
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Title: Should a co-op housing association file Form 1120 or 1120-C for tax purposes? 1 I'm currently reviewing the books for a cooperative housing association and noticed something odd in their tax filing history. They've been filing Form 1120 (regular corporate tax return) every year, but since they're definitely a housing co-op, I would have expected them to use Form 1120-C (cooperative association tax return). I'm trying to determine whether I should continue with the Form 1120 for consistency or switch them to Form 1120-C, which seems more appropriate given their organizational structure. Is there any IRS guidance or rule that would permit a cooperative housing association to file using the standard 1120 instead of the specialized 1120-C form? The association has about 87 units and has been operating for approximately 15 years. I don't want to create issues with the IRS by suddenly changing their filing method, but I also want to make sure they're using the correct form going forward. Any insights from those with experience auditing CIRAs (Common Interest Realty Associations) would be greatly appreciated!
My tax issue somehow fixed itself and I'm not sure what happened. I filed an amended return about 3 months ago because I realized I made a mistake with my earned income credit. My transcript suddenly updated today with all these codes: 971 Notice issued 768 Earned income credit 846 Refund issued 971 Amended tax return or claim forwarded for processing 977 Amended return filed 43277-462-87615-2 290 Disallowed claim 89254-638-99014-2 This Product Con So basically my transcript is showing that my claim was disallowed but I still got a refund? I checked my bank account and the money actually hit yesterday. I never called the IRS or did anything after filing the amendment. Looking at the codes, it seems like they processed my amended return (977) and forwarded it (971), but then issued a notice (971) before applying the earned income credit (768) and issuing a refund (846). But then there's this "Disallowed claim" code (290) with a completely different reference number (89254-638-99014-2) than my amended return reference (43277-462-87615-2). I'm totally confused about why they would disallow my claim but still give me the money. The transcript seems contradictory. My original amendment was to correct my EIC calculation, which I think I underreported initially. Now I see they gave me the EIC (code 768) but also disallowed something (code 290). Did anyone else experience this type of confusion? Is this normal or should I be worried they'll take the money back? I don't want to spend this refund if they're going to suddenly realize they made a mistake and demand repayment.
I work as a tax professional and see this scenario frequently. What's happening is that the IRS processed different parts of your amended return separately. The code 768 (Earned Income Credit) and 846 (Refund Issued) show they approved and processed your EIC correction, which was likely the main focus of your amendment. The 290 "Disallowed claim" with the different reference number is probably rejecting a separate, smaller item on your return - maybe a deduction or credit that wasn't related to your EIC issue. This is actually how the system is designed to work now - they'll approve the clear-cut items (like correcting an EIC calculation error) while continuing to review other aspects. The different reference numbers indicate different processing tracks within their system. You should receive a CP12 or similar notice in the mail explaining exactly what was disallowed, but based on what you've described, you're entitled to keep the refund you received. The 846 code is your confirmation that the money is legitimately yours. Just keep good records of everything in case questions arise later.
I've seen a lot of confusion about how long it takes to get your refund after completing identity verification, so I wanted to share what I know based on my experience with the system. Here's a step-by-step breakdown of what actually happens after verification: 1. Initial verification processing: 1-2 weeks The IRS needs to confirm your identity was properly verified in their system. 2. Return to normal processing queue: 2-4 weeks Your return gets placed back in the normal processing queue, but not necessarily at the front. 3. Final review and approval: 1-2 weeks A final review is conducted before approval for refund release. 4. Refund issuance: 1 week Once approved, your refund is scheduled for direct deposit or check mailing. So while the IRS quotes 9 weeks as the maximum timeframe, in my experience and tracking multiple cases, the actual timeline is typically 5-7 weeks for most people after verification. The 9-week estimate is their way of managing expectations for worst-case scenarios. What has been your experience with post-verification timelines?
This is really valuable information! I'm currently going through the verification process myself and was getting anxious about the timeline. Based on what everyone is sharing, it seems like the actual experience is: โข Most people get their refunds in 4-6 weeks after verification โข The 9-week timeline is definitely a worst-case scenario buffer โข Transcript and WMR updates can be unreliable - sometimes the money just appears One thing I noticed from reading through these experiences is that the reason for verification seems to matter a lot. Simple identity verification appears to process faster than cases involving income discrepancies or other red flags. Has anyone kept track of whether filing early vs. late in the season affects post-verification processing times? I'm wondering if the timing of when you verify during tax season impacts how long it takes.
