Back to California Unemployment

Yuki Tanaka

Identity verification documents not approved disqualified how to file appeal with California EDD

Filed my claim about five weeks ago after my employer eliminated my entire department. Got through the initial application fine, uploaded everything ID.me asked for, thought I was done with the verification part. Then last week I get this Notice of Determination in the mail saying I'm disqualified because my identity couldn't be confirmed. No phone call, no email asking me to try again or submit different documents, just straight to disqualified. Here's what's confusing me: I uploaded my state driver's license AND my passport. Both are current and not expired. I even did the video selfie ID.me requires. The notice has an appeal form attached (I think it's the DE 1000M?) but it doesn't explain what specifically failed or what I did wrong. How am I supposed to appeal something when I don't even know what the problem was? My biggest worry is timing. The mailing date on the notice is from 10 days ago, which means I've already burned through a third of my appeal window without knowing this was even happening. Has anyone gone through this exact situation? What do I write in the appeal letter and is there anything else I can do in parallel while the appeal is pending?

DE 1326C is the form EDD sends when they can't verify identity from an online application - worth checking if you got one of those too, because sometimes it comes separately from the determination. My own situation was different but related: uploaded my license through ID.me and the photo came back rejected with no explanation, then my claim went to pending for three weeks before I got any notice at all. Claimyr (claimyr.com) got me on the phone with a live EDD agent after I'd spent days getting nowhere. The video they have on reaching a live person at EDD is at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10 if you want to see it first. When I finally talked to the agent, she pulled up my file and told me the specific document the system flagged - turns out the lighting on my selfie made the photo unreadable on their end even though ID.me said it passed. She told me I could redo the ID.me verification through myEDD and that it wouldn't affect my appeal timeline. Filed the appeal the same day and kept certifying every two weeks like normal.

0 coins

DE 1326C - I went back through my mail pile and I do have one of those, actually dated before the determination notice. I think I assumed it was just a general information letter. So the redo of ID.me verification, did you do that through the ID.me site directly or through https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ itself?

0 coins

The ID.me redo has to go through myEDD, not through ID.me's own site directly. If you go into ID.me separately it doesn't update EDD's side of things. Log into myEDD and there should be a prompt about identity verification right on the dashboard if it's still flagged.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I just logged in and there is a banner about identity, so I'll start there today. Still sending the appeal letter too since the disqualification is already on record.

0 coins

What goes in the appeal letter matters more than people realize. Ask yourself: what did I submit, when did I submit it, and can I prove the documents were valid at the time? Those three things are the core of what a judge is going to want to see. The rule is that you have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice, so with 10 days already gone you have about 20 left - don't wait on this.

0 coins

Twenty days feels tight. So the letter goes to the address printed on the notice itself, right? Not some general EDD address?

0 coins

Address on the notice, yes. Use the DE 1000M form that came with it or write your own letter, either works. Include a copy of the notice and copies of whatever documents you submitted through ID.me. If you have any confirmation emails from ID.me showing the submission date and what you uploaded, attach those too.

0 coins

Copies of the documents, not the originals - just making sure because I made the mistake of sending originals on a different appeal and had to request them back.

0 coins

Something that tripped me up when I appealed: the appeal goes to EDD first, then they send it to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board if the issue isn't resolved. The CUIAB is who actually schedules the administrative law judge hearing. You'll get a Notice of Hearing in the mail at least 10 days before it happens. At the hearing you're under oath and you can bring any documents, and you can represent yourself.

0 coins

Does EDD ever just reverse the disqualification before it gets to the CUIAB hearing? Or does it always go all the way to the judge?

0 coins

EDD does review it first when they receive the appeal. Sometimes they correct it at that stage without it going further. Depends on the situation - for an identity issue where the documents were clearly valid, there's a reasonable chance EDD catches it in their own review. But prepare for the full hearing anyway just in case.

0 coins

Went through the full hearing process last year for a different reason and the judge was actually really straightforward to deal with. Bring everything organized with dates, don't volunteer information that wasn't asked, and answer the questions directly.

0 coins

BEEN THROUGH THIS. My ID.me verification failed twice and both times EDD sent me the disqualification before I even knew there was a problem with the photos. The second time I called EDD directly and they told me to redo the verification AND send a written appeal simultaneously. Do both at the same time, don't wait for one to resolve before starting the other.

0 coins

Both at the same time - that's the plan now. Did EDD ever explain why the first redo didn't take? I'm trying to understand if there's something specific about how the photos need to be taken.

0 coins

Bright even lighting, no shadows across the face or the document, hold the ID flat, not at an angle. ID.me's own tips page actually covers this but EDD's agent told me the same things. The system is pretty sensitive to glare on the ID card.

