


Ask the community...
Has anyone tried just setting up a separate sole proprietorship for the equipment rental part? I'm wondering if I could invoice clients separately - one invoice from my service business and another from an equipment rental business with a different name and EIN.
I tried this approach and it didn't work well. The IRS looks at related activities and may still consider it all one business, especially if the equipment is used in conjunction with your services for the same clients. Also, having two businesses created more paperwork and confusion with my clients who didn't want to deal with multiple invoices and payment processes.
I've been dealing with this exact issue for the past three years as a freelance DP who rents out my RED camera package. What I learned from my CPA is that the key isn't necessarily how your clients issue the 1099s, but how you can substantiate separate business activities. The IRS Publication 535 actually covers this - if your equipment rental is "incidental" to your services (meaning you primarily rent to clients you're also providing services to), then it's all considered one business subject to SE tax. However, if you can show that you have a separate equipment rental business (renting to other operators, production companies you don't work for, etc.), then you might qualify to report that portion on Schedule E. I started tracking every equipment rental separately in QuickBooks and made sure to actively market my gear rental independently. Now about 30% of my equipment income comes from rentals where I'm not providing services, which helps establish it as a separate business activity. The documentation is crucial if you get audited. Your current QuickBooks setup is a good start, but make sure you're also tracking which rentals include your services versus equipment-only rentals. That distinction could save you significant money in self-employment taxes down the road.
This is really helpful advice! I'm new to freelance work and have been wondering about this exact situation. When you say you "actively market your gear rental independently," what does that actually look like? Are you listing on ShareGrid or other platforms, or is it more about having separate marketing materials and contracts for equipment-only rentals? I want to make sure I'm setting up my documentation correctly from the start rather than trying to fix it later.
Has anyone compared Free Tax USA to TurboTax for business filers? I've been using TurboTax for years but the price keeps creeping up every year. Now they want $170 just for the basic self-employed version before adding state filing!
Thanks! That's really helpful. Did you find the switch process easy? I'm worried about losing all my previous years' data that's in TurboTax.
The switch was actually pretty straightforward! You can't transfer data between the systems, but honestly I found that was kind of a blessing in disguise - it forced me to review all my business expenses and deductions from scratch, and I actually found some things I'd been missing in previous years. Free Tax USA has a good "prior year comparison" feature where you can reference what you claimed last year while entering your current info. Just keep your prior year return handy as reference. The most time-consuming part was just re-entering my business info and setting up my expense categories again, but that's really a one-time thing. One tip - if you're making the switch, start early in tax season so you're not rushed. But the actual filing process was just as smooth as TurboTax, and the savings were totally worth the minor inconvenience of not having my data auto-imported.
I've been using Free Tax USA for my consulting business for two years now and it's been solid. One thing I'd add to what others have said - if you're worried about making mistakes, their customer support is actually pretty responsive via email. I had questions about how to handle some equipment depreciation and they got back to me within a day with clear guidance. The learning curve isn't too steep if you have your records organized. I keep a simple spreadsheet throughout the year tracking income and expenses by category, so when tax time comes I just reference that while filling out the forms. Takes me about 3 hours total now, compared to the 2-hour meeting + back-and-forth with my old CPA that cost 10x more. One heads up - make sure you understand the difference between business expenses and personal deductions before you start. The software will ask about both, but it's on you to categorize things correctly. When in doubt, err on the conservative side or do a quick Google search about what's deductible for your type of business.
17 One thing nobody has mentioned yet - if you do decide to file jointly, you need to include a statement signed by both you and your spouse agreeing to be taxed on your worldwide income. This is in addition to getting the ITIN. My tax preparer missed this last year and it caused a huge headache with our return getting flagged for review.
3 Does your spouse physically need to sign the statement? My husband lives in Australia and getting documents back and forth is a pain. Can he just sign electronically?
