


Ask the community...
This might be a software issue more than a tax rule issue. I've found that sometimes the sequence of questions in tax software can trip you up. Try this: 1) Enter the 1098-C information first 2) When it asks if the vehicle was gifted, say NO initially 3) Complete the car donation section 4) Go back and edit your entries to indicate it was a gift, but make sure you enter the original purchase date and estimated value from when your family member bought it (not when they gave it to you) This worked for me last year with a similar donated car situation in H&R Block software.
Would this approach work in TurboTax too? I'm having almost the identical issue but with TT and a car my grandpa gave me that I donated to a local charity.
Yes, the approach works in TurboTax too. The key is the sequence of entering information. TurboTax tends to make assumptions if you immediately identify something as a gift. Enter the donation details first, then go back to modify the acquisition information. For TurboTax specifically, after entering the 1098-C information, look for the "Asset Information" section where you can edit the basis details. Enter what your grandfather originally paid for the car (estimate if needed) and when he purchased it originally. This establishes a proper basis instead of the $0 that TurboTax might default to.
I think everyone is overcomplicating this. If you have a 1098-C showing gross proceeds over $500, your deduction is simply limited to that amount - period. The gift aspect shouldn't matter at all for a vehicle donation. The charity sold it for $650, so that's your maximum deduction (assuming you itemize). Check if you selected "Noncash Charitable Contributions" correctly in your tax software. You may have accidentally selected a different type of donation that's triggering these basis questions.
That's not quite right. The basis absolutely matters with donated property, even vehicles. The deduction is limited to the LESSER of your basis or the gross proceeds reported on the 1098-C. So if your basis is $0 (which can happen with fully depreciated gifted property), your deduction would also be $0, even if the charity sold it for more.
I stand corrected! You're right about the "lesser of" rule. I checked Publication 526 and it does specify that for vehicle donations, your deduction is limited to the smaller of your basis or the gross proceeds from the charity's sale. This explains why the software is asking about the gift - it's trying to determine the basis. If the original owner had already fully depreciated the car (common for older vehicles), then the basis might indeed be $0, which would limit the deduction to $0 regardless of sale proceeds.
Has anyone tried H&R Block's free file option for self-employment? Their website says they support Schedule C but I'm not sure if that's only in their paid versions.
H&R Block's truly free version doesn't support Schedule C or self-employment income. You'd need their Self-Employed version which runs about $85 for federal filing plus another $37 per state. I switched from them to FreeTaxUSA last year and saved a ton of money. H&R Block isn't terrible, but they're almost as expensive as TurboTax for self-employment stuff.
One option nobody's mentioned yet is using the IRS's fillable PDF forms directly. They're free, and you can file electronically in most states. It's not as user-friendly as the guided options, but if you're comfortable with basic tax concepts, it's doable. I switched to this method after using TurboTax for years, and while there was a learning curve, I actually understand my taxes better now. Plus I save about $200 each year not paying for the self-employed version of commercial software.
I've thought about going the direct form route, but I'm a bit intimidated by figuring out depreciation schedules on my own. Did you find good resources for learning how to do that part correctly? I'm comfortable with the general Schedule C stuff but some of the more technical aspects make me nervous about doing it without software guidance.
I found Publication 946 from the IRS really helpful - it explains all the depreciation rules. There are also some free online depreciation calculators that can help you determine the right amounts. I created a spreadsheet that I update each year for tracking my business assets and depreciation. The first year was definitely the hardest, but now I just update my spreadsheet annually. I actually feel more confident now because I understand exactly what's happening rather than trusting software to make the right choices for me. If you're comfortable with spreadsheets, it's totally doable with a bit of research.
One thing nobody's mentioned is that the home office deduction can sometimes trigger audits if not done correctly. Make sure you're being reasonable with what you claim. For example, claiming 50% of your apartment as "office space" is going to raise flags. Also remember you need to file Form 8829 if you're using the regular method. If you're using the simplified method, it's much easier - you just fill out a worksheet on Schedule C.
