


Ask the community...
I was audited last year for my gambling losses from horse racing. I had kept the losing tickets but no detailed log. Here's what happened: The IRS sent me a letter asking for documentation of my gambling losses. I provided all my losing tickets bundled by month (the best I could do) along with a statement explaining my gambling habits (weekly visits to the track, typical bet amounts, etc.). They accepted about 85% of my claimed losses. They disallowed some because a few tickets were smudged and unreadable. I had to pay back some tax plus a small amount of interest, but there were NO penalties because they didn't consider it fraud - just insufficient documentation. My advice: claim the losses if you have the tickets, but maybe be a bit conservative in your total amount. And start keeping better records going forward!
Did they make you come in for an in-person audit or was it all handled through mail? I'm curious about how the process works specifically for gambling losses.
It was all handled through mail - I never had to meet with anyone in person. They sent a letter requesting documentation, I mailed back my tickets and explanation, and about 8 weeks later they sent their determination letter. I did get one phone call from an auditor asking about my typical gambling patterns, but it was brief and straightforward. They seemed mostly concerned with verifying that the tickets could reasonably be mine and that the total amount made sense given my described habits. The entire process took about 3 months from start to finish.
I'm a little late to this thread, but I wanted to share that the most important thing is that your claimed losses seem REASONABLE compared to your winnings. If you won $5,000 but are claiming $4,990 in losses, that looks suspicious. If you claim maybe 50-75% of your winnings amount in losses, it raises fewer flags. Also, the IRS knows most casual gamblers don't keep perfect records. Sort your tickets by month at minimum. Count them up. Maybe take photos of the piles as extra documentation. The physical tickets themselves are pretty good evidence - they're dated, have serial numbers, and can't be easily fabricated. Just be reasonable with your claim and you should be fine.
This is really helpful! If I have about $6,800 in winnings, would claiming around $4,000 in losses (based on my actual losing tickets) seem reasonable? Or should I go even lower to be safe?
That ratio sounds very reasonable! $4,000 in losses against $6,800 in winnings is about 59%, which is well within the range that looks normal for casual gambling. The IRS expects most gamblers to have substantial losses - that's how the gambling industry works. Just make sure you organize those losing tickets as best you can. Even if you can't remember exact dates, try to group them by approximate time periods (like "Spring 2023" or "October-December 2023"). Taking photos of the organized piles before you file can also serve as backup documentation. Given that you already have the physical tickets and a reasonable loss-to-win ratio, I'd feel confident claiming that amount. The key is that it passes the "sniff test" - it's not so high that it looks like you're trying to zero out your winnings completely.
I've been through this before. In my experience, checking transcripts constantly just adds stress. I recommend setting up direct deposit if you haven't already, then just check once each Thursday morning. My cycle code was 0405 last year and 0505 the year before. Both times, my deposit arrived about 5-7 days after the transcript updated with an 846 code. The IRS is actually pretty consistent once they process your return.
I'm in the exact same boat! Filed January 31st with cycle code 0405 and have been checking my transcript religiously. As a fellow gig worker (I do Uber), I totally understand the stress of waiting for that refund when you have car expenses piling up. Based on what everyone's saying about Thursday updates, I'm really hoping we both see movement this week. The uncertainty is the worst part - at least now I know to focus my checking on Thursday mornings instead of refreshing constantly throughout the week. Hang in there!
As someone who moved from Boston to Malaysia 3 years ago while keeping my condo in the US, here's my practical experience: 1) The IRS looks at your overall situation to determine domicile - not just property ownership 2) I still file US taxes (citizens must), but qualify for Foreign Earned Income Exclusion 3) I rent out my US condo and pay US tax on that income (it's US source) 4) Key for proving foreign domicile: foreign bank accounts, housing contract, utility bills, foreign driver's license, club memberships, etc. 5) Document your moving expenses and shipping of personal belongings This isn't just about taxes but also state-specific obligations. I formally terminated my MA residency to avoid state taxes. The most helpful thing was keeping a detailed calendar of my physical presence in each country.
Did you have to file any special forms with Massachusetts to terminate your residency? I'm in a similar situation with my apartment in NYC but moving to Singapore, and I'm wondering about NY state taxes.
