Back to California Unemployment

Maya Lewis

Employer making employees refuse work to fire them and deny unemployment benefits - is this legal?

Last month my manager pulled me and three coworkers into a meeting and said our department was being "restructured." But instead of laying us off, they started handing us tasks they knew we couldn't complete — projects with impossible deadlines, roles completely outside our job descriptions, assignments in locations two hours from where we normally work. When we pushed back or said we couldn't take on certain tasks, HR documented it as "refusing work" and used that as grounds to fire us for cause. Now all four of us are being denied unemployment benefits because EDD is apparently seeing a termination for misconduct on our records. I've been paying rent, utilities, groceries all on credit cards for the past six weeks. Filed my claim through UI Online right away but it shows pending every week and I got scheduled for a phone interview. I honestly don't know if EDD sees through what this employer did or if we're all just stuck. Has anyone dealt with something like this where the employer engineered the situation to make you look like you refused work? What actually happens in the phone interview when both sides give completely different stories?

DE 4800 came in the mail about a week after I filed, same kind of situation where my employer was feeding the narrative to EDD before I even got a chance to speak. What happens in the phone interview is that the interviewer goes through the specific circumstances around why you stopped working — they want dates, what exactly was asked of you, what you said, and why. Both you and the employer give your sides separately. The interviewer doesn't tell you what the employer said, and you don't get to hear the employer's version in real time. EDD then makes a decision based on the whole picture. The key thing for your situation is that "misconduct" under EDD's standard isn't just getting fired — your employer has to actually prove there was misconduct. If what they're claiming is that you refused unreasonable assignments or tasks outside your contract, that context matters and you absolutely need to lay it all out during the interview. Write down a timeline now, before the interview, with every task they gave you, what was unreasonable about it, and what you said when you pushed back.

0 coins

The DE 4800 I got listed the interview date about nine days out from when I received it. I've been writing notes obsessively since I filed but honestly wasn't sure if any of that detail would matter or if EDD just rubber-stamps whatever the employer says.

0 coins

Rubber-stamping the employer's version is actually a myth — EDD really does look at both sides. Had a firing situation myself and the employer's characterization of what happened was pretty different from mine. The Notice of Determination came and it went in my favor.

0 coins

The timeline documentation is genuinely what saves people in these interviews. Specific dates and task descriptions are way harder for an employer to deny than general claims about attitude or performance.

0 coins

Switched jobs three times in five years and twice had messy exits where the employer controlled the narrative. For the second one, my employer's response to EDD described behavior I didn't even recognize as my own. What shifted things for me was that I was extremely specific in the interview about the sequence of events — the exact date I was given the new assignment, what was different about it from my usual duties, and that I'd flagged concerns to my manager in writing before I was let go. If you have any emails, texts or written notices that show the nature of these assignments, screenshot and save everything right now. EDD can't see your inbox but you can speak to what those messages said during the interview.

0 coins

Emails are actually something I do have — there's a chain where my manager assigned me to a location over 100 miles from my usual office with less than 48 hours notice, and I replied asking if there was some flexibility given I had no way to arrange transportation that fast. HR documented that reply as a refusal.

0 coins

That email chain sounds like exactly the kind of evidence that makes an employer's "refused work" claim fall apart. Keep that.

0 coins

yeah same kind of thing happened to my coworker, manager documented everything in a way that made normal questions look like insubordination. EDD doesn't always see through it but definitely lay it all out

0 coins

Termination-for-cause flag on my UI Online showed pending for almost five weeks before my interview was even scheduled. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what I ended up using to get a live EDD agent on the phone — there's a video about reaching a live person at EDD at https://youtu.be/JmuwXR7HA10. The agent pulled up my claim and told me the pending status was because the employer had flagged it as a voluntary quit, which wasn't what actually happened. Knowing exactly what the employer told EDD meant I could prepare my interview around correcting that specific claim instead of guessing what angle they'd taken. The agent also confirmed my DE 4800 had been generated and told me which questions were listed as the reason for the interview.

0 coins

Knowing what the employer actually told EDD before the interview would change everything about how I prepare. My biggest fear is walking in and not knowing which part of their story I need to address most urgently.

0 coins

DE 4800 lists the general topic areas but not the employer's specific claims — finding out what EDD actually has on file before the interview is a totally different thing and that's worth a lot.

0 coins

Going to try reaching an agent before my own interview next week. Same situation, former employer is claiming I abandoned my post but what actually happened is they changed my shift to overnight with two days notice after I'd been days-only for three years.