My refund got accepted January 26th then about ruffly two in a half weeks later I received the letter from the irs to call prove my identity which I did now couple days ago it says my refund been delayed but the amount hasnt changed and my transcript hasnt updated and transcript has a date on it march 9th
I accidentally went over my HSA contribution limit for 2023 by $750. I just realized my mistake and I'm planning to submit the excess contribution removal form to my HSA provider to fix this issue. I'm confused about what happens after I submit this form. Will my HSA provider send me a corrected 5498-SA for my 2023 taxes so I can avoid paying that 6% penalty? Or do I have to pay the penalty for 2023 and then file something different for 2024 to get that penalty money returned to me? I'm wondering if it would just be easier to pay the penalty and then reduce my 2024 HSA contribution by $750 instead. My main goal is to avoid any penalties if possible. This whole thing is giving me a headache. Also, how do I figure out how much interest this excess contribution has generated? Do I need to include that in what I remove?
I think you're overthinking this. I had the same issue last year (overcontributed by about $400) and just paid the 6% penalty. It came out to $24. Way easier than going through all this paperwork, waiting for corrected forms, calculating earnings, etc. If it were thousands of dollars, I'd worry more about the removal process, but for smaller amounts, sometimes the simplest path is just to pay the small penalty and move on with life. The forms and time involved in fixing it properly weren't worth it to me for such a small penalty amount.
That's terrible advice. Why would you willingly pay a penalty you can legally avoid? The excess contribution removal process isn't that complicated - most HSA providers have a simple form. Plus if you don't remove it, you either have to pay the penalty AGAIN the following year or reduce your contribution limit.
I understand the appeal of just paying the penalty to keep things simple, but there's another factor to consider. If you don't remove the excess contribution, it continues to be subject to the 6% penalty each year until you either remove it or reduce future contributions by that amount. So for your $400 overcontribution, you'd pay $24 this year, another $24 next year, and so on until it's addressed. That adds up over time and makes the removal process worth it even for smaller amounts.
Just to add one more perspective on timing - I'm a tax preparer and see this HSA overcontribution issue fairly often. The April 15th deadline for excess contribution removal is firm, but there's one thing that might help if you're really pressed for time. Some HSA providers will accept the removal request by phone and then send the paperwork afterward for your records. This can save a few days if you're cutting it close to the deadline. Just make sure to get that confirmation number and follow up to ensure they received your phone request. Also, regarding the extension - filing Form 4868 for an automatic extension is super straightforward and can be done online through the IRS website in just a few minutes. You don't need to provide a reason. This gives you until October 15th to file your actual return while still meeting the April 15th deadline for the HSA removal. One last tip: if your HSA is with a major provider like Fidelity, HSA Bank, or HealthEquity, they typically have dedicated HSA customer service lines with reps who are specifically trained on these excess contribution situations. Much more helpful than general customer service.
@Eli Butler I did not initially file for an extension because the excess contributions were identified after we knew about them medicare (was backdated We) removed them and the earnings, but I am struggling with the amended returns pursuant to 301.9100-2. Are the earnings reported in 2026 or 2025? Fidelity will not send and updated 1099-SA.
Adrian Connor
15 Great discussion here! As someone who's dealt with several cooperative housing associations over the years, I can confirm that the switch from Form 1120 to 1120-C is usually the right move for true housing co-ops. One thing I'd add is to carefully review the cooperative's bylaws and proprietary lease agreements before making the switch. The IRS looks at both the legal structure AND the actual operations to determine if an entity qualifies for cooperative tax treatment under Section 216. Key factors to check: - Do residents own shares in the corporation rather than individual units? - Are there proprietary leases tied to share ownership? - Does the co-op operate on a cost-recovery basis rather than for profit? - Are any patronage dividends or refunds distributed based on use/occupancy? If you can answer yes to these questions, Form 1120-C is definitely the way to go. The patronage dividend deductions alone can result in significant tax savings, as mentioned earlier in this thread. Also worth noting - if the co-op has been consistently profitable on Form 1120 filings, switching to 1120-C might reveal they've been missing opportunities to reduce taxable income through proper cooperative accounting methods.
0 coins
gil terriberry
Krappppp! Our previous treasurer was filing 1120-H with zero tax liability. Since her departure, we haven't filed anything. The last tax year filed was 2021. We're 16 units, market rate, and over 105 years old, have run out of a checking account the whole time as far as I can tell. How much trouble are we in?
0 coins
Sarah from Claimyr
Gil, sorry this waited so long. First, the IRS says Form 1120-H is for three kinds of homeowners associations: condominium management, residential real estate management and timeshare associations. Whether your co-op fits is worth confirming with a CPA, because most co-ops file Form 1120. Second, the federal late-filing penalty is figured on tax owed. For returns more than 60 days late, the minimum is $525 or 100% of the unpaid tax, whichever is less, so years with no tax due usually carry little federal penalty. Your state may differ. The usual fix is to file the missing years (2022 onward) with a CPA who works with co-ops, rather than waiting for a notice.
0 coins