
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I just read about this new bill that would slash IRS funding to increase aid to Israel, and as someone who works with taxes regularly, I'm seriously concerned. We've barely got a functional tax administration system as it is. The people cheering for IRS cuts have clearly never had to deal with them on a professional level. Last month, I had a client who received an incorrect 1099 - definitely not their income, clearly a mistake. Should have been a simple fix, right? Nope. We couldn't get ANY response from the IRS because they're already so understaffed and overwhelmed. We ended up having to file a Tax Court petition just to get someone's attention! Complete waste of time and resources. As soon as the IRS attorney saw our petition, she immediately agreed to fix it. The right outcome, but we should never have needed to go that far. I get so annoyed when I see all these dramatic reports about IRS agents with guns acting like some kind of tax police. That's not reality at all. Only the Criminal Investigation Division agents carry weapons - and they absolutely should, considering they're dealing with actual criminals. Regular IRS employees aren't breaking down doors unless you're involved in serious criminal tax fraud. The IRS needs MORE administrative staff, not less. They need resources to function properly. Cutting their budget further will just make everything worse for regular taxpayers trying to resolve legitimate issues. Rant over. Anyone else feel this way?
Hey everyone, I'm in a bit of a situation with the EITC (earned income tax credit) this year. From what I've been reading, I think I qualify for all the requirements except the age thing. The rules say you need to be at least 25 years old, and my birthday falls just a few days before the April tax filing deadline this year. I'm wondering if I should wait until after my birthday to file so I can claim the EITC, or if that's not how it works? Would I still qualify since I'll be 25 before the deadline? Or do I need to wait until next year's taxes? I'm really struggling financially right now and could use the extra money from the EITC. I know there's like a 0.5% penalty per month if you file late, but I think I can still submit before the deadline hits if I wait until my birthday. Any advice would be super appreciated!
Don't forget to check if your state has its own version of EITC! Many states have their own earned income credits with slightly different rules. In my state, the age requirement is actually different than the federal one. Might be worth checking if your state offers something you can claim now.
I hadn't even thought about state-specific credits! Do you know where I should look to find out if my state has different age requirements for their version of the EITC?
Check your state's department of revenue or taxation website - they usually have a dedicated page for state tax credits. Just google "[your state] earned income tax credit" and it should come up. You can also look at your state tax form instructions which typically list all available credits. About half of US states offer their own EITC, and the rules do vary. Some states make it a percentage of the federal credit, but others have their own qualifications. Worth checking because even if you don't qualify for the federal one, you might get some benefit from your state!
Just a heads up if ur turning 25 - check if ur "childless" for tax purposes. The EITC age requirement is only 25+ if ur filing without qualifying children. If u have qualifying kids that u can claim, then the age requirement doesn't apply at all! Kinda confusing but that's how it works.
I'm super confused about this whole "Use Tax" thing on my state tax return. It asks if I purchased any out-of-state untaxed goods and says I would owe Use Tax if I did. But what exactly counts for this??? A few specific questions I have: 1. If I bought a textbook online for my classes, would that count? Especially since textbooks are tax exempt in my state anyway? 2. What about when I buy stuff from vending machines around campus? The machines are in-state, but I think the company that owns them might be based elsewhere. 3. Does Use Tax only matter if I buy stuff from states without sales tax (like Oregon or New Hampshire)? Sorry for all the questions - I'm trying to file my taxes myself for the first time and this is giving me a headache! My parents always handled this stuff before.
FYI - here's a simple breakdown of what usually counts for Use Tax: - Online purchases where no sales tax was collected - Items bought in other states with lower or no sales tax - Purchases from overseas vendors - Items bought directly from individual sellers who don't collect tax What usually DOESN'T count: - Items bought in your own state (that's sales tax) - Items that are tax exempt in your state (if textbooks are exempt from sales tax, they're usually exempt from use tax too) - Digital downloads (in some states) - Services (in states where services aren't taxed
Thanks for this! Quick question - what about things bought while on vacation in another state and brought back? Like if I buy clothes in Oregon (no sales tax) and bring them home to California?
That's exactly what use tax is designed for! If you buy clothes in Oregon (no sales tax) and bring them back to California, technically you owe California use tax on those items. This is one of the most common situations where use tax applies, but also one of the hardest for states to enforce. Generally speaking, if you bought something significant (like expensive electronics, jewelry, furniture, etc.) while out of state and didn't pay sales tax, you should report it on your state return and pay the use tax.
Just looked at my state's instructions and they have a "use tax lookup table" based on income. So if you make $30,000-$49,999, they say you can just pay $23 in use tax without keeping records. Seems WAY easier than tracking every Amazon purchase all year lol!
My cousin from Ecuador just got a 1098-T form in the mail from when she studied for one semester at a university in California back in 2022. Talk about delayed mail! The form shows about $23K in tuition and housing costs that were covered by her home university's exchange program. She also had some spending money that her grandparents gave her as a gift for the trip. She was strictly on a student visa and didn't work at all while in the US. I'm confused about whether she needs to file anything with the IRS now that she's received this form. She's been back in Ecuador for over a year already. Does getting a 1098-T automatically mean she has to file US taxes even though she wasn't working and was only there to study? The whole situation seems weird since the form took so long to reach her.