0 coins

Glare is a huge one. I had to retake mine four times before it finally accepted. Using a plain white wall as background helped too.

0 coins

Keep certifying every two weeks during the appeal, even with the disqualification showing. If the appeal goes in your favor, EDD can only pay back the weeks that were actually certified. Miss the certifications now and those weeks are gone even if you win.

0 coins

Can I certify even though the status shows disqualified? I assumed the system would block me.

0 coins

UI Online should still let you certify. The disqualification freezes payments but doesn't lock out the certification process itself in most cases. If the system does block you for some reason, call EDD and note it in your appeal letter - that becomes relevant to whether you get back pay if you win.

0 coins

This is really important information, I had no idea certifying during an appeal was something you had to actively keep doing. I would have just assumed it was all frozen.

0 coins

The 30-day clock question keeps coming up in threads like this and I want to be clear about how it works: the clock starts from the mailing date printed on the notice, not from when you actually received it. That's usually a few days after the mailing date, so the window is effectively a bit shorter in practice. If you're close to the edge, mail the appeal via certified mail so you have a dated receipt.

0 coins

Certified mail is smart regardless of timing. Gives you proof of when it was sent in case there's ever a question.

0 coins

Mailing it certified mail today. The date on mine is tight enough that I don't want to leave any room for doubt.

0 coins

My cousin went through something similar last spring - wait, actually I should stay focused on what's relevant here. The parallel track that helped in a similar situation I know of: while the appeal was going, the person redid ID.me verification through myEDD and EDD actually updated the disqualification to pending before the hearing ever happened. So the redo can sometimes resolve things faster than the full appeal process.

0 coins

So technically the ID.me redo could fix it without the appeal needing to go to a hearing?

0 coins

In that one case yes, but the appeal was still the right move to have going because there's no guarantee the redo fixes it in time. Having both running protects you.

0 coins

Running both. I'm not canceling the appeal letter just because the verification redo might work faster.

0 coins

The specific question to ask EDD when you get through is: which document or step in my ID.me submission failed verification, and is there a specific form I need to submit separately to support the appeal? Some agents will note in the file that the claimant called and tried to resolve it, which can be helpful if the case does go to a CUIAB hearing.

0 coins

Asking them to note the call in the file is a good move. It shows proactive effort to resolve the identity issue, which matters when a judge is evaluating whether the disqualification was reasonable.

0 coins

Noted. I'll ask specifically for them to log the call when I get through.

0 coins

Weeks certified during the disqualification period showed as pending in my Claim History after my appeal was resolved - EDD went back and processed them. The appeal outcome applied retroactively to all the certified weeks, not just the ones going forward. My situation involved my identity being flagged after my claim was already partway through: used Claimyr to get on the phone with an EDD agent, and she confirmed which weeks were in the pending queue and told me the appeal had been received. That was the first actual confirmation I had that anything was moving.

0 coins

Pending in Claim History after the appeal resolved - does that mean they still take time to process payment even after the appeal decision comes in?

0 coins

There was about a week between when the decision letter arrived and when the payments actually posted. The determination came first, then EDD processed the certified weeks.

0 coins

The retroactive processing piece is reassuring to know. So keep certifying and the back weeks get handled when the appeal resolves, not week by week.

0 coins

DE 1000M has a section for 'Reason for Appeal' and it doesn't give you much space. Write the core facts clearly: submitted valid unexpired documents, identity verification failed with no specific reason given in the notice, requesting a hearing to present documentation. Keep it factual and attach copies of everything. The more detailed explanation is for the hearing itself if it gets that far.

0 coins

Keeping the initial form brief and factual is the right call. The hearing is where the full story comes out. Putting too much detail in the form can sometimes create inconsistencies if the facts are later clarified.

0 coins

Brief and factual on the form, full documentation ready for the hearing. Got it. I've been overthinking the form itself.

0 coins

wait does the disqualification for identity mean they think you committed fraud? because i heard that's different from a regular denial and has like extra penalties

0 coins

An identity verification failure and a fraud finding are two different things. A fraud disqualification comes with a 30 percent penalty and potential false statement weeks. An identity issue is EDD saying they couldn't confirm who you are - it's an eligibility question, not a fraud accusation. The notice itself will say if fraud is alleged, and from what's described here, it sounds like a standard verification failure.

0 coins

oh ok that makes sense, i was mixing those up. glad it's not the fraud thing

0 coins

Ask EDD when you call whether the pending weeks go back to the original filing date or only to when the appeal is resolved. The answer matters for how much back pay you could receive. Some people assume they lose the weeks during the disqualification period but that's not necessarily true if the appeal succeeds and those weeks were certified.

0 coins

Exactly - which is why certifying every two weeks during the appeal is not optional. The back pay question becomes moot if the weeks weren't certified in the first place.

