Back to California Unemployment

Chloe Delgado

UI claim reopened but system shows reopen your claim again - what's happening with California EDD?

So I'm losing my mind a little here. My benefit year is still open and I had a few weeks of work that ended, so I went into UI Online and clicked through to reopen my claim like you're supposed to do. Got a confirmation that it went through. But now every time I log back into myEDD, the homepage is still showing me that same prompt to reopen my claim. Like it never processed. I've tried logging out and back in, different browser, even my phone - same thing every time. My Claim History doesn't show anything new. No pending weeks, nothing. Has anyone seen this glitch before or is my reopen actually stuck somewhere? I've been out of work for two weeks already and I'm not sure if I should try submitting the reopen again or if that would just make things worse. Really don't want to mess up whatever is in progress if something actually is happening on their end.

DE 4581 paper certification and the online reopen are two totally different things, just so that's clear - you're talking about the reopen prompt on the homepage, not a certification form, right? Because the homepage prompt showing up again after you clicked through happened to me and it turned out the reopen hadn't gone all the way through. The system gave me a confirmation screen but then when I called EDD they said nothing was on file for the reopen. Ended up having to do it again.

0 coins

Yeah, definitely the homepage prompt - I never got to certifying anything yet because I can't tell if the reopen is actually in. That's what worries me, the confirmation screen felt real but the homepage looks exactly the same as before I did it.

0 coins

Confirmation screens on UI Online can be deceiving, honestly. The site sometimes shows a success message but if Claim History doesn't update within a day or two, something likely didn't process right.

0 coins

Had this happen last spring. Redoing the reopen a second time didn't create duplicate issues for me, it just went through the second time. But I'd wait a full business day first before hitting it again.

0 coins

The myEDD system has had some weird caching issues where the homepage doesn't refresh properly even after an action goes through. Before assuming the reopen failed, check the Payments tab in UI Online and also look at Claim History really carefully - sometimes a reopen registers but the homepage widget just hasn't caught up. Give it 24 hours minimum. If Claim History still shows nothing after that, the reopen probably needs to be submitted again.

0 coins

Payments tab shows nothing either, same as before. Claim History is empty of any new activity. It's been about 36 hours since I hit submit on the reopen so I'm starting to think it really didn't go through.

0 coins

36 hours with no Claim History movement, yeah I'd try the reopen again. The system usually posts something within a day if it took.

0 coins

Payments and Claim History both quiet after a day and a half is a pretty clear signal the reopen didn't register. Try submitting it one more time and watch for any confirmation number this time around.

0 coins

Eight weeks into my last claim the exact same thing happened - reopen prompt kept coming back after I'd already clicked through it, and Claim History sat empty. Ended up reaching out through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because I couldn't get through on 1-800-300-5616 no matter how early I called. The agent pulled up my account and said the reopen request had a system error and nothing had been submitted on their end, so it was fine to do it again from scratch. There's a video Claimyr put out about reaching a live person at EDD that walked me through what to expect: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. After I resubmitted the reopen that same day, Claim History updated with the pending weeks within about 4 hours.

0 coins

This is really helpful - knowing the agent could actually see on their end whether anything was submitted makes me feel better about trying to get through to EDD directly. I'll look into that option.

0 coins

Same type of error happened to my reopen attempt last fall. The EDD phone line is brutal to get through on but once you actually reach someone they can see exactly what's on the account.

0 coins

The reopen prompt looping back is almost always a sign nothing went through on EDD's side. Good to know an agent can confirm it right away instead of guessing.

0 coins

Something I thought for a long time was that submitting a reopen twice would cause problems - like EDD would see duplicate requests and flag the account. That's not really how it works. The system either processes the reopen or it doesn't, and if the first attempt failed, doing it again is just submitting the actual first real one. If you're concerned, the live chat through the Help button in UI Online runs Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m., and an agent can check whether anything is showing before you resubmit.

0 coins

Didn't realize the live chat hours were that specific - 9 to 2. I work weird hours so that's actually helpful to know I need to plan around that window.

0 coins

The live chat is way underused. People don't realize it exists and just keep hammering the phone line. Logged into the Help button last month and got someone in about 20 minutes.

0 coins

Duplicate reopen concern is a real worry a lot of people have but yeah, the system just processes or rejects, it doesn't stack them in a way that flags the account. Submit it again.

0 coins

My reopen attempt last year showed me a confirmation and I assumed everything was fine. Waited almost two weeks before realizing nothing had moved. The mistake I made was not checking Claim History the same day. If you do resubmit, check back within a few hours rather than assuming the confirmation screen means it's done.

0 coins

Two weeks is brutal - I'm already at 36 hours and panicking a little, so I really don't want this to drag on much longer.

0 coins

Claim History updating same day is the real confirmation, not the green checkmark screen. Learned that the hard way too.

0 coins

UI Online confirmation messages really should not be trusted on their own. The Claim History update is the only thing that tells you something actually happened.

0 coins

There's also the question of what week your reopen is supposed to start from. The reopen starts on the Sunday of the week you submit it, not backdated to when your last job ended. So if you're submitting it now versus a few days ago, you may have already lost some weeks depending on when exactly your work ended. This is worth getting clear on before you just resubmit without thinking about timing.

0 coins

Wait, so if my job ended two weeks ago and I attempted the reopen last week but it failed, those weeks might just be gone?

0 coins

The claim week starts on Sunday - if the reopen eventually processes for this current week's Sunday, the gap weeks before that may not be claimable. That's one reason getting this resolved fast matters.

0 coins

Definitely try to get the reopen confirmed and submitted as soon as possible. Every day counts for which weeks end up being eligible.

0 coins

Had a thought reading through all of this - is the reopen prompt you're seeing on the homepage the standard one that always shows up when a claim is inactive, or does it look different from what you saw the first time you used it? Sometimes the page just defaults to that prompt as a generic landing state and it doesn't actually mean the reopen failed. Worth logging out completely, clearing your browser data, and logging back in fresh to see if the prompt changes or if Claim History has updated.

0 coins

Cleared cache and cookies, logged back in fresh, still exactly the same prompt. Claim History has not changed. I think at this point I need to just resubmit and also try to reach EDD to confirm.

0 coins

Fresh login with cleared cache and still the same screen plus empty Claim History pretty much confirms the reopen didn't register. Resubmit it.

0 coins

Yeah if clearing the browser didn't change anything and Claim History is still blank, the technical fix isn't going to solve this - the reopen just needs to go through again.

0 coins

The other thing nobody mentioned yet is that after a reopen is processed, you still have to certify before any money moves. So even once you get the reopen confirmed in Claim History, you'll be waiting for the certification window to open up and then you certify for two weeks at a time like normal. The reopen itself doesn't trigger a payment - it just re-activates the claim so you can start certifying again.

0 coins

That's good to know so I don't get confused later and think something is wrong when no payment shows immediately after the reopen goes through.

0 coins

So many people think the reopen itself releases the funds. It's really just the first step - certifying is what actually gets the payment moving.

0 coins

The first certification after a reopen usually covers a waiting period week plus one paid week, same as when a claim first opens. Might want to keep that in mind for the first payment amount.

0 coins

EDD's phone line at 1-800-300-5616 is open 8 to 5 on weekdays and that's genuinely the most direct way to get a human to look at your account and confirm whether a reopen is in the system. I know getting through is a whole ordeal but for something like this where you're not sure if the action registered, talking to an agent who can literally read your account history is the fastest way to stop guessing.

0 coins

Calling is my plan at this point. At least then I'll know for sure instead of trying to interpret what UI Online is or isn't showing me.

0 coins

Calling early in the week, like Monday morning right at 8, tends to have slightly shorter waits than later in the week in my experience.

0 coins

For anyone reading this later: a reopen in California EDD is for when your same benefit year is still active but you went back to work for a bit and now that job ended again. If your benefit year has fully expired, reopening is not an option - you'd need to file a completely new claim. UI Online will usually tell you if the year is over, but if you're not sure, Claim History shows the original claim start and end dates.

0 coins

Benefit year is 52 weeks from the Sunday the original application week started. Important distinction because a lot of people think they can reopen past that point.

0 coins

New claim after a benefit year expires also means a new base period, which could affect the weekly benefit amount. Something to be aware of if earnings have changed.

0 coins

DE 429Z from the original claim shows when the benefit year ends. Good document to hold onto for exactly this reason.

0 coins

Last month my Claim History went blank for three days after I submitted a reopen and I genuinely thought I'd lost the whole thing. Eventually used Claimyr to get through to EDD because the phone line was running over an hour of hold music before disconnecting. The agent confirmed the reopen had been received but was showing a processing hold because a document from an old issue on my account hadn't been fully cleared. She noted the account and said to check Claim History again in 48 hours, and sure enough the pending weeks showed up.

0 coins

A processing hold from an old unresolved issue is something I hadn't even thought of. That's a whole other layer. I'll ask about that specifically if I get through to someone.

0 coins

Old unresolved issues blocking a reopen is actually more common than people realize. EDD doesn't always flag it clearly on UI Online - the account just kind of stalls.

0 coins

That's exactly why getting an agent eyes-on the account is so valuable for a situation like this. UI Online gives you just enough information to be confused.

0 coins

My cousin told me that if the reopen fails you just have to file a whole new claim - that's not right at all. As long as the benefit year is still open, you keep trying to reopen, not file fresh. Filing a new claim when a benefit year is active could actually cause problems because EDD would see two active claims for the same period. Don't do that.

0 coins

100 percent correct. A new claim while the benefit year is active is not how it works. The reopen process exists specifically for this situation.

0 coins

Filing a duplicate claim during an open benefit year can create adjudication issues that slow everything down significantly. Reopen is the right path, even if it's taking multiple attempts.

0 coins

EDD's own process for this is clear: same benefit year, job ends, you reopen - not refile. The reopen option in UI Online only appears when the year is still valid, which is part of what tells you which process you're in.

0 coins

Something I ran into on my own reopen last year - the system kept looping the prompt at me and I eventually figured out my identity verification through ID.me had lapsed somehow, which was blocking the reopen from completing on the backend even though the frontend seemed to accept my submission. The fix was going into ID.me separately, confirming my verification was still current, and then the reopen went through on the next attempt. Worth checking if you haven't already.

0 coins

I had no idea ID.me verification could lapse and block a reopen. Going to check that right now actually.

0 coins

ID.me verification going stale is an underreported reason for things not processing. Good catch.

0 coins

Had the same ID.me issue after a gap in my claim. EDD couldn't tell me directly that it was ID.me causing it - I had to go log into ID.me and re-confirm the connection myself.

0 coins

The CalJOBS registration is another thing that can silently block a reopen from completing. If you registered when you first filed but let the resume go inactive or stale, some accounts get flagged when reopening. EDD's requirement is that the registration and resume stay current - if you haven't logged into CalJOBS since your last claim period ended, it might be worth going in and refreshing your resume to make sure that's not the hidden hold-up.

0 coins

CalJOBS being a factor in the reopen itself is news to me. I did register originally but I haven't touched it since. Adding that to my list of things to check.

0 coins

The CalJOBS requirement is real and EDD can pause payments or processing if the registration has gone dormant. Definitely worth a login to make sure it's still active.

0 coins

EDD's notice when you first registered should have said to keep the resume current. Easy thing to forget about when you go back to work for a stretch.

0 coins

Reading through - has the original poster checked the actual myEDD homepage versus just UI Online inside it? Sometimes the reopen confirmation ends up visible only in a specific section of the main myEDD screen and not inside the UI Online claim view. The two dashboards can show slightly different things, which catches people off guard.

0 coins

Honestly I've been going straight to UI Online and checking Claim History from there. I'll look more carefully at the top-level myEDD homepage at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ to see if something is showing there that I've been missing.

0 coins

The myEDD landing page and the UI Online section inside it do sometimes show different statuses. Worth a fresh look at both.

0 coins

Before my reopen went through on a previous claim, the agent I spoke to through Claimyr also told me my pending certification windows would still be available for the weeks after the reopen processed, as long as I submitted the certifications within the allowed timeframe. The reopen itself doesn't auto-certify anything - those weeks sit there waiting for you to certify them through UI Online or Tele-Cert.

0 coins

That's a relief - I was worried the pending weeks would just disappear if the reopen sat unresolved for too long. Good to know the certification windows stay available.

0 coins

Certifying after a reopen works the same as regular certifying - UI Online or Tele-Cert at 1-866-333-4606. The pending weeks don't auto-expire while you're waiting for the reopen to process.

0 coins

The key thing is that you do still have to certify each two-week period yourself once the reopen is confirmed. The reopen just re-opens the door, nothing gets paid until you go through the certification process.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I had a situation where I submitted my reopen, it didn't show in Claim History, and then I submitted it again - and both actually went through, creating a weird duplicate state on the account. EDD sorted it out when I messaged them through UI Online, but it did cause about a week's delay. So rather than just blindly resubmitting, I'd recommend confirming the first attempt truly failed (via EDD agent or live chat) before hitting submit again.

0 coins

This is exactly the scenario I was worried about when I first posted. Now I definitely want to confirm with EDD first before I hit that reopen button again.

0 coins

Sending a message through UI Online is a good middle step if you can't get an agent on the phone right away. At least you have a paper trail of asking EDD to confirm the status.

0 coins

The duplicate reopen situation is the edge case that makes it worth taking an extra step before resubmitting. Usually fine, but sometimes it creates its own issue that takes longer to unwind than the original problem.

0 coins

Something worth flagging for the original poster: even during all of this uncertainty about whether the reopen processed, make sure you're keeping track of your work search activity for each week. The weeks after your job ended still require that you were able and available for work and actively looking. If those weeks eventually do show up as claimable after the reopen goes through, you'll need to certify accurately for each one and be able to say you were doing all of that.

0 coins

I've been applying to jobs the whole time so that's covered, just been keeping rough notes on what I applied to and when. Good reminder to keep that going.

0 coins

Work search requirements don't pause just because the reopen is stuck in limbo. You still need to have been able, available and looking for every week you eventually certify.

0 coins

The worst part of this whole situation is that UI Online doesn't give you a clear error message when a reopen fails - it just kind of silently goes back to the same state, which makes it impossible to know what actually happened. A system that shows a confirmation screen and then acts like nothing occurred is genuinely terrible design. EDD really should build in a clearer failure notification.

0 coins

The silent failure on UI Online is a known frustration. No error code, no follow-up email, nothing - just the same screen waiting for you again like you never did anything.

0 coins

UI Online's confirmation screen giving false confidence has caused so many people to miss weeks they should have been certifying. The system really needs a 'your action did not complete' message.

0 coins

EDD's tech infrastructure has improved a bit but this particular issue - silent processing failures on reopen submissions - has been around for years. For now the workaround is just manually verifying through Claim History or an agent.

0 coins

Final thought from me: once you do get the reopen confirmed and your first certification window opens, don't delay on certifying. The first certification after a reopen typically covers your waiting week and then the first paid week, and those windows can close if you miss them. Set a reminder for yourself as soon as you know the certification period opens so you don't add another delay on top of everything you've already been through.

0 coins

Noted - I'll set a calendar reminder the day the reopen is confirmed so I certify as soon as the window opens.

0 coins

Missed certification windows on the reopen are a separate headache from the reopen itself. Getting the timing right at that step saves a lot of back-and-forth with EDD.

0 coins

The first cert after a reopen matters a lot for getting any of the pending weeks paid. Don't let it sit.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure