
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I'm in a bit of a situation with one of my employees who went on a business trip overseas. They handled all the planning and arrangements since they're familiar with the country, which was super helpful for us. The trip was 100% business-related - meetings with clients, industry conferences, the works. Here's the issue - they put all the expenses on their personal credit card (hotels, flights, meals, transportation) with the understanding that I'd reimburse them when they got back. But things got crazy busy at the office after they returned, and now it's been about 4 months since the trip ended and I still haven't processed their reimbursement. I'm finally getting ready to cut them a check, but I'm worried about the IRS accountable plan rules. I know there are 3 requirements, and rule #2 says expenses need to be substantiated "within a reasonable period of time." My employee has all the receipts and documentation for the two-week trip, but I'm not sure if 4 months is considered reasonable. Some sources online mention 30 days as the standard timeframe. Would the reimbursement still qualify as an accountable plan expense if I pay them now? My accountant wasn't very helpful, just said "it's fine" without explaining why. Really appreciate any insights!
I'm wondering about a situation with my Roth IRA that's been bothering me. I've had some investments in my Roth that haven't performed well at all (down about 30% from what I put in). I know regular investment accounts allow for tax loss harvesting, but I'm confused about how this works with Roth IRAs. If I decide to withdraw money from my Roth IRA and I've lost money on those investments, can I use tax loss harvesting or claim a capital loss deduction on my tax return for the year I make the withdrawal? Or are Roth IRA losses treated differently since they're already tax-advantaged accounts? I'm trying to decide whether to cut my losses on these investments or just hold and hope they recover. Any clarification would be super helpful since I'm planning my tax strategy for next year!
Has anyone actually successfully claimed a Roth IRA loss on their taxes before? My tax software doesn't even seem to have a place to enter this.
I tried to claim a Roth IRA loss back in 2019 after closing all my accounts at a loss. My accountant said it had to be reported as a miscellaneous itemized deduction subject to the 2% AGI floor on Schedule A. But since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act suspended those deductions, it didn't actually benefit me at all. He said to hold onto the documentation in case the law changes back after 2025.
This is such a frustrating aspect of Roth IRAs that I wish was explained better upfront. I went through a similar situation a few years ago when some of my tech stocks in my Roth got hammered during a market downturn. What I learned the hard way is that while you can't claim the losses for tax purposes, you should still think strategically about what to do with underperforming investments in your Roth. Since there are no tax consequences for selling within the Roth, you have complete flexibility to reallocate without worrying about capital gains taxes. I ended up selling my losing positions and diversifying into broader index funds. Even though I couldn't write off the losses, getting out of concentrated positions that weren't recovering helped my Roth perform better over the long term. The tax-free growth on the recovery has been worth more than any tax deduction would have been. Also, if you're still contributing to retirement accounts, consider doing future contributions to taxable accounts where you CAN harvest losses, and keep your Roth focused on investments with the highest long-term growth potential.
I'm currently in college and unexpectedly made about $71,000 in short term capital gains this year. After doing some research about what taxes I owe, I stumbled across something called "estimated taxes" which I've never dealt with before. Then I found out about this "safe harbor rule" and I'm trying to figure out if it applies to my situation. From what I understand, since I didn't have any taxable income last year, when I filed my taxes for that year, my total tax owed on line 24 of Form 1040 was $0. I did have an internship this summer where they withheld taxes from my paychecks. Does this mean I qualify for the safe harbor rule? I'm really confused about whether I need to make estimated tax payments on these capital gains now or if I can just wait until tax filing season. Any help would be appreciated since this is all new to me!
Has anyone used TurboTax to handle estimated taxes for capital gains? Their interface is confusing me and I can't figure out where to input the estimated payment I already made.
Just want to add that if your capital gains came from crypto, make sure you're tracking all your transactions properly. The IRS is really cracking down on crypto reporting. I learned this the hard way when I got a CP2000 notice questioning my crypto gains.
This is so important! I made the mistake of not properly tracking my crypto transactions when I had similar gains. Make sure you have records of the date you bought, the date you sold, the purchase price, and the sale price for every transaction. If you used multiple exchanges, you'll need to gather data from all of them. There are tools like Koinly or CoinTracker that can help aggregate everything, but the key is being thorough with your record keeping from the start.
Hey folks, I could use some tax advice from others who've been in a similar situation. I'm a contract healthcare worker making about $118k this year. My deductions are pretty minimal, and I'm trying to find legit ways to reduce my tax burden. From what I've researched, forming an S Corporation might make sense at my income level, but I'm not totally convinced. My main concerns: About the reasonable salary requirement - I work roughly 28 hours weekly. The going rate for my profession in my area is about $37/hour. If I multiply that by 1456 hours annually, that's around $53.8k. Would the IRS consider this a reasonable salary? Or am I playing with fire? The startup costs worry me too. From what I understand, it'll cost $1500-2500 to get a tax professional to set this up and manage it properly. Plus there's the ongoing expense of filing those additional tax forms each year. My income situation is pretty stable - I'm not expecting dramatic growth since I'm billing hourly rather than building a scalable business. I also discovered there's a 5.5% corporate tax I'd need to pay in my state. When I run the numbers, I'm unsure if the self-employment tax savings actually justify all the extra costs and complexity. Is an S Corp really worth it for someone in my position, or am I better off staying as a sole proprietor until I'm earning significantly more?
