
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
So I just got back into trading on Robinhood after being away for like 3 years. Since I hadn't updated my account info in forever, they hit me with backup withholding on my first trade I made on Feb 14, 2024. I sold some stock for $3,100 and Robinhood withheld about $930 from it! From what I understand, the only way to get that withheld money back is through my tax return, and I'd need to file using a Consolidated 1099 form. But here's the thing - this all happened in 2024, so I can't get it back on my 2023 taxes that I'm doing now, right? I have to wait until next year? The confusing part is when I go into the Robinhood app and check the tax center tab, I can't find anything about a Consolidated 1099. It's like it doesn't exist in my account. Am I looking in the wrong place or is it too early for them to generate one since this just happened? Anyone dealt with this before? Kinda need that money back and not sure what to do next.
Just checked Where's My Refund and saw 'Action Required' status. Not sure what to do next. โข Filed my taxes on March 1st (did all my gig work income correctly) โข Got a letter to verify identity 2 weeks ago โข Went to local IRS office Monday to verify in person โข Checked WMR today and still says 'Action Required' Does it take time to update after verification? Really need this refund soon for car repairs so I can keep doing deliveries. Any help appreciated!
Hey Kingston! I went through almost the exact same situation last year with my delivery driver income. The "Action Required" status after in-person verification is super common and usually just means their system hasn't caught up yet. Since you verified on Monday, I'd give it until next Monday (the full 7 business days) before panicking. In the meantime, definitely call that 800-830-5084 number that Evelyn mentioned - it's specifically for identity verification follow-up and they can tell you if there's anything else needed beyond what you already did. When I called, they confirmed my verification went through but there was a secondary review happening that wasn't showing up anywhere else. Also, since you mentioned needing the refund for car repairs to keep working - I totally get that stress! If you have a smartphone, you can set up text alerts through the IRS2Go app so you'll know immediately when your status changes instead of constantly checking WMR. Hang in there, it should resolve soon! ๐๐ช
I'm going through this exact same thing right now! Filed early February, got the identity verification letter, went in person last Thursday, and still showing "Action Required" on WMR. It's so nerve-wracking when you're waiting for that refund money. From what I've learned lurking in these forums, it seems like the 7-9 business day window is pretty standard, but every situation is different. Since you verified Monday, you're probably still within that normal timeframe. One thing that helped me stay sane was creating an account on IRS.gov and checking my tax transcript - sometimes it shows more detailed info than WMR about what's actually happening with your return. The codes can be confusing but at least you might see if the verification was processed on their end. Really hoping yours updates soon! The car repair situation adds so much extra stress when your income depends on it. Keep us posted on how the phone call goes if you decide to call that verification line! ๐ค
@Malik Great question about the transcript codes! When I was going through this last year, the main codes to look for are: - Code 971 with Action Code 506: This means your identity verification was received and is being processed - Code 570: This is a hold code that shows up during verification - Code 572: This releases the hold once verification is complete The dates next to these codes will give you a better timeline than WMR sometimes. If you see a recent 971/506 entry, that's a good sign your in-person verification was logged in their system. Also @Vincent and @Kingston - I found that checking the transcript on Wednesdays seemed to show the most recent updates, since that's apparently when they do a lot of their weekly processing. The transcript updates faster than WMR in most cases. Hope this helps decode some of that confusing number soup! The whole system really could be more user-friendly for sure.
@Malik Great question about the transcript codes! When I was going through this last year, the key codes to look for are: - Code 971 with Action Code 506: This means identity verification was initiated - Code 972 with Action Code 506: This shows the verification was completed/resolved - Code 570: Additional account action pending (usually appears while they're reviewing) - Code 571: This releases the 570 hold once everything clears If you see the 972 code with your verification date, that's a good sign the identity part went through. But like others mentioned, there could still be secondary reviews happening that show up as different codes. The transcript definitely gives you more detail than WMR, but honestly the codes are like learning a foreign language! ๐ I kept a cheat sheet of what each one meant when I was dealing with this. The waiting is so stressful when you're trying to decode what the IRS is actually doing with your return. @Vincent and @Kingston - hopefully seeing those codes will give you both some peace of mind about where things stand!
I'm at my wits end looking at our tax situation again. This feels totally backwards to me. My husband and I both claim 0 allowances on our W-4 forms at work, which I thought meant they'd withhold MORE than enough taxes throughout the year. I was under the impression that claiming 0 meant the max would be taken out, then when we file jointly with our 3 kids plus mortgage interest and other deductions, we'd get a nice refund. But nope! For the third year in a row, we OWE money! We're talking about $2,800 this time, which is killing our budget. What gives? If we're both claiming the maximum withholding (0 allowances), why isn't enough being withheld to cover our tax liability? Shouldn't the withholding tables account for married couples filing jointly at our income levels? I just don't understand why they don't take enough out during the year when we've specifically asked them to take the MOST out by claiming 0. Is there something else we need to do on our W-4s? Do we need to request additional withholding? I'm so confused and frustrated with this whole process.
