


Ask the community...
Has anyone tried using the specific ID method for figuring out which shares you sold? I'm dealing with multiple purchases of the same stock over years and some sales are showing up as undetermined. My broker is telling me to use FIFO (first in, first out) but I think that's going to result in a higher tax bill.
You can use specific ID, but only if you identified the specific shares to be sold at the time of the sale. If you didn't specify which shares you were selling when you made the transaction, then you're stuck with your broker's default method (usually FIFO). You can't retroactively choose specific identification after the fact.
This is exactly the situation I found myself in last tax season! What helped me was creating a detailed spreadsheet tracking all my transactions. For the undetermined term lots, I went back through old account statements and trade confirmations to establish purchase dates. One tip that saved me time: if you have dividend reinvestment records, those often contain the purchase dates for fractional shares that might be causing some of the "undetermined" classifications. Also, don't forget that for inherited securities, you get a stepped-up basis to the fair market value on the date of death, and the holding period is automatically considered long-term regardless of how long you actually held them. The key is being systematic about it. I used Form 8949 with the appropriate boxes checked (C for short-term noncovered, F for long-term noncovered) and made sure to include code "B" in column (f) to indicate the basis wasn't reported to the IRS. Keep all your documentation - the IRS may not have the broker's records, but they can still ask you to substantiate your positions.
This spreadsheet approach is really smart! I'm dealing with a similar mess right now. Quick question - when you say "code B" in column (f), is that for ALL noncovered securities or just the ones where you had to estimate the basis? I have some noncovered lots where I do have the original purchase confirmations, so I know the exact basis and dates. Do those still get code B since the broker didn't report the basis to the IRS?
I'm new to this community and going through the exact same frustrating experience! Filed in early February, accepted within 48 hours, and now it's been almost 3 months with just a blank transcript. My "as of date" just changed from March 12th to April 22nd this week, which is what led me to search for answers and find this helpful thread. It's both reassuring and concerning to see so many others dealing with identical situations. I also claimed EITC for the first time this year, so that's probably contributing to the delay based on what everyone's mentioned. The lack of communication from the IRS is what makes this so stressful - like just give us SOME indication of what's happening! I've definitely joined the obsessive transcript checking club too. Probably refresh that page 4-5 times a day hoping for some miracle update, even though I know it's not productive. But when you're counting on that money and have no idea if your return is lost in some processing black hole, it's impossible not to check constantly. Thank you to everyone sharing their experiences and advice - this community has been way more helpful than anything on the IRS website. Really hoping this latest "as of date" change actually means real progress for all of us stuck in limbo! π€
Welcome to the community and the frustrating waiting club! I'm also new here but dealing with almost the exact same timeline - filed in early February, accepted right away, and now sitting here almost 3 months later with nothing but that blank transcript and changing "as of dates" that feel like they're mocking us at this point! I didn't claim EITC but I'm starting to think the IRS is just completely backed up this year regardless. It's honestly been such a relief finding this thread and realizing I'm not the only one going crazy over this. The obsessive transcript checking is so real - I've probably looked at mine more times than I care to admit, always hoping this will be the magical moment something finally appears! From reading through everyone's experiences, it sounds like the "as of date" changes can be a good sign that they're at least doing SOMETHING with our returns, even if we can't see it yet. Trying to stay optimistic that all of us early filers will finally get some movement soon. This waiting game is absolutely brutal! π©
I'm new to this community but dealing with the exact same situation! Filed in early February, accepted immediately, and it's been over 10 weeks now with nothing but a blank transcript. My "as of date" just changed from March 8th to April 25th yesterday, which is what brought me here looking for answers. Reading through all these responses has been incredibly helpful - it's both reassuring to know I'm not alone and frustrating to see how common this issue is this year. I also claimed EITC for the first time, so that's likely part of the holdup based on what others have shared. The obsessive transcript checking is so real! I've probably refreshed that page at least twice a day for the past month, always hoping this will be the time something finally shows up. It's especially maddening when friends who filed in March already have their refunds while those of us who filed early are still waiting. From what I'm gathering from the more experienced members here, the "as of date" change could indicate they're finally processing something, but it's not a guarantee. The lack of transparency from the IRS is what makes this so stressful - even a simple "your return is in queue position X" would be better than complete silence! Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences and advice. This community has been way more informative than any official IRS resource I've found. Fingers crossed all of us stuck in this limbo finally see some real progress soon! π€
This is such a fantastic resource! As someone who's been dreading calling the IRS about my 2023 tax return for months, having these detailed navigation steps laid out makes the whole process feel so much more manageable. I've been reading through all the comments and taking notes on everyone's tips - the consensus about calling Tuesday-Thursday mornings at 7:00 AM, having all documents ready, and keeping a notepad for reference numbers is incredibly helpful. I'm particularly grateful for the mention of the Refund Hotline at 800-829-1954 since that's exactly what I need to check on. One thing I'd add for other newcomers like myself - don't forget to have your filing status and AGI from your most recent return handy too, as several people mentioned the system often asks for these for verification. Thank you for putting this together and to everyone who shared their experiences - you've all made this intimidating process feel much more approachable!