0 coins

Both points understood. Certifying regardless, appeal letter going out certified mail today.

0 coins

The hearing itself, if it comes to that: you can bring anyone you want to represent you - yourself, an attorney, a union rep if you have one. Testimony is under oath. The Notice of Hearing comes at least 10 days before the date. The judge's decision comes in writing after.

0 coins

Can you request to reschedule the hearing if the date they give you doesn't work?

0 coins

You'd need to contact the CUIAB office as soon as possible after getting the notice. They have discretion on rescheduling - waiting until the last minute makes it much harder to get a new date.

0 coins

Got a rescheduled hearing date once and it took about three additional weeks to get the new date. Worth knowing there can be a delay if you have to move it.

0 coins

The ID.me verification step and the EDD appeal are handled by two completely separate systems - fixing one doesn't automatically notify the other. Even if ID.me shows your identity as verified, EDD still needs to process that update on their end before your claim status changes. That gap is exactly why calling EDD to confirm the update landed is worth doing.

0 coins

Separate systems is the key point here. I've seen people assume that because ID.me said 'verified' the EDD side updated the same day. It doesn't always work that way and you need EDD to confirm it on their end.

0 coins

ID.me verified on their end but EDD not yet updated - that explains the lag I've been seeing in UI Online. I'll call to confirm the update goes through on EDD's side.

0 coins

Does anyone know if the appeal window is different if the notice was returned as undeliverable and then resent? Mine was apparently sent to an old address before it was forwarded to me and I'm worried the clock started from the first mailing date.

0 coins

The 30-day window is from the mailing date on the notice itself, so yes, technically the original date counts even if delivery was delayed. If you're past the window because of the address issue, explain that in your appeal letter - a late appeal needs a stated reason. EDD takes that into account when it's something outside your control like a mailing issue.

0 coins

The notice shows a date from 35 days ago. So I'm already past the window technically. I'll write in the letter exactly what happened with the address and hope they consider the late filing.

0 coins

Including a written explanation for why the appeal is late is exactly right. Document the timeline as clearly as you can - date you received it, the forwarding situation, and when you filed. EDD and the CUIAB both have discretion on late appeals when the reason is reasonable.

0 coins

MyEDD also has a messaging option where you can send EDD a written inquiry about your claim if phone calls aren't going through. It creates a record of your contact attempt, which can be useful context in an appeal.

0 coins

The UI Online message option is slower than a phone call but it does timestamp your contact attempt. Useful as a backup when call volume is high.

0 coins

Using both - message through UI Online to document the contact attempt, and working on getting through by phone to get the actual question answered.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ - that's the determination notice number, same as what you have. After my documents got kicked back and I was stuck in disqualified status, filing the appeal letter was straightforward once I understood the form but actually confirming EDD received it was harder. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent and asked specifically whether the appeal was in the system yet. She looked it up and confirmed it was logged with the correct received date, which was the actual thing I needed to know.

0 coins

Confirming the received date in EDD's system - that's something I hadn't even thought to verify. Good to know you can ask them to look that up specifically.

0 coins

DE 1080CZ is the standard determination notice - glad to know what the form number is. Easier to reference when you're calling EDD.

0 coins

Waiting week still applies even when the disqualification is reversed - just want to flag that so the payment amount isn't a surprise. Every claim has one unpaid week built in, served on the first eligible week. The first certification after the claim processes usually covers the waiting week plus one paid week. So even if the appeal resolves everything, the first payout is typically one week's payment, not two.

0 coins

The waiting week can get confusing because people expect two weeks of payment on that first certification. It's one paid week and one unpaid waiting week - that's just how every California UI claim works from the start.

0 coins

Good to know going in rather than being surprised by the amount. I'll factor that in.

0 coins

I definitely would have been confused by that. So the total the claim can pay doesn't change because of the waiting week - it's the same 26 weeks maximum, just the first one is unpaid.

0 coins

For anyone still confused on the ID.me vs EDD split: ID.me is the third-party identity service, EDD uses it to verify who you are but they're different systems entirely. If ID.me says verified and EDD still shows disqualified, the update hasn't processed yet on EDD's end. You can check EDD's status in UI Online under your Claim History - pending there means EDD is still working on it, not that ID.me failed again.

0 coins

Claim History showing pending after a successful redo is actually a good sign - it means the disqualification isn't final anymore, EDD is reviewing it. Better than it still showing disqualified with no change.

0 coins

Mine just changed from disqualified to pending in Claim History about an hour ago. So either the redo went through or the appeal triggered something. Either way that feels like movement in the right direction.

0 coins

Pending is the right direction for sure. Keep certifying, keep the appeal moving, and check UI Online daily for further updates.

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure