


Ask the community...
Quick tip for anyone with capital loss carryforward - remember that you need to use short-term losses first against short-term gains, and long-term losses first against long-term gains. Only after that can you use remaining losses of either type to offset the other type of gain. Then use up to $3,000 against ordinary income. The ordering matters for tax optimization.
Is it better to use short-term or long-term losses against ordinary income if you have the choice? I've got both kinds carrying forward.
Short-term losses should generally be used first against ordinary income if you have the choice, as short-term gains (had you realized them instead of losses) would have been taxed at your higher ordinary income rate. Long-term losses are typically better saved to offset future long-term gains when possible, since long-term gains are taxed at preferential capital gains rates. By preserving long-term losses for future long-term gains, you're potentially getting more tax benefit in the long run.
One thing that's really important to understand is that capital loss carryforwards don't expire - they can be carried forward indefinitely until fully used up. This is different from some other tax provisions that have time limits. Also, if you're married and file jointly, both spouses' capital losses get combined on the joint return. But if you switch from married filing jointly to married filing separately (or vice versa), the carryforward rules get more complicated. The unused losses stay with whoever originally realized them. For record keeping, I'd recommend creating a simple spreadsheet to track your carryforward amounts by year and type (short-term vs long-term). This makes it much easier when you're doing your taxes each year, especially if you switch tax software or preparers.
This is really helpful advice about the indefinite carryforward period! I didn't realize there was no expiration date on capital losses. That's a relief since I have a pretty substantial loss that will take me years to fully utilize. The spreadsheet idea is brilliant - I'm definitely going to set that up. Quick question though: when tracking short-term vs long-term losses in the spreadsheet, should I also note the original transaction dates? Or is it enough to just categorize them as ST/LT based on the holding period when the loss was realized? Also, does the carryforward amount ever get adjusted for inflation or does it stay at the nominal dollar amount from when the loss occurred?
I completely understand your situation - I made the same transition from CPA to DIY tax prep about 3 years ago for my real estate partnership K-1s. The key is being methodical and not rushing through it. One thing that really helped me was printing out both my current K-1 and my prior year tax return side by side. This way I could see exactly how my CPA handled each item and follow the same pattern. Pay special attention to how passive losses were handled on Form 8582 - even with a profit this year, you likely have suspended losses that need to be tracked. For your specific question about AMT, I'd recommend at least running through the calculation if your K-1 has any entries in Box 17 (AMT adjustments) or if your total income exceeds around $100k. The good news is that with recent tax law changes, fewer people are actually subject to AMT than before, but it's worth checking. A couple of additional tips from my experience: - Double-check that your partnership's EIN is entered correctly in your tax software - Make sure you understand whether your partnership made any Section 199A elections that might affect your QBI deduction - Keep detailed records of any distributions you received during the year, as these affect your basis calculations TurboTax actually handles K-1s pretty well if you take your time with the interview process. The key is having all your supporting documents organized before you start. Good luck with your DIY approach - it gets much easier after the first year!
This is really practical advice, Paolo! The side-by-side comparison method with your prior year return is brilliant - I wish I had thought of that approach when I was getting started. Your point about Section 199A elections is particularly interesting. How would I know if my partnership made any special elections that might affect the QBI deduction? Is this something that would be clearly noted in the K-1 supplemental materials, or would I need to contact the partnership directly to ask about it? Also, when you mention keeping detailed records of distributions for basis calculations - are you tracking just the cash amounts, or do you also need to track the dates and any specific characterization the partnership provides? I've been pretty casual about filing away those quarterly distribution notices, but it sounds like I should be more systematic about it. Thanks for the reassurance about TurboTax handling K-1s well. It's encouraging to hear from someone who successfully made this transition and found it manageable after the initial learning curve. The methodical approach you describe definitely seems like the way to go rather than trying to rush through it.
