UI claim balance dropped after certifying new claim instead of extension - what happened to my California EDD weeks?
Okay so I'm kind of freaking out right now and need someone to help me understand what happened. My benefit year ended about two weeks ago and I still had what I thought were remaining weeks I hadn't used. When I went into UI Online I saw an option to file and I clicked through it thinking it was going to continue my existing claim somehow, but now I'm looking at my Claim History and my balance looks completely different — way lower than what I expected based on the weeks I hadn't touched. Some background: I got laid off from my warehouse supervisor job back in spring and started collecting in May. Things were going okay, I found some part-time work for a couple months over summer which cut into my payments but didn't stop them. Then the part-time gig ended in September and I went back to certifying normally. I had been tracking my maximum benefit amount and I genuinely thought I still had around $2,100 left in my old claim's balance. Now it looks like UI Online is showing a totally different weekly benefit amount and a completely different maximum. I think I accidentally filed a brand new claim instead of doing something with my old one. Did I lose those remaining weeks? Can I get the old balance back? Or does a new claim just wipe everything out? The new weekly amount showing is actually lower than what I was getting before, which makes no sense to me if I was making similar wages. Really need someone who's been through this to help me make sense of this.
71 comments

Benjamin Carter
Balance dropping to something that looked wrong hit me last month — my DE 429Z showed $387 a week but after I filed what I thought was a continuation, the new award showed $298. Couldn't get anyone on the phone through the main line so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to a live EDD agent. They walked through my Claim History with me and confirmed the new claim had pulled from a different set of quarters than my original — my highest earning quarter had rotated out of the base period window. The agent also said the old claim's remaining balance doesn't carry over: once a benefit year closes, whatever weeks you didn't use are gone. That's just how it works on a new claim, they start the math fresh. There's a video on the Claimyr site showing how to reach a live person at EDD if you want to see it first: https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorWait, so the unused weeks from my old claim are just gone? That's the part that's destroying me right now. I had maybe 5 or 6 weeks of balance left and I was counting on that money.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
The old balance not carrying forward is accurate — each claim is its own bucket and when that benefit year ends, unused weeks don't roll into a new one. The new claim gets calculated from whatever your base period wages look like at the time you file it.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorThat makes me feel a little better knowing it's not a glitch at least, but it still stings. The new weekly amount being lower is what I really need to understand.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
The lower weekly amount on the new claim is almost certainly a base period shift. Your original claim pulled from the first four of the last five completed calendar quarters before you applied back in May. When you filed the new claim now, those quarters have shifted — if the high-earning quarter you had before is no longer inside the new base period window, your weekly amount gets calculated on a lower set of wages. If the new claim doesn't meet the minimum wage thresholds using those quarters, EDD automatically checks an alternate base period — your four most recent completed quarters. But if your claim is already valid under the standard base period, that alternate doesn't come into play to push the number up. The DE 429Z you get in the mail for this new claim will show the exact quarters they used.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorSo the system isn't broken, it just recalculated from a different set of quarters that happened to have lower wages in them? My highest-paid quarter was actually when I was working full time before the first layoff, and that quarter is probably older now.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Exactly that. EDD uses roughly a year-and-a-half lookback but the standard base period doesn't include the most recent completed quarter, so wages from your peak earning period can fall off the edge of the window over time.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorOkay that actually makes a lot of sense. The quarter where I made the most was about 18 months back so I guess it's outside whatever window they're using now.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
My claim year closed while I still had three weeks of balance unused — same situation. EDD doesn't extend a claim past its 52-week benefit year just because there were weeks left. The year starts the Sunday you first apply and ends 52 weeks later no matter what. After that you file new, and new means a fresh calculation. You're not being cheated, the unused balance genuinely expires.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorThe 52-week thing is what I missed. I didn't realize the year had a hard end date and I should have used those weeks before it closed.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
A lot of people think unused weeks just carry forward forever, but yeah it's a fixed window. If you're going to have any gap in certifying, keeping an eye on your benefit year end date is really important.
