


Ask the community...
I'm in a very similar situation with about $2,900 in winnings from Chumba and LuckyLand this year, and this thread has been incredibly eye-opening! I had no idea about the potential tax implications until I started researching it recently. What's really helpful is seeing so many people confirm that reporting as "Other Income" is the safest approach, especially with the direct IRS guidance that several folks obtained. I've been keeping loose track of my redemptions, but clearly need to get much more organized with documentation. One question I haven't seen addressed - for those of you who have been reporting social casino winnings for multiple years, have you noticed any patterns in terms of which platforms eventually start sending 1099-MISC forms? I'm wondering if some companies get more compliant over time as they grow larger or face more regulatory pressure. I'm definitely going to start that detailed spreadsheet approach immediately and plan to report everything when I file. Better to be overly cautious than deal with potential issues down the road. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences and research - this has been incredibly valuable information that I couldn't find anywhere else!
Great question about compliance patterns over time! From what I've observed over the past few years, there does seem to be a trend where larger, more established platforms gradually become more compliant with tax reporting requirements. For example, I've been playing since 2022, and I noticed that some platforms that never sent forms in their early years started issuing 1099-MISC forms once they reached a certain size or got acquired by larger gaming companies. It seems like they reach a point where the regulatory risk outweighs the administrative burden of proper tax reporting. That said, the timing is still really unpredictable. I've had platforms send forms for relatively small amounts one year, then nothing the next year despite higher winnings. The inconsistency is maddening, which is exactly why keeping your own detailed records is so crucial. Your approach of starting the spreadsheet now and reporting everything as "Other Income" is spot on. I wish I had been that organized from the beginning! One thing I've learned is that even if you think your winnings are "small," they can add up quickly across multiple platforms throughout the year. Better to track everything from day one than try to reconstruct it later.
I've been dealing with this exact situation and wanted to share what worked for me. After winning about $3,200 across Chumba and LuckyLand this year, I was getting nowhere with customer support about tax forms, so I took a different approach. I ended up using one of those AI tax tools someone mentioned earlier (taxr.ai) to analyze my situation, and it was incredibly helpful in understanding the distinction between traditional gambling and these sweepstakes-style platforms. The tool confirmed that these winnings should be reported as "Other Income" rather than gambling winnings, which aligns with what others have shared here. What really helped me was creating a simple system: I exported all my redemption emails into a folder, took screenshots of my account histories from each platform, and organized everything by date and amount. When tax season comes, I'll have everything ready to report, regardless of whether I receive any 1099-MISC forms. The key insight I got from the tax tool and this thread is that the IRS doesn't really care about the technical distinction between "sweepstakes" and "gambling" - they just want you to report the income. Since these platforms are notoriously inconsistent with their own reporting, keeping detailed personal records is absolutely essential. For anyone in a similar boat, I'd definitely recommend being proactive about documentation and reporting. The peace of mind is worth way more than trying to guess whether these companies will handle it properly on their end.
This is such a helpful approach! I'm relatively new to this community and have been following this discussion because I just started playing on these platforms a few months ago. Your system of organizing redemption emails and screenshots sounds really smart - I wish I had thought of that from the beginning. I'm curious about the AI tax tool you mentioned (taxr.ai) - did it give you any specific guidance about how to handle the documentation when you actually file your taxes? Like, do you need to attach all those screenshots and emails to your return, or just keep them for your records in case of an audit? Also, as someone who's just getting started with this, do you think it's worth reporting smaller amounts too? I've only redeemed about $400 so far, but based on everything in this thread, it seems like the safe approach is to report everything regardless of the amount. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's really reassuring to see people being proactive about this!
I'm going through this exact same situation right now! Filed my 1040-NR in mid-March as an H-1B holder (was on F-1 status for part of the tax year) and it's been over 2 months with zero updates. The "Where's My Refund" tool just shows the same useless "still being processed" message every time I check. This thread has been incredibly helpful - I had no idea that non-resident returns took so much longer than regular 1040s! I didn't claim any treaty benefits, but I did have income from multiple states which might be complicating things. Reading about everyone's experiences with tax transcripts is really eye-opening - I'm definitely going to request mine this week to see if there are any specific hold codes explaining the delay. One thing I'm wondering about - has anyone here had experience with status changes during the tax year (like F-1 to H-1B)? I'm worried that might be adding extra complexity to my return review since I had to report income under two different visa statuses. My tax preparer said it was filed correctly, but now I'm second-guessing everything! The waiting is so stressful, especially when you see people with regular 1040s getting their refunds in 2-3 weeks. At least now I know what to expect timeline-wise based on everyone's experiences. Thanks for starting this discussion - it's such a relief to know I'm not the only one dealing with this frustrating process!
