyle Wallace
You're in luck! If all your stock sales had their cost basis reported to the IRS by your brokerage (which is usually indicated on your 1099-B), then you generally don't need to complete Form 8949 for those transactions. When your tax software gave you Form 8453, it was likely just being overly cautious. Form 8453 is used to submit certain paper forms that can't be e-filed, but in your case, it sounds unnecessary. The summary reporting option in the software was designed precisely for situations like yours where the basis was fully reported to the IRS. However, it's important to double-check your 1099-B forms from your brokerage. Look for any transactions where Box 3 is NOT checked, as these would require Form 8949 reporting. If all transactions have Box 3 checked (indicating basis was reported), you should be fine with just the summary on Schedule D.
0 coins
Ryder Ross
•Thanks for the explanation! Just to clarify - if I have some transactions where Box 3 is checked but others where it's not checked, would I only need to report the unchecked ones on Form 8949? And should I still submit the Form 8453 in that case?
0 coins
Kyle Wallace
•Yes, you would only need to complete Form 8949 for the specific transactions where Box 3 is not checked. Those are the only ones requiring the detailed reporting. Regarding Form 8453, you typically only need to submit this if you have certain attachments that cannot be e-filed. For most taxpayers using modern tax software with reported basis transactions, this form isn't necessary. The software might be presenting it as a standard procedure, but if all your transactions had basis reported (Box 3 checked), you shouldn't need to submit additional paperwork.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
After spending hours trying to figure out how to handle my stock sales last year, I stumbled upon this amazing tool at https://taxr.ai that completely changed my tax filing experience. I was dealing with exactly your issue - confused about Form 8949 requirements and whether I needed to list every transaction or could use the summary. I uploaded my 1099-B documents to taxr.ai and it analyzed everything, clearly showing which transactions needed detailed reporting on Form 8949 and which ones could be summarized. It explained that transactions with basis reported to the IRS (typically marked in Box 3 of your 1099-B) don't need the detailed Form 8949 listing. What I really appreciated was how it explained the different categories (A, B, C, etc.) on Form 8949 and automatically sorted my transactions into the right categories. Saved me so much time compared to my previous years of manual entry!
0 coins
Henry Delgado
•Does it work with multiple brokerages? I have accounts with three different companies and they all format their 1099s differently which is driving me crazy.
0 coins
Olivia Kay
•I'm a bit skeptical about these tax tools... How does it handle wash sales? I had some that crossed between different brokerages last year and my accountant said that's something automated systems often miss.
0 coins
Gianni Serpent
•Yes, it absolutely works with multiple brokerages - that was actually one of my favorite features! It can process 1099s from virtually all major brokerages (Fidelity, Schwab, Vanguard, Robinhood, etc.) and standardizes the information regardless of how they format their documents. For wash sales across different brokerages, it has a specific feature that identifies potential wash sales by analyzing transaction dates and securities across all your uploaded documents. It flags these transactions and explains the wash sale rules, though you should still review them since some complex situations might need additional attention. The system is designed to catch these cross-brokerage issues that most basic tax software misses.
0 coins
Henry Delgado
I just wanted to update everyone here - I tried taxr.ai after seeing it recommended and I'm seriously impressed. I was dreading doing my taxes because I had over 200 stock transactions across multiple accounts this year. The tool instantly identified that most of my transactions had basis reported to the IRS and I only needed to list about 15 transactions on Form 8949 (ones from an old brokerage that didn't report basis correctly). It saved me hours of work and the anxiety of potentially making a mistake. For anyone dealing with stock sales and Form 8949 confusion, it's definitely worth checking out! The explanations about which transactions need detailed reporting versus summary reporting were super clear.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
If you're still having trouble with your Form 8949 questions, you might want to call the IRS directly for clarification. I know, I know - I used to laugh whenever someone suggested calling the IRS because it seemed IMPOSSIBLE to get through. I tried for weeks last year and kept getting disconnected or waiting for hours. Then I found this service called Claimyr (https://claimyr.com) that somehow gets you past the IRS phone queue. You can see how it works in this video: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c - basically they use some technology to hold your place in line and call you when an actual IRS agent is available to talk. I had specific questions about my Form 8949 requirements last month and was connected to an IRS rep within about 30 minutes. The agent confirmed that I didn't need to file Form 8949 for transactions where the basis was reported to the IRS and explained exactly what my obligations were. So much better than guessing or stressing about doing it wrong!
0 coins
Jibriel Kohn
•How does this actually work? Seems kinda sketchy that they can somehow jump ahead in the IRS phone queue when the rest of us have to wait for hours...
0 coins
Edison Estevez
•Yeah right. I've heard about these "get through to the IRS" services before and they never work. Last time I called the IRS I was on hold for 3+ hours and then got disconnected. You're telling me this magically solves that problem? I'll believe it when I see it.
0 coins
Joshua Hellan
•It doesn't jump ahead in the queue - it just holds your place in line automatically. The way it works is they use a system that calls the IRS and navigates through all those annoying automated menus, then stays on hold so you don't have to. When an actual human IRS agent picks up, that's when they call you and connect the call. You still "wait" the same amount of time, but you don't have to sit there with a phone to your ear the whole time. I was skeptical too, trust me. I've been disconnected by the IRS phone system more times than I can count. But this actually worked for me - I was able to make lunch, do some work, and then got a call when an agent was available. The IRS person I spoke with gave me the exact guidance I needed about my Form 8949 question, which saved me from potentially filing incorrectly.
0 coins
Edison Estevez
I have to eat my words. After my skeptical comment yesterday, I decided to try Claimyr out of desperation because I had the exact same Form 8949 question and couldn't find a clear answer online. I figured it wouldn't work, but it actually did! Got a call back in about 45 minutes, talked to an actual IRS agent who confirmed that transactions with basis reported to the IRS (Box 3 checked on 1099-B) don't need to be itemized on Form 8949. For my situation, I could just use the summary totals on Schedule D. The agent also explained that Form 8453 is only needed in specific situations when you have attachments that can't be e-filed, which wasn't the case for me. Sorry for being so negative before - this service actually solved my problem when I was ready to give up.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
Looks like everyone covered the Form 8949 question pretty well, but I wanted to add a tip: even though you don't technically need to fill out Form 8949 for basis-reported transactions, I still keep a spreadsheet of all my trades for my own records. Last year I got an IRS letter questioning some of my capital gains, and having that detailed record made it super easy to respond and clear things up. The IRS doesn't always correctly match all the information from your brokerages, especially if you have multiple accounts.
0 coins
James Johnson
•How do you organize your spreadsheet? I've been trying to create something similar but I'm not sure what columns/info I should be tracking for tax purposes.
0 coins
Emily Nguyen-Smith
•I keep it pretty simple but effective. My main columns are: Date Acquired, Date Sold, Stock Name/Symbol, Number of Shares, Purchase Price (per share), Sale Price (per share), Total Cost Basis, Total Proceeds, and Gain/Loss. I also have a column for notes where I mark things like wash sales or special situations. For stocks held in multiple lots with different purchase dates, I track each lot separately. I organize them by short-term and long-term sections, which makes it easier to check against the totals on my 1099-B forms at tax time.
0 coins
Sophia Rodriguez
I'm SO confused by all this tax stuff. My H&R Block software says I need Form 8949 but my friend who uses TurboTax said she didn't have to fill it out at all??? We both have stocks with Fidelity. Does it depend on which tax software you use????
0 coins
Mia Green
•Different tax software might present things differently, but the actual IRS requirements are the same regardless of which program you use. Check your 1099-B from Fidelity - if Box 3 is checked for all your transactions (meaning basis was reported to IRS), then technically you don't need to list each transaction on Form 8949. Some tax software might still ask you to enter all transactions individually while others offer a summary option. Either way, the end result should be similar - transactions with reported basis can be summarized on Schedule D instead of being itemized on Form 8949.
0 coins
Luca Romano
I went through this exact same situation last year and it was so stressful! The key thing to understand is that when your brokerage reports the cost basis to the IRS (which shows up as Box 3 being checked on your 1099-B), you generally don't need to fill out Form 8949 for those specific transactions. However, I'd recommend double-checking a few things: First, look at ALL your 1099-B forms and make sure Box 3 is checked for every single transaction. If even one transaction has Box 3 unchecked, you'll need Form 8949 for that one. Second, if you had any wash sales or made any adjustments to the cost basis that your brokerage didn't account for, you might still need Form 8949. The Form 8453 your software generated might just be a precautionary measure. Most modern tax software is pretty good about only requiring it when you actually have forms that can't be e-filed. Since you used the summary option and everything was reported by your brokerage, you're probably fine without it. One last tip - keep all your brokerage statements and 1099-B forms for your records, even if you don't need to submit detailed forms. The IRS occasionally sends notices asking for clarification on capital gains, and having those documents makes responding much easier!
0 coins