0 coins
KhalilStar
Something I want to flag for anyone reading this: once your benefit year ends and you file a new claim, you don't have an option to go back to the old one. I tried asking about this exact thing in the UI Online chat (the Help button, available 9 to 2 on weekdays) and the agent confirmed that the system closes the old benefit year fully. What you CAN do is make sure you're certifying every eligible week under the new claim so you don't lose more weeks this time around.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorI haven't certified under the new claim yet — should I do that right away even while I'm still figuring out whether the balance is correct?
0 coins
KhalilStar
Certify for whatever weeks are showing as available to certify. Missing certification weeks means EDD can't pay those weeks later, even if the claim is valid. You can still ask EDD questions about the balance calculation separately.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
This is the right call. Keep certifying while you sort out any other questions — stopping never helps your situation.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Went through almost this identical thing in October. Filed what I thought was an extension and ended up with a brand new claim showing a different amount. The key thing I learned: check your DE 429Z when it comes in the mail, usually within two weeks of filing. It will list out the actual quarters EDD used and the wages for each one. If any wages are listed wrong — like a quarter shows less than you actually earned — that's when you'd want to contact EDD to get it corrected.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorGood to know I should wait for the DE 429Z before fully panicking. I've only been looking at UI Online which shows the weekly amount but doesn't break down the quarters.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
UI Online won't show you the base period wage breakdown — you need the DE 429Z for that. And if any of the wage figures look wrong once you get it, you have 30 days from the mailing date to appeal it in writing.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
The appeal window on the DE 429Z catches a lot of people off guard because they don't realize it's even an appealable document. The 30-day clock starts from the date printed on the notice itself.
0 coins
Noah Irving
The part-time work you did over summer is worth thinking about. You mentioned your hours reduced your payments for a couple months — the wages from those weeks may now be inside the base period for your new claim but at a lower hourly rate than your full-time wages. If those part-time quarters are now your highest quarters in the new window, that would drag the weekly amount down directly.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorOh man I didn't even think about that. The part-time job paid about half my full-time rate and I worked it for about two and a half months. That could easily be one of the stronger quarters in the new base period if my old full-time wages are outside the window now.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Use the Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site to run an estimate based on what your wages looked like in each of the last six quarters. It won't be exact but it'll help you see whether the number EDD landed on makes sense.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
My cousin had almost this exact thing happen and she kept asking why the new claim was 'less money than before' — but it turned out her employer had also submitted slightly different wage amounts to EDD than she expected. The DE 429Z will show you what wages EDD actually has on file. If the number doesn't match your pay stubs, that's a discrepancy worth pursuing.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Wage discrepancies between what an employer reported and what the claimant earned are actually more common than people realize. EDD uses employer-reported wages but if they're wrong, the claimant can dispute them with documentation.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
She ended up calling with her pay stubs and got the quarterly wages corrected, which bumped her weekly amount up a bit. Not a huge fix but it mattered when bills were due.
0 coins
Madison King
DE 429Z mailing dates caught me too — my new claim was filed and I was watching UI Online every day expecting some updated number to show up there, but the full breakdown only came in the mail. While I was waiting and also trying to figure out whether my CalJOBS registration had transferred to the new claim, I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent about the registration question. The agent pulled up my new claim and confirmed that CalJOBS registration doesn't automatically carry over when a new claim is filed — I needed to verify it was current, within 21 days of the date on the new DE 8405 notice.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorI had no idea CalJOBS registration is tied to each claim separately. I haven't gotten a DE 8405 yet but now I know to watch for it.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
The 21-day window on the DE 8405 is a real deadline — missing it can pause payments on the new claim. Good heads up to watch for that notice when the new claim documents arrive.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Worth logging into CalJOBS now just to make sure your resume is up to date even before the DE 8405 arrives. That way you're not scrambling when the clock starts.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Before my benefit year closed I had someone tell me that unused weeks would automatically extend the year — that was completely wrong and I wish I'd double-checked. The 52 weeks is a hard end, the balance doesn't extend your year, and there's no general extension program running in California right now that adds weeks on top of the standard 26. The only way to keep collecting beyond 26 weeks of payments is California Training Benefits if you're in EDD-approved training, and even that has specific requirements and a deadline to apply.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorNo one told me about the hard cutoff either. I think I assumed 'you have X dollars left' meant those dollars would always be there whenever I needed them.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
The balance on a claim is better thought of as a cap than a savings account — EDD won't pay more than that maximum but it also won't hold unused amounts past the benefit year end date.