17 Your spouse does need to sign it, but electronic signatures are accepted by the IRS now. My wife was able to sign the document digitally and send it back to me as a PDF. Just make sure it's a proper digital signature, not just a typed name. The statement itself isn't complicated - it just needs to clearly state that you're both electing to treat the non-resident alien spouse as a US resident for tax purposes, include both your names, the tax year, and both signatures. There's no specific IRS form for this statement.
7 Just to add a bit more info - I've been in this situation for 3 years with my Brazilian husband. If you choose Married Filing Separately, be aware that you'll lose some tax benefits like education credits, child tax credits, earned income credit, etc. You also can't contribute to a Roth IRA if your income is above $10,000. Filing jointly with the election usually results in lower taxes overall, but then you have the hassle of getting an ITIN and reporting foreign income. It's worth calculating both ways if you can.
10 How long did it take to get the ITIN for your spouse? I heard the processing time can be really long.
It took about 7-8 weeks to get my husband's ITIN when we applied. This was during peak tax season though, so processing times were longer than usual. The IRS says it typically takes 7-11 weeks, but I've heard of people getting theirs in as little as 4-6 weeks during slower periods. One tip - make sure you include certified copies of his passport (not photocopies) with the W-7 application, or you'll have to send the original passport which can take even longer to get back. We learned this the hard way on our first attempt and had to resubmit everything.
I've been using FreeTaxUSA for 5 years now. The state returns are usually available by mid-January, sometimes earlier depending on your state. For your estimated payment, you can probably just use the same method you used for Q3 unless your income has changed significantly.
Which tax software is best for self-employed people? I have a small side business and TurboTax always upsells me to their most expensive version.
I made the switch from TurboTax to FreeTaxUSA two years ago and it was one of my best financial decisions! A few tips for your transition: 1. **State returns timing**: California forms are usually available by late January, but you're right to be concerned about the January 15th deadline. I'd recommend calculating your estimated payment based on your Q3 method or using 110% of last year's tax liability to be safe. 2. **Data entry**: Since this is your first year with FreeTaxUSA, gather all your previous tax documents beforehand. The interface is clean and intuitive, but you'll need to manually enter everything this first time. 3. **Features you might miss**: FreeTaxUSA doesn't have some of TurboTax's bells and whistles like the mobile app for document photos, but honestly, I found those features more gimmicky than useful. 4. **Import capabilities**: You can import W-2s and 1099s directly from most major employers and financial institutions, which saves a ton of time. The $15 state fee is still a steal compared to what TurboTax was charging me ($120+ for state). You'll love not being constantly upsold to premium versions you don't need!
Mateo Perez
Dumb question but do personal checks from clients who didn't send 1099s count as "under the table" income? My tax guy said i don't need to report income without a 1099 but that sounds wrong to me.
0 coins
Freya Larsen
ā¢Your tax guy is 100% wrong and giving you dangerous advice. ALL income must be reported regardless of whether you received a 1099 or not. "Under the table" income is still legally required to be reported on your tax return. The 1099 system exists so the IRS can verify income, but the absence of a 1099 doesn't mean you don't owe taxes on that income. If you're audited and they discover unreported income, you'll face back taxes, penalties, and potentially interest. Your tax preparer is setting you up for serious problems - I'd strongly consider finding a new one who follows the law.
0 coins
Logan Stewart
This is exactly the kind of mixed income situation that trips up a lot of freelancers! The good news is that having personal reimbursements mixed with business income in your bank account isn't inherently problematic - you just need to be able to document the difference. Here's what I'd recommend: Create a simple spreadsheet with three columns - Date, Amount, and Type (Business Income vs Personal Reimbursement). Go through your bank statements and categorize each deposit. For the reimbursements like your dad's utility bills or friend payments, keep any supporting documentation (texts, emails, original receipts) that show these were reimbursements rather than income. The IRS cares about accuracy, not perfection in your banking setup. As long as you can substantiate which deposits were actual income versus personal transactions, you'll be fine. That said, definitely consider opening a separate account for future business income - it makes everything so much cleaner come tax time. One last thing - make sure you're setting aside money for quarterly estimated tax payments if you haven't been doing that already. Self-employment tax can be a nasty surprise if you're not prepared!
0 coins