


Ask the community...
One thing nobody has mentioned yet - check if you can adjust your withholding for the remainder of the year instead of making it permanent. My wife and I had a similar situation and our payroll department let us do a one-time additional withholding to catch up for the year. We just submitted a request to take an extra $3000 out of one paycheck (split between both of us) rather than changing the W-4 permanently. Might be less paperwork if your employer allows it!
That's a great suggestion! I didn't know you could do a one-time withholding adjustment. Would I just ask our HR department about this option?
Yes, exactly! Just reach out to your HR or payroll department and ask if they allow one-time additional withholding requests. Most larger companies have a form for this. It's sometimes called a "one-time deduction request" or "special payroll deduction." The advantage is you don't have to remember to change your W-4 back later, and you can handle the entire under-withholding issue in one shot instead of spread across multiple paychecks. Just make sure to keep a copy of whatever form you submit and follow up to confirm it was processed correctly!
Don't forget to recheck your W-4s in January! I made this mistake - fixed my withholding after getting a similar letter, but then forgot to update it for the new year and ended up in the same situation again. The IRS withholding calculator becomes available with updated tax tables usually by early February each year. I now put a reminder in my calendar to check our withholding quarterly.
Anyone know if I need to attach any additional documentation when submitting Form SS-8? My employer is definitely going to fight this classification issue, and I want to make sure I have everything covered from the start.
When I filed SS-8 last year, I included copies of my contract, emails showing how they controlled my work schedule and processes, and a detailed description of my daily work responsibilities. The more evidence you have showing employer control, the stronger your case. Remember the key factors are behavioral control, financial control, and relationship type. Document everything that shows they treated you like an employee!
Thanks for the detailed advice! I definitely have emails showing them dictating my hours and how to do tasks. I'll compile those along with my contract. Did you also include any information about other employees doing similar work who were classified as W-2 instead of 1099?
Fyi - I tried doing this with TurboTax last year and their software didn't properly support Form 8919. Ended up having to switch to TaxAct at the last minute. Glad to hear FreeTax USA supports it better!
One important thing no one has mentioned yet - make sure you're getting Form 8832 from the Montessori school with their tax ID number and payment information. You'll need this to properly document the childcare expenses for the Child and Dependent Care Credit. Also, there are income limits and maximum credit amounts to be aware of. For one child, the maximum expenses you can claim is $3,000 per year (or $6,000 for two or more children). The actual credit percentage depends on your income level.
Thanks for mentioning the form! Quick question - is it Form 8832 or did you mean something else? I've been looking online and Form 8832 seems to be related to business entity classification, not childcare expenses. Is there a different form number I should be asking my son's Montessori for?
You're absolutely right, I made a mistake with the form number. I meant to say that you should get documentation from the childcare provider, which is typically reported on Form 2441, not 8832. Most providers will give you a receipt or year-end statement with their tax ID (EIN) and the total amount you paid during the year. Some providers will complete Form W-10 (Dependent Care Provider's Identification and Certification) which gives you their official information for tax purposes. That's what you'll need when completing Form 2441 to claim the Child and Dependent Care Credit. Thanks for catching my error!
Has anyone actually had success claiming Dependent Care Credit when their ex claimed the child as a dependent? I've been told conflicting things by different preparers.
Yes! I successfully did this last year. The key is that you must have custody for more than half the nights of the year to claim the Dependent Care Credit, even if your ex claims the child as a dependent due to your agreement. I had to paper file though, because TurboTax kept giving me errors when I tried to enter it this way.
Here's what my CPA told me about this exact situation: The CUSIP is basically just an identifier for the specific fund/security. For IRS matching purposes, they only care about the federal payer ID. If you report the total amount that matches what Vanguard reported to the IRS under their payer ID, you won't have any issues. But listing each fund separately (still using the one payer ID) makes it easier to track cost basis if you sell shares in the future.
Does this same approach work for 1099-INT forms with multiple interest payments from the same bank? I have like 15 different accounts at the same credit union and they're all on one form.
Yes, the same principle applies to 1099-INT forms with multiple accounts from the same financial institution. You can list each account separately on Schedule B using the same payer ID for all of them, or combine them into one line item. For 15 different accounts, I'd probably combine them unless you really need to track each account separately for some reason. Most tax software has a limit on how many entries it will accept for the same payer before suggesting you consolidate them anyway.
Has anyone notice that different tax software handles this differently? In H&R Block, it automatically combines all entries with the same payer ID. But when I tried TurboTax at my friend's house, it let me enter each fund individually.
Ava Johnson
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - make sure you look into the EITC (Earned Income Tax Credit) rules too if you're going to claim them. There are special rules for claiming EITC with qualifying children, and the disability status might actually help you qualify for more. Plus don't forget about the Child Tax Credit and the Credit for Other Dependents. When I claimed my niece who has special needs, I got way more back than I expected because of these credits. Just make sure you have documentation of their diagnosis and any expenses related to their care.
0 coins
Liam O'Donnell
ā¢Thanks for mentioning this! Do you know if I would qualify for the Child Tax Credit specifically, or would it be the Credit for Other Dependents since I'm the grandparent, not the parent? Also, would my daughter still be able to get the disability benefits if I claim the kids on my taxes?
0 coins
Ava Johnson
ā¢You can potentially qualify for the Child Tax Credit even as a grandparent! The relationship test for the CTC includes grandchildren. As long as they meet the other tests (lived with you more than half the year, you provided more than half their support, they're under 17, etc.), you can claim the full Child Tax Credit, which is worth much more than the Credit for Other Dependents. Your daughter can continue receiving the disability benefits for the children regardless of who claims them on taxes. The tax dependency status and disability benefits eligibility are separate systems. The important thing is that you're actually using the majority of resources (including your own money plus a portion of those benefits) to support the children.
0 coins
Miguel Diaz
Has anyone dealt with the autistic dependent situation specifically? My grandson is also on the spectrum and I found there are additional tax benefits I qualified for, like the Child and Dependent Care Credit if you pay for specialized care while you work. Also, some therapy expenses might qualify as medical expenses if you itemize deductions instead of taking the standard deduction.
0 coins
Zainab Ahmed
ā¢Yes! We claim my wife's brother who has autism and we deduct a lot of his therapy expenses as medical expenses. If their medical expenses exceed 7.5% of your AGI, you can itemize and deduct them. Also look into FSA or HSA accounts to pay for these expenses pre-tax if possible.
0 coins