If I have multiple side businesses I run from the same home office, can I claim the deduction for each business or is it one deduction total? And does having a home office deduction affect selling your house later with the capital gains exclusion?
You can't double-dip by claiming the same home office space for multiple businesses. You need to allocate the space between your businesses based on usage, but the total can't exceed 100% of that space. For example, if you use your office 60% for Business A and 40% for Business B, you'd deduct those percentages of your eligible home office expenses on each business's Schedule C. Regarding capital gains, yes, there's an impact. If you've taken depreciation on your home through the regular method home office deduction, you'll need to recapture that depreciation when you sell. The simplified method doesn't include depreciation, so it doesn't affect your capital gains exclusion the same way. This is actually a big advantage of the simplified method that many people overlook.
Has anyone here been audited for their home office deduction? What was your experience? I've been taking it for 3 years and am worried that I haven't kept good enough records.
I was audited two years ago. They mainly wanted to verify that my office was exclusively used for business. I provided photos, a diagram of my apartment showing the dedicated room, and my work calendar showing regular use. They also looked at my utility bills compared to what I deducted. Since I had most documentation, it went smoothly, but it was stressful. Now I keep way better records.
Quick question - are you filling as a dependent on someone else's taxes? My sister had this exact problem and it turned out our parents had claimed her, which affected her ability to take the education credits.
One little trick I learned with H&R Block specifically - sometimes you need to go back and purposely change an answer then change it back again to get the education credits to "refresh" and show up. Try going back to the education section, change something minor, then change it back and continue forward. Stupid software glitch but it worked for me last year!
Sean Fitzgerald
Something no one mentioned yet - if you have a home office deduction for self-employment, don't forget you can also deduct office supplies, equipment, and business-related software! I spent about $1,200 on a new desk, ergonomic chair, printer, and some organizational stuff for my home office last year, and deducted all of it as business expenses separate from the actual home office space deduction. Also, if you use your personal cell phone partially for business, you can deduct that percentage of your phone bill. Same with internet if you haven't already included it in your home office calculation.
0 coins
Zara Khan
ā¢Can you deduct things like a coffee maker or mini fridge in your office space? I have both in mine and use them exclusively during work hours, but wasn't sure if that crosses into "personal use" territory.
0 coins
Sean Fitzgerald
ā¢This gets into a gray area. The coffee maker and mini fridge would generally be considered conveniences rather than necessities for business function. The IRS might view these as personal items even if used during work hours. The key test is whether they're ordinary and necessary for your specific business. For example, if you regularly have client meetings in your home office and provide refreshments, you might have a stronger case. But for most home offices, these items would be scrutinized in an audit. If you do claim them, keep detailed logs showing they're used exclusively for business purposes. Personally, I'd be cautious about claiming these unless they're clearly tied to a business need beyond personal convenience.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
Quick warning about home office deductions that I learned the hard way - if you take depreciation using the regular method, you'll have to pay some of that back (called "recapture") when you sell your house. I sold my house last year and got hit with an unexpected tax bill because I'd been claiming home office deductions for 7 years. Not saying don't take the deduction, just be aware and maybe set aside some of those tax savings for the future if you think you might sell. The simplified method doesn't have this issue since there's no depreciation component.
0 coins
Mateo Gonzalez
ā¢How much was the recapture? Was it a significant amount? I've been doing the regular method for 4 years now but might switch to simplified if the recapture is really bad.
0 coins
MoonlightSonata
ā¢It was about $7,400 in my case, which definitely hurt. I had been deducting about 20% of my 1,500 sq ft house for 7 years, so it added up. The recapture is basically taxing the depreciation benefit you received over the years. If you've only been doing it for 4 years, it won't be as bad as mine was, but it's something to consider. I would have probably still done the regular method because the yearly tax savings were significant, but I wish I'd put some of those savings aside knowing I'd have to pay some back eventually. The simplified method is safer if you don't want to deal with recapture later.
0 coins