Franchise tax question — applied my payment to the wrong year and can't get anyone on the phone
Paid what I owed for 2024 through Web Pay back in April and thought I was done. Checked MyFTB a few weeks later and the balance for 2024 is still showing up as unpaid. Looked closer and it looks like the payment got applied to 2023, which had a zero balance already. So now I've got a past-due balance sitting on 2024 and no clue how to get it moved. I've tried phoning the FTB customer service line twice this week and both times I either got a busy signal or sat on hold until I gave up. Does anyone know the right number to call for something like this, and is there anything I can do in MyFTB to fix it or do I have to get a live person involved?
78 comments

Keith Davidson
800-852-5711 is the main customer service line for personal income tax stuff, weekdays 8 AM to 5 PM. For a payment applied to the wrong year, you do need to talk to someone — there's nothing in MyFTB that lets you move a payment between tax years yourself. Keep trying that number or try right at 8 AM when they first open.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorTried at 8:05 this morning and still got a 40-minute estimated hold. I'll keep at it but this is getting frustrating.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Not sure 800-852-5711 is the right number here — if there's a balance due showing, wouldn't that go to the collections line instead?
0 coins
Keith Davidson
Collections at 800-689-4776 handles accounts that have gone into active collections. A payment applied to the wrong year that you're trying to sort out is still a customer service matter, so 800-852-5711 is the right starting point.
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
April 15 was the due date for the 2024 return and payment both. If your 2024 balance is now showing past due because the payment landed on 2023, the late payment penalty could start adding up — 5% of the unpaid amount right away and then half a percent more for each month it stays open. Getting this corrected matters sooner rather than later.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorThat's what's worrying me. I made the payment on time, it just went to the wrong year. Does that mean I'm still on the hook for the penalty even if I can prove I paid?
0 coins
Ana Erdoğan
Whether or not FTB waives the penalty once they sort out the year is something only they can decide. You'd want to explain what happened and ask about penalty relief when you get someone on the line. FTB 2918 is the One-Time Penalty Abatement form if you need to go that route formally.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Hmm, one clarification on the 5% — that's the late payment penalty, but there's also a separate delinquent filing penalty if the return itself was filed late. Those are two different things and they don't stack the same way.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
A payment I made in September ended up sitting on the wrong tax year too — 2023 again, same as yours, when I owed it for 2024. Claimyr (claimyr.com) handled the hold on the customer service line so I ended up talking to an FTB representative. She confirmed the payment had been applied to 2023 and that it hadn't touched my 2024 balance at all. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at the Franchise Tax Board: https://youtu.be/XbqD8mexcoQ. The rep told me to expect a letter from FTB about next steps and to keep an eye on MyFTB for any updates to the account.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
How recent was your call? Wondering if the hold situation is as bad as it's been this week.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Phoned about two weeks ago, mid-morning on a Tuesday. I can't say whether it's the same right now.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Does the service work for the collections line too, or just customer service? I've got a separate situation I need to reach 800-689-4776 about.
0 coins
Elijah Knight
Mine was the customer service line. FTB's collections line is a different number and I can't say for certain either way on that one.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
60 days from April 15 to protest a Notice of Proposed Assessment caught me off guard on my own account last year. If FTB issues one because the 2024 balance looks unpaid, you've got that window to respond. Don't let that clock run without acting. File the protest through MyFTB or mail it in, but keep track of the dates on any notice you receive.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorHaven't gotten an NPA yet but now I'm watching the mail every day.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
An NPA would only come after FTB has gone through a few other steps — they'd typically send a Notice of State Income Tax Due first showing the balance with a payment voucher. The proposed assessment is further down the line.
0 coins
Jessica Suarez
Fair point. I jumped ahead. The Notice of State Income Tax Due (FTB 4963) would come first if they flag the 2024 balance. That gives you a chance to dispute before it escalates.
0 coins
Lily Young
MyFTB chat might actually help you here even if the phone lines are slammed. Inside your MyFTB account the chat can see your account details, so you could ask them to confirm which year the payment is showing on. General chat without logging in can't do that — it can only answer basic questions and they'll tell you they can't access your account.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorI didn't realize the MyFTB chat could see my account. Logging in and trying that now.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Tried the in-account chat myself once for a payment question and they told me to call. Might depend on the complexity of what you're asking.
0 coins
Lily Young
That tracks — simple balance or payment status questions they can handle, but anything that needs a manual correction probably still needs a rep on the phone.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Automated line at 800-338-0505 runs 24/7 and can give you balance information. It won't fix the mis-applied payment but at least you can confirm exactly what each tax year shows before you call in. That way you're not going in blind and you can describe the problem clearly to the rep.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorUsed it last night. 2023 shows a credit and 2024 shows a balance due. At least I know what I'm dealing with now.
0 coins
Justin Chang
That 24/7 line is good for getting the balance numbers. I used it before my own call in and it helped me have the right amounts ready so the rep didn't have to look up everything from scratch.