This is such a common problem! The key issue is that the withholding tables assume you're the only earner in your household when you select "Married." When both spouses work and earn similar amounts, you end up in higher tax brackets than the withholding calculations expect. Here's what you need to do immediately: 1. **Update both W-4 forms** - The new 2020+ W-4 is completely different from the old allowances system. You both need to fill out fresh forms. 2. **Check the "Two Jobs" box** - In Step 2 of the new W-4, there's a checkbox for couples where both spouses work. This automatically adjusts your withholding upward. 3. **Only ONE spouse claims the kids** - Don't both claim your 3 children. The higher earner should claim them in Step 3, the other spouse leaves it blank. 4. **Consider extra withholding** - You can specify an additional dollar amount to be withheld each paycheck in Step 4(c). Based on owing $2,800, you might want each of you to have an extra $50-75 withheld per paycheck. The IRS also has a withholding calculator on their website that can help you figure out the exact amounts. Don't let this drag on another year - update those W-4s now and you should see the difference in your next paychecks!
This is incredibly helpful! I had no idea about the "Two Jobs" checkbox - that explains so much. Quick question though: when you say the higher earner should claim the kids, what if we make almost exactly the same amount? Like within $2-3k of each other? Does it matter which one of us claims them then? Also, is there a rule of thumb for calculating that extra withholding amount in Step 4(c)? You mentioned $50-75 per paycheck but I'm not sure how to figure out what's right for our situation specifically.
When you earn nearly the same amount, it really doesn't matter which spouse claims the children - the tax benefit will be identical either way. I'd just pick whoever has the slightly higher income or whoever processes payroll changes faster at their company. For the extra withholding calculation, here's a simple method: Take the amount you owed last year ($2,800) and divide by the total number of paychecks you both receive annually. So if you're both paid bi-weekly (26 paychecks each = 52 total), that's $2,800 รท 52 = about $54 per paycheck total. You could split this evenly ($27 each) or have one person withhold the full amount. But honestly, I'd start with just updating to the new W-4s with the "Two Jobs" box checked first. That alone might fix most of your underwithholding issue. You can always add extra withholding later if needed, but the two-jobs adjustment is usually pretty significant. The IRS withholding calculator at irs.gov/W4App can give you the most precise numbers if you want to get really accurate with it.
This is exactly what happened to us! We were in the same boat - both claiming 0 on our old W-4s and still owing every year. The problem is that "married" withholding assumes only one spouse works, so when you both have jobs with similar incomes, you end up in higher tax brackets than expected. Here's what finally fixed it for us: We both filled out brand new W-4 forms and checked the "Two Jobs" box in Step 2. That single checkbox made a huge difference! We also made sure only one of us claimed our kids (I claimed all three since my salary is slightly higher), and the other spouse left Step 3 blank. Since you owed $2,800 this year, you might also want to add some extra withholding in Step 4(c) just to be safe. We added $40 per paycheck each after our first year with the new forms, and now we get a small refund instead of owing. Don't wait - update those W-4s right away! Your HR departments should have the current forms, and you'll see the increased withholding in your next paychecks.
The $40 per paycheck definitely made a noticeable difference in our take-home pay - about $80 less per month total between both of us. But honestly, it was SO worth it to not get hit with that huge tax bill in April! We just thought of it as forced savings that we'd get back if we overwitheld. We actually started with the IRS withholding calculator first (irs.gov/W4App) which suggested we needed about $35 per paycheck extra, but we rounded up to $40 just to be extra safe. The calculator is really helpful because you can input your exact salaries, number of kids, deductions, etc. and it gives you precise recommendations for each line of the W-4. My advice would be to start with just the new W-4 forms and the "Two Jobs" checkbox first - that might be enough to fix most of your problem without needing extra withholding. Then you can always adjust later if needed. Better to start conservative and add more withholding than to go overboard right away!
The $40 extra per paycheck definitely reduced our take-home pay, but honestly it was worth it to avoid that stressful surprise tax bill! If you're paid bi-weekly, that's about $1,040 less per year in take-home pay ($40 ร 26 paychecks), but you're avoiding a $2,800+ tax bill, so you're still ahead by almost $1,800. We actually started with the IRS withholding calculator first - it suggested we needed about $75 total extra withholding per paycheck between both of us. We decided to start conservative with $40 each and see how it went. You could always start smaller, like $25 each, and adjust upward if needed. The peace of mind is honestly priceless though. No more dreading tax season or scrambling to find money we don't have for a surprise tax bill!
