< Back to California Unemployment

Second EDD eligibility interview after already being paid - is my ex-employer contesting?

So I've hit a weird situation with my unemployment claim. I was terminated from my retail management position back in November (they said 'performance issues' but I suspect it was because I reported safety violations). Anyway, I filed for UI right away, had my phone eligibility interview about 3 weeks later, and EDD approved my claim. I've been receiving benefits for almost 2 months now with no issues. But yesterday I got a notice through UI Online that I'm scheduled for ANOTHER eligibility interview this Thursday! The message doesn't explain why they need a second interview. I'm totally freaking out - could my former employer be trying to contest my claim now? Why would EDD schedule another interview after already approving me and paying benefits for weeks? Has anyone experienced this? Should I be worried about having to repay benefits?

Sofia Morales

•

This happens more often than you'd think. Your former employer has up to 30 days to respond to EDD after they're notified of your claim. Sometimes employers miss the initial notification deadline but then contest later. Another possibility is that your employer provided new information that EDD wants to verify with you. Don't panic though - having already been through an eligibility interview where they determined you were eligible works in your favor. Make sure you have documentation ready that supports your version of the termination. If you have emails, performance reviews, or anything showing the safety violations you reported, have those ready. Also, since you mentioned safety violations, make sure to clarify whether you were fired in retaliation for reporting those (which would strengthen your case).

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

Thanks for this info! I didn't realize employers could still contest after benefits had started. I do have a few emails documenting the safety issues I reported, plus text messages from my supervisor that seem to indicate the performance issues only became a problem after my report. I'll definitely have those ready. Do you know if I should mention the possible retaliation first or wait until they ask about the reason for termination?

0 coins

StarSailor

•

exact same thing happened 2 me last yr. ex boss tried 2 say i was fired for misconduct after i already got approved. EDD made me do 2nd interview but still kept paying me. just tell the truth and ull be fine

0 coins

Dmitry Ivanov

•

I've been through three EDD appeals (won all of them) and this is EXACTLY what happens when an employer contests late!!! They wait until you're already getting paid and then try to pull the rug out!! The EDD system is RIGGED to favor employers because if they can get your claim denied, their UI tax rates don't go up!!! Make sure you RECORD your interview (California is a two-party state so tell the interviewer you're recording) and DON'T let them twist your words about why you were fired!!! Also, they LOVE to trap you with the "did you break any company policies" question - ALWAYS say NO even if you were 5 minutes late once, because they'll use ANY admission against you!!!

0 coins

Sofia Morales

•

I appreciate your enthusiasm but some of this advice could be problematic. You absolutely should not lie to EDD about policy violations - that can result in penalties for false statements. Instead, be honest but provide context. And while you can request to record the interview, just be aware the interviewer can decline and proceed without recording.

0 coins

Dmitry Ivanov

•

Fine, don't listen to someone who's actually WON against the system multiple times. I'm just saying these EDD interviewers work with employers all day long and they're NOT on your side!!!!

0 coins

Ava Garcia

•

This is a common scenario with EDD. The second interview is typically scheduled for one of these reasons: 1. Your employer responded to your claim after the initial determination was made 2. EDD found some conflicting information they need to clarify 3. Your employer formally appealed the initial determination A few tips for your interview: - Answer questions directly and truthfully - Stick to facts rather than emotions regarding the termination - If your termination was related to reporting safety violations, that may qualify as whistleblower protection - Have your employment dates, final pay details, and separation explanation ready If you're having trouble getting through to EDD to ask questions before your interview, I'd recommend Claimyr (claimyr.com). They connect you directly to an EDD representative without the endless busy signals. Saved me hours of frustration when I had a similar situation. Their video demo at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10?si=TSwYbu_GOwYzt9km shows exactly how it works.

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

Thanks for breaking this down so clearly. I'll definitely focus on sticking to the facts during the interview. Do you know if they'll make a determination during the call or will I have to wait for a decision?

0 coins

Ava Garcia

•

Usually they don't make the determination during the call itself. The interviewer gathers information and then makes a decision afterward. You'll typically receive a notice of determination within 7-10 days after the interview. Keep certifying for benefits while you wait - if you remain eligible, you'll want those weeks certified.

0 coins

Miguel Silva

•

wait so did u quit or get fired? cuz if u quit u might not qualify even if they alrdy paid u. i kno someone who got paid for 3 months then had to pay everything back cuz edd found out they actually quit not fired

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

I was definitely fired - they called it a termination for performance issues. I didn't quit. I know quitting without good cause can disqualify you from benefits.

0 coins

Zainab Ismail

•

Just went through this exact situation in January! Was getting benefits since October, then boom - second interview notice. Turned out my employer claimed I was terminated for misconduct (I worked in healthcare), but I had documentation showing I followed all protocols. My advice: 1) Be super prepared with DATES. The interviewer kept asking me about specific incidents with exact dates, and when I could provide them, it seemed to help my credibility. 2) Stay calm and don't get defensive - I started getting worked up when they repeated my employer's accusations and I think it made me sound guilty at first. I ended up having benefits paused for 2 weeks while they made their determination, but then they ruled in my favor and backpaid the missed weeks. Good luck!

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

That's so helpful to know! Did they tell you during the interview that your benefits would be paused? And was there anything specific you said that you think helped them rule in your favor?

0 coins

Zainab Ismail

•

Yes, at the end of the interview they told me payments would be on hold pending determination. The thing that helped most was having written evidence (emails) showing I'd followed proper procedures and asked for clarification from management before the incident they claimed was misconduct. Having specific dates was definitely clutch - I had a little timeline prepared which helped me sound confident.

0 coins

Connor O'Neill

•

my cousin works for edd and she says they do random 2nd interviews sometimes just to check for fraud. might not be your employer at all, just routine

0 coins

Sofia Morales

•

One important point that hasn't been mentioned: while you're waiting for this to be resolved, make absolutely sure you continue certifying for benefits every two weeks on your regular schedule. Even if your payments get temporarily paused during this process, keeping up with your certifications ensures you'll get backpay for those weeks if the determination remains in your favor. Also, take detailed notes during your interview. Write down the interviewer's name, ID number if provided, and key points discussed. This can be valuable if you need to reference the conversation later or if you have to appeal.

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

Thank you - I wouldn't have thought about continuing to certify if payments get paused. That's really good advice. And I'll definitely take notes during the call.

0 coins

StarSailor

•

jst wondering did u get laid off or fired? cuz thats diffrent 4 edd rite?

0 coins

Dylan Cooper

•

I was fired/terminated. They specifically said it was for performance reasons, though I believe it was actually because I reported safety violations. It wasn't a layoff since they weren't eliminating my position - they actually hired someone to replace me two weeks later.

0 coins

TaxRefund AI

Expert Assistant
Secure

Powered by Claimyr AI

T
I
+
6,640 users helped today