Hey Isabella! I'm also dealing with the same frustrating wait - filed my 1040-NR back in February and still nothing! Your situation with the F-1 to H-1B status change during the tax year is really interesting, and you're right to wonder if that's adding complexity. From what I've seen working with other international students who had status changes, the IRS does tend to flag those returns for additional review. They need to verify that income was reported correctly under each status and that the transition was handled properly. It's not necessarily a problem with how it was filed - it's just another layer of manual verification they have to do. The fact that you had income from multiple states probably isn't helping either. I've heard that multi-state returns for non-residents often get pulled for review to make sure state tax obligations were calculated correctly. Definitely get your tax transcript like everyone's suggesting! Even if there are hold codes you don't understand, at least you'll know if there's a specific issue or if you're just in the normal (unfortunately long) processing queue. And don't second-guess your tax preparer too much - status change situations are complex but very common, and if they specialize in non-resident returns, they've probably handled similar cases before. Hang in there - the waiting is awful but everyone here eventually got their refunds!
I'm going through the exact same frustrating situation! Filed my 1040-NR in early March as an F-1 student from Vietnam, and it's now been over 2 months with absolutely no progress. The "Where's My Refund" tool has been completely useless - just the same generic "still being processed" message for weeks. Reading through everyone's experiences in this thread has been both reassuring and nerve-wracking. Reassuring to know this insane wait time is apparently normal for non-resident returns, but nerve-wracking to realize I could be waiting until fall! I also claimed treaty benefits for my teaching assistantship income, so based on what others have shared, that manual review process is definitely adding months to my timeline. I'm absolutely going to request my tax transcript after seeing how helpful it was for others here. The idea that there might be specific hold codes explaining what's actually happening (instead of just wondering if my return disappeared) is incredibly appealing right now. At least then I'll know if there's a real issue that needs addressing or if I'm just stuck in the normal processing queue. One thing that's really helped my stress level is seeing that literally everyone who's posted here eventually got their refund - it just took way longer than expected. I was starting to panic that something had gone wrong with my filing, but it sounds like 4-6 months is unfortunately just the reality for 1040-NR returns with treaty benefits. Thanks so much for starting this discussion @Fatima Al-Farsi - it's such a relief to find others dealing with this same nightmare! The waiting is awful when you're counting on that money, but at least now I have a realistic timeline and some actionable steps to get more information.
Check your loan estimate carefully! Mine had an origination charge of 1% but when i looked at the breakdown it was actually 0.25% for points (deductible) and 0.75% for underwriting fees (not deductible). They lump it all together as "origination" which is super confusing.
This! My lender did the exact same thing. One line item called "origination fee" but it was actually multiple different charges. Had to ask for the itemized breakdown.
Great advice from everyone here! I went through this same confusion last year. One thing that really helped me was getting the HUD-1 Settlement Statement (or Closing Disclosure for newer loans) and looking specifically at line 801 for "Loan Origination Fee" and line 802 for "Loan Discount (Points)". If your 1.25% fee shows up on line 802 or is specifically labeled as discount points, it's likely deductible. If it's on line 801 as a service fee, it's probably not. Also, the IRS has a specific test for deductible points: they must be computed as a percentage of the loan amount, paid for your main home, be customary in your area, and not exceed the amount generally charged. Your lender should be able to confirm which category your fee falls into - don't be afraid to press them for specifics since this affects your taxes!
This is super helpful! I didn't know about the specific line numbers to look for on the closing documents. When you say "customary in your area" - is there a way to research what's typical for mortgage points in my region, or is that something the lender should already know and confirm for me? I want to make sure I'm prepared with the right questions when I talk to them.
I'm dealing with a very similar situation! I've been working remotely for a European company while living in the US and regularly transferring my salary back through various services including Western Union. One thing I learned that might help you - the key distinction is between the original income (which you definitely need to report on your US taxes as worldwide income) and the actual transfer of that money between your accounts (which isn't a taxable event itself). For the FBAR reporting that others mentioned, the threshold is if your foreign accounts had a combined balance over $10,000 at ANY point during the year - even if it was just for one day. This caught me off guard initially because I thought it was based on year-end balances. Also, keep detailed records of the exchange rates on transfer dates. While small currency fluctuations usually don't create significant taxable gains, if there are large swings between when you earned the money and when you transferred it, there could be some currency gain/loss to account for. Have you considered using a service like Wise instead of Western Union? The fees are usually lower and they provide better documentation that's easier for tax reporting purposes.