0 coins

There's a misconception floating around in threads like this that if your employer says "fired for cause" EDD automatically denies you. That's not how it works. EDD's standard is about misconduct specifically, and the burden sits with the employer — they have to actually demonstrate that what you did rose to the level of misconduct. Refusing an assignment that was outside what you were hired to do, or that was physically impossible to comply with on short notice, isn't automatically misconduct. EDD makes the call after the interview and weighs both accounts. Keep certifying every two weeks no matter what while this is pending.

0 coins

Certifying has stressed me out because I'm not sure whether to mark that I'm available for work when I'm also dealing with the pending adjudication — but yes, I've been doing it.

0 coins

Available for work means exactly what it sounds like — are you able to work and looking for work each week you certify. The adjudication being open doesn't disqualify you from being available, those are separate questions on the certification.

0 coins

Exactly — keep certifying through the whole process. If the decision comes back in your favor, those weeks only get paid if you certified them. Stopping early means losing weeks you'd otherwise be owed.

0 coins

Got fired from a warehouse job two years ago under almost identical circumstances — they started assigning me to a different facility 90 minutes away and when I said I couldn't get there reliably without a car, they wrote me up for "refusing assignment" three times and then terminated me. EDD's interview came about three weeks later. The interviewer asked me point blank whether I was given notice about the location change, how much notice, whether I tried to arrange transportation, and what I told my supervisor. Because I'd kept the texts where I actually asked my supervisor about carpooling options, I could speak to exactly what I did and didn't say. Decision came in my favor about two weeks after the interview.

0 coins

Two weeks after the interview for the decision — that's actually helpful to know in terms of timeline. Did they pay all the pending weeks at once when the decision came through?

0 coins

Payments posted within about 24 hours of the decision hitting. All the pending certified weeks paid out at the same time. The relief of seeing that in UI Online was something else.

0 coins

Location changes with no notice are specifically the kind of thing EDD considers when they're deciding whether a refusal was reasonable. Document the distance and the notice you got.

0 coins

something i want to flag is that some people in these situations also qualify to appeal as if they quit for good cause — like if the employer made the job so intolerable that any reasonable person would have left. but OP was actually fired so the frame here is misconduct on the employer's side to prove, not OP proving good cause for quitting. just making sure the thread doesn't confuse those two paths because they work pretty differently

0 coins

This is worth clarifying — quit vs. fired really does change the entire structure of the EDD process. For a firing, the employer has to show misconduct. For a quit, the person has to show they had a compelling reason. OP's situation is the fired path, so the burden question falls on the employer.

0 coins

My termination paperwork says "terminated for cause" so I'm definitely in the fired category. Good to understand the distinction though because I'd half-talked myself into framing this as a quit situation.

0 coins

yeah "terminated for cause" is the fired path, the burden is on them. you're in the right lane

0 coins

The four of you being in the same situation actually strengthens your individual cases in the interview. If EDD sees that the same employer simultaneously fired four employees from the same department for the same documented reason, that pattern is going to look like exactly what it is. Mention in your interview that this happened to multiple coworkers at the same time. It's context EDD doesn't have unless you give it.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about framing it that way explicitly. The fact that all four of us got the same treatment in the same week from the same manager does paint a pretty clear picture.

0 coins

Coordinating with your coworkers about what each of you experienced and says in the interview could matter a lot here. EDD interviews each person separately but the pattern across four claims can still emerge.

0 coins

Don't coordinate stories, just share facts — make sure you each have the actual dates and task descriptions clear in your own memory. The truth being consistent is different from scripting answers.

0 coins

CalJOBS registration is something to get done now if you haven't yet. After filing, most claimants get a Notice of Requirement to Register for Work (DE 8405) and have 21 days from the date on that notice to register on CalJOBS and post a resume. Missing that deadline can pause payments independent of the adjudication issue. It tripped me up during my own claim because I was so focused on the pending status that I didn't pay attention to the CalJOBS requirement until someone mentioned it.

0 coins

DE 8405 — I actually got this in the mail and completely forgot about it in the chaos of the pending status and the interview scheduling. Going to do CalJOBS registration today.

0 coins

caljobs.ca.gov is the site, registration is pretty straightforward. The resume doesn't have to be polished, it just has to be posted.

0 coins

CalJOBS caught me off guard too. Nobody mentions it when you file and then suddenly you're at risk of losing payments over something you didn't know was required.

0 coins

Weekly benefit amount on my DE 429Z was lower than I expected, which is what sent me to the phone in the first place. Claimyr got me through to an EDD agent after I'd gotten no response to my UI Online messages for two weeks. The agent explained that my weekly amount was based on my highest-paid quarter in the standard base period, and because I'd been part-time during one of those quarters, it pulled down the calculation. She also checked whether I might qualify under the alternate base period, which uses the four most recently completed quarters — my situation didn't change but at least I understood why the number was what it was. The alternate base period only gets used if the standard one doesn't give you a valid claim at all, not just to get a higher amount.

