


Ask the community...
Here's something nobody mentioned yet - have you checked if your parents already claimed you as a dependent on their return? If they did, and then you file an amendment claiming yourself as independent, it's going to cause problems. Before you go further with fixing the technical form issues, make sure your parents understand you're filing as independent. If they've already claimed you and filed, one of you will need to make an adjustment. The IRS computers will flag conflicting claims for the same person.
That's actually a really good point I hadn't considered. I did talk to my parents before filing the amendment and they agreed I should file as independent since I provided more than half of my own support last year. But now that you mention it, I'm not 100% sure they didn't already claim me on their return that they filed back in February. Should I have them check their return before I fix mine? Would that affect the specific error I'm getting about the credits not matching?
Definitely have them check their return first. The error you're getting about credits not matching could actually be indirectly related to this dependent status issue. When you change from dependent to independent, it affects multiple calculations throughout your return. The issue might be that TurboTax is trying to give you credits that you're eligible for as an independent filer, but the system is getting confused because there's conflicting information about your status in the IRS database. If your parents claimed you, the IRS computers may be rejecting certain credits you're trying to claim on your amended return, causing those total amounts to be inconsistent.
Why not just call TurboTax support directly? They deal with these specific error codes all the time. The error message is clearly about the tax credits not matching up between forms, and they should be able to walk you through exactly which fields to check. I had a similar rejection with a different code last year, and the TurboTax rep actually did a screen share with me and pointed out exactly where the inconsistency was. Much easier than trying to figure it out yourself.
Have you checked the Get My Payment tool on the IRS website? Even though you filed late, it might give you info about your stimulus payment status. That's how I tracked mine.
I tried the Get My Payment tool but it's not showing any info for me. I think because I filed so late (just this March for previous years), the system might not be updated yet. Has anyone else had luck with this tool after filing really late?
The Get My Payment tool probably isn't showing your info because it's designed for tracking the original distribution of stimulus payments, not for tracking payments that are being processed as Recovery Rebate Credits on tax returns. At this point, your best bet is to check your tax transcript on the IRS website. It'll show any credits applied to your account and any refunds scheduled to be issued. Sometimes this updates before the Where's My Refund tool shows anything.
This happened to me last year. The IRS applied my stimulus to my back taxes automatically, then sent me what was left over. It took about 6 weeks after they processed my return. You should get a notice explaining the breakdown of how they applied it.
One thing nobody has mentioned yet is that your father needs to be aware of recapture rules if he doesn't maintain 100% business use for the entire recovery period. If business use drops below 50% in future years, he could face significant recapture of the benefit. Also, there are phase-out schedules for both the bonus depreciation and the EV credit depending on the year of purchase. Bonus depreciation under 168(k) is scheduled to phase down 20% each year starting in 2023, and the EV credit has manufacturer sales caps and income limits. Make sure he's working with a tax professional who can help him understand all the implications before making such a large purchase.
Thanks for bringing up the recapture issue - that's something I wasn't aware of. What exactly is the "recovery period" and how long would he need to maintain business use? He plans to use it exclusively for business for at least 5 years. Also, do you know if there's an income limit that might prevent him from claiming the full EV credit? His 1099 income fluctuates year by year.
The recovery period for vehicles is typically 5 years, so your father's plan to use it exclusively for business during that time would avoid recapture issues. If business use drops below 50% during those 5 years, he would need to recapture the excess depreciation taken and report it as ordinary income. Yes, there are income limits for the EV credit. For a single filer, the credit begins to phase out at $150,000 AGI and is eliminated at $160,000. For married filing jointly, those thresholds are $300,000 and $310,000 respectively. With fluctuating 1099 income, he should do some tax planning to see if he'll fall under these limits in the year of purchase. If he's close to the threshold, he might want to consider timing the purchase or implementing strategies to reduce his AGI for that year.
Another consideration - make sure to check if the specific Tesla model is eligible for the full $7500 credit. Not all EVs qualify for the full amount anymore due to battery sourcing requirements. The IRS maintains a list of qualifying vehicles and their credit amounts. Also, don't forget about potential state incentives! Many states offer additional tax credits or rebates for EV purchases on top of the federal benefits.