This is really helpful! I had no idea about the "any point during the year" rule for FBAR - I was definitely thinking it was just year-end balances too. That's a crucial detail that could easily trip people up. I'm curious about your experience with Wise vs Western Union for documentation. Do they provide better tax-friendly statements? I've been sticking with Western Union because it's familiar, but if Wise makes the record-keeping easier for tax purposes, that might be worth switching. How detailed are their transaction records compared to Western Union receipts? Also, when you mention currency gain/loss accounting - do you calculate this based on the exchange rate when you originally earned the income versus when you transferred it? That seems like it could get pretty complex to track accurately.
I've been in a similar boat with international transfers and want to share some practical insights that might help. First, you're absolutely right that you shouldn't be paying taxes twice on the same income - the transfer itself isn't taxable, but there are definitely reporting requirements to be aware of. Beyond what others have mentioned about FBAR filing, make sure you understand the timing requirements. The FBAR is due by April 15th (with an automatic extension to October 15th), but it's filed separately from your tax return through FinCEN's website. Missing this deadline can result in significant penalties even if no taxes are owed. For your Western Union transfers specifically, I'd recommend keeping a simple spreadsheet tracking each transfer with the date, amount in foreign currency, USD amount received, and the exchange rate. This documentation will be invaluable if you ever face questions about the source of funds. One thing to watch out for - if your total transfers for the year exceed certain thresholds (like $10,000 from a single foreign source), you might also need to consider Form 3520 reporting requirements depending on the exact nature of your employment arrangement overseas. Also, since you mentioned working remotely for an Asian company, double-check whether you need to file any forms related to foreign earned income exclusion (Form 2555) if you qualify. This could potentially reduce your US tax liability on the original income.
Samantha Howard
I've been through the exact same F1 visa tax confusion and want to add some clarity to the great advice already given here. The key thing that helped me understand this was realizing there are actually TWO separate tests working together: 1. **The 5-year exemption rule**: Your first 5 calendar years in F1 status (2013-2017 for you) automatically make you a nonresident alien, regardless of days present. 2. **The Substantial Presence Test**: Starting in 2018, you calculate using the weighted formula. Based on your numbers, you'd likely be a **resident alien** for 2020 tax purposes (Form 1040), but here's what saved me: the **closer connection exception** via Form 8840. Since you were present less than 183 days in 2020 (only 159), and it sounds like you maintained strong ties to your home country, you can likely still elect to be treated as a nonresident. The bank account, family home, and voter registration you mentioned would be strong evidence. **Important warning**: You'll probably need to review 2018 and 2019 too. I made the mistake of filing as nonresident those years when I should have been resident, and had to file amended returns. It was a pain but ultimately got me a refund! My advice: Get help from a tax pro who specializes in international student taxes. The potential amended returns and Form 8840 elections can get tricky, and you want to make sure you're doing everything correctly to avoid future IRS issues.
0 coins
Yuki Nakamura
โขThis is such a helpful thread! As someone who just started dealing with F1 visa tax issues, I'm learning so much from everyone's experiences. I'm curious though - for those who had to file amended returns for 2018/2019, did you end up owing more money or getting refunds? I'm in a similar situation where I think I filed as nonresident when I should have been resident, and I'm worried about what that might mean financially. Also, when you filed Form 8840 for the closer connection exception, did the IRS ever question your documentation or ask for additional proof? I have similar ties to my home country but want to make sure I'm prepared if they scrutinize my claim. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's reassuring to know others have navigated this successfully!
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
As someone who went through this exact F1 visa tax maze a few years ago, I can tell you that you're asking all the right questions! The confusion is totally understandable because the rules are genuinely complex. Based on your timeline, here's what I learned when I was in your shoes: **Your 5-year exempt period**: 2013-2017 were your exempt years as an F1 student. During these years, you were automatically a nonresident alien regardless of how many days you were present. **For 2020**: Starting in 2018, you begin using the Substantial Presence Test. Your calculation would be: - 2020 days: 159 - 2019 weighted (รท3): 73.7 days - 2018 weighted (รท6): 36.3 days - **Total: 269 days** Since this exceeds 183 days AND you were present more than 31 days in 2020, you'd technically be a **resident alien** for 2020 tax purposes and should use **Form 1040**. **BUT** - and this is important - since you were present less than 183 days in 2020 (only 159) and it sounds like you maintained strong ties to your home country, you might qualify for the **closer connection exception** using Form 8840. This would let you elect to be treated as a nonresident. **Red flag**: You should also check 2018 and 2019. I made the mistake of filing as nonresident those years when I was actually a resident alien under the test. Had to file amended returns, but it worked out fine. My recommendation? Find a tax professional who specializes in F1 visa situations. The potential amended returns and Form 8840 can get tricky, and you want to get it right the first time!
0 coins