Just got the details from Jackson Hewitt about PATH Act refunds for 2025. According to their website, if you claimed either the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC), the IRS has to hold the refund until after February 14 due to the Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes (PATH) Act - this is to prevent tax fraud. I was looking at their webpage titled "PATH Act Refund Delays: When to Expect" and it breaks down all the key takeaways: "The Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes (PATH) Act requires the IRS to hold refunds for taxpayers who claim the Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) or Additional Child Tax Credit (ACTC) until after February 14, in order to prevent tax fraud. The IRS will update its website and app on February 17, 2025, with refund updates for early filers who claimed the EITC or ACTC. PATH funding will be done in two batches, on February 19 and February 20, 2025. Most of the time, the IRS will fund tax refunds within 21 days, but does not guarantee a certain date. The IRS will lift the PATH Act holding requirement on February 17, 2025, and fund most refunds of taxpayers claiming either the EITC or ACTC by February 28, 2025." They're making it clear that the PATH funding will be released in those 2 specific batches - February 19 and February 20, 2025. The IRS website and app will update with refund info for early filers who claimed EITC or ACTC on February 17, 2025. Jackson Hewitt also mentions: "You don't have to wait for the IRS to get money. File with Jackson Hewitt and apply for a No Fee Tax Refund Advance loan, and you could get money the same day if approved on a prepaid card." They even have a promotion saying "NEW CLIENTS save money on expert tax prep. Starting at $49! Terms apply." If you claim the EITC or ACTC on an early filed return, the IRS puts a hold on your refund for a special review to make sure you report these credits correctly. I know these credits are important for families, but this holding period is frustrating and ridiculous. The webpage acknowledges how important tax refunds are for families. Anyone else stuck waiting on PATH refunds? I understand they need to prevent fraud, but making families wait until late February when many people file in January seems excessive.
used taxr.ai last year and it was spot on with my refund date. Already used it this year too and its showing Feb 20 deposit for me lets gooooo
This is so helpful! I filed early January with H&R Block and claimed both EITC and ACTC. Been stressing about when I'll actually see my refund. The February 17th update date and Feb 19-20 batch releases give me something concrete to look forward to instead of just "sometime after Feb 14th." Really appreciate you sharing the Jackson Hewitt breakdown - makes it way clearer than the confusing IRS language. Still think it's ridiculous that families have to wait this long when we need the money for bills and expenses, but at least now I know exactly what to expect and when. Gonna mark my calendar for Feb 17th to check WMR!
Hey everyone! Quick tax question here. I'm a self-employed contractor doing custom cabinetry work, and I've been traveling to a neighboring state for a big kitchen renovation project. I'll be there for about 5-6 weeks total. Can I claim the standard per diem rates for my meals and hotel stays when I file my taxes, or am I limited to only deducting my actual expenses with receipts? And if I can use the per diem rates, what's the current standard amount for lodging and meals? I've heard different things from different people. Thanks for any help you can provide - tax season is coming up fast and I want to make sure I'm tracking everything correctly!
Has anyone used the IRS per diem app or is there a better app to track all this stuff? I'm terrible at keeping receipts but don't want to miss out on deductions.
Great question about per diem rates! Just to add to what others have shared - make sure you're looking at the current year's rates since they can change annually. The GSA updates their per diem rates every October 1st for the new fiscal year. Also, keep in mind that even though you can use the meal per diem without receipts, you still need to maintain records of your business travel dates, destinations, and the business purpose. A simple travel log or calendar notation works fine for this. One more tip - if you're doing a long-term project like your 5-6 week renovation, double-check that it qualifies as "temporary" work away from your tax home. Generally, if you expect the work assignment to last less than one year, you're good to go for travel deductions. But if it extends beyond that or becomes indefinite, the IRS might consider it a change in your tax home rather than travel. Good luck with your project and tax planning!
Anthony Young
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - make sure you're keeping detailed records of ALL your trades and the withholding amounts yourself, don't just rely on Robinhood's tax documents next year. I had a similar issue and when my 1099 finally came, the withholding amount they reported was wrong. Had to go through months of statements to prove the correct amount. Total nightmare. Screenshot everything!!
0 coins
Charlotte White
This is great advice. I always export my transaction history monthly from every broker I use. Robinhood makes this pretty easy - just go to Statements & History and you can download CSV files of all your activity.
0 coins
Mikayla Davison
I had a very similar experience with Robinhood backup withholding last year! You're absolutely right that you can't get that money back until you file your 2024 taxes next year - it's frustrating but that's just how the system works. One thing that helped me was setting up quarterly estimated tax payments for 2024 to account for the fact that I already had $930 withheld. Since you've essentially prepaid part of your 2024 taxes through the backup withholding, you might be able to reduce or skip some estimated payments depending on your overall tax situation. Also, definitely keep your own spreadsheet tracking every trade and withholding amount. When my 1099-B came the following year, there were some discrepancies I had to sort out with Robinhood's support team. Having my own records made it much easier to resolve. The good news is once your W-9 info is properly verified in their system, the withholding should stop completely on future trades. Just give it a few business days after updating to take effect.
0 coins