This entire thread has been such a lifesaver! I'm also completely new to dealing with IRS issues and was feeling so overwhelmed about making that first call. Your point about having filing status and AGI ready is really helpful - I wouldn't have thought to prepare that information beforehand. I'm in a similar situation with my 2023 return and have been procrastinating for weeks because the phone system seemed impossible to navigate. Reading everyone's experiences and tips here has given me the confidence to finally tackle this next week. The Tuesday-Thursday 7:00 AM strategy seems to be the golden advice that keeps coming up. Thanks for adding that verification tip - I'm making a checklist of everything to have ready before I dial!
This is an incredible comprehensive guide! As someone who's been avoiding calling the IRS for weeks about my 2022 amended return, having these step-by-step instructions makes the whole process feel so much less intimidating. I've been reading through all the additional tips in the comments and I'm amazed at how helpful this community is - the advice about calling Tuesday-Thursday mornings at 7:00 AM, having all documents ready, and keeping a notepad for reference numbers is going straight into my preparation notes. One thing I'd add for fellow newcomers is to also have your previous year's tax return handy, not just the current year you're calling about, since I've heard they sometimes ask for verification information from prior returns. The extension shortcuts that Olivia mentioned (800-829-0582 with direct extensions) sound like a game-changer for avoiding the lengthy phone menu navigation. Thank you Henry for putting this together - you've created a resource that's going to save so many people hours of frustration!
I've been following this thread and wanted to add another potential cause I've encountered - check if your payroll system is handling state unemployment insurance (SUI) wage bases correctly. Some payroll systems incorrectly include SUI adjustments in federal tax calculations, especially when employees hit state-specific wage base limits that differ from federal limits. Also, if you're using a third-party payroll processor, they sometimes make "correcting" entries that don't get properly reflected in your 941 calculations. I'd recommend requesting a detailed payroll tax reconciliation report from them that shows exactly how they calculated each tax component for the quarter. One more thing - make sure you're not double-counting any year-end adjustments or corrections that might have carried over from Q4 of last year. Sometimes accounting departments make manual adjustments that create phantom discrepancies in subsequent quarters.
This is really valuable insight about the SUI wage base issues - I hadn't considered that our payroll system might be mixing state and federal calculations. We do use ADP for payroll processing, and I'm now wondering if some of their automated adjustments are creating these discrepancies without us realizing it. I'll definitely request that detailed tax reconciliation report you mentioned. Do you know specifically what to ask for from ADP? I want to make sure I get the right report that shows the federal tax calculations broken down by component. Also, your point about year-end adjustments carrying over is interesting - we did have some W-2 corrections from last year that required amended forms. I should check if any of those corrections are somehow affecting this quarter's calculations.
