


Ask the community...
Have you considered investing the would-be Q3 and Q4 estimated payments? Since you're definitely going to overpay, you could put that money into a high-yield savings account or short-term CD until you file next year. At current rates, you could make a few hundred dollars of interest on that money instead of giving it to the government. It's not a solution to the overpayment, but at least you'd get something back on the money you've already overpaid.
That's a really good point! I hadn't thought about the opportunity cost of just letting that money sit with the IRS. Any specific recommendations for where to park those funds for ~6-8 months that would be relatively safe but still give decent returns?
Treasury bills are probably your best bet right now for short-term parking of funds. 6-month T-bills are yielding around 5.3% as of last week, which is better than most high-yield savings accounts. They're backed by the federal government so essentially risk-free. Alternatively, several online banks have special CD promos right now in the 5.0-5.5% range for 6-9 month terms. Just make sure there's no early withdrawal penalty or that it's minimal in case you need the funds before your tax filing.
I made the EXACT same mistake last year! My reccomendation is to stop make estamated payments immediately if your wireholding will already cover everythibg. Then I'd suggest changing your W-4 to have ZERO taxes taken out for the rest of the year if possible! This is totally legla if you've already met your tax obligation thru withholding + estimated tax payments. I did this last July and had way biger paychecks for the second half of the year which was nice but still ended up with a $8k refund which sucks. Don't try to generate extra income or capital gains to "use up" the credits - that makes no financial sense!
Be careful with changing to zero withholding - you need to make sure you meet one of the safe harbor provisions first. Either 90% of current year tax or 100% of last year's tax (110% if you're a higher earner). If you've already paid enough through Q1+Q2 estimated payments plus year-to-date withholding to cover that, then yes, you can go to zero for the rest of the year.
For Schedule A line 5a specifically, don't forget you can also include: - State income taxes paid with your previous year's state return (if you owed) - Any state estimated tax payments you made during the year - Local income taxes (city or county) if you have those A lot of people just put their W-2 state withholding which might be leaving money on the table!
Question: if I paid state taxes when I filed last year (April 2024 for tax year 2023), which tax year does that count for on Schedule A - 2023 or 2024?
It counts for the year you actually paid it. So if you paid additional state taxes in April 2024 when you filed your 2023 return, that payment would be a deduction on your 2024 Schedule A (the return you'll file in 2025). This is a common misunderstanding! The rule is that you deduct state and local income taxes in the year you actually pay them, not the tax year they apply to. So keep those payment records handy for this year's taxes.
Anyone know if foreign income taxes can be listed on Schedule A line 5a as well? I worked overseas for 3 months last year.
You usually have two options for foreign taxes - you can take a credit using Form 1116 OR deduct them on Schedule A. The credit is generally better because it reduces your tax directly rather than just reducing taxable income. But it depends on your specific situation.
Don't forget you can also try contacting the payroll provider your company used rather than the company itself! Most businesses use third-party payroll services like ADP, Paychex, or Gusto, and those companies often retain records and provide employee portals. If you know which service your employer used, try contacting them directly. I was able to get W2s from 3 years ago this way after my previous employer went out of business.
That's a great idea! I think they used ADP actually. Do you know if there's a general customer service number for employees to contact them or would I need a specific account number?
For ADP, try calling their W2 services line at 800-247-3237. You'll need to verify your identity with your SSN and some other basic info. If you had an online account with them previously, you might still be able to log in at https://my.adp.com even if you no longer work there. If you don't know what service they used, try asking former coworkers if you're still in touch with any. Even if you don't have an account number, most payroll providers can look you up by SSN and previous employer.
Umm, isn't anyone else wondering why this person needs their pre-tax income? The mortgage company should be looking at your adjusted gross income (AGI), not pre-tax income. That's what they use to calculate debt-to-income ratios. Just use line 11 on your 1040. Pre-tax doesn't matter for most loan qualifications.
Some lenders do look at gross income before certain deductions. Self-employed people especially get evaluated differently. My mortgage broker wanted to see my gross contractual income rather than just what showed up on my tax return after all the deductions.
That makes sense for self-employed people, but OP mentioned a W2 which typically means they're an employee. For W2 employees, lenders usually just want Line 1 of the 1040 or Box 1 of the W2. Pre-tax retirement contributions don't usually get added back in unless the loan is borderline and they need to squeeze out a bit more qualifying income. If they're trying to qualify for a specific loan amount, they might want to know the maximum income they can claim. But generally, mortgage underwriters follow pretty standardized guidelines for W2 employees.
Have you tried looking at the state-specific forum on H&R Block's website? Sometimes there are known issues with specific states that they post about there. Last year there was a glitch with New York state returns that was causing random rejections. Also, might be worth calling H&R Block support directly. Their free version does include support for state filing issues - most people don't realize this. The number should be in your account under "Help" or "Contact Us".
H&R Block's support isn't great in my experience. I called them last year with a similar issue and waited 1.5 hours just to have them tell me to "try again tomorrow" which didn't solve anything. They just read from scripts and don't have access to the actual state rejection reasons.
That's surprising to hear. I've had decent experiences with their phone support, but I guess it depends on who you get and maybe the time of year. You're right that early April is probably their busiest time so support quality might drop. An alternative is to try their live chat support instead of phone. The wait times are usually much shorter and you can get a transcript of the conversation which is helpful when following their instructions.
Have you tried using a different tax software? Sometimes the issue is with how one particular tax program formats the submission. I switched from H&R Block to FreeTaxUSA after having similar problems and my return went through fine. Most tax programs will let you import your info from a PDF of your H&R Block return, so you don't have to start completely from scratch. Might be worth trying if nothing else works!
AstroAdventurer
I think the answer depends on the complexity of the question. For basic stuff like "Can I deduct my mortgage interest?" I don't need to research. But for anything with nuance or that seems unusual, absolutely research it. I've seen too many colleagues confidently give wrong answers because they didn't bother to check. Tax law is too complex and changes too often to rely solely on memory.
0 coins
Javier Mendoza
ā¢What's your go-to research source? I've been using the IRS website but sometimes it's hard to navigate.
0 coins
AstroAdventurer
ā¢My primary research source is the actual Internal Revenue Code and Treasury Regulations when I need definitive answers. They're comprehensive but can be dense reading. For day-to-day questions, I use a combination of CCH IntelliConnect and Bloomberg Tax. They're subscription services but worth every penny for the time they save and the confidence they provide. They include practical explanations, examples, and citations to relevant code sections and cases. I also frequently check IRS publications for more straightforward explanations, though they don't cover every nuance.
0 coins
Emma Wilson
Any1 else think its crazy how many tax pros just make stuff up? Had a client come to me after another preparer told them they could deduct 100% of meals (wrong) and their entire cell phone bill as a business expense without documentation (also wrong). When I asked the client if the preparer researched this, they said "no he seemed very confident." Confidence ā correctness in taxes!!
0 coins
Malik Davis
ā¢Omg yes! Just had someone come to me with a MESS of a return from last year. Previous preparer had claimed random deductions with zero documentation and now they're being audited. Be confident in your research, not your memory!
0 coins