0 coins
Ella Knight
To directly answer whether you can get the old balance back: you can't. That's not EDD being difficult, it's just how UI benefit years work. What you should focus on now is making sure the new claim is calculated correctly from your actual wages. File an appeal on the DE 429Z if the wages used look wrong, keep certifying every two weeks, and get your CalJOBS registration squared away when you get the DE 8405.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorAppreciate having it laid out that clearly. So my path is: wait for the DE 429Z, verify the wages match my pay stubs, appeal in writing within 30 days if anything's off, and certify in the meantime.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Exactly that. And keep any pay stubs or earnings records from the last 18 months organized so you can respond quickly if something's off on the DE 429Z.
0 coins
William Schwarz
EDD phone lines during this time of year are absolutely brutal — tried calling three different days last week and got cut off every single time before reaching anyone. I've started sending messages through Ask EDD for anything that isn't urgent because at least there's a written record even if the response takes a while.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorHow long does Ask EDD usually take to respond? I'm trying to decide whether to wait for that or keep trying the phone.
0 coins
William Schwarz
In my experience, Ask EDD has been anywhere from 5 days to two and a half weeks, which is why I only use it for things where I don't need an answer immediately. For something time-sensitive I'd try the phone or the UI Online chat window between 9 and 2 on a weekday.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
The live chat from the Help button in UI Online has been faster than the phone for me lately. Still a wait but at least you're not getting disconnected.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Two weeks after my benefit year closed I got a form in the mail asking me to verify my identity again for the new claim — a DE 1326C. Had not expected that since I'd already verified with ID.me when I filed the original claim. Apparently filing a new claim can trigger identity verification again in some cases.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorShould I be on the lookout for that too? I already have an ID.me account from before.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
Watch for a DE 1326C in the mail. If it comes, respond to it quickly because pending weeks stay pending until EDD gets the verification back. Having the ID.me account already set up makes the online verification part faster.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
ID.me is already linked so the online path should go smoothly if you get that notice. The main thing is not to ignore it if it shows up.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
My first certification on a new claim always confuses me because the first eligible week is actually an unpaid waiting week — EDD doesn't pay it. So the first time you certify you're covering the waiting week plus one paid week, but payment-wise you only see money for the second week. If the balance on UI Online looks off after your first certification, that might be why.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorOh I did not know the waiting week resets with a new claim. So I won't get paid for my very first week even though I'm certifying?
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Right — the waiting week is served once per claim and it doesn't count toward the 26 weeks you can be paid. It just means week one of a new claim is always unpaid while you wait to serve it.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
The waiting week also isn't the reason the balance looks lower — it's that the total maximum on the new claim is different from what the old claim's maximum was. Two separate calculations.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
My weekly amount dropped by $67 when my second claim was filed and I genuinely thought EDD had made a mistake. Spent two weeks convinced something was wrong before I actually pulled out my pay stubs and ran the numbers myself quarter by quarter. Turned out my highest-earning quarter from two years ago was no longer in the base period window and the quarters EDD actually used were accurately showing what I'd earned during a slower stretch. Sometimes the lower number is just the accurate number.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorThat's a little humbling to hear, honestly. I might need to do that same exercise before I go further down the 'EDD made an error' path.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Run the estimate on the Unemployment Benefit Calculator on EDD's site with your actual quarterly wages — it'll tell you pretty quickly whether the number makes sense or not.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Something that tripped me up: I thought the new weekly amount being lower meant I was doing something wrong with the certification. The weekly benefit amount is set when you file and doesn't change based on how you certify — it only changes if EDD recalculates based on corrected wages or a different base period.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorGood to know the certification process itself doesn't affect the weekly amount. I was worried I had checked the wrong box somewhere.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
The only things that change your payment for a given week are your earnings during that week — if you work part-time and report wages, the first $25 or 25 percent of what you earned gets excluded and the rest reduces that week's payment.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
My benefit year end date also snuck up on me — I completely missed it and went two weeks without certifying because I didn't realize a new claim had to be filed. By the time I sorted it out those two weeks were gone. Used Claimyr to get a live EDD agent on the line and asked whether there was any way to certify retroactively for the gap weeks on the new claim. The agent looked at my account and said the new claim had been filed but those two gap weeks between the benefit year end and when I actually filed weren't claimable because a claim only starts on the Sunday of the week you file it.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorSo the two weeks I let lapse between when my benefit year ended and when I filed the new claim — are those just gone too?