This is an excellent point. The Inflation Reduction Act changed the requirements, and now the vehicle must meet North American final assembly requirements. Additionally, there are critical mineral and battery component requirements that affect the credit amount. Tesla has been adjusting their supply chain to qualify, but it varies by model and can change.
One thing nobody's mentioned yet - if your wife's business is still fairly new, it might be operating at a loss. If that's the case, filing jointly is almost definitely better because those business losses can offset your W2 income, potentially putting you in a lower tax bracket. Also, with a December baby, make sure you claim the Child Tax Credit - that's up to $2,000 for 2024 taxes. You qualify for the full amount with your income level.
Thanks so much for mentioning this! My wife's business is actually still in the investment phase and will probably show a small loss for 2024. I didn't even think about how that might offset my W2 income if we file jointly. Do you know if there are any limits to how much business loss can offset regular income? And yes, we'll definitely claim the Child Tax Credit!
There are some limits, but they probably won't affect you. The business loss can generally offset your other income, but if the loss is very large (over $270,000 for married filing jointly in 2024), it might be subject to the excess business loss limitation. For most small businesses with moderate losses, you can use the full amount of the loss to offset your W2 income. This is a huge advantage of filing jointly - if you filed separately, your wife's business loss could only offset her income, not yours.
Don't forget about self-employment taxes too! Your wife will need to pay those on her business profits (15.3% for Social Security and Medicare). That's on top of regular income tax. If her business isn't making much profit yet, the tax hit won't be bad. But once she starts making good money, you might want to look into forming an S-Corp instead of sole proprietorship to save on some of those SE taxes.
Yeah but S-Corps come with their own headaches. You have to run payroll, file more complicated returns, etc. I wouldn't recommend it until the business is making at least $40k in profit.
Emma Thompson
Don't forget that the "primary purpose" test also takes into account the reason you went to the location in the first place. If you would never have gone to that location except for the business conference, there's a stronger argument that business was the primary purpose, even with the extended stay. But with such a long personal portion (4 days business, ~26 days personal), you're definitely in allocation territory. Document everything related to the business portion extremely well. Also, be careful with your other deductions during the personal days - those hotel costs, meals, etc. during the vacation portion are not deductible at all.
0 coins
Malik Jackson
ā¢I've heard that you could potentially make a case that the primary purpose is business if the conference is in a location you wouldn't typically vacation in. Like if it's in a random midwest city in winter versus a beach destination. Does that actually hold up with the IRS?
0 coins
Emma Thompson
ā¢There's some truth to that, but it's more nuanced. The location factor is one element the IRS might consider, but it's not determinative by itself. The ratio of business to personal days is usually given more weight. However, if you can demonstrate that you wouldn't have made the trip at all except for the business purpose, it strengthens your position. But with a 4:26 day ratio of business to personal, that's going to be a tough argument to win regardless of location. The overwhelming personal time makes it clear that personal pleasure was a major consideration in the trip.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
Honestly I'd suggest just calling it what it is - a vacation with a small business component - and deducting accordingly. The risk of taking too aggressive a position isnt worth the small tax benefit. Plus with business travel deductions being such an audit trigger anyway, being conservative is probably the smarter move. I tried to get cute with mixed business/vacation travel a few years back, claiming everything was primarily business, and got totally hammered in an audit. Ended up owing back taxes plus penalties. Lesson learned the hard way!
0 coins
Connor Gallagher
ā¢Yikes, that's definitely not what I want! How detailed was the audit? Did they ask for specific documentation about what you did each day of your trip? I think I'll follow the allocation advice, better safe than sorry.
0 coins
Isabella Costa
ā¢The audit was surprisingly thorough. They asked for a daily itinerary showing exactly which hours were spent on business activities, names and business relationships of people I met with, and how each meeting related to my business. They also wanted to see emails setting up business meetings, conference registration receipts, and even questioned why I stayed extra days if I didn't have business activities scheduled. Good call on being conservative with your deductions. The few hundred dollars you might save taking an aggressive position isn't worth the headache of an audit, potential penalties, and interest if they disallow the deductions later.
0 coins