Confused about long term collectible tax rates for gold and silver - need clarification!
Title: Confused about long term collectible tax rates for gold and silver - need clarification! 1 I'm getting totally different answers everywhere I look about how long term collectible tax rates work for precious metals like gold and silver. I know regular long term capital gains taxes fall into those 3 brackets (0%, 15%, and 20% depending on income), but what about collectibles? Is the 28% collectible tax rate completely separate from those normal capital gains categories, or does it just replace the 20% bracket when you're dealing with collectibles? Everyone keeps saying "up to 28%" which is super confusing - does that mean there are still different brackets for collectibles based on income? Or is it always a flat 28% no matter what? I've been investing in some gold and silver coins over the past few years and need to figure out what I'm looking at tax-wise if I sell some of them. If any CPAs or people who've actually dealt with this on their taxes could weigh in, that would be amazing. Thanks in advance!
19 comments
Join the conversation
Gemma Andrews
7 The collectible tax rate is a bit confusing but I can help clarify. For long-term capital gains on collectibles (including precious metals like gold and silver), the maximum tax rate is indeed 28%. This doesn't simply replace the 20% bracket in regular capital gains. The phrase "up to 28%" means the rate depends on your ordinary income tax bracket. If your ordinary income tax rate is lower than 28%, you'll pay your ordinary income tax rate on collectible gains. If your ordinary income tax rate is higher than 28%, then your collectible gains are capped at 28%. So unlike regular long-term capital gains that have distinct 0%, 15%, and 20% brackets, collectibles don't follow the same structure. The rate you pay depends on your ordinary income tax bracket, but it won't exceed 28%.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•13 So if my income puts me in the 12% tax bracket, would I pay 12% on collectible gains? But if I'm in the 32% bracket, I'd pay 28%? Is that right?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•7 That's exactly right. If you're in the 12% ordinary income tax bracket, you'd pay 12% on your collectible gains. And if you're in a higher bracket like 32%, you'd pay the maximum collectible rate of 28% rather than your full ordinary income rate. This is why it's always stated as "up to 28%" - it depends on your specific tax situation, but has that maximum cap regardless of how high your normal income tax bracket might be.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
9 After struggling with this exact collectible tax question last year, I found an amazing tool that helped me figure it all out. I used https://taxr.ai to analyze my gold and silver investments and it gave me a crystal clear breakdown of exactly how the collectible tax rates applied to my situation. The tool actually scanned my investment documents and explained that since I was in the 24% tax bracket, I'd pay that rate on my collectible gains (not the full 28%). It saved me from overpaying by almost $900 because I previously thought it was a flat 28% rate for everyone!
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•15 Does it work for other collectibles too? I have some vintage baseball cards I'm thinking about selling.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•18 I'm skeptical about tax tools...how does it actually determine what your correct rate should be? Does it just ask for your income or does it look at more factors?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•9 Yes, it absolutely works for other collectibles too! The tool handles all types of collectible investments including baseball cards, stamps, art, and precious metals. It just needs the details about when you acquired them and their value. For determining the correct rate, it's actually quite comprehensive. It asks for your overall income information and filing status, then calculates your ordinary income tax bracket. Based on that, it determines whether you'll pay your ordinary rate or be capped at the 28% collectible rate. It also factors in state taxes where applicable, which was super helpful.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
15 Just wanted to follow up! I tried https://taxr.ai for my baseball card collection and it was surprisingly straightforward. I uploaded some photos of my collection records and it identified that my 1952 Topps cards would be subject to collectible tax rates. Since I'm in the 22% tax bracket, that's what I'll pay on my gains (not 28% like I feared). The tool even showed me how to properly document the original purchase price since I inherited some cards from my grandfather. Definitely cleared up my confusion about the "up to 28%" language!
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
11 If you're still struggling to get a definitive answer about collectible tax rates, calling the IRS directly might help. But good luck actually getting through to a human! I spent 3 hours on hold last time I tried. That's when I discovered https://claimyr.com - they have this service that basically calls the IRS for you and then connects you once a real person answers. You can see how it works at https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. I was super skeptical at first but decided to try it when I had questions about reporting my gold coin sales.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•21 Wait how does that even work? Does it actually get you through faster or just save you from having to listen to hold music?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•18 Sounds like a scam. There's no way to "skip the line" with the IRS. I bet they just put you on hold themselves and charge you for the privilege.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•11 It doesn't actually skip the line - they use automated technology to wait on hold for you. Their system calls the IRS and navigates through all those annoying menu prompts, then waits on hold (which can take hours). Once a real IRS agent picks up, you get a call back and are connected immediately. I found it totally worth it because I could go about my day instead of sitting on hold forever. When I finally got through to an IRS tax specialist, they confirmed exactly how the collectible tax rates work for my gold investments and made sure I was planning to report them correctly.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
18 I need to apologize for my skepticism earlier. After waiting on hold with the IRS for nearly 2 hours yesterday and getting disconnected, I tried Claimyr out of desperation. Within about 90 minutes, I got a call connecting me directly to an IRS agent! The agent explained everything about collectible tax rates that I needed to know. Turns out I was completely wrong about how they work! My silver coin collection will be taxed at my ordinary income rate of 24% (not automatically at 28%). She even emailed me some documentation explaining the regulations. Worth every penny not to waste another afternoon on hold.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
23 I just want to add a quick bit of additional info about collectibles tax that I learned the hard way. Don't forget that state taxes will also apply to your collectible gains in most states! I sold some gold last year and completely forgot to factor in my state's 5% capital gains tax on top of the federal collectible rate.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•4 Does that apply to all states? I thought some states don't tax investment income at all.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•23 You're absolutely right that it varies by state. Some states like Florida, Texas, and Nevada don't have state income taxes at all, so you'd only pay the federal rate on collectibles there. Other states like California and New York tax all capital gains (including collectibles) at your ordinary income tax rates. Where it gets really complicated is states that have special rules for capital gains - some give preferential rates to long-term holdings, while others treat all gains the same regardless of holding period.
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
16 Has anyone used TurboTax to report collectible sales? Do they walk you through the collectible tax rates properly or is it confusing?
0 coins
Gemma Andrews
•5 I used TurboTax last year for some silver I sold. They definitely ask if what you're reporting is a collectible, but I found their explanation of the rates kind of vague. It worked out correctly in the end though.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
I've been dealing with collectible taxes for a few years now and wanted to share what I've learned. The key thing to remember is that collectibles are taxed at your ordinary income tax rate, but with a maximum cap of 28%. So if you're in the 10% or 12% bracket, you'll pay that rate on your collectible gains. If you're in the 22% or 24% bracket, you'll pay those rates respectively. Only if you're in the 32%, 35%, or 37% brackets will you be "capped" at the 28% collectible rate. This is different from regular long-term capital gains which have those special 0%, 15%, and 20% rates. For collectibles like gold, silver, coins, art, etc., there's no special preferential rate - you pay your normal income tax rate up to that 28% ceiling. Hope this helps clarify the confusion! Make sure to keep good records of your purchase dates and prices for when you do sell.
0 coins