Back to IRS

Aria Washington

1099 for Canadian contractor — do I actually file one with the IRS?

Running a small LLC and I hired a web developer based in Canada to do some contract work for us earlier this year. Paid her a few thousand dollars total across a couple of invoices. Now I'm trying to sort out year-end paperwork and I genuinely don't know if I'm supposed to issue a 1099 for Canadian contractor work or whether the IRS even wants me to report this. My accountant is on a long vacation and I can't get a straight answer from googling. The contractor is not a U.S. person, doesn't have an SSN, and all the work was done remotely from her home in Canada. Do I need an EIN or ITIN from her to issue anything? Or does the foreign contractor situation change what the IRS expects me to do entirely? I want to make sure I'm not missing a filing requirement before the end of the year.

Foreign contractors generally fall outside the 1099-NEC requirement that applies to U.S. persons — your question about what the IRS expects is the right one to start with. The form that actually matters for payments to non-U.S. individuals is a W-8BEN, which your contractor fills out to certify her foreign status. Without that on file, you're in a gray area. The IRS's site has the forms and instructions, and a tax professional familiar with cross-border payments is really the right call here since the rules around withholding and reporting for foreign contractors depend on factors specific to your situation.

0 coins

She never sent me a W-8BEN. I didn't even know to ask for one. So now I'm trying to figure out whether I should request it retroactively or whether that ship has sailed for 2025 payments.

0 coins

Retroactive W-8BEN is still worth getting — it documents the foreign status even after the payment. Keep it with your records. Whether it changes what you owe for 2025 depends on your situation, so definitely loop in your accountant or a tax pro on the specifics.

0 coins

Didn't know W-8BEN existed until last year. My bookkeeper brought it up when I started paying a designer in Mexico. These forms don't come up unless someone in the know flags them.

0 coins

The withholding question is what trips most people up here. If the contractor is truly foreign and the work was performed entirely outside the U.S., there's usually no withholding obligation on the payer's side — but that determination hinges on where the services were actually delivered. Canada-based work done in Canada is different from, say, a foreign national working from U.S. soil. The instructions on Form W-8BEN and the IRS's publication for payers of foreign persons walk through the analysis, though a CPA or enrolled agent with international experience is the clearest path to a confident answer on your own situation.

0 coins

She was 100% in Canada the whole time, never set foot in the U.S. for any of this work. That detail seems important based on what you're saying.

0 coins

Location of services matters a lot in these situations. Worth documenting that in writing — even just an email from the contractor confirming where the work was performed — in case the IRS ever asks.

0 coins

I had a similar situation with a developer in the UK last tax year and my CPA said the same thing: source of income and location of services are the two things that drive the analysis. Definitely not a DIY determination.

0 coins

Wages and withholding on my own account were the reason I ended up needing to phone the IRS this fall. Two W-2s from employers I'd had in 2025, and the numbers on my transcript didn't match what I had on paper — wanted to know what the IRS actually had on file for me before I filed. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handles the hold time on 800-829-1040 for you so you end up talking to a live IRS agent. Demo of how it works reaching a live person at the IRS: https://youtu.be/_kiP6q8DX5c. The agent pulled up my wage and income transcript for 2025 and read off both employers' withholding figures — one matched, one was off, so I knew exactly what I was dealing with before I filed. For the OP's question though: the IRS's own Business and Specialty Tax Line at 800-829-4933 handles EIN-related business questions, though for foreign contractor withholding rules you'd really want a tax professional first.

0 coins

Didn't realize the transcript could show employer-reported withholding like that. Useful to know even outside my contractor question.

0 coins

My wage and income transcript was off this year too — a 1099-NEC from a client hadn't posted yet when I checked in October. Ended up waiting another few weeks and it showed up. These things can lag.

0 coins

The difference between what an employer reports and what ends up on the transcript is something I never thought about until it caused a problem. Good heads up.

0 coins

Worth being clear on something that gets confused in these threads: a 1099-NEC is for U.S.-based independent contractors generally, while Form 1042-S is what payers use to report certain payments to foreign persons. These are separate IRS forms with separate filing deadlines and rules. Whether your specific payment to your Canadian contractor requires a 1042-S depends on the type of income, withholding status and other factors your tax professional would assess. The IRS has Publication 515 for payers, which walks through the categories of payments and when reporting is required.

0 coins

1042-S is a form I had never heard of before this thread. I need to look at Publication 515. Is that on the IRS's site at irs.gov?