0 coins

The base period thing is news to me. My hours were also reduced before I was fired — does that affect the weekly benefit calculation or is it already baked into whichever quarter they use?

0 coins

Whatever wages you actually earned in that quarter are what count. If your hours were cut, those reduced wages are reflected in the calculation. The DE 429Z will show you what they used.

0 coins

Alternate base period being automatic, not something you have to request, is something a lot of people don't know. EDD switches to it automatically if needed. The agent was right that it's not used just to bump up an amount on a valid claim.

0 coins

HR at my last company was incredible at documentation that made normal employee behavior look like a pattern of problems. What I didn't know until after the fact was that I could have been submitting my own documentation to EDD during the adjudication process — things like email records, written notices, anything that shows the context around your firing. During the phone interview I was asked if I wanted to submit additional evidence. Say yes and ask how to send it.

0 coins

I didn't know you could submit additional evidence during that call. What format did they accept — email forwarded somewhere, fax, mail?

0 coins

The interviewer told me I could mail supporting documents to the EDD address on the DE 4800. It took a couple extra days but I sent copies of the emails I had. No idea if they read them all but they went into the file.

0 coins

Physical mail to the address on the DE 4800 is the standard way. Keep copies of everything you send.

0 coins

Misconduct is specifically what an employer has to prove when someone is fired. Getting that definition wrong cost me weeks of unnecessary stress — a coworker told me early on that EDD automatically sides with employers on firings, which is not accurate at all. EDD decides after hearing both sides, and an employer claiming "refused work" still has to show that the refusal was unreasonable, that you knew what you were doing was wrong, and that it rose to the level of intentional misconduct. Impossible deadlines and location changes given with no notice don't automatically meet that bar.

0 coins

The word "intentional" is doing a lot of work in that explanation. My pushback on the impossible assignment wasn't defiance, it was asking a clarifying question via email. I need to frame that clearly in the interview.

0 coins

Exactly — the nature of your response to the assignment matters as much as the fact that you responded. Asking a clarifying question is not refusing.

0 coins

The employer also has to tell EDD their version. If they respond with vague "performance issues" language instead of specific documented misconduct, EDD notices that too.

0 coins

Appeal process exists if the decision goes against you and I want to make sure that's on your radar. If EDD sends you a Notice of Determination (DE 1080CZ) that says you're disqualified, an Appeal Form (DE 1000M) comes with it. You have 30 calendar days from the mailing date on that notice to file the appeal in writing. After EDD reviews it, the case goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. An administrative law judge holds a hearing and your documentation — those emails, the assignment notices, the timeline you're building now — becomes much more directly relevant there than in the initial phone interview.

0 coins

30 days from the mailing date, not from when I receive it — that's an important distinction. Good to know the appeals path exists even if I'm hoping the interview resolves it.

0 coins

Mailing date is what starts the clock, yes. Write the date on the envelope when it arrives so you have a reference point.

0 coins

The appeals hearing is different from the phone interview — it's more formal, you're under oath, and you can bring documentation more directly. If the initial decision goes wrong, the appeal is a real second chance.

0 coins

My former employer contested my claim and I lost the initial determination even though I was pretty confident in my situation. The appeals hearing ended up being where I actually got to lay out the full picture with documentation in front of a judge. Definitely don't treat a bad initial determination as the end of the road.

0 coins

How long between filing the appeal and the actual hearing for you?

0 coins

Mine was scheduled a few weeks after I filed the appeal and I got the Notice of Hearing by mail at least ten days before it happened. The judge was thorough and listened to everything.

0 coins

Good to know the hearing is actually a real hearing and not just someone glancing at paperwork. Sounds like it's worth going through if the first decision is wrong.

0 coins

Severance pay is something to flag if any of you received it. It's on EDD's list of income to report when you certify — you report it in the week it was earned according to the certification questions. EDD decides how it affects any payment for that week. Some people assume severance automatically disqualifies them from collecting but that's not what EDD says — file and certify and report what you received and let EDD make the determination.

0 coins

No severance was offered in our situation — the company framed the firings as for-cause terminations, so they're not volunteering any exit packages. But useful to know for others reading this.

0 coins

In that case it's not a factor for you, but it trips people up often enough that it's worth naming in a thread like this.

0 coins

Vacation pay and in-lieu-of-notice pay are also on that reporting list. Any pay from the last employer beyond regular wages should be reported as the certification asks.

0 coins

FOUR EMPLOYEES FROM THE SAME DEPARTMENT IN THE SAME WEEK. EDD should absolutely see that for what it is. I went through a layoff where my employer also tried to dress it up as performance terminations across a whole team and it was exhausting to fight. The system puts a lot of weight on what the employer files and it shouldn't be that hard to get a fair hearing but honestly it is. Keep at it, all of you.

0 coins

The collective aspect of this is something I've been thinking about a lot. We're all filing separately and going through interviews separately, which feels isolating.

0 coins

Isolating is exactly the right word. The process treats each claim individually even when the situation is obviously coordinated on the employer's side.

0 coins

The fact that EDD interviews both sides is actually the system working the way it's supposed to — the employer's version gets documented and so does yours, and inconsistencies in the employer's account across four separate claims could be meaningful.

0 coins

Pending status staying frozen after the interview is what had me spinning out for weeks. After my interview for a wrongful termination situation, UI Online showed pending for over three weeks with no explanation. Used Claimyr to reach a live EDD agent who checked my file and found that the employer had submitted a late response that reopened the adjudication. That's why the determination was delayed. The agent noted it and told me EDD would still issue the Notice of Determination once the review was complete. Knowing there was a specific reason for the delay and not just a black hole helped me stop assuming the worst.

0 coins

Late employer response reopening the adjudication — that's a scenario I hadn't considered. I'll keep that in mind if my pending status doesn't move after the interview.

0 coins

The not knowing is genuinely the hardest part. My claim has been pending so long I've started assuming the worst by default even when I try not to.

0 coins

The UI Online Claim History showing pending doesn't tell you why it's pending, which is the whole problem. At least when you can find out what's actually in your file, you know what you're dealing with.

0 coins

Work search requirements stay active while your claim is in adjudication. For every week you certify, EDD expects you to be able to work, available for work, and looking for work. Keep a personal record of jobs you're applying to — dates, employer names, positions. EDD doesn't tell you a specific number of contacts you need in a week but being able to demonstrate genuine job search activity matters if your claim is ever reviewed.

0 coins

I've been applying but keeping track of where I applied has been inconsistent. Starting a spreadsheet today.

0 coins

Even a simple list in your notes app with the date, employer and position is enough. The habit of recording it matters more than the format.

0 coins

Work search being required during adjudication is something EDD doesn't exactly advertise loudly. Good to have it said plainly here.

0 coins

ID.me verification is worth confirming if you haven't. Your claim showing pending could partly be an identity verification hold, separate from the adjudication issue. If EDD couldn't verify your identity through ID.me automatically, you'd have gotten a Request for Identity Verification (DE 1326C) in the mail. Check whether that's sitting in your mailbox or needs action.

0 coins

I did get verified through ID.me when I applied online — it walked me through the photo process during the application. But worth flagging for anyone else reading this who skipped that step.

0 coins

Good — when ID.me goes smoothly it's usually not the hold-up. Some people apply online and think verification is optional and then wonder why everything is pending.

0 coins

DE 1326C sitting unaddressed in a pile of mail has stalled more claims than people realize. First thing to check when things go unexpectedly pending.

0 coins

CalFresh is worth looking into if covering groceries on credit card is becoming unsustainable. Unemployment benefits count as income when you apply, so your benefit amount factors into the eligibility determination. Apply through BenefitsCal or call 1-877-847-3663. It doesn't affect your EDD claim and you can be receiving unemployment while also receiving food assistance as long as you meet the income requirements the county sets.

0 coins

Hadn't thought about CalFresh. I've been trying to handle everything on my own but that's not sustainable. Worth looking into.

0 coins

The stigma around applying for CalFresh or other assistance is real but it's exactly what it's there for. Apply now, sort the rest out later.

0 coins

BenefitsCal is also where Medi-Cal applications go if you lost health coverage when you were terminated. Worth checking both at the same time.

0 coins

Phone line at 1-800-300-5616 operates Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Pacific, closed on state holidays. Live chat is available through the Help button in UI Online, Monday through Friday 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. If you need to reach EDD between now and your interview, those are the two options. Messages through your UI Online account also go to EDD but response time varies.

0 coins

Live chat hours being shorter than phone hours is something I didn't realize. 9 to 2 Monday through Friday is a narrow window for people who are job searching during the day.

0 coins

Narrow window is right — first thing in the morning right at 9 tends to be the best shot at getting into a chat session before capacity fills.

0 coins

i've had decent luck with 9am sharp but even then it's hit or miss. phone line has been impossible for me personally

0 coins

California Unemployment AI

Expert Assistant
Secure