0 coins
Wesley Hallow
Exactly the idea. Having the specifics ready makes the call faster once you do get through.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Payment plan question on my own account brought me to the collections line last month. A monthly due date on my installment agreement wasn't showing what I expected in MyFTB, so I tried Claimyr to reach an FTB representative without sitting on hold all afternoon. The rep confirmed the monthly amount and due day on record for my plan. The $34 setup fee had already posted and the acceptance letter was listed as mailed, so it was just a timing thing on when it'd arrive.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Did the rep say anything about how long the acceptance letter usually takes to arrive?
0 coins
Grace Thomas
She said to watch for a letter in the mail and that MyFTB would also update. Didn't get a specific timeframe beyond that.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Payment plans top out at $25,000 and have to be paid off within 60 months — just flagging that in case the monthly amount on record doesn't match what you were expecting.
0 coins
Grace Thomas
Mine was within that range. What surprised me was finding out the online application isn't available once a wage garnishment is active — good thing I'd phoned instead.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
30 days from the date on a Request for Tax Return to respond is tighter than most people realize. If you don't reply, the next one is a Demand, and no reply to that leads FTB to estimate your income and issue an NPA with extra penalties stacked on. I know that's not exactly your situation but it happened to my brother-in-law and the balance they estimated was way off.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorI did file my 2024 return, so this shouldn't apply to me — but that's genuinely alarming to know about.
0 coins
Lauren Wood
Right, you're past that stage. Mostly flagging it because the thread's been helpful and others might be in that spot.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
To be precise on that — after the Demand for Tax Return (FTB 4601) goes unanswered, FTB issues a Notice of Proposed Assessment that includes the demand penalty, which is 25% of the total tax, on top of the delinquent filing penalty. That can add up fast.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Collections line being different from customer service tripped me up once. I called 800-852-5711 about a wage garnishment and they transferred me over to 800-689-4776. If your situation has moved into collections territory — like an earnings withholding order — you'd want the second number right away. For a payment misapplication that's still pretty fresh, customer service first makes sense.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorMine hasn't reached the garnishment stage, thankfully. Still in the 'payment in the wrong place' phase.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Worth knowing the EWOT is what FTB sends to the employer — the earnings withholding order for taxes. It tells the employer to hold up to 25% of wages. Completely separate from a bank levy which goes after your account directly.
0 coins
Ezra Bates
Correct — and once an EWOT is in place, only FTB can change the amount. It doesn't go away until the balance is paid in full or FTB releases it.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
October 15 is the extended deadline to file, but a lot of people don't realize that extra time to file isn't extra time to pay. The payment was still due April 15. If you'd filed on extension and also paid late, you'd have both the late payment penalty and the delinquent filing penalty running. In your case you paid on time — it just went somewhere else — so the question is really about getting FTB to recognize the payment on the right year.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorPaid and filed both by April 15 this year. The payment just ended up on 2023 for some reason.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
Does FTB ever explain how a payment ends up on the wrong year? Like is it something in the Web Pay screen that's easy to click wrong?
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Web Pay has you select the tax year when you set up the payment. If it defaults to something or you pick the wrong one, it goes there. Best to double-check the year on screen before you submit.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Sending FTB a secure message through MyFTB is another way to put your situation in writing if the phone hold is too long. You can attach documents — so you could include a screenshot of your payment confirmation showing the date and amount. That creates a paper trail while you wait to get someone on the phone.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorI do have the confirmation from Web Pay. Good idea to send it in writing too in case the phone situation drags on.
0 coins
Sophia Carson
Secure messages in MyFTB allow attachments, so a payment confirmation screenshot would work. FTB's response comes back through MyFTB as well.
0 coins
Justin Chang
Exactly — and it timestamps when you sent it, which matters if penalties start showing up and you need to show you were actively trying to resolve it.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
Address listed on my FTB account was an old one, and I only found out when a Notice of State Income Tax Due didn't reach me for months. Tried Claimyr to reach an FTB representative and asked what mailing address they had on file. It was still my address from three years ago. I updated it in MyFTB right after — Profile, then Update contact information. Mentioning it because a lot of people in a similar spot to yours might miss notices the same way I did.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorChecked mine and it's current, fortunately. But that's a good thing to verify — especially if something is about to be mailed.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
Address changes can also be done by mailing form FTB 3533 or phoning 800-852-5711 if someone doesn't have a MyFTB account yet.
0 coins
Kylo Ren
True, the online way is the fastest if you're already in MyFTB though.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
Five weeks was how long I waited once for a standard letter from FTB to arrive after a rep said to watch the mail. Not trying to alarm you but their correspondence isn't always quick. Checking MyFTB regularly for account updates is usually faster than waiting for paper.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorMyFTB already shows the payment landing on 2023. I can see the credit there. Just nothing correcting the 2024 balance yet.
