


Ask the community...
Tax Topic 151 can be confusing, but it generally means your refund is being held for review or offset. This could be due to several reasons: unpaid (student loans, child support, back taxes), identity verification issues, or the IRS needing additional documentation to verify your claims (like dependents or credits). Even if you don't think you owe anything, there might be old or issues from previous years. I'd recommend calling the IRS directly at 1-800-829-1040 to get specific details about your situation, or check your account online which will show any holds or codes. The wait times can be long, but it's the best way to get clarity on why your refund is delayed.
This is really helpful information! I'm new to dealing with tax issues and was wondering - if someone receives Tax Topic 151 but genuinely doesn't owe any debts, how long does the review process typically take? And is there a way to speed it up by proactively sending documentation, or do you have to wait for them to request specific documents first?
I'm going through something very similar right now! My LLC converted to an S-Corp in August 2024, and my CPA also put January 1, 2024 as the effective date on Form 2553. I was initially confused like you, but after reading through these responses and doing some research, it seems like this is actually a legitimate strategy. What I learned is that the IRS has specific relief procedures (like Rev Proc 2013-30 that others mentioned) that allow for retroactive S elections under certain circumstances. The key is that you have to demonstrate you intended S-Corp treatment from the beginning and meet the filing deadlines. I ended up calling the IRS Business line to check on my election status, and the agent confirmed they received it and said it looked fine. She mentioned that even if they can't approve the January 1st date, they'll just adjust it to the actual formation date - no penalties or major issues. My advice would be to give it a few weeks to process, then call to check the status. If there are any problems, the IRS will send you a letter explaining what needs to be corrected. Don't panic - this seems to be a pretty routine situation that accountants deal with regularly!
This is really reassuring to hear from someone going through the exact same situation! I've been losing sleep over this for the past few days thinking I might have messed up my entire S-Corp election. Your experience with the IRS agent saying it "looked fine" gives me a lot of hope. Did you have to wait long to get through when you called the Business line? I've been debating whether to call now or wait a bit longer for it to process. Also, when you say "a few weeks to process" - is that how long it typically takes for them to review Form 2553? I filed mine about 3 weeks ago and haven't heard anything back yet. Thanks for sharing your experience - it's exactly what I needed to hear!
I'm an enrolled agent and I see this confusion about Form 2553 effective dates all the time. Your accountant likely did this intentionally, and it's actually more common than you'd think. Here's what's happening: When you request a January 1st effective date for an entity formed later in the year, you're essentially asking the IRS to treat your corporation as an S-Corp for the entire tax year. This can be beneficial because: 1. You avoid filing a short-period C-Corp return for the pre-election period 2. You get S-Corp tax treatment (pass-through taxation) for the full year 3. It simplifies your tax compliance The IRS has specific procedures that allow this under certain circumstances. Revenue Procedure 2013-30 provides relief for late or retroactive S elections when you can show you intended S-Corp status from formation. However, you're right that the election can't technically be effective before the entity exists. What typically happens is: - If the IRS approves the January 1st date under the relief procedure, you get full-year S treatment - If they don't approve it, they'll automatically adjust it to your incorporation date (June 15, 2024) Either way, you won't face penalties as long as the form was filed within the 75-day window from incorporation. The IRS will send you a determination letter confirming the effective date they've approved. I'd recommend waiting 60-90 days from your filing date, then calling to check the status if you haven't received confirmation. Don't stress too much - this is a routine situation that gets resolved smoothly in most cases.
This is a really solid tax strategy that I've seen work well for many families. One additional consideration I'd suggest is timing the stock transfer and sale carefully. If your mom has other income sources (like Social Security or pension), you'll want to calculate her total projected income for the year to make sure the capital gain doesn't push her above the 0% bracket threshold. Also, consider whether she needs all $100k at once or if the renovations could be spread over multiple years. If you could gift and have her sell portions of the stock across 2-3 years, it might help keep her in that 0% bracket each year while also allowing you to use more of your annual gift exclusion ($18,000 per year) rather than dipping into your lifetime exclusion. Don't forget that she'll also need to meet the long-term capital gains holding period requirement (over 1 year), but since she inherits your holding period with the gifted stock, this shouldn't be an issue if you've held it long-term.
