


Ask the community...
I just wanted to add some reassurance here - I received my Austin letter about 3 weeks ago and it was indeed a 5071C verification notice. The whole experience was much less stressful than I anticipated! A few practical tips based on my recent experience: 1. When you get the letter, don't panic if the deadline seems tight - they actually give you 30 days from the letter date, not the date you receive it 2. I recommend trying the online ID.me route first since it's available 24/7, unlike the phone lines 3. Have your tax return handy during verification - they might ask you to confirm specific amounts from your filing 4. If you're married filing jointly, only the primary taxpayer needs to complete the verification My verification was completed online in about 35 minutes (including multiple attempts at getting decent photos), and I saw the 570 hold code removed from my transcript exactly 6 business days later. Refund hit my account 3 days after that. The IRS has definitely streamlined this process compared to previous years. While it's frustrating to have the delay, the actual verification steps are pretty straightforward now. Good luck and try not to stress too much about it!
This is so reassuring to read! I'm actually expecting a letter from Austin tomorrow too and have been pretty anxious about it. Your timeline gives me hope - 6 business days to remove the hold and then just 3 more days for the actual refund sounds way better than some of the horror stories I've heard from previous years. The tip about having your tax return handy during verification is really helpful - I wouldn't have thought of that! Quick question: when you say the primary taxpayer needs to complete verification for joint filers, does that mean the spouse can't do it even if they have all the same documents and information? Just trying to understand the process better in case I need to coordinate with my partner. Thanks for sharing your positive experience - it's exactly what I needed to hear right now!
Based on your timeline and description, this is very likely to be a 5071C identity verification letter from the IRS. The Austin Service Center is indeed one of the main facilities that handles identity verification correspondence, and your 15-day timeframe from acceptance to letter generation is pretty typical for these cases. A few things to prepare for while you wait: 1. **Gather your documents now**: You'll likely need a government-issued photo ID (driver's license or passport), your Social Security card, and a copy of the tax return in question 2. **Check your transcript one more time**: Look for any new transaction codes that might have appeared since your last check - specifically TC 971 with Action Code 522 or 524, which would confirm identity verification requirements 3. **Consider your verification options**: Online through ID.me is usually fastest (available 24/7), but you can also verify by phone or schedule an in-person appointment at a Taxpayer Assistance Center The good news is that this process has become much more streamlined over the past couple of years. Most people who complete online verification see their refund released within 7-10 business days. While the delay is frustrating, it's become a fairly routine part of the process for many taxpayers. Don't stress too much - the letter will have very clear instructions on exactly what you need to do. Keep us updated on what you receive!
This is such a comprehensive overview - thank you! I'm actually in a very similar situation and have been checking my transcript obsessively. I haven't seen any TC 971 codes yet, but I do have a TC 570 that appeared a few days ago. Your advice about gathering documents ahead of time is spot on - I'd rather be overprepared than scrambling around looking for my Social Security card when the letter arrives. One thing I'm curious about: have you noticed if there are certain factors that make returns more likely to get flagged for verification? I keep wondering if it was something specific on my return or just random selection. The 7-10 day timeline for refund release after verification is really encouraging compared to some of the longer delays I've read about in previous tax seasons.
Has anyone used TurboTax for this? Do they handle HSA excess contributions properly? I'm in a similar situation with about $45 in excess contributions.
I used TurboTax last year for a similar issue. It does handle Form 8889 and Form 5329, but the interview process wasn't very clear for excess HSA contributions. I actually had to manually override some entries to get it right. If your situation is straightforward, it should work, but for anything complex, I found their guidance lacking.
I went through something very similar last year with multiple HSA accounts due to employer changes. For your $16 excess, you're absolutely making the right call to just pay the 6% tax - it's only going to cost you about $0.96. One thing to keep in mind: if you don't correct the excess contribution, you'll technically owe that 6% tax each year until the excess is removed. However, given how small the amount is, even paying it for several years would cost less than the time and hassle of trying to coordinate distributions from closed HSA accounts. For future reference, if you ever have a larger excess contribution, you can also "absorb" it by contributing less than your annual limit in a subsequent year. The excess essentially gets offset against your unused contribution room. But again, for $16, just paying the tax is definitely the path of least resistance. Make sure to keep good records of this excess contribution and the tax payments in case the IRS ever asks about it down the road.
This is really helpful advice! I'm dealing with a similar situation but with a $28 excess contribution from when I changed jobs mid-year. The "absorbing" it in future years by under-contributing is something I hadn't heard of before - that sounds much simpler than trying to get distributions from my old HSA provider. Just to make sure I understand correctly - if my annual HSA limit next year is $4,300 and I only contribute $4,272, that would effectively "use up" my $28 excess from this year? And I wouldn't owe the 6% tax going forward? Also, do you know if there's any special reporting required when you offset an excess this way, or does it just naturally work out on Form 8889?
Just wanted to add my recent experience to help others in similar situations! I received my amended return via direct deposit about 3 weeks ago. My 846 code showed up on a Tuesday, and the money actually hit my account on that exact same day - which surprised me based on what I'd been reading about typical wait times. I think the key factor might be which bank you use. I have my account with a credit union that tends to process ACH transfers pretty quickly. My friend who banks with a larger national bank had to wait 4 business days after her 846 date for the same type of deposit. For anyone still waiting, I'd definitely recommend setting up account alerts if your bank offers them rather than constantly checking your balance. The money will show up when it shows up, and the alerts saved my sanity during the waiting period. The direct deposit for amended returns is absolutely legitimate now - just be prepared for the timing to vary more than regular refunds.
That's really interesting about the credit union processing it the same day! I'm with a smaller regional bank and I'm hoping they might be faster than the big national banks too. The account alerts tip is brilliant - I've been driving myself crazy checking my balance every few hours since I saw my 846 code yesterday. It's so helpful to hear all these real experiences from people who've actually gone through this process recently. When I first started researching amended return direct deposits, I was getting so much conflicting information online. This thread has been way more useful than anything I found on the IRS website or other forums. Really appreciate everyone sharing their timelines!
I'm currently in the exact same boat as the original poster! Just saw my 846 code appear this morning with a Friday date, and I've been obsessively checking my bank account every hour. Reading through everyone's experiences here has been incredibly helpful and reassuring. It's amazing how much conflicting information is out there about amended returns and direct deposits. My tax preparer told me it would definitely be a check, but clearly that's outdated information. Based on what everyone's shared here, it sounds like the 3-5 business day window after the 846 date is pretty realistic to expect. I'm particularly grateful for the tips about watching for additional codes after the 846 and setting up bank alerts instead of constantly refreshing my account. This community has been way more informative than anything I could find on the IRS website. Will definitely report back once my deposit comes through to add another data point for future people in this situation!
Welcome to the amended return direct deposit club! It's so frustrating how much outdated info is still floating around out there. I just went through this exact same situation about 6 weeks ago and was pulling my hair out trying to figure out what was actually going to happen. Your tax preparer definitely has outdated information - the IRS only started allowing direct deposits for amended returns relatively recently, so a lot of tax professionals haven't caught up yet. Based on my experience and what I've seen others report here, that 3-5 business day window is pretty accurate for most people. One thing I'd add to the great advice already given - if you have access to the IRS2Go mobile app, you can check your amended return status there too. Sometimes it updates before the transcripts do. And definitely don't panic if Friday comes and goes without seeing the deposit - the 846 date is when they initiate it, not necessarily when your bank will make it available to you. Looking forward to your success story update! This thread has become such a great resource for people going through this process.
Can someone explain in simple terms why we have to do all this backdoor Roth stuff anyway? It seems unnecessarily complicated. Why doesn't the government just let people contribute to Roth IRAs regardless of income? The annual limits are already pretty low.
It's because Roth IRAs were originally designed as a retirement vehicle for middle-income people. The tax benefits are pretty significant since all growth is tax-free, so Congress limited them based on income. The backdoor method exists because there's no income limit on Traditional IRA contributions (though there are limits on deductibility), and there's no income limit on conversions from Traditional to Roth. This loophole has been known for years but Congress has never closed it, essentially making it an approved method. It's definitely more paperwork, but for high-income earners, getting money into a Roth is usually worth the extra steps.