I'm going through this exact same situation right now! Just got my K-1 from a real estate partnership and trying to figure out TurboTax for the first time instead of paying my CPA. One thing I discovered that's been really helpful is making sure I understand the difference between the various types of income on the K-1. My partnership has entries in both Box 1 (ordinary business income) and Box 2 (rental income), and I initially thought these might go to the same place, but they actually have different tax implications. Also, regarding your question about AMT - I called the partnership directly to ask if they had any AMT adjustment items, and they were able to tell me right away whether I needed to worry about Form 6251. Might be worth a quick call to yours as well. Has anyone here dealt with K-1s that have multiple state allocations? My partnership operates in three different states and I'm not sure if that complicates the reporting or if TurboTax handles that automatically. The learning curve is definitely steep but I'm finding that taking it step by step and not trying to rush through everything makes it much more manageable. Good luck with your DIY journey!
Welcome to the DIY K-1 club, Maxwell! You're absolutely right about taking it step by step - that's definitely the key to not getting overwhelmed. Your point about Box 1 vs Box 2 is really important. Box 1 (ordinary business income) and Box 2 (rental income) do go to different sections of Schedule E and can have different passive activity treatment, so it's great that you caught that distinction early. Regarding the multi-state situation you mentioned - yes, this does add complexity! TurboTax should handle the allocations, but you'll likely need to file tax returns in each state where the partnership operates and has income allocated to you. Each state will want its share of the income reported on their state return. The partnership should provide you with state-specific allocation information, usually in the supplemental schedules that come with your K-1. One tip: make sure you keep track of which states you'll need to file in, as you might be eligible for credits on your home state return for taxes paid to other states. TurboTax will usually prompt you about this, but it's good to understand the concept. Smart move calling the partnership about AMT items - that direct communication can save a lot of guesswork. Keep that partnership contact handy because you might have follow-up questions as you work through the return!
Lot of good advice here but nobody has mentioned the importance of the LLC Operating Agreement! That document should specify your actual status in the company and might clarify if you're supposed to be treated as a member, manager, employee or some combination. Request a copy ASAP if you don't already have one. Also, if they're paying you from a different entity than the one you work for, that could indicate they're using a Professional Employer Organization (PEO) or some kind of employee leasing arrangement, which is actually pretty common and not necessarily shady. But if that's the case, they DEFINITELY should be withholding taxes!
This is good advice. I'd also recommend checking if the LLC is treated as a "disregarded entity" for tax purposes, which is common for single-member LLCs. The tax treatment would flow through to the owner in that case, which complicates things further.
Excellent point about disregarded entities. If it's a single-member LLC being treated as a disregarded entity, then the tax situation gets even more complex. In that case, the company would be taxed as a sole proprietorship, and the owner would generally be unable to be classified as an employee of their own company for tax purposes. But given that the OP mentioned "profit units" that vest, it sounds more like a multi-member LLC with some kind of equity compensation structure. In that case, the LLC operating agreement would be absolutely crucial to understand exactly what those "profit units" represent in terms of actual ownership.
This situation has several red flags that suggest potential tax fraud or worker misclassification. The fact that they're claiming you as an employee for COVID relief purposes while simultaneously refusing to withhold taxes is particularly concerning - that's essentially having it both ways for their financial benefit. Here's what I'd recommend doing immediately: 1. **Document everything** - Save all contracts, pay stubs, emails about your status, and any communications regarding the COVID relief claims. Screenshot or print anything that might disappear. 2. **Request your LLC documentation** - Get copies of the Operating Agreement, any amendments, and confirmation of the LLC's tax election (partnership vs. corporation). You have a right to this information as a purported member. 3. **Calculate your potential tax liability** - Since no taxes have been withheld, you're likely on the hook for both income taxes AND self-employment taxes (15.3%) if you're truly classified as a self-employed LLC member. This could be a substantial amount. 4. **Consider professional help** - This situation is complex enough that you might want to consult with both a tax professional and an employment attorney. Many offer free consultations and can help you understand your rights and obligations. The discrepancy between your "employment contract" language and their current claims about your status, combined with the different payment entity and COVID relief issues, suggests this company may not be handling worker classification properly across the board.