One thing to watch out for - if your cousin received any money directly (like that spending money from grandparents) OVER $100k, she would need to file FBAR forms reporting foreign gifts. But it sounds like her gift was much smaller than that threshold. Also, some countries have tax treaties with the US that affect how scholarships are taxed. Might be worth checking if there's a specific US-Ecuador tax treaty that applies here.
The gift was definitely under $5k, so nowhere near that threshold! I hadn't even thought about tax treaties between countries. Is there an easy way to check that?
You can find tax treaties on the IRS website under "Tax Treaties" - they have a page listing all countries with tax treaties with the US. For Ecuador specifically, there are some provisions but they mostly relate to income earned from working, not scholarships or grants. Given the small gift amount and the fact that all scholarship money went to qualified expenses, your cousin is almost certainly in the clear with no filing requirements.
My daughter studied abroad in similar circumstances and we were told by her university that international students should file Form 8843 "Statement for Exempt Individuals with a Medical Condition" even if they don't have to file a tax return. It's not actually a tax return, just a statement that explains your presence in the US. Maybe worth looking into?
Last year I had to make a career change to become a caregiver for my dad who was diagnosed with Alzheimer's. Big life change for sure. I was working as a high school counselor for almost 20 years and would consistently get around $4k-6k back every year filing as head of household with my son as a dependent. For 2023, I worked until mid-May then quit. My W-2 income for those months was about $42k. After that, I picked up some freelance consulting work as a 1099 contractor making roughly $10k total. During this time, I also sold some investments that resulted in a capital loss exceeding $3k, which I assumed would offset the taxes I'd owe on my 1099 income. But when my accountant filed my return, I ended up owing $125! I was completely blindsided by this. Looking at my return more carefully, I don't think my accountant properly applied the capital loss. I feel like there were some serious mistakes made that cost me several hundred or possibly a couple thousand dollars. Is it reasonable to think she messed up? Should I file an amended return?
From what you described, it sounds like your accountant might have made a mistake, but not necessarily with the capital loss. Here's my take: When you switch from W-2 to 1099, you're hit with self-employment tax that's about 15.3% on top of regular income tax. Your capital loss of $3k would offset income tax but NOT self-employment tax. If you made $8k on 1099 work, you'd owe about $1,200 just in self-employment tax. Your capital loss might have saved you $600-700 in income tax, which explains why you still ended up owing. I'd recommend checking if your accountant claimed all possible deductions for your 1099 work (home office? business expenses? mileage?). Those deductions reduce BOTH income tax and self-employment tax, unlike capital losses.
Thanks for this explanation. I didn't realize that capital losses don't offset self-employment tax. That might explain a lot. I definitely worked from home for all my 1099 income - would that qualify for home office deduction? I used my living room as my workspace since I didn't have a separate office.
For the home office deduction, you need a space used "regularly and exclusively" for business. If your living room was also used for personal activities, it typically wouldn't qualify. However, if you had a specific section of the living room that was used only for work (like a desk area never used for anything else), that portion might qualify. Other deductions you should check for include any supplies, software, internet costs (partial), phone expenses, and any industry-specific materials you purchased. Also, if you drove anywhere for your 1099 work, those miles are deductible. Even small deductions add up and reduce both your income tax and self-employment tax burden.
Former tax preparer here. One thing nobody's mentioned - when you say you had a capital loss "greater than $3k", was part of it carried forward to future years? The $3k limit is just for offsetting ordinary income in the current year. If your total loss was say $5k, then $3k would offset income this year and $2k would carry forward to next year. Also, make sure your accountant properly accounted for any quarterly estimated tax payments you should have made on your 1099 income. That could explain some penalties if you didn't make those payments.
Liv Park
I think people don't realize that cutting IRS funding actually INCREASES the deficit. The IRS brings in far more money than it costs to operate. Every dollar spent on enforcement returns something like $5-6 in previously uncollected taxes. Cutting their budget is penny-wise, pound-foolish. It's the big fish who benefit from a weakened IRS - wealthy individuals and corporations with complex tax situations who can hide income or inflate deductions knowing the IRS doesn't have resources to properly audit them. The average W-2 employee gets their taxes automatically withheld and has nowhere to hide anyway.
0 coins
Leeann Blackstein
Do you have a source for that $5-6 return on investment figure? I'm not doubting you, just would like to read more about it since that's a compelling argument against budget cuts.
0 coins
Liv Park
The Treasury Department's own analysis from 2021 estimated that every additional dollar invested in tax enforcement yields at least $5 in revenue. More recent studies suggest the return could be even higher for certain enforcement activities targeting high-income individuals and large corporations. For comparison, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has historically used more conservative estimates of a 3:1 to 5:1 return ratio, but even at the low end, that's still a 300% return on investment. There's a good article in the Journal of Tax Policy from last quarter that breaks down different enforcement activities and their respective ROIs. The highest returns come from audits of high-income individuals with business income and large corporations with international operations.
0 coins
Ryder Greene
Can someone explain why there's so much pushback when the IRS tries to get more funding? I don't understand why better tax enforcement is so controversial. Is it just because nobody likes paying taxes?
0 coins
Carmella Fromis
It's political theater. Politicians know attacking the IRS plays well with their base, regardless of the practical impacts. There's decades of anti-government rhetoric that's made "IRS" a four-letter word to many voters. Plus, powerful donors benefit from a weakened tax enforcement system.
0 coins