0 coins

Yes, Publication 515 is on the IRS's site. Search it by name and it comes right up. It's dense but the section on independent contractors is what you'd focus on.

0 coins

My accountant mentioned 1042-S when I asked about a payment to a foreign vendor last year. She said most small businesses never deal with it because of how the foreign-source income rules shake out, but that you have to actually do the analysis rather than assume.

0 coins

Agreed that 1042-S trips people up. I confused it with 1042 (the annual return itself) for a while. They're related but different things.

0 coins

If your contractor has an EIN or ITIN already, that changes some of the paperwork logistics — but it doesn't change the underlying analysis of whether her income is U.S.-source and whether withholding applies. The contractor's tax identification number matters for form-filing purposes, but the determination of whether you owe withholding happens before you get to that step. Ask your contractor whether she has a U.S. tax ID; she may have one from prior U.S. client work. If she doesn't, Form W-7 is how foreign individuals apply for an ITIN, though that's her process to navigate, not yours.

0 coins

She mentioned she's worked with U.S. clients before so she might have an ITIN already. I'll ask her directly.

0 coins

My Canadian freelancer had an ITIN from previous U.S. client relationships — made the paperwork much simpler on our end. Definitely worth asking before assuming she doesn't have one.

0 coins

Knowing whether they have an existing ITIN or EIN saves a lot of back and forth. Some foreign contractors who regularly work with U.S. businesses already have this sorted.

0 coins

The bigger practical risk here isn't so much the 1099 — it's whether you should have been withholding 30% on the payments and remitting that to the IRS. I'm not saying you owe it, because a tax professional has to look at whether the services were U.S.-source income. But that's what the IRS would look at if they ever examined your business return. The W-8BEN your contractor provides is what relieves you of the withholding obligation in most cases. No form on file means you were technically the withholding agent. Talk to a CPA before year-end if you can.

0 coins

The 30% withholding thing is what I was most afraid of reading about. Really need to get my accountant on the phone before January.

0 coins

The withholding agent concept is what catches small businesses off guard with foreign contractors. It's not intuitive if you've only ever worked with U.S. contractors where the 1099-NEC process is straightforward.

0 coins

My CPA used the term 'withholding agent' and I had no idea what she meant at first. Once she explained it was me, as the payer, who's responsible for remitting anything withheld — that's when the stakes clicked.

0 coins

Has anyone actually called the IRS about a foreign contractor question directly? I'm in a similar situation with a contractor in the Philippines and I keep going back and forth on whether the IRS phone line would even answer something this specific or just punt me to a tax professional anyway.

0 coins

My experience is that 800-829-1040 for individuals and 800-829-4933 for businesses can answer procedural questions about forms and filing requirements. They generally won't give you a legal ruling on your specific tax situation, but they can tell you what a form does and when it's required. For the nuanced analysis on withholding, though, that really does need a tax professional.

0 coins

They're pretty good at explaining what a form is and what triggers its use. Where they draw the line is telling you definitively what your obligation is — that's tax advice territory that they refer out.

0 coins

Useful to know. I'll probably try calling just to get some clarity on the forms themselves before sitting down with a CPA.

0 coins

The U.S.-Canada tax treaty is worth mentioning here — Canada and the U.S. have a treaty that affects how certain types of income are taxed and what withholding rates apply. Business income earned by a Canadian resident from U.S. clients can be affected by treaty provisions. This is another reason why the IRS's standard rules for foreign persons need to be read alongside the treaty for Canadian contractors specifically. Your tax pro should factor that in.

0 coins

I had no idea there was a U.S.-Canada tax treaty that could affect this. This is getting more complicated than I expected. Definitely getting a CPA in front of this.

0 coins

The treaty is relevant and your tax professional would know to look at it. Bring it up specifically when you talk to them so it's on their radar.

0 coins

Tax treaties are what most online sources gloss over. The generic answer about foreign contractors doesn't account for them, which is why country-specific situations like Canada, UK or Mexico need individual analysis.

0 coins

My LLC made payments to a Canadian graphic designer last year for similar reasons — remote work, never in the U.S., not a U.S. person. My accountant's conclusion after reviewing the W-8BEN and the nature of the services was that no 1042-S was required and no withholding applied. But she said the same analysis done on slightly different facts could have come out differently. That's the thing — small changes in how the work is classified or where it's considered sourced can shift the answer.

0 coins

Knowing someone else went through this for a Canadian contractor and came out the other side is reassuring. Though I hear you that my facts might not match yours exactly.