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
Based on what the agent told me about my situation, yes — the new claim starts the Sunday of the week you filed it, not the week your old benefit year ended. If there's a gap between those two dates, EDD doesn't back-pay that gap.
0 coins
William Schwarz
This is a hard lesson for anyone reading. File the new claim as soon as you know the benefit year is ending, even before it officially closes, so you don't lose days in between.
0 coins
KhalilStar
CalJOBS registration on a new claim is not optional for most people. The DE 8405 gives you 21 days from the date printed on that notice to register and post a resume on CalJOBS. EDD will tell you clearly if you happen to be exempt — otherwise assume you're not. Payments can get held if the deadline passes without it being done.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorNoted. I'll go check my CalJOBS profile tonight and make sure the resume is updated so I'm ready when the DE 8405 shows up.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
The CalJOBS site can be slow sometimes — I'd log in sooner rather than later just to make sure your credentials still work. Last thing you want is to be locked out of the account when you need to update something before a deadline.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Went through two claim cycles now and the second time was definitely less confusing, mostly because I knew what to look for. The base period shift that lowers the weekly amount on a new claim is actually in EDD's written materials but nobody reads it until after they're confused. While waiting on a question about my second claim I was also trying to figure out whether my pension income needed to be reported — ended up using Claimyr to get through to an agent who confirmed I needed to report it at each certification and that EDD would determine any offset.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
AuthorWait, pension income affects the weekly payment too? I might have a small pension from an old employer and didn't even think about that.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
The agent said pension from past work can reduce benefits and EDD decides the amount. Report it when you certify and EDD handles the calculation — don't try to guess what it'll reduce.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
Social Security is different — that one doesn't get reported or deducted. But a traditional pension or retirement payment from a past employer is on the list of things to report during certification.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Reading this whole thread because I'm about to hit my own benefit year end in about six weeks. So the move is to file the new claim right before or right as the year closes and not wait around after?
0 coins
Ella Knight
File as soon as you're eligible to — there's no advantage to waiting and gaps between your old claim closing and the new one starting cost you days. Keep an eye on the benefit year end date in UI Online and plan ahead.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
Also make sure you've certified for every week you're eligible to certify before the year ends. Even if you're still job hunting, any week you're able and available to work should be certified so you don't leave paid weeks on the table.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Got it. Certify every eligible week right up to the end, file the new claim promptly, then watch for the DE 429Z and DE 8405. That's my checklist now.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
For anyone who reads this thread later: the reason a second claim sometimes shows a lower weekly amount isn't that EDD is shortchanging you or made a mistake. The base period shifts with every new claim you file, and whichever quarters fall into that window determine your wages — and therefore your weekly amount. If your best-paid work was more than about 15 to 18 months before you filed, it might not be in the picture anymore.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
The 15-to-18-month framing is a useful way to think about it. If someone got a big raise or took on overtime two years ago, that period could be fully outside any base period by the time a second claim rolls around.
0 coins
Noah Irving
And conversely, if someone worked a lot of overtime or picked up a second job in the last year, a second claim might actually come out higher. It really just depends on when the high-earning periods happened relative to when the claim is filed.
0 coins