Thanks for explaining, that makes sense. It's just frustrating how everything in the tax code seems designed to create extra hurdles. I get limiting the tax advantages, but this seems like it just creates work for no reason since the backdoor option exists anyway.
I had a very similar situation last year and can confirm what others have said - you handled this correctly! The key thing that helped me understand it was realizing that the recharacterization essentially "undoes" your original Roth contribution and treats it as if you had made a nondeductible Traditional IRA contribution all along. The $450 in earnings that got moved with the recharacterization will indeed be taxable income when you convert it back to Roth in 2024. But this is actually normal - any time you convert from Traditional to Roth, you pay taxes on the growth that happened in the Traditional account. One tip: when you get your 1099-R forms, double-check that the amounts match what you expect. Sometimes brokerages make errors on these forms, especially with more complex transactions like recharacterizations. I had to get mine corrected last year because they initially showed the wrong distribution code. Also, don't forget that your 2024 backdoor Roth conversion ($7,000) is completely separate from all this 2023 recharacterization business, so make sure you're tracking both properly for your 2024 taxes.
Gabrielle Dubois
This is really helpful information! I'm in a similar situation with my consulting business and had no idea about the rent payment 1099 requirement that Benjamin mentioned. I've been paying office rent to my landlord monthly and it definitely exceeds $600 for the year. One thing I'm still confused about - if I use a business credit card to pay contractors, do I still need to issue 1099s? Or does the credit card company handle that reporting? I've been using my business Amex for most contractor payments to keep better records, but now I'm wondering if that changes my 1099 obligations. Also, for those who mentioned using online services, has anyone tried just using the IRS's own free fillable forms? I'm trying to keep costs down as a new business owner but don't want to mess up the filing process.
0 coins
Sean Doyle
ā¢Great questions! Yes, you still need to issue 1099s even if you paid contractors with a business credit card - the payment method doesn't change your reporting obligations. The credit card company reports your business expenses to you, but they don't handle 1099 reporting to the IRS or your contractors. For the IRS free fillable forms, they work fine if you only have a few 1099s to file, but they can be time-consuming if you're dealing with multiple contractors. You'll need to manually enter all the information and handle the distribution to contractors yourself. The forms are available on the IRS website, but make sure you're using the current year versions. Regarding rent payments, you're correct that you'll need to issue a 1099-NEC to your landlord if you paid more than $600 in rent during the year (assuming they're not a corporation). Make sure you have their W-9 form on file with their TIN - if you don't have it, you might need to backup withhold at 24% on future payments until you get it.
0 coins
Luca Russo
I've been following this thread and wanted to share my experience from last year when I was in a very similar position with my freelance marketing business. The 1099 requirements can definitely feel overwhelming at first, but once you understand the basics, it becomes much more manageable. A few additional tips that helped me: First, set up a simple tracking system now for next year - even just a basic spreadsheet where you log contractor payments as you make them. Include their name, amount, date, and whether you have their W-9 on file. This saves so much scrambling in January. Second, don't forget about the state requirements! Some states have their own 1099 filing requirements that are separate from the federal ones. Check with your state's tax department to see if you need to file copies there as well. Finally, if you're using payment platforms like Zelle or Cash App for business payments, keep detailed records since these might not show up in your regular business banking reports. I learned this the hard way when trying to reconcile my payments at year-end. The January 31st deadline is firm, so definitely don't wait until the last minute. Good luck with your filings!
0 coins
Chloe Martin
ā¢This is such valuable advice, especially about the state requirements! I had no idea some states have separate 1099 filing obligations. As someone who's completely new to this, I'm already feeling more confident about handling it properly. Your point about payment platforms like Zelle and Cash App is particularly helpful - I've definitely used those for a couple of smaller contractor payments and wouldn't have thought to include them in my tracking. Do you know if there's a specific dollar threshold where those informal payment methods become problematic, or should I just avoid them entirely for business transactions going forward? Also, when you mention setting up a tracking system, do you include any other details beyond name, amount, date, and W-9 status? I'm thinking maybe project description or payment purpose might be useful for my own records, but I don't want to overcomplicate things.
0 coins