I've been dealing with payroll tax compliance for over 15 years, and a $140 fraction of cents adjustment on any size payroll is absolutely a red flag. This line should never exceed a few dollars at most, regardless of your payroll volume. Based on what you've already discovered with that February deposit discrepancy ($58,435 vs $58,294.81), you're definitely on the right track. That single error alone accounts for most of your $140 adjustment. Here are a few additional things to check: 1. Verify that your Schedule B reflects tax LIABILITY by pay period end dates, not when deposits were actually made. This is a common source of confusion. 2. If you switched payroll providers or had any system updates during the quarter, double-check that employee data transferred correctly, especially for anyone approaching wage base limits. 3. Look for any manual journal entries your accounting team might have made to "correct" payroll taxes that weren't properly communicated to whoever prepared the 941. 4. Check if any employees had mid-quarter status changes (like becoming exempt from certain taxes) that might not have been calculated correctly. Don't file until you get this sorted out. The IRS computers flag unusual adjustments, and you really don't want to deal with correspondence notices when this can be fixed now with some careful reconciliation work.
This is exactly the kind of comprehensive advice I was hoping for! The point about tax LIABILITY by pay period end dates vs actual deposit dates is crucial - I think this might be where our accounting team got confused. We did have a payroll system update in January that migrated some employee data, so your suggestion about checking that transfer is spot on. I'm also going to look for any manual journal entries since our accounting department sometimes makes "corrections" without documenting them properly. One follow-up question: when you mention checking for mid-quarter status changes, are you thinking about things like employees going from hourly to salary, or more like changes in tax exemption status? I want to make sure I'm looking at the right type of changes. Thanks for emphasizing not to file until this is resolved. I'd much rather spend the time now getting it right than deal with IRS correspondence later.
Natasha Petrova
Great question about cell phone deductions! Just to add to the excellent advice already given - when you're calculating that 70% business use percentage, make sure you're being consistent across all your mixed-use items. The IRS likes to see that your methodology makes sense and that you're applying the same logic to similar expenses. One thing I learned the hard way is to document your business use percentage calculation method in writing and keep it with your tax records. Don't just estimate - write down something like "Based on tracking calls/texts for 3 weeks in March, approximately 70% of phone usage was for client communications and work-related activities." This kind of documentation can be invaluable if you ever get questioned. Also, since you mentioned you're doing contractor work, remember that you can deduct the business portion of your monthly phone bill too, not just the phone itself. If you're using 70% for business, that applies to your monthly service costs as well. These ongoing expenses can really add up over the year!
0 coins
Cameron Black
β’This is really helpful advice about documenting the methodology! I'm just starting out with contractor work and honestly had no idea I needed to write down HOW I calculated my business use percentage. I was just planning to wing it with rough estimates. Your point about being consistent across all mixed-use items is something I hadn't thought about either - if I claim 70% business use for my phone, I should probably use a similar percentage for my laptop and other equipment that I use the same way. Thanks for the heads up about keeping written documentation with tax records too!
0 coins
Jackie Martinez
One thing I'd add to all this great advice - make sure you understand the difference between expensing and depreciating your phone. If it's under $2,500 (which most phones are), you can use the de minimis safe harbor rule and deduct the full business percentage in the year you purchase it. But if you go with a really expensive phone or bundle it with accessories that push the total over that threshold, you'll need to depreciate it over several years. Also, for your pre-business purchases like that monitor and keyboard - the fair market value when you start using them for business is key. You can't use the original purchase price if the items have depreciated. Look up what similar used items are selling for when you convert them to business use. This protects you if the IRS questions why you're claiming a deduction on something you bought months before starting your business. One last tip: set up a simple system now for tracking all this stuff going forward. Whether it's a spreadsheet, an app, or just a notebook, start documenting business use percentages and dates right away. It's so much easier than trying to reconstruct everything at tax time!
0 coins
Zara Malik
β’This is exactly the kind of detailed info I was looking for! The de minimis safe harbor rule at $2,500 is super helpful to know - my new iPhone will definitely be under that threshold so I can deduct the full business percentage right away. Your point about using fair market value for the pre-business items is really important too. I was planning to just use what I originally paid for my monitor and keyboard, but you're right that I need to figure out what they were actually worth when I started using them for business. That makes total sense from an IRS perspective. I'm definitely going to set up a tracking system now rather than scrambling later. Do you have any recommendations for simple ways to track business use percentages ongoing? I'm thinking maybe just a basic spreadsheet with dates and brief notes about how I'm using each item?
0 coins