0 coins

The 'it depends on the facts' answer is frustrating but it's genuinely true with foreign contractor payments. Two businesses paying Canadian contractors for seemingly identical work can end up in different places depending on how the services are described and contracted.

0 coins

My accountant said something similar about classification — how the contract describes the work matters for how the IRS categorizes the income type.

0 coins

Status on my amended 2024 return was showing nothing useful in the tool for weeks. I'd mailed a 1040-X back in August and wanted to know if it had even been received. Used Claimyr on 800-829-1040 and ended up with an IRS agent on the line — she confirmed the amended return had been received and gave me the date it was logged in their system. That was enough to know it wasn't lost in the mail. For the main question in this thread, the IRS's international taxpayer line might be an option, but honestly for a business paying foreign contractors, Publication 515 and a tax professional are the starting points.

0 coins

Good to know there's a way to actually confirm things were received by the IRS. My amended return situation is a separate story but I'll keep that in mind.

0 coins

Mailed returns and amended returns disappearing into the void is a real fear. Having a way to confirm receipt without just waiting is helpful.

0 coins

Eight to twelve weeks for an amended return to process is what the IRS says, but just knowing it was received takes a lot of the anxiety out of waiting.

0 coins

Whether the contractor needs to supply a W-8BEN or W-9 is actually a key distinction that some people mix up. A W-9 is for U.S. persons — you use it to get their TIN for a 1099. A W-8BEN is for foreign individuals certifying non-U.S. status. If your Canadian contractor gave you a W-9 instead of a W-8BEN, that changes the picture and probably means you'd treat her as a U.S. person for reporting purposes. Ask specifically which form she can provide.

0 coins

She hasn't given me either one, so I need to ask which is appropriate for her situation. I'm guessing W-8BEN based on this thread.

0 coins

W-9 versus W-8BEN is exactly the split that matters. If she's a Canadian citizen residing in Canada with no U.S. tax status, W-8BEN is the right form for her to give you. But she should confirm with her own tax advisor.

0 coins

My contractor in Germany sent me a W-8BEN without being asked because she'd dealt with U.S. clients before. Some experienced foreign contractors already know the drill.

0 coins

Employer identification numbers come up in this thread — worth noting that if the OP's Canadian contractor has set up any kind of U.S. entity or has a U.S. EIN from prior work, that changes things again. An EIN is free to get from the IRS and is issued right away online, but that's her process. For the OP, what matters is what tax identification she can certify, which flows into which form applies.

0 coins

She hasn't mentioned a U.S. entity but I'll ask. It would simplify things if she had an EIN on the U.S. side already.

0 coins

Foreign contractors who regularly work with U.S. businesses sometimes set up U.S. entities or obtain EINs for exactly this reason. It's worth a direct conversation with your contractor about her setup.

0 coins

Hired a Canadian video editor last spring for a documentary project. The whole W-8BEN conversation was new territory for me too. My CPA walked me through it and it turned out to be less complicated than I feared — the form itself is not long. But I was really glad I didn't just ignore the paperwork because I was confused. The year-end rush is not the moment to discover a withholding issue.

0 coins

Year-end rush is exactly where I am right now. The form being shorter than I expected is at least a small relief.

0 coins

The form's length isn't the issue — it's knowing which form to use and what it triggers. That's where the professional guidance earns its fee.

0 coins

My first time dealing with foreign contractor paperwork I definitely tried to DIY it and ended up spending more time confused than it would have taken to just ask a CPA upfront.

0 coins

EIN applications for businesses paying foreign contractors is something that sometimes comes up in reverse — people ask whether they need a new EIN for a foreign-related entity structure. Generally if you already have an EIN for your LLC, that's what you'd use on any forms you're required to file as a withholding agent. The IRS's online EIN application is immediate if you ever do need one, and there's no fee.

0 coins

Good to know my existing EIN is probably what I'd use on any forms. I was wondering if the foreign contractor aspect required something separate on my end.

0 coins

Your existing EIN as the payer is what goes on any withholding or information return you file. You don't need a separate one for foreign contractor payments.

0 coins

The Taxpayer Advocate Service is worth knowing about if you end up in a situation where the IRS hasn't resolved something within a reasonable timeframe and it's causing real financial hardship. For a question like this one — where you're trying to determine your filing obligations before year-end — they're not the right starting point, but it's good to know TAS exists at taxpayeradvocate.irs.gov if something goes sideways later.

0 coins

Keeping TAS in the back of my mind. Right now I just need to get the year-end compliance right, but good to know there's an advocate option if something goes wrong with the IRS.

