
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
I won a pretty big prize on a scratch off ticket in 2023 and I know you can write off gambling losses up to the amount of your winnings. I've kept all my losing scratch off tickets (probably worth a few thousand dollars) but I don't have any detailed records of when I purchased them - I just toss them in my car and eventually bring them inside. My wife and I just did our joint married taxes, and it's already suggesting we take the itemized deduction even without adding the scratch off losses. The WG-2 from my big win is already documented since I paid taxes when I cashed it in. What I'm wondering is: if I add these scratch off losses to my deductions, what are the chances the IRS will audit me? Would just having the physical losing tickets be enough documentation if they do? And what happens if they decide my documentation isn't sufficient - would I get in serious trouble or would I just have to pay back the additional refund? I'd love to maximize our refund if possible, but I'm also fine with our return as it is now. I haven't found much clear information online about people deducting gambling losses with just the physical tickets, so I'm feeling uncertain about the whole thing.
So I really messed up last year. I was planning to file my 2023 taxes, but got caught up with multiple W-2s from different jobs. One employer only offers W-2s online, and when I tried to access it, their website was down for over a week. I got frustrated and, well... I just never ended up filing at all. Most of my income in 2023 was from serving at restaurants, so I'm almost certain I owe money rather than getting a refund. I know there are penalties for failing to file when you owe, and I'm starting to worry about how bad this might be. I've scheduled an appointment with a tax preparer in about 10 days to handle my 2024 taxes (normally I just use those free tax sites but I think they've been shorting me - I somehow owed $1,300 when I was only 19). I'm wondering if I should try to deal with the unfiled 2023 taxes before seeing them, or if I can handle both issues at the same appointment? What's weird is that I haven't gotten any notices from the IRS about my unfiled 2023 taxes. No calls, no letters, nothing. That's partly why it slipped my mind, but now I'm wondering if that's normal or if there's a storm coming. How much trouble am I in here?
Just my two cents, but I think you should definitely tell your tax preparer about the unfiled 2023 return during your appointment for 2024. They deal with this situation ALL THE TIME, trust me. When I worked as a server, I had a similar issue where I owed money multiple years and got overwhelmed. My tax guy handled everything - filed my back taxes, set up a payment plan, and even got some penalties reduced. It was way less painful than I expected. Don't try to handle the 2023 return yourself if you're already planning to see a professional for 2024. Let them handle both and do it right. The peace of mind is worth it, and they might save you money in the long run.
Thanks for the advice! That's reassuring to hear. Do you think I should still try to gather all my 2023 W-2s before the appointment? And did your tax preparer charge extra for handling the unfiled year?
Yes, definitely gather all your 2023 W-2s beforehand if possible. The more prepared you are, the smoother (and potentially cheaper) the process will be. If you can't get them all, at least bring what you have so your preparer knows what they're working with. My tax preparer did charge a bit extra for the unfiled return - about $50 more than my current year return. But honestly, it was money well spent for the stress relief and making sure it was done correctly. Some preparers charge the same for current and prior years, while others have a small additional fee. Just ask upfront so there are no surprises.
You're definitely not in as much trouble as you think! Missing one year happens more often than you'd expect, especially with multiple W-2s and website issues like you experienced. The lack of IRS notices is actually pretty normal - they're still working through backlogs and it often takes 12-18 months before they start sending letters about unfiled returns. Don't let that false sense of security fool you though - it's better to get ahead of it. Since you mentioned most of your income was from serving, there's a decent chance you might have had enough taxes withheld to cover what you owe, or you might even be due a refund. Server wages often have higher withholding rates, and if you're young, you might qualify for credits you don't know about. Definitely bring up the 2023 situation with your tax preparer at your scheduled appointment. They can handle both years efficiently and help you understand exactly where you stand. In the meantime, start gathering those 2023 W-2s - contact the employer with the website issues directly if needed, or you can request wage transcripts from the IRS. Don't stress too much about this. You're being proactive now, which is what matters. The penalties for late filing aren't pleasant, but they're manageable, especially if you file before the IRS gets around to creating a substitute return for you.
So I've got this frustrating situation with a partnership return I'm working on. The partners have health insurance paid by the partnership, which is being reported as a guaranteed payment on the partnership return as required. This then flows through to their personal returns. Here's what's confusing me - it seems like the health insurance has already been deducted for QBI (Qualified Business Income) purposes as a partnership expense through the guaranteed payment. But our tax software is turning around and backing it out AGAIN on the partners' personal returns! Is anyone else dealing with this same issue? We're seriously considering just overriding the software calculation, but I want to make sure I'm not missing something important here. What's weird is that our software was doing the exact same thing with S Corp owner health insurance reported on W-2s as wages a couple weeks ago. There was a huge uproar from users, and they finally pushed an update to fix it. But they haven't made any changes to the partnership treatment, which seems like the exact same situation to me. Am I crazy here?
