


Ask the community...
One option you may want to consider is just selling your Canadian ETFs and buying US equivalents. That's what I ended up doing after battling with PFIC reporting for 2 years. Yes, you'll take a tax hit upfront, but the long-term compliance headache might not be worth it. Many Canadian ETFs have very similar US counterparts.
Wouldn't selling trigger that punitive tax rate the first poster mentioned though? Wouldn't that be worse than just dealing with the annual reporting?
Yes, selling will trigger the tax event at potentially the highest rate plus interest charges if you're using the default PFIC method. However, it's a one-time pain versus ongoing compliance costs and headaches. If you can make a QEF election for the current year before selling, that might reduce the tax impact somewhat. Or if you've only held them for a short time, the interest charges might not be too severe. I did the math and realized that even with the higher tax rate on selling, the amount I'd save in accounting fees over the next decade made it worthwhile to just take the hit and simplify my life.
Has anyone successfully used the Mark-to-Market election for their PFICs? My Canadian broker provides year-end market values but not detailed PFIC information statements.
I use MTM for my Australian ETFs. You can only make the election on a timely filed return for the year, and once you make it, you're stuck with it. The upside is you report gains/losses annually as ordinary income (no special PFIC tax rates). The downside is you can't claim losses beyond your gains from other MTM PFICs. It's way less complicated than the default method though.
Another content creator here! Something nobody mentioned yet - if you're making under $400 net profit for the year from your content creation, you don't owe self-employment tax (though you still report the income). This surprised me when I started out. Also, if your main job already has you close to the Social Security tax limit ($160,200 for 2025), the math changes significantly on what you need to save. My accountant helped me realize I was saving way too much once I hit that threshold at my day job.
Wait what? I thought ANY side income got hit with self-employment tax! Are you sure about the $400 thing?
Yep, 100% sure about the $400 threshold for self-employment tax. It's directly from the IRS rules. If your net earnings from self-employment are less than $400, you don't have to pay the SE tax, though you still report the income on your tax return for income tax purposes. Most new content creators don't realize this and end up saving way too much when they're just starting out. Of course, most people who stick with it eventually earn more than $400 in profit annually, but it's good to know the actual threshold.
Just my two cents - I've been creating content for 2 years now and the biggest mistake I made was not separating my business and personal finances from day 1. Get a separate bank account (doesn't have to be a business account) where you deposit all your platform earnings and pay for expenses. Then I automatically transfer 35% of each deposit into a "tax savings" account. At the end of the year, I usually have more saved than I need for taxes, but that's way better than coming up short!
One thing nobody mentioned yet - make sure you're taking advantage of all the deductions you can on Schedule C before calculating your self-employment tax! You'll want to deduct any legitimate business expenses from your $4,000 before calculating the SE tax. Things like: - Home office (if you have a dedicated space) - Internet and phone expenses (business portion) - Any supplies or software - Mileage for business travel - Professional development costs This will lower your net profit, which means less self-employment tax. I made the mistake of not claiming these my first year and overpaid by hundreds!
Do you need receipts for all of these? I did some freelance work last year but was terrible about keeping records. Can I still claim some of these deductions?
You should ideally have documentation for all business expenses, but the level of documentation varies. For things like home office, you need to know the square footage. For mileage, you should have a log of business trips. For expenses like internet and phone, you can calculate the business percentage based on reasonable usage. If you don't have exact receipts but have bank or credit card statements showing the purchases, that can work too. The key is being able to show the expense was real and business-related if you ever get audited. For this year going forward, I recommend using a free app to track expenses or even just a simple spreadsheet. It makes tax time so much easier!
Has anyone used the IRS Direct Pay system for self-employment taxes? Is it pretty straightforward? I'm in the same boat as OP but worried about making a mistake on which payment type to select.
I used Direct Pay last year. When you go through the steps, you select "Form 1040" and then "Tax Return" or "Balance Due" as the payment type (I used Balance Due). Then select the right tax year. It was actually easier than I expected. Just make sure you keep the confirmation number they give you after the payment processes. I also took a screenshot of the confirmation page just to be safe.