0 coins

TAS helped someone I know navigate a complicated situation where the IRS hadn't responded to a letter for months. Good to have that resource in your back pocket for when the normal process stalls.

0 coins

Form 911 is how you request TAS assistance, though like the person above said, it's really for when the IRS process has broken down rather than for proactive compliance questions.

0 coins

One contractor paperwork thing nobody brings up early enough: get the W-8BEN before you pay, not after. Once the money has changed hands, chasing documentation is awkward and sometimes the contractor isn't responsive. Having the form before the first invoice makes the whole thing cleaner. For next year's Canadian contractor engagements, build it into your onboarding checklist.

0 coins

Before-payment is advice I'll take forward. This year is already messy but I can at least build a better process for 2026 payments.

0 coins

Exactly right on timing. Building foreign contractor documentation into the contract or onboarding step prevents the year-end scramble. Same as W-9s for domestic contractors — collect before the first payment.

0 coins

My firm added a foreign contractor documentation checklist to our standard vendor onboarding after getting caught flat-footed the first time. Takes five minutes to do upfront and saves hours later.

0 coins

Reply or document confirmation was actually what I needed from the IRS last month. Sent in some supporting paperwork they'd requested and wanted to know if it had been logged before a deadline passed. Used Claimyr on the number on my notice and ended up talking to an IRS agent who confirmed the document had been received and gave me the date it posted to my account. That deadline anxiety went away fast once I had that confirmation. For the OP: if your CPA determines you have any forms to file or any correspondence to send the IRS about the contractor payments, keeping proof of receipt matters.

0 coins

Deadline anxiety with the IRS is very real. Knowing there's a way to confirm documents were received rather than just hoping is helpful.

0 coins

Certified mail is what I use for anything important going to the IRS, but even then knowing it arrived at the building isn't the same as knowing it was logged on the account. Useful to know you can verify that.

0 coins

The gap between 'we delivered it' and 'they processed it' is where a lot of anxiety lives. Delivery confirmation from the postal service doesn't tell you whether the IRS actually has it in the system.

0 coins

Pulling the OP back to the core question: even if no 1099-NEC is required for a Canadian contractor, your business records should still document the payments clearly — the invoices, the contractor's foreign status, the nature of the services and where they were performed. If the IRS ever questions a deduction on your business return for contractor expenses, those records are what you'd produce. Good recordkeeping protects you regardless of how the reporting question resolves.

0 coins

Records are something I've been decent about — I have all her invoices and the payment records. I'll make sure to add documentation of her Canadian location and that the work was done there.

0 coins

Invoice documentation plus the W-8BEN when you get it covers the main bases. The contract itself, if you had one, is also worth keeping — it describes the services and where they were to be performed.

0 coins

Contracts for freelance work sometimes get skipped when it's a quick project, but even a simple written agreement over email that describes the scope and location of work has value as a record.

0 coins

The IRS's international taxpayer resources at irs.gov cover a lot of this ground if you want to read the official guidance before talking to your CPA. There's material for payers of foreign persons specifically. It won't substitute for professional advice on your own situation but it's useful background so you're not walking into the CPA conversation cold.

0 coins

Going to spend some time on irs.gov this weekend before my accountant gets back. At least I'll have better questions to ask.

0 coins

Reading the IRS's own materials first is exactly the right move. CPAs appreciate clients who've done homework — it focuses the conversation on your specific facts rather than basic explanations.

0 coins

The IRS's international pages can be dense but the explanations for payers are written for businesses, not tax attorneys. Worth the time.

0 coins

Offset showing up on my account was why I had to reach out to the IRS this past month — a prior-year balance had been adjusted and I wanted to know what the IRS had on record as the new figure before I made any additional payments. Used Claimyr on 800-829-1040 and an IRS agent read off the adjustment amount on my account for the year in question. Cleared up the discrepancy I was seeing. On the OP's foreign contractor situation: if your CPA determines any withholding should have been remitted and you end up with a balance on your business account, the online account at https://www.irs.gov/your-account shows what's owed by tax year and payment history.

0 coins

Hoping I don't end up with a balance situation, but noting the IRS Online Account link in case I need to check that.

0 coins

Knowing the actual figure on the account rather than what you calculated is important before making a payment. Good to know the IRS agent can confirm that.

0 coins

My IRS Online Account has been useful for checking payments posted correctly after I made them. Gives me peace of mind that the payment isn't floating somewhere unapplied.

0 coins

IRS AI

Expert Assistant
Secure