


Ask the community...
I still don't understand how our tax system works. If I'm in the 12% bracket based on my annual salary, why does a bigger check suddenly get taxed at 22%? That's nearly double! The system seems designed to confuse us. š¤
It's not that the bigger check is *actually* taxed at 22% - it's just that the withholding is calculated at 22% as an estimate. When you file your taxes, all your income is taxed based on your actual tax bracket. If you're really in the 12% bracket, you'll get the difference back as a refund. The IRS just has this rule about supplemental wages (bonuses, commissions, etc.) being withheld at a flat 22% rate to simplify things for employers. It's not a conspiracy, just a withholding method.
I totally get your frustration! I went through the same thing when I got my first big bonus. The 22% withholding on supplemental wages feels like a punch to the gut when you're expecting your regular withholding rate. What helped me was thinking of it this way: the payroll system doesn't know your full financial picture - it just sees a big paycheck and assumes you might be in a higher tax bracket. The 22% rate is like a "safety net" to make sure the IRS gets enough upfront, even if it's too much. You're absolutely right that it's annoying to give the government an interest-free loan, but at least you know you'll get it back at tax time if you're actually in the 12% bracket. Some people actually prefer the forced savings aspect, but I'm like you - I'd rather have my money now!
idk but my cousin had the same issue last year and it turned out to be a mistake on their end. keep pushing!
Have you tried calling the IRS directly at 1-800-829-1040? They can usually tell you if there are any holds or offsets on your account that might not show up on the Treasury offset line. Also, if you have an online IRS account, you can check your account balance there - sometimes it shows pending offsets before they actually process. Keep documentation of all your calls and reference numbers in case you need to dispute something later.
I've been filing taxes for over 15 years, and I've learned that while exceptions exist, it's best to assume the system works as designed. In my experience, about 95% of refunds follow the same pattern: transcript updates with an 846 code and DDD, then money arrives on that exact date (or 1-2 days early for certain banks). Last year I thought I might get paid early because my transcript hadn't updated but WMR showed approved, but it still followed the normal timeline. Just trying to set realistic expectations - the waiting game is tough but almost everyone goes through it.
I can share my experience from this filing season - I actually did receive my refund 2 days before the DDD appeared on my transcript! Filed in early February, transcript showed "still processing" for weeks, then suddenly got the direct deposit. The DDD (846 code) didn't show up until the day after I received the money. My bank (Chase) processed it on a Friday even though the official date was the following Monday. So yes, it can happen, though it seems pretty rare. I think it depends on your bank's processing schedule and how the IRS batches payments. Don't count on it happening, but it's not impossible. The transcript system definitely lags behind the actual payment processing sometimes.
Don't forget to look into cost segregation for your rental property! Instead of depreciating everything over 27.5 years, you can potentially break out components like appliances (5 years), carpeting (5 years), landscaping (15 years) etc. This accelerates your depreciation deductions in the early years. Also, take lots of "before" pictures and document everything. The IRS loves to challenge rental property deductions so having good records is crucial. I've been audited twice on my rental properties and good documentation saved me both times.
Is cost segregation worth it for a smaller property? I've heard the studies can be expensive. At what property value does it start making sense to do this?
Cost segregation definitely makes more sense as property values increase, but there are now more affordable options for smaller properties. As a rough guideline, properties valued at $400,000+ can usually benefit enough to justify the cost, but it depends on your specific situation. Some tax software now includes simplified cost segregation tools that are much more affordable than the traditional engineering-based studies. These can work well for single-family or small multi-family properties. The higher your tax bracket, the more valuable the accelerated depreciation becomes, so that's another factor to consider when deciding if it's worth it.
Make sure you understand the "placed in service" rules for your rental property. You can't start taking depreciation until the property is actually ready to be rented. If you're doing major rehab, depreciation starts when the property is habitable and you're actively trying to rent it - not when you first got the property. Also watch out for the passive activity loss limitations depending on your income level. If your rental shows a paper loss because of depreciation but your income is above certain thresholds, you might not be able to deduct those losses against your other income without some planning.