One important thing no one's mentioned yet: if this is a true cannabis "plant-touching" operation, there are MAJOR tax implications beyond just the structure of your investment. Under Section 280E, cannabis businesses can't deduct normal business expenses because it's federally illegal. This means the business itself will have much higher effective tax rates, which directly impacts your returns. Make sure the PE firm's projections are accounting for this - many don't, which makes their return forecasts totally unrealistic. Also, depending on your state, you may need to register as an "interested party" with the cannabis regulatory body, even as a passive investor. Some states have restrictions on out-of-state investors too.
Is this still true with all the recent changes to federal cannabis policy? I thought things were changing with banking and taxes.
Yes, it's absolutely still true. While there have been some banking improvements with the SAFE Banking provisions, Section 280E is still very much in effect and will remain so until cannabis is rescheduled or descheduled at the federal level. The recent policy changes have mainly affected banking access and research, but the tax code restrictions remain unchanged. Any legitimate PE firm in the cannabis space should be building their financial models with 280E limitations factored in, resulting in effective tax rates that can reach 50-70% depending on the operation's structure. Always ask to see their tax assumptions when reviewing projected returns.
A bit off topic, but how are you verifying this cannabis PE firm is legitimate? I've seen a TON of scams in this space. Did they provide a private placement memorandum? Are they registered with the SEC? Have you verified the actual ownership of the farm they're investing in? Just be careful. The cannabis industry attracts a lot of shady operators because of the legal gray areas and limited banking options.
Thanks for bringing this up - honestly I haven't done as much due diligence as I probably should. They did provide an investment memorandum but I haven't verified SEC registration or the actual farm ownership. Do you have suggestions for what specific documents I should be requesting or how to verify their legitimacy?
Absolutely. Request their Form D filing with the SEC (all private offerings should have this), check the backgrounds of all principals through FINRA BrokerCheck, and get proof of the actual cannabis licenses they hold or have applied for. Also ask for references from current investors, and ideally visit the actual operation if possible. Request their detailed tax strategy document specifically addressing 280E issues - legitimate operators will have this prepared. Finally, have an attorney experienced in cannabis review all documents before transferring any money. The extra $1-2k in legal fees could save you from a total loss on your investment.
Laila Prince
Another thing to consider - make sure you get everything in writing! Even after you pay what they say you owe now and even if you get a stipulated decision, keep ALL documentation from this entire process. I had a similar situation where the IRS agreed with my response to a CP2000, but then two years later, I got a notice about the same issue again because different departments weren't communicating. Having all my previous correspondence, including the written acceptance of my explanation, saved me from having to fight the same battle twice. Also, make sure you send your payment with a clear memo/note referencing your specific case number from the CP2000. This helps ensure it gets applied to the correct tax year and issue.
0 coins
Sasha Reese
โขThat's a really good point about keeping all the documentation. Should I also be sending the payment by certified mail or some other trackable method? And do I need to include a copy of the latest CP2000 with my payment?
0 coins
Laila Prince
โขAbsolutely send your payment via certified mail with return receipt requested. That gives you proof of exactly when you sent it and when they received it. I would recommend including a copy of the payment voucher from the CP2000 (not the entire notice), along with a brief letter stating that this payment is for the agreed amount on your CP2000 dated [specific date] for tax year 2019. Include your Social Security number, the notice number, and any other reference numbers on the CP2000. Better to include too much identifying information than not enough.
0 coins
Isabel Vega
Has anyone else noticed how often the left hand of the IRS doesn't know what the right hand is doing? Last year I had THREE different departments giving me THREE different answers about the exact same issue. One suggestion I haven't seen mentioned yet - if you can afford it, it might be worth getting a brief consultation with a tax attorney who specializes in Tax Court cases. They might only charge you for 30 minutes and could give you specific advice for your situation. Sometimes spending $150 on a consultation can save you thousands in headaches later.
0 coins
Dominique Adams
โขTotally agree about the IRS departments not communicating. I work at an accounting firm and we see this constantly. The examination department will agree to one thing while the collections department is still pursuing the original amount. For the OP, you might check if your local Low Income Taxpayer Clinic (LITC) can help. If you qualify based on income, they provide free representation.
0 coins