This is really helpful advice about spreading it across multiple years! I hadn't considered that approach. My mom's total income from her pension and Social Security is around $35k annually, so there's definitely room to stay within the 0% bracket even with some capital gains added in. The renovations could potentially be phased - we could do the most critical safety updates first (bathroom grab bars, ramp installation) and then tackle the kitchen and flooring next year. This way I could gift maybe $50k worth of stock this year and another $50k next year, keeping her well within the 0% capital gains threshold both years. Thanks for pointing out the holding period inheritance - I've held most of these stocks for 3+ years so that shouldn't be an issue. Really appreciate the strategic thinking here!
This is exactly the kind of thoughtful tax planning that can really benefit families in your situation. One thing I'd add to the excellent advice already given - make sure to keep detailed records of the original purchase dates and costs for all the stock you're gifting. The IRS can be particular about cost basis documentation, especially for older holdings. Also, since you mentioned your mom has mobility issues, you might want to consider setting up the brokerage account transfer and sale process to be as simple as possible for her. Many brokerages offer phone-based trading services for older clients, or you could potentially set up a limited power of attorney to help her execute the sales when she's ready. One last thought - if any of the renovation work qualifies for accessibility improvements, there might be additional tax credits available at the federal or state level that could further reduce her overall tax burden. Worth checking into!
Great point about the accessibility tax credits! I didn't even think about that. Do you know if things like wheelchair ramps and bathroom modifications typically qualify? And would those credits apply to my mom's tax return or could I potentially claim them if I'm paying for the work? Also really appreciate the suggestion about setting up the brokerage account to be user-friendly for her. She's not super comfortable with technology, so having a phone-based option would probably be much easier than trying to navigate online trading platforms.
Another option worth exploring - some hospitals have started offering remote work options for certain departments after COVID. My wife works in medical billing at a hospital and now works from home 3 days a week, which cuts her parking costs significantly. Might be worth asking if your role could support even partial remote work. Every little bit helps!
Unfortunately I'm a direct patient care tech so remote work isn't possible for me. I'm looking into all the pre-tax benefit options mentioned here though. Just found out my hospital does offer something called a "Transportation Spending Account" that might help! Meeting with HR next week to learn more.
That Transportation Spending Account sounds promising! I work at a different hospital system and we have something similar - it's been a game changer for my budget. You can typically use pre-tax dollars for parking, public transit, rideshare to/from transit stops, and even some bike expenses if you cycle to work. The way it works is they deduct the money from your paycheck before taxes are calculated, so you save on federal, state, and FICA taxes. For someone in your tax bracket, that $145/month parking expense could effectively cost you closer to $110-120 after tax savings. It's not a full deduction like the old days, but it's still significant relief. Make sure to ask HR about the annual limits (I think it's $315/month for 2024) and whether they have any waiting periods for enrollment. Some places only let you sign up during open enrollment or after qualifying life events. Good luck with your meeting!
Giovanni Martello
For real tho, dont forget to look into sales tax issues too. Depends on your state, but most require you to collect sales tax on the stuff you make and sell. It's separate from income tax and can bite you if you ignore it.
0 coins
Savannah Weiner
ā¢That's a really good point. I got hit with back sales taxes when my state found out about my Etsy shop. Do services like bathroom remodels have sales tax though? I thought it was just for products?
0 coins
Anastasia Fedorov
Great question about the sales tax! It really depends on your state, but many states do tax construction/remodeling services differently than just selling products. In my state, if you're providing both materials AND labor (like a full kitchen remodel), you typically need to collect sales tax on the total project cost, not just the materials. However, some states only tax the materials portion, and others have exemptions for certain types of construction work. Since Jessica mentioned a $14,500 kitchen remodel, that's definitely substantial enough that she should check with her state's department of revenue about sales tax requirements. The tricky part is that once you start doing bigger projects like this, you're clearly operating as a business rather than just selling occasional hobby items. Most states have thresholds where you need to register for a sales tax permit once you hit certain revenue levels. Better to get ahead of it now before it becomes a bigger issue down the road!
0 coins