Thanks for mentioning the "placed in service" timing - that's something I was confused about! So even though I own the property now, I can't start depreciating until after all the rehab is done and I'm actively trying to find tenants?
Exactly right! The "placed in service" date is when the property is ready and available for rent, not when you acquire it. So if you're doing major rehab work, you'll need to wait until the property is in rentable condition before you can start claiming depreciation. However, don't forget that the improvement costs you're putting into the rehab will become part of your depreciable basis once the property is placed in service. So while you can't depreciate during the rehab period, those improvement costs aren't lost - they get added to your basis and then depreciated over the 27.5 year schedule starting from your placed-in-service date. Keep detailed records of all your rehab expenses separated by repairs vs improvements, as @a54173a88722 mentioned earlier. This documentation will be crucial when you're ready to start your depreciation schedule.
Luca Conti
Has anyone here actually formed an S-Corp after being sole prop? I'm considering it for 2023 after getting hit with massive SE taxes like OP. Is it worth the hassle and extra costs?
0 coins
Omar Hassan
ā¢I switched to S-Corp 3 years ago and it's saved me roughly $7,500-9,000 annually in SE taxes. There are definite costs though - I pay about $1,200/year for payroll service and S-Corp tax prep, plus have to maintain better records. The general rule I've found is that S-Corps start making financial sense when your net profit is consistently above $60,000-80,000. Below that, the compliance costs often outweigh the SE tax savings. You also need to be disciplined about paying yourself a "reasonable salary" which is a somewhat gray area that can get you in trouble if you're too aggressive.
0 coins
Omar Hassan
ā¢I use Gusto for payroll and it's been great - very user-friendly and they handle all the tax filings and payments automatically. There are cheaper options like SurePayroll or even PayrollCity that might work if you're looking to minimize costs. You have flexibility with payroll frequency. Many S-Corp owners do quarterly or even annual payroll to minimize processing fees, and that's perfectly acceptable to the IRS. Just make sure your total salary for the year meets the "reasonable compensation" standard. I personally do quarterly to keep things simple and to spread out my personal tax withholdings throughout the year.
0 coins
Daniel Rogers
I've been in a similar situation and it's incredibly frustrating! Unfortunately, as others have confirmed, retroactive S-Corp elections for 2022 are essentially impossible at this point. The deadlines are very strict. However, don't give up on reducing your SE tax burden! A few additional strategies to consider: 1. **Quarterly estimated payments for 2025** - Start making them now to avoid underpayment penalties and spread the cash flow impact 2. **Maximize retirement contributions** - If you haven't already, consider a SEP-IRA contribution (up to 25% of net SE income or $66,000 for 2023, whichever is less). This reduces your taxable income. 3. **Payment plan with IRS** - If the tax bill is overwhelming, the IRS offers installment agreements. You'll pay interest, but it can make the burden manageable. 4. **Professional review** - Given the size of your potential tax bill, it might be worth having a CPA or EA review your return one more time before filing to ensure you're not missing any legitimate deductions. For 2023 and beyond, definitely explore S-Corp election if your profits justify it. The SE tax savings can be substantial once you account for the additional compliance costs. Hang in there - this too shall pass!
0 coins
Yara Sayegh
ā¢This is really helpful advice, especially the point about quarterly estimated payments for 2025. I'm definitely going to look into the SEP-IRA contribution - I hadn't realized I could still make a contribution for 2022 that would reduce my SE income. The payment plan option is also something I need to seriously consider. Do you know if there are any penalties for setting up an installment agreement, or is it just the interest charges? My cash flow is pretty tight right now so spreading this out would be a huge relief. I'm also curious about the professional review suggestion - at what point does it make sense to pay for a second opinion? My tax situation isn't incredibly complex, but given the size of this SE tax bill, maybe it's worth the investment.
0 coins