This is really comprehensive advice, thank you! I'm especially concerned about point #3 regarding the tax liability. If I've been getting paid since October 2023 without any tax withholding, am I looking at penalties for not making quarterly estimated payments? I had no idea I might be responsible for self-employment taxes on top of regular income tax - that 15.3% rate is scary when applied to months of back pay. Should I be setting aside money now for what I might owe, or is there a chance this gets resolved in my favor if it turns out I should have been classified as an employee all along?
Oof this sounds super frustrating! The fact that you have a refund freeze code 810 but it says "no return filed" is definitely weird. Code 810 usually means they're holding your refund for review, but if there's no return on file, that doesn't make sense. I'd suggest calling the IRS directly at 1-800-829-1040 and asking them to explain the disconnect between the transcript showing no return but having transaction codes. Also might be worth checking if your SSN or other info got mixed up somehow during filing. Keep all those papers they sent you - you'll probably need them when you call!
This is super helpful advice! @Connor Murphy definitely keep those papers and when you call, ask them specifically about the disconnect between code 810 and no "return filed -" that combo makes zero sense. Also maybe ask if there was an identity verification flag or something that s'preventing your return from showing up properly in the system?
This is definitely a confusing situation! The combination of "no return filed" with a refund freeze code 810 is contradictory - you can't have a refund freeze if there's supposedly no return on file. This sounds like either a system glitch or your return got stuck somewhere in processing. A few things to try: 1) Call the IRS early morning (7-8am) on Tuesday-Thursday for shorter wait times, 2) Ask specifically about the code 810 and why it shows up with no return filed, 3) Request they check if your return is stuck in errors/review departments. Also double-check that your SSN and personal info match exactly what you filed with. Keep those papers handy when you call - they might have clues about what's really going on behind the scenes!
This is great advice! I'm dealing with something similar and the early morning call tip is gold - actually got through in like 20 mins yesterday doing that. @Connor Murphy when you call definitely ask them to check if your return is in the errors "department or" has any identity verification holds. Sometimes returns get flagged for manual review and just sit there for months without showing up in the regular system.
Pedro Sawyer
Honestly the 60,100⬠exemption you mentioned sounds like the Beckham Law (Special Impatriate Tax Regime), but I don't think you'd qualify based on what you described. You need to be moving to Spain specifically because a Spanish company hired you or your foreign company formally transferred you there. Working remotely for a US company usually doesn't qualify unless there's an actual formal assignment letter and the company has some presence in Spain.
0 coins
Mae Bennett
ā¢That's not entirely true. I actually qualified for the Beckham Law while working remotely for a US company. The key was that my US employer had to issue a formal letter assigning me to work from Spain, even though they had no office there. I had to register as a taxpayer within 6 months of arriving and submit form Modelo 149.
0 coins
Carlos Mendoza
I'm actually going through something similar right now - dual citizen planning to move to Madrid while keeping my US job. One thing I haven't seen mentioned is the timing aspect. Since both countries use calendar years, you'll want to be really careful about when you establish Spanish tax residency within the year. If you move mid-year, you might be able to split your tax obligations - paying US taxes on income earned before becoming a Spanish resident, and then dealing with the treaty provisions only for the period after establishing residency. This could potentially simplify your first year's filings. Also, don't forget about state taxes if you're currently in a state with income tax. You'll need to establish that you've truly severed ties with your home state to avoid triple taxation (federal, state, and Spanish). Some states are notoriously aggressive about claiming you're still a resident even after moving abroad. Have you considered consulting with a tax advisor who specializes in US-Spain cases? The treaty is complex enough that the cost of professional help often pays for itself in avoiding mistakes.
0 coins
Sean Flanagan
ā¢This is really helpful timing advice! I hadn't thought about the mid-year residency establishment strategy. Quick question though - how do you actually prove to the US state that you've severed ties? I'm currently in California and I've heard they're particularly aggressive about this. Do I need to change voter registration, close bank accounts, sell property, etc.? Also, regarding the professional tax advisor recommendation - does anyone have specific recommendations for advisors who really know the US-Spain treaty inside and out? I've talked to a few CPAs locally but they seem to just give generic international tax advice rather than treaty-specific guidance.
0 coins