The issue is 100% a software problem. Health insurance for partners reported as guaranteed payments reduces QBI at the partnership level. The software is making a second reduction at the individual level, which is incorrect. If you don't want to override, another approach is to NOT report the health insurance as a guaranteed payment on the 1065, and instead just show it as a footnote on the K-1 and have the partner deduct it on their 1040. This isn't technically correct per IRS instructions, but effectively gets the right QBI result. But honestly, just overriding the software calculation is cleaner.
Wouldn't the approach of not reporting as a guaranteed payment cause other issues though? Like wouldn't it mess up the partner's self-employment tax calculation? The guaranteed payment affects both SE tax and QBI.
You're absolutely right - that workaround would indeed cause SE tax issues by understating the guaranteed payments subject to self-employment tax. I shouldn't have suggested that approach. The correct method is definitely to report the health insurance as a guaranteed payment on the 1065 and then override the QBI calculation on the 1040 to prevent the double reduction. It's frustrating that we have to manually fix software issues, but at least it's a straightforward override.
This is such a widespread issue this filing season! I'm seeing it across multiple software platforms - UltraTax, ProSeries, Drake, and others all had similar bugs with the QBI calculations for partnership health insurance. What's really frustrating is that the software companies seem to understand the S Corp treatment (health insurance in W-2 wages shouldn't reduce QBI again on the individual return) but haven't applied the same logic to partnerships. The concept is identical - the guaranteed payment for health insurance already reduces QBI at the partnership level. For anyone still dealing with this, I'd strongly recommend documenting your override with a detailed workpaper. Include references to Reg. Sec. 1.199A-3(b)(1)(vi) and note that the guaranteed payment has already reduced QBI at the entity level. The IRS guidance is pretty clear on this point, even if the software implementation has been problematic. Has anyone heard if the major software companies have committed to fixing this for next filing season? It seems like such a basic issue that affects so many partnership returns.
Hey tax people - I need some advice on my situation. I've been working full-time at a manufacturing company until July when I got pretty seriously injured and had to go on short term disability. My employer has a group disability insurance policy they pay for, and I also have a supplemental policy through Colonial Life that comes out of my paycheck each month. I'm trying to figure out if I need to pay taxes on the disability payments I received for the last 5 months of the year. The group policy paid about $2,800/month and my personal policy kicked in another $950/month. I haven't received any tax forms for these payments yet and I'm confused about whether they count as taxable income or not. My HR department wasn't very helpful when I called - they just said to talk to my tax person, but I usually just use TurboTax. Does anyone know how disability payments get taxed? Would appreciate any guidance here!
Watch out for state taxes too! The federal rules about disability payments that everyone mentioned are correct (employer paid = taxable, you paid after-tax = non-taxable), but some states have different rules. For example, New Jersey doesn't tax any disability payments regardless of who paid the premiums. California has its own state disability program with different tax rules. Worth checking your state's specific laws on disability income.
Does anyone know about New York state? I'm on short term disability in NY and can't figure out if I need to pay state taxes on the payments.
New York generally follows the federal rules for taxing disability benefits. So if your benefits are taxable for federal purposes (employer paid the premiums), they're typically taxable for NY state purposes too. New York does have its own temporary disability insurance program, but those benefits follow the same general rule - if you paid for it with after-tax dollars, the benefits are tax-free. If it was employer-paid or paid with pre-tax dollars, the benefits are taxable.
Did anyone else have issues with their disability payments not being reported correctly on tax forms? My short-term disability was paid by Cigna but I never got any tax forms from them, and my employer's W-2 doesn't seem to include those payments either.
I had the exact same problem! Turns out the insurance company was supposed to file a W-2 for the disability payments, not my employer. I had to call Cigna and request a corrected W-2 specifically for the disability pay. They classified it as "third-party sick pay" on a separate W-2.
You should definitely contact Cigna directly about the missing tax forms. Insurance companies are required to issue tax documents for disability payments when they're taxable, but sometimes there are delays or the forms get sent to an old address. If your employer paid the premiums for the Cigna policy, those disability payments are taxable income and Cigna should have issued either a W-2 or 1099-MISC. Call their customer service line and ask specifically about tax documents for disability benefits - they should be able to reissue them or tell you if the payments were non-taxable (which would mean you paid the premiums with after-tax dollars). Don't file your taxes until you get this sorted out, otherwise you might end up having to file an amended return later.