One aspect nobody's mentioned is health insurance. As a >2% S Corp shareholder, your health insurance premiums can't be paid pre-tax through the company like regular employees. Instead, the company pays them, includes them as taxable wages on your W-2, then you deduct them on your personal return. This gets complicated and can impact your overall savings calculations, especially if you're purchasing your own health insurance as a healthcare contractor. Also, retirement options change. SEP IRAs are simple as a sole proprietor, but S Corps often use Solo 401(k)s instead, which allow for potentially higher contributions but more paperwork. Consider these factors in your total cost/benefit analysis. The tax savings need to outweigh ALL the additional complexities.
Based on your $118k income and 28-hour work week, you're right at the threshold where S Corp benefits become marginal. Here's what I'd consider in your position: Your reasonable salary calculation of $53.8k (28 hours ร $37/hour ร 52 weeks) is defensible, but consider using annual hours instead of weekly estimates to account for time off. The IRS likes to see documentation showing how you arrived at your salary. At your income level, you'd save roughly $9,800 in SE tax on the $64k distribution portion, but after factoring in setup costs (~$2,000), ongoing expenses (~$3,000-4,000 annually), and your state's 5.5% corporate tax (~$6,500), your net savings would be minimal - maybe $0-2,000 annually. Given the administrative burden and your stable hourly income model, I'd suggest waiting until you're consistently earning $140k+ before making the switch. At that point, the math becomes more compelling and justifies the complexity. For now, focus on maximizing your SEP-IRA contributions (up to $29,500 for 2024) and other deductions available to sole proprietors. The S Corp will still be there when your income grows.
So I've been trying to figure out why I have to pay so much to file my dang taxes every year. Did some digging online and found out something that really ticked me off! Apparently we could ALL be filing our taxes for free in like 5 minutes if companies like H&R Block and TurboTax weren't spending millions and millions in lobbying to keep the system complicated! Like, the IRS already has all our W-2 info and most of our financial details anyway. In other countries, they just send you a form that's already filled out, you check it, sign it, and you're done! But these tax prep companies are literally paying politicians to keep us confused and dependent on their expensive software. I paid $89 last year for TurboTax "Deluxe" just to file a pretty simple return. That's on top of the actual taxes I owed! Anyone else feel like we're being taken advantage of by this system? Have you found any actually free ways to file that don't have hidden fees or upsells?
I've been using FreeTaxUSA for the past 3 years and it's WAY better than TurboTax or H&R Block. Federal filing is completely free and state is only $15. No hidden upgrades or confusing tiers of service. Just straightforward filing.
This is exactly why we need more people to know about these alternatives! I've been using the actual IRS Free File program for years (when I can find it buried on their website), but it's ridiculous that they make it so hard to locate. The fact that TurboTax was literally hiding their free version from search engines should be criminal. We're talking about a basic government service that every citizen needs, and private companies are deliberately making it harder and more expensive just to pad their profits. What really gets me is that my tax situation isn't even complicated - just W-2 income and standard deduction - yet I was paying $60+ every year before I found the free options. Multiply that by millions of taxpayers and you can see why these companies fight so hard to keep the system broken.
Malik Thompson
Has anyone addressed whether foreign currency conversion is part of the substantiation requirement? My employee's trip had expenses in euros, but some of the credit card statements show the converted USD amount while others just show the euro amount.
0 coins
Yara Khalil
For foreign currency conversion, the IRS allows you to use either the actual exchange rate from the credit card statement (if available) or the official exchange rate for that date. Since your employee paid with their personal card, the simplest approach is to reimburse based on the USD amount shown on their credit card statement, as this reflects the actual cost to them including any conversion fees. For receipts that only show euros, you'll need to document what exchange rate you used for conversion and apply it consistently. Most accounting software can handle this automatically, or you can use the Treasury Department's official exchange rates if you want to be extra safe.
0 coins
Malik Thompson
Thanks for explaining! My employee's credit card included the USD conversion amount for most charges, so I'll use those. For the few that didn't convert, I'll look up the Treasury rates for those specific dates. Appreciate the help!
0 coins
Sean O'Donnell
One thing to keep in mind for future international business trips is to establish clear expectations upfront about expense documentation and reimbursement timing. I learned this the hard way when one of my employees went to Brazil and came back with a mix of Portuguese receipts, cash payments with no receipts, and credit card charges that took weeks to fully post. Now I require employees to: - Take photos of receipts immediately using a expense tracking app - Submit a preliminary expense report within 7 days of return (even if some charges haven't posted yet) - Provide final documentation within 30 days This has eliminated the stress of wondering whether we're meeting IRS requirements and makes the reimbursement process much smoother for everyone involved. It sounds like your employee did everything right with the documentation - it's just the processing delay on your end that caused concern.
0 coins