
IRS
CommunityGovernment Services


Ask the community...
Hi everyone! I'm in a bit of a panic trying to figure out my tax situation. I moved from Canada to the US last August on a TN visa for a software engineering job, and now I'm completely lost trying to file my US taxes for the first time. I started working in the US on August 15, 2022, so I was only here for about 4.5 months last year. My employer provided me with a W-2, but I have no idea what to do with it or how to determine my residency status for tax purposes. I think I'm considered a "dual-status alien" since I was both a non-resident and resident in the same tax year? But the IRS publications are so confusing! I also had some Canadian income before moving (about $65,000 CAD from January to August), and I already filed my Canadian taxes for that. Do I need to report this on my US return too? What about my Canadian bank accounts and investments? I've been trying to use TurboTax but it keeps asking me questions I don't know how to answer. Does anyone have experience filing as a TN visa holder for the first time? Should I just break down and hire a tax professional at this point? The April deadline is coming up fast and I'm getting really worried!
According to IRC Section 6402, the IRS has authority to offset refunds against outstanding tax liabilities. However, I am uncertain if this applies when a formal installment agreement (Form 9465) is already established and in good standing. I have been making timely payments on my 2022 tax balance per agreement terms since receiving my ITIN last year. For tax year 2023, I am expecting a refund of approximately $1,850. Will this amount be automatically applied to my outstanding balance despite my active payment plan? Per Publication 594, the IRS states they can offset refunds, but does not specifically address installment agreement situations.
The IRS will take your refund. This happens to everyone on a payment plan. Your refund will be applied to your debt automatically. No exceptions. This actually benefits you by reducing your balance faster and cutting down on penalties and interest. Your monthly payment amount stays the same. You'll receive a notice showing how they applied your refund. Don't count on getting any of that money back.
I went through this exact situation two years ago. The IRS will absolutely take your refund even with an active payment plan - it's automatic. Here's what happened in my case: I had a $4,200 balance from 2021 taxes with a $175/month payment plan. When I filed my 2022 return expecting a $1,600 refund, the IRS applied the entire amount to my outstanding balance. My monthly payment stayed at $175, but my payoff date moved up significantly. The good news is that applying your refund reduces the principal balance, which means less interest and penalties over time. You'll get a CP49 notice showing exactly how they applied your refund. While it's disappointing not to get cash in hand, it's actually the most cost-effective outcome for your overall tax situation.
I'm totally confused about this CP30 notice I just got for my 2022 taxes. I'll just use approximate figures here. According to the notice: Tax payments I made - $27,000 Tax I actually owed - $24,800 Failure to pay proper estimated tax penalty - $120 Refund due - $2,080 Here's what's weird though - I already received a refund for $2,200 a while back. The refund amount on this notice ($2,080) seems to be my original refund minus this $120 penalty they're suddenly claiming I owe. But I don't get it. The estimated tax I paid clearly exceeded what I owed by a pretty decent amount. So why am I getting hit with a penalty for underpayment of estimated tax? Does anyone understand how this works? Planning to call the IRS tomorrow but I've heard horror stories about trying to get through to a real person. Any insights before I wade into that nightmare?
I'm a bookkeeper and see this issue ALL THE TIME. The estimated tax system is designed for people who have consistent income throughout the year. When you have variable or seasonal income, you need to use Form 2210 Schedule AI (Annualized Income Installment Method) to properly calculate your quarterly payments. The standard estimated tax rules assume your income is earned evenly throughout the year, which doesn't work for many self-employed people. With Schedule AI, you calculate each quarter's payment based on actual income for that period.
Can you request removal of the penalty if you've never had this issue before? I've filed and paid taxes correctly for 10+ years and this is my first estimated tax penalty.
Yes, absolutely! It's called First-Time Penalty Abatement (FTA). If you have a clean compliance history for the 3 prior tax years (filed all returns on time and paid or arranged to pay any tax due), the IRS will typically waive the penalty the first time you make a mistake. Just call and specifically request a "First-Time Penalty Abatement" for your estimated tax penalty. You can also write a letter requesting this. It's one of the most underutilized tax relief options available!
Estimated tax penalties are calculated on Form 2210. You should double-check the IRS calculation by completing this form yourself to make sure the penalty is correct.
Form 2210 looks crazy complicated tho. Do tax software programs like TurboTax handle this automatically?
Most tax software will calculate Form 2210 automatically when you enter your estimated tax payments and withholding amounts. TurboTax, FreeTaxUSA, and H&R Block all handle this. The software will determine if you owe the penalty and calculate the amount for you. However, if you have irregular income throughout the year, you might need to manually select the "annualized income installment method" option in the software to potentially reduce or eliminate the penalty. Not all software makes this option obvious, so you might need to look in the estimated tax or penalty sections specifically.
So I think I'm totally misunderstanding how tax brackets work and hoping someone can help clear this up. I'm trying to figure out if social security and medicare contributions count towards federal income tax calculations. Here's my confusion - I'm pretty sure I'm in the 22% tax bracket this year. When I'm looking at my paystub and figuring out where I'll end up for the year, should I be adding up the federal income tax PLUS social security PLUS medicare to determine if I'm hitting that 22% correctly? Or am I only supposed to be looking at the federal income tax contribution by itself? I always thought they were all bundled together as "federal taxes" but my coworker was saying they're completely separate things. Hoping someone can explain this in simple terms because I'm honestly lost. Thanks in advance for any help!
Another way to think about this: your pay stub might show deductions like: - Federal Income Tax: $X (this is what your tax bracket applies to) - Social Security: 6.2% of your gross pay (up to limit) - Medicare: 1.45% of your gross pay The tax brackets (10%, 12%, 22%, etc.) only apply to that first number. FICA taxes are fixed percentages that don't change based on income brackets.
This makes sense, but now I'm confused about state income tax. Is that also separate from the federal tax brackets? I'm in California if that matters.
Yes, state income tax is completely separate from federal tax brackets. California has its own progressive tax bracket system that's independent of the federal system. So you'll pay: 1. Federal income tax (based on federal brackets) 2. Social Security and Medicare (fixed percentages) 3. California state income tax (based on CA state brackets) Each has its own separate calculation and rules. California's highest rate is actually higher than the federal rate for high earners!
This is such a common confusion! I made the same mistake for years. The key thing to remember is that tax brackets are ONLY for federal income tax - they have nothing to do with FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare). Think of it this way: when you hear someone say "I'm in the 22% tax bracket," they're only talking about the federal income tax portion of their paycheck deductions. The Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%) taxes are completely separate flat rates that everyone pays regardless of their income level or tax bracket. So if you're trying to verify you're in the 22% bracket, you only look at your federal income tax withholding, not the total of all your tax deductions. Your coworker was absolutely right - they're separate things, even though they all come out of your paycheck at the same time. It's also worth noting that tax brackets are marginal, meaning only the income that falls within each bracket gets taxed at that rate. So being "in the 22% bracket" doesn't mean all your income is taxed at 22% - just the portion that exceeds the lower bracket thresholds.
I run a reselling business on the side that's been doing pretty well. Last year my total sales hit around $1.2M across several platforms. Most of my inventory moves through my main channels, but I also sell on this smaller website that just sent me a 1099-K for 2024. The 1099-K they sent only shows about $9,500 in payments they made to me. I've been tracking all my sales income together for my Schedule C, including what I made from this website. My question is - do I need to report this 1099-K separately somewhere on my taxes, or can I just include it as part of my total self-employment income on my Schedule C since it's all from the same reselling business? I don't want to accidentally report the same income twice or miss reporting something important. I use tax software but it keeps asking me about 1099-K forms specifically and I'm not sure if I should be entering this separately or if it's already covered by my Schedule C reporting. Any help would be appreciated!
Has anyone had issues with sales tax being included on their 1099-K? My platform reports the full transaction amount including sales tax on the 1099-K, but the sales tax isn't actually my income since I remit it to the state. Should I still report the full 1099-K amount on Schedule C and then deduct the sales tax portion as an expense?
I went through this exact same situation last year with my consulting business. I had multiple 1099-Ks from different payment platforms totaling about $15K, but my actual business income was much higher since I also received direct payments and checks. The key thing to remember is that you report your TRUE total business income on Schedule C Line 1 (gross receipts), not just what's on the 1099-Ks. The 1099-K is just third-party verification of some of your payments - it doesn't limit what you can report as income. When you enter the 1099-K information in your tax software, it's mainly for IRS matching purposes. The software should automatically include those amounts in your Schedule C totals rather than creating separate income categories. Just make sure your Schedule C gross receipts line reflects ALL your business income for the year, including the $9,500 from that 1099-K plus everything else you earned from your reselling business. One tip: keep detailed records showing how your 1099-K amounts tie into your total reported income. This helps if the IRS ever questions the numbers during their automated matching process.
Isaiah Thompson
Has anyone dealt with Social Security and Medicare taxes on a TN visa? My employer withheld these taxes from my paychecks, but I've heard conflicting information about whether TN visa holders are exempt under the totalization agreement between US and Canada.
0 coins
Nick Kravitz
TN visa holders are generally NOT exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes unless you have a Certificate of Coverage from the Canadian government. This certificate (form CPT56) needs to be requested before you come to the US, and it's only valid if you're staying for 5 years or less and still maintain ties to the Canadian social security system. If you didn't get this certificate before coming to the US, your employer was correct to withhold these taxes. The good news is that under the totalization agreement, your US Social Security contributions can eventually count toward your Canadian pension (CPP) credits when you retire.
0 coins
Philip Cowan
I went through this exact same situation last year as a TN visa holder from Canada! The advice about filing Form 1040-NR as a nonresident is spot on. One thing I'd add is to be extra careful about the tax treaty elections - Form 8833 can save you money but you need to file it correctly. Also, don't forget about state tax implications even though you're in Washington (lucky you - no state income tax!). Some states have different residency rules than federal, but WA makes it simple. For the FBAR reporting, the threshold is $10,000 USD aggregate in all foreign accounts at any point during the year. So if your Canadian accounts totaled more than $10K at any time in 2022, you need to file FinCEN Form 114 by April 15th (no extensions allowed). One mistake I made was not keeping good records of my Canadian tax payments. If you have any investment income from Canada that was subject to withholding tax there, make sure to claim the Foreign Tax Credit on Form 1116 to avoid double taxation. The tax software mentioned above (taxr.ai) actually helped me catch this - saved me about $800! The deadline pressure is real, but you've got this! Consider getting help if your situation is complex, but for a straightforward W-2 situation, the nonresident-specific software should handle it well.
0 coins