This is such a timely question! I'm currently dealing with a similar situation as a tax preparer who specializes in expat returns. The key distinction everyone's touching on is absolutely correct - domicile is about intent and your center of vital interests, not just property ownership. The IRS looks at the totality of circumstances including where you maintain bank accounts, voter registration, professional licenses, family ties, and personal belongings. For your Singapore move specifically, a few important considerations: 1) Singapore doesn't have a tax treaty with the US, so you won't get treaty benefits that might reduce withholding on US-source income 2) If you do rent out the NYC apartment later, you'll face 30% withholding on gross rental income (not net) unless you elect to treat it as effectively connected income and file a US return 3) Keep detailed records of your move - shipping receipts, lease agreements in Singapore, utility connections, etc. This documentation will be crucial if the IRS ever questions your domicile change 4) Consider the timing of your move for tax purposes - if you move mid-year, you might want to file as a dual-status taxpayer The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion will likely be your friend here, assuming you meet either the physical presence or bona fide residence test. Just remember it only applies to earned income, not investment income or rental income from your US property.
One important thing to note - if your state taxes retirement distributions differently than the federal government, you might need to make adjustments on your state return. For example, some states exempt retirement income up to certain limits, while others fully tax it regardless of whether it was taxed federally. Check your state's department of revenue website for specific guidance on Roth conversions. Most states have publications that explain their treatment of retirement distributions, including Roth conversions. That's the most reliable source rather than hoping a tax preparer gets it right.
I had a very similar situation with my 2024 Roth conversion! My 1099-R also showed zeros in boxes 14 and 16, which initially made me think I didn't need to report anything to my state. After doing some research and calling my state tax department, I learned that you definitely need to report the conversion amount even when those boxes are blank. The blank boxes just mean no state taxes were withheld at the time of conversion - it doesn't mean the transaction isn't reportable. What helped me was looking at my state's specific instructions for retirement distributions. Most states have you report the same amount that's in box 1 or box 2 of your 1099-R (depending on your state's rules). Since your traditional IRA had only after-tax contributions and you have Form 8606 documentation, you shouldn't owe additional state tax on the conversion, but the reporting is still required. I'd recommend checking your state's tax department website for their specific guidance on retirement distributions and Roth conversions. Every state handles these differently, so getting the official guidance for your specific state is the safest approach.
My state's website actually had pretty detailed guidance specifically about Roth conversions, but it was buried in their retirement income publication rather than being prominently featured. I had to search through several PDF documents to find the relevant sections. As for calling the state tax department - I waited on hold for about 90 minutes before getting through to someone who could help. It was frustrating, but the agent I spoke with was very knowledgeable and walked me through exactly how to report the conversion on my state return. She confirmed that even with blank boxes 14 and 16, the conversion amount still needed to be reported using the amount from box 2. If you decide to call, I'd recommend having your 1099-R and Form 8606 handy, along with any specific questions written down. The agent was able to give me state-specific guidance that I couldn't find anywhere online. Given what some others mentioned about services that wait on hold for you, that might be worth considering if you don't want to spend the time waiting yourself.
My state's website had pretty general retirement distribution guidance, but it did mention Roth conversions specifically in their FAQ section. The key thing I learned is that most states default to using the federal tax treatment unless they have specific exceptions. As for calling the state tax department - I actually had a terrible experience with the wait times! I spent over 2 hours on hold the first time I tried, and then got disconnected. That's actually why I was interested when someone mentioned that Claimyr service earlier in this thread - wish I had known about it when I was dealing with this issue. If you do decide to call, I'd recommend trying early in the morning right when they open, or late in the afternoon. Mid-morning and lunch time seemed to have the worst wait times. But honestly, if you have clear documentation with your Form 8606 showing the after-tax basis, following the general reporting guidance on your state's website should be sufficient. The main thing is just making sure you report the distribution amount even though no state taxes were withheld. Better to report it and owe nothing than to not report it and have questions later!
Emily Thompson
One thing that really helped me when I amended was keeping detailed records of WHY I made each change. The IRS sometimes sends follow-up questions, and having your reasoning documented makes responding so much easier. Also, if you're getting a refund from the amendment, don't spend it right away - sometimes they do additional reviews that can take months to finalize.
0 coins
Connor O'Brien
Just wanted to add that if you're amending because you forgot to include income (like that 1099), the sooner you file the better. The IRS has matching programs that will eventually catch missing income anyway, so being proactive shows good faith. Also, double-check that all your Social Security numbers and names match exactly what's on file with the IRS - even small discrepancies can cause delays in processing your amendment.
0 coins
Omar Zaki
ā¢Yes, definitely update your name with Social Security first! I learned this the hard way - if your SSN record doesn't match what you file, it can cause major delays and even rejection of your amendment. You'll need to visit a Social Security office with your marriage certificate and ID. Once that's updated (usually takes a few weeks), then file your amendment using your new married name. It's an extra step but will save you headaches later!
0 coins
Miguel Silva
ā¢Yes, definitely update your name with Social Security first! You'll want to file Form SS-5 with SSA before filing your amendment. The IRS system will flag mismatched names and it can seriously delay processing. I learned this the hard way when my sister got married - her refund was held up for months until she got everything synced up properly.
0 coins