0 coins
Paige Cantoni
That image of the payment confirmation in MyFTB — you can usually see when FTB received and processed a payment versus just when you submitted it. Those dates can matter if penalty questions come up.
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
FTB field offices in Los Angeles, Oakland, Sacramento, San Diego and Santa Ana can take in-person appointments. For a payment misapplication you might be able to go in and talk to someone face to face instead of fighting the phone line. Appointments are scheduled from FTB's Office locations page.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorI'm near one of those cities actually. Hadn't thought about going in person. Is it faster to get an appointment than to get through on the phone?
0 coins
Brooklyn Foley
Can't say from personal experience — I've only phoned. Might be worth checking FTB's site to see what's available near you.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
They accept check, money order and credit card at field offices. No cash. Useful if you end up needing to make any payments in person while you're sorting this out.
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
One-Time Penalty Abatement being available once in a lifetime is something most people don't know exists. If penalties do show up on your 2024 account because of this payment situation, it covers the late filing and late payment penalties for tax years starting on or after January 1, 2022. You'd need to have all your required returns filed and not have used it before. It's requested on form FTB 2918 or through MyFTB.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorHaven't touched it before and I'm fully filed for every year. Good to know that option exists.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Does the One-Time Penalty Abatement apply if the late payment was technically the result of a payment applied to the wrong year — like, can you argue you paid on time and it was mislabeled?
0 coins
Ellie Lopez
That's really a question for FTB directly. The abatement covers the penalty itself, but whether the penalty should even apply given your circumstances is a different conversation — and that's the one to have with a rep on the phone.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
Reasonable cause relief is a separate path from the One-Time Penalty Abatement. You'd use form FTB 2917 and submit a written statement explaining what happened with documentation. It doesn't stop FTB from collecting in the meantime though — you'd want to pay what's owed and then file the claim for refund to get the penalty back if they agree with you.
0 coins
Kennedy Morrison
Timing on a claim for refund — it generally needs to be filed within four years of the return's original due date, or one year from the overpayment, whichever is later. Easy to miss that window if you wait too long.
0 coins
Nina Fitzgerald
Correct, and the claim for refund has to be in writing, signed, with the reason spelled out. It doesn't automatically stop collection while it's pending.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorOkay so if penalties do land on the account my options are the One-Time Penalty Abatement through FTB 2918, or reasonable cause through FTB 2917, but I'd need to pay first and then fight for the refund. That's a lot to deal with for a payment that went to the right state just the wrong year.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Automated 24/7 line giving you balance info on both years is actually the fastest way to stay updated while you wait for the phone situation to resolve. 800-338-0505. Check 2023 and 2024 separately to see if anything shifts on either year.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Keeping track of when each balance changes could help you document what happened if penalty questions come up later. Worth noting the dates when you check.
0 coins
Hunter Brighton
Exactly — and if the 2024 balance drops to zero before any penalty is assessed, you're in a much better position than if you waited.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
FTB's scams page is worth a quick look if you get any unexpected calls claiming to be FTB about this. They say they contact people by mail several times before ever calling directly, and they won't threaten arrest or ask for prepaid cards. If something feels off, treat it as a scam.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorGood reminder. I've gotten phishing calls about tax stuff before. I know to ignore anything that sounds threatening or asks for weird payment methods.
0 coins
Marcus Williams
FTB's site at https://www.ftb.ca.gov/ has the scams page under the help section. Any suspicious contact can be reported there.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Taxpayer Advocate Services at 800-883-5910 is a last resort if the normal channels genuinely aren't resolving a hardship — things like a wage garnishment or levy causing immediate financial difficulty. For a payment applied to the wrong year that hasn't yet escalated to collections action, you're probably not at that stage. But the number's there if you get to a point where it's really affecting you.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorHopefully I won't need that, but I'm saving the number.
0 coins
Chad Winthrope
Their request form is the FTB 914 if you do need to make a formal request. And yes — standard hold time frustration on the phone lines isn't something they handle, it needs to be a genuine hardship tied to a levy, garnishment or lien.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Intent to Offset Federal Payments — FTB 1102 — is a notice worth knowing about if the 2024 balance stays unpaid long enough. It means FTB can send the debt to the U.S. Treasury Offset Program, which could take your federal refund and add a fee on top. Unlikely to get there quickly but it's one of the downstream consequences of leaving a balance unresolved.
0 coins
Taylor Chen
AuthorBetween this thread and my own panic, I've learned more about FTB's escalation process than I ever wanted to know. Getting through on the phone this week is my top priority.
0 coins
Jay Lincoln
Intent to Offset is kind of a wake-up call letter when it comes. Getting ahead of the balance before it arrives is definitely the right instinct.
0 coins
Dylan Baskin
Agreed. FTB tends to send several letters before anything that drastic kicks in. The key is responding to each one before its date.
0 coins