


Ask the community...
H&R Block offers an Peace of Mindยฎ guarantee that covers penalties and interest if they make a mistake. Call them ASAP and explain the situation. But it sounds like they didn't make an error if you forgot to tell them about stock sales - that wouldn't be covered. You might still qualify for their Audit Support though, where they'll explain the notice and help you respond. Worth checking what your service package included!
I just got off the phone with H&R Block and you're right - since I didn't disclose the stock sales, they're not responsible. But they were still helpful and walked me through setting up an installment agreement with the IRS. Going to be tight financially for a while, but at least I understand what happened now. Lesson learned - I'll be much more careful tracking ALL my income next year!
Anna, glad you figured out what caused the discrepancy! Unreported stock sales are actually one of the most common reasons people get CP14 notices. The IRS automatically matches 1099-B forms from brokerages against tax returns, so they catch these pretty quickly. Since you've identified the issue and are setting up a payment plan, make sure to file an amended return (Form 1040X) to properly report the capital gains. This will show the IRS you're taking responsibility for the error. If you held the stocks for more than a year, you might qualify for lower long-term capital gains rates which could reduce what you owe. Also, keep detailed records of this whole process - if you ever face a similar situation in the future, having documentation of how you resolved it properly will be helpful. It's a stressful lesson but you're handling it the right way!
This is really helpful advice about filing the amended return! I hadn't even thought about that part. Quick question - do I need to wait until after I talk to the IRS about the payment plan to file the 1040X, or should I do it right away? I want to make sure I do everything in the right order so I don't accidentally complicate things further.
Has anyone tried negotiating for comp time instead of direct payment for training? My department also has zero budget for training, but my supervisor approved me taking a 2-day software course during work hours and counting it as regular work time. Technically, I still paid for the course myself, but not having to use PTO was worth about $350 in equivalent salary. Might be a partial solution if your manager has time approval flexibility even without budget authority.
This is actually a great workaround! My agency does something similar with a "professional development day" policy where we get 16 hours annually to use for approved courses/conferences. You still pay the registration fees, but at least you're on the clock. Worth asking if your county has any similar policies.
This is such a frustrating situation that so many government employees face! I've been dealing with something similar in my department. One thing that's worked for me is creating a "professional development portfolio" that I present during annual reviews. I document every training I've completed (even self-funded ones), how they've improved my work quality, and specific examples of projects where those skills made a difference. Last year, this approach helped me get approval for a reclassification review that came with a small pay bump. While it didn't directly reimburse my training costs, the extra income more than covered what I'd spent on professional development. The key was showing concrete ROI on the investments I'd already made. Also, check if your county participates in any state or federal professional development consortiums. Sometimes there are free or heavily subsidized training opportunities available through these programs that individual departments don't advertise well. Our HR finally sent out an email about a state-sponsored certification program that would have cost me $1,200 privately but was completely free through the consortium.
FYI everyone, banking gets complicated too! When I moved to Canada but kept working for my US employer, I maintained US bank accounts for direct deposit. Just remember that Canadian residents must report foreign accounts on Form T1135 if the total cost of all foreign assets exceeds CAD $100,000. Also, Canadian banks may limit services for US citizens due to FATCA reporting requirements. I had to shop around to find a bank comfortable with my dual-status situation.
Great question about dual citizenship vs permanent residency! From a tax perspective, there's actually no difference - both Canadian citizens and permanent residents are taxed on worldwide income once they establish Canadian tax residency. The key factor is where you're considered a resident for tax purposes, not your citizenship status. What matters more is establishing your "tax residency" date in Canada, which is typically when you move and establish significant residential ties (home, spouse/family, personal property). This date determines when you start filing Canadian tax returns and claiming foreign tax credits. One thing to watch out for with your $95K income: make sure you understand the timing of when to start claiming Canadian residency. If you move mid-year, you might be able to optimize which country gets primary taxing rights for that transition year. Also, don't forget about potential state tax obligations - some states like California are notoriously difficult to escape from a tax perspective even after you move to Canada. The Foreign Tax Credit should handle most of the double taxation, but you'll want to run the numbers carefully since Canadian tax rates vary significantly by province. Your effective tax rate in Canada could be higher or lower than what you're currently paying in the US depending on which province you choose!
This is really helpful info! I'm just starting to research this whole process and feeling pretty overwhelmed. When you mention "establishing significant residential ties" - what exactly counts as that? I'm planning to rent an apartment initially rather than buy, and I don't have a spouse or family to bring with me. Would things like getting a Canadian driver's license, opening local bank accounts, and registering for healthcare be enough to establish tax residency? Also, do you know if there's a minimum number of days I need to be physically present in Canada during that first year to qualify as a tax resident?
I feel like high schools should teach this basic tax info! I went years thinking I was being taxed at my highest bracket rate on ALL my income. Literally nobody explained the progressive system to me until I was 30.
100% agree. I'm a high school math teacher and I've been fighting to add a personal finance unit that includes tax calculations. The pushback I get is "it's too complicated" or "that's what tax preparers are for" - but this is such basic knowledge everyone should have.
@Abigail Spencer That s'so frustrating! Personal finance education is desperately needed. Even something as simple as explaining marginal vs effective tax rates could save people so much confusion and stress. I see posts like this all the time where people are genuinely worried they re'doing something wrong with their taxes when they just don t'understand the progressive system. Keep fighting the good fight - maybe you could start with a simple example like the one Austin posted above to show administrators how accessible this information can be when explained clearly.
This is such a great discussion! I had the exact same confusion when I first started doing my own taxes. One thing that helped me visualize the progressive tax system is thinking of it like filling up buckets - you fill the first "bucket" (lowest tax bracket) completely before moving to the next one, and each bucket has its own tax rate. For anyone using TurboTax, another way to see this breakdown is to look at Form 1040 after you've completed everything. Line 16 shows your total tax, and if you look at the tax tables or use the worksheet, you can see exactly how the progressive calculation works. The software does all the math automatically, but seeing the actual form helps you understand what's happening behind the scenes. It's also worth noting that this is why tax withholding from your paycheck might not always be perfect - your employer's payroll system estimates your annual tax based on each paycheck, but it can't always account for things like bonuses, second jobs, or other income that might push you into different brackets throughout the year.
Dmitry Volkov
If ur return hasn't been processed yet, maybe try calling IRS to see if they can stop it? idk if that works but worth a shot
0 coins
StarSeeker
โขgood luck getting through to a human on the phone ๐
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
I went through this exact situation last year! Definitely amend - the IRS will eventually match the W2c with your return anyway, so it's better to be proactive. File Form 1040X as soon as possible. Since your corrected W2 shows less income, you'll likely get an additional refund which is nice. Just be prepared for the long wait - mine took about 16 weeks to process, but that was during peak season. The sooner you file the amendment, the sooner you'll get your additional refund!
0 coins