Hey fellow tax pros! I'm freaking out a bit about this IRS WISP (Written Information Security Plan) requirement. Our small tax firm just got an email from the IRS about the Security Summit's new data security plan that "simplifies this complex area" but honestly, it feels like one more complicated thing we need to figure out. We have about 5 preparers in our office and I'm supposed to have this plan in place like... yesterday. Has anyone actually implemented this yet? What exactly does compliance look like in practice? Are there templates or examples I can follow? I'm worried we're missing something critical here, especially with all the client data we handle. Any advice from those who've already tackled this WISP compliance would be super appreciated!
Has anyone been through an actual IRS review of their WISP? I'm curious what they look for and how intensive the process is.
I went through a security compliance check last year. It wasn't as scary as I expected. They didn't nitpick every detail of the WISP but focused on whether we had one, if it covered the major areas, and if we were actually following it. The agent looked at our paper document disposal methods, checked that we use encryption and multi-factor authentication, and asked several questions about how we respond to suspicious emails or potential breaches. They seemed most concerned with seeing that security was taken seriously rather than just having a perfect document.
This thread has been incredibly helpful! I'm in a similar situation with a small firm (3 preparers) and have been putting off the WISP requirements because it felt so daunting. Reading everyone's experiences makes it seem much more manageable. I especially appreciate the practical breakdown from Edward about the 5 key elements to focus on. We're already doing some of these things but not consistently documenting them. The reminder about actually implementing versus just documenting really resonates - I can see how easy it would be to create a beautiful plan that sits in a drawer unused. One question for the group: how often should we be reviewing and updating our WISP? Is this something that needs annual updates, or only when we make significant changes to our practices? Also, @Marilyn Dixon, I feel your pain about the email attachments - we've been doing the same thing for years without thinking twice about it. Definitely time to move to a secure portal system!
Amara Nwosu
I was audited last year for my gambling losses from horse racing. I had kept the losing tickets but no detailed log. Here's what happened: The IRS sent me a letter asking for documentation of my gambling losses. I provided all my losing tickets bundled by month (the best I could do) along with a statement explaining my gambling habits (weekly visits to the track, typical bet amounts, etc.). They accepted about 85% of my claimed losses. They disallowed some because a few tickets were smudged and unreadable. I had to pay back some tax plus a small amount of interest, but there were NO penalties because they didn't consider it fraud - just insufficient documentation. My advice: claim the losses if you have the tickets, but maybe be a bit conservative in your total amount. And start keeping better records going forward!
0 coins
AstroExplorer
Did they make you come in for an in-person audit or was it all handled through mail? I'm curious about how the process works specifically for gambling losses.
0 coins
Amara Nwosu
It was all handled through mail - I never had to meet with anyone in person. They sent a letter requesting documentation, I mailed back my tickets and explanation, and about 8 weeks later they sent their determination letter. I did get one phone call from an auditor asking about my typical gambling patterns, but it was brief and straightforward. They seemed mostly concerned with verifying that the tickets could reasonably be mine and that the total amount made sense given my described habits. The entire process took about 3 months from start to finish.
0 coins
Giovanni Moretti
I'm a little late to this thread, but I wanted to share that the most important thing is that your claimed losses seem REASONABLE compared to your winnings. If you won $5,000 but are claiming $4,990 in losses, that looks suspicious. If you claim maybe 50-75% of your winnings amount in losses, it raises fewer flags. Also, the IRS knows most casual gamblers don't keep perfect records. Sort your tickets by month at minimum. Count them up. Maybe take photos of the piles as extra documentation. The physical tickets themselves are pretty good evidence - they're dated, have serial numbers, and can't be easily fabricated. Just be reasonable with your claim and you should be fine.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Farsi
This is really helpful! If I have about $6,800 in winnings, would claiming around $4,000 in losses (based on my actual losing tickets) seem reasonable? Or should I go even lower to be safe?
0 coins
AstroAce
That ratio sounds very reasonable! $4,000 in losses against $6,800 in winnings is about 59%, which is well within the range that looks normal for casual gambling. The IRS expects most gamblers to have substantial losses - that's how the gambling industry works. Just make sure you organize those losing tickets as best you can. Even if you can't remember exact dates, try to group them by approximate time periods (like "Spring 2023" or "October-December 2023"). Taking photos of the organized piles before you file can also serve as backup documentation. Given that you already have the physical tickets and a reasonable loss-to-win ratio, I'd feel confident claiming that amount. The key is that it passes the "sniff test" - it's not so high that it looks like you're trying to zero out your winnings completely.
0 coins