Back to California Paid Family Leave

AstroAce

Paid family leave notice of determination can't reach anyone about wage continuation

Filed my PFL care claim about three weeks ago to look after my mom while she recovers from surgery. Everything seemed fine at first, got my receipt number, the Notice of Computation came in the mail and showed what my weekly amount would be. But then last week a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination (DE 2514) showed up and I honestly don't know what to do with it. My employer does wage continuation during leave and I'm worried that's why they flagged something, but the notice doesn't really spell it out in plain language. I've been trying to reach someone at EDD for four days straight and cannot get through. The line just rings and eventually disconnects. Has anyone dealt with a determination notice when they also had wage continuation from their employer? Do I have to appeal? Is there even time?

DE 2500E on my own care claim had me going in circles for a week before I figured out what was happening. Spent two mornings back to back dialing that 877 number and getting cut off before anyone picked up. Ended up trying Claimyr (claimyr.com) and finally got a live EDD agent on the line. The agent pulled up my claim and said the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification had been issued but was sitting unlinked to my payment method because I hadn't confirmed direct deposit in SDI Online. She walked me through what needed fixing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Four mornings I tried that number before seven a.m. and got nothing but a busy signal or a hang-up. Hard to believe some third-party service solves that when EDD itself can't keep the line open. What actually happened when you tried it?

0 coins

Dialed in, the service stayed on hold with EDD in my place, and my phone rang when an actual EDD agent picked up. That agent worked for EDD, not whatever service I used. She confirmed the DE 2500E issue and I had it fixed same day.

0 coins

The agent told them what was sitting unlinked on their own claim. That matches what EDD says about confirming payment method in SDI Online before the first payment processes. Worth knowing for anyone who chose direct deposit and hasn't double-checked it.

0 coins

Alright, hadn't thought of it that way. If the agent was straight EDD staff then I'd actually get a real answer about my claim. Might give it a shot after the week I've had trying that line.

0 coins

The determination notice scared me too when it arrived on my own bonding claim last year. The DE 2514 comes with an Appeal Form (DE 1000A) and you have thirty days from the notice date to appeal if you disagree with what EDD decided. That window is firm, so check the date printed on your notice right away and count from there.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Pulled the notice out just now and checked the date. I'm on day seven of the thirty. So I still have time, which is a relief. But I need to understand WHY they made the determination before I decide whether to appeal.

0 coins

Exactly right. Reading the notice carefully usually tells you the reason, even if the language is dense. The appeal goes in through SDI Online or by mail with the DE 1000A that came with the notice.

0 coins

The thirty-day clock catches a lot of people off guard. Good that you checked the date immediately.

0 coins

Wage continuation tripped me up on a PFL claim too, so here's what I found out. The rule is that your wages plus your PFL benefit can't go over what you'd normally earn. If your employer is paying your full salary during leave, EDD may determine you're not losing wages, which is the whole basis for getting PFL. That's likely what the determination is about.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

My employer pays about sixty percent of my salary during leave, not the full amount. So I am losing wages. Does that change things? I would have assumed partial wage continuation still qualified me.

0 coins

That part I'd honestly verify directly with EDD, because how they calculate it against your PFL benefit depends on the specifics. The notice should state their reasoning. If their math is wrong, that's your appeal.

0 coins

I'm not sure but I think I read somewhere that EDD can still pay the difference between what your employer pays and what you'd normally make? Not sure if that's how it works for care claims specifically. Someone who knows for sure should weigh in.

0 coins

The rule is that wages plus PFL can't exceed your normal wages, not that any wage continuation disqualifies you. If your employer is paying sixty percent, PFL might cover part of the gap. What's on the determination notice is what matters, so read that section closely and compare it to your own numbers.

0 coins

Appeal form is on the back of the DE 2514. Fill it out, send it in. Don't wait around hoping EDD changes something on their own because they won't.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Looked at the back of the notice and the DE 1000A is right there, you're right. I didn't even realize it was attached.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. It's easy to miss.

0 coins

My client went through something similar last spring and she told me the wage continuation thing is a super common reason for a determination. The employer reports it and EDD adjusts. Definitely read exactly what the notice says they found.

0 coins

Whether your client's situation matches this person's depends entirely on what the determination actually says. Too many variables.

0 coins

Fair enough. That's why I said to read what it says. Just sharing that she wasn't alone in getting one.

0 coins

Intermittent days reporting was where I personally got confused and ended up needing to phone EDD. Kept forgetting to report the days I went back part time and wasn't sure how the DE 2580GF worked. Tried Claimyr to reach someone because that PFL line was impossible to get through on my own. The agent confirmed which weeks EDD had on record as reported and which ones were still showing as pending, so I knew exactly what I needed to send in.

0 coins

Haven't heard of Claimyr before. What does it actually do?

0 coins

You set it up, it stays on hold with EDD while you go do other things, and your phone rings when an agent from EDD picks up. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I've got a question about my own DE 2580GF that I haven't been able to get answered. Might be worth trying for that.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that line for three weeks now. would actually try anything at this point.

0 coins

Dealt with the same determination notice situation with my wife's claim after her second bonding period. EDD sent the DE 2514 and we panicked, but it was just about her returning to part-time work and us not reporting wages properly. Appealed it and explained the hours, anyway it got sorted eventually.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Not reporting wages is exactly the kind of thing I'm worried I did wrong too. When you appealed, did you just explain on the form or did you send additional documents with it?

0 coins

We wrote it out on the DE 1000A and attached a letter from her employer showing the hours and what she was paid each week. EDD wanted the breakdown. Took a while but they accepted it.

0 coins

Attaching documentation makes the appeal a lot stronger. Good point.

0 coins

Wage continuation and PFL together is genuinely confusing and EDD's notice language doesn't help. The key thing nobody mentions is that you're appealing the determination, not reapplying. Those are very different things. Reapplying resets your 41-day clock and might cost you benefits.

0 coins

Wait, so if I filed a new claim instead of appealing I could actually lose some of the benefits from the original dates? That's scary. I haven't gotten a determination yet but I'm going to remember this.

0 coins

Exactly. The appeal keeps your original claim dates intact. A new claim starts fresh. If you disagree with EDD's finding, appeal within thirty days using the form that came with the DE 2514.

0 coins

yeah def dont file a new one, appeal the original. i made that mistake once and it was a mess to sort out

0 coins

Something I got wrong on my first care claim: I assumed the Notice of Computation was an approval. It isn't. That notice just shows the potential weekly benefit amount. The DE 2514 is what tells you what EDD actually decided about eligibility. Those two notices do completely different things.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

That distinction would have saved me a lot of confusion. I thought getting the Notice of Computation meant I was approved and then the DE 2514 threw me completely.

0 coins

Many people make that exact assumption. The Notice of Computation arriving doesn't mean EDD has finished reviewing the claim.

0 coins

EDD's own materials make this clear if you look for it, but they don't go out of their way to explain it in the notices themselves. The DE 429DF is the computation, the DE 2514 is the determination. Different documents, different purposes.

0 coins

Thirty days to appeal. Count from the date on the notice, not the date you received it.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Checked the postmark versus the date on the notice. There's a three-day gap. So my actual window is a bit shorter than I thought. Good to know.

0 coins

Don't cut it close. Mail the appeal with enough time to spare or submit it through SDI Online.

0 coins

DE 2514 landed on my claim last month because EDD said my employer's wage continuation made me ineligible for the period they were covering. I tried Claimyr after a week of getting nowhere on the phone line. The agent pulled up my determination and confirmed the specific pay period EDD had flagged and what the wage amounts they had on file were. That let me know exactly what I needed to dispute in my appeal.

0 coins

Had a similar experience using it for a payment method question on my own claim. The agent confirmed my direct deposit was set up correctly on their end but said the first payment had been issued to the debit card I'd had on the previous claim. Got it sorted from there.

0 coins

Which card is it? I didn't set up direct deposit and don't know what to expect.

0 coins

EDD's card is through Money Network. The agent said it would arrive by mail if I hadn't gotten it already, and that was the case for me.

0 coins

Good to know the card isn't through the old bank anymore. That confused people for years.

0 coins

The appeal form asks for your reason. Be specific. 'I disagree with EDD's finding' isn't enough. Write exactly what your employer pays, what period they cover, and why that shouldn't disqualify you entirely or should only reduce your benefit.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Wrote out a rough draft of what I'd put on the appeal and it helped me realize I was being too vague. Going to include the actual dollar amounts from my employer's written leave policy.

0 coins

Attach that written policy if you have it. A document from HR is better than your word alone.

0 coins

HR letter plus a pay stub showing what you actually got during leave. Both together make it really hard for them to argue with.

0 coins

Part D on my care claim had already been submitted by the doctor's office online when I tried Claimyr to confirm EDD had received it. The agent looked up my claim and said Part D was showing as received and matched to my receipt number, which was the one thing I'd been anxious about. That confirmation let me stop worrying about the 41-day deadline.

0 coins

Honestly sounds like marketing to me. A service that just 'stays on hold' for you and suddenly you get through when nobody else can? Hard to believe that's real.

0 coins

Thought the same thing when I first saw it mentioned. Tried it anyway after my own attempts at that line went nowhere for days. The agent picked up and confirmed my receipt number was in their system and matched the claim ID I'd been given. Turned out my receipt number was correct but I'd been checking the wrong claim ID in SDI Online.

0 coins

Okay if someone who was skeptical tried it and got an actual EDD agent on the line, that's different from just taking someone's word for it. Might try it to ask about where my own Part D stands.

0 coins

The 41-day thing is real pressure. Glad you got that confirmed before the window closed.

0 coins

edd is impossible to reach this is nothing new. tried calling eleven times in two days last month and not once did i get a person

0 coins

Eleven calls and nothing is unfortunately pretty standard. I had four straight mornings of that before I found another way through.

0 coins

what did you do

0 coins

Got a live EDD agent eventually. The line is brutal on your own.

0 coins

I'm in a somewhat similar situation but my determination hasn't come yet and I'm already nervous. If I get a DE 2514, do I appeal right away or wait to see if EDD reconsiders on their own?

0 coins

Don't wait. EDD doesn't reconsider on its own. The thirty-day clock starts from the date on the notice and nothing stops it. Appeal the moment you've read the notice and understand what you're disputing.

0 coins

Okay. I'll read it immediately if one arrives and not set it aside. That thirty-day window sounds easy to accidentally let pass.

0 coins

People let it pass all the time. Set a calendar reminder the day the notice arrives.

0 coins

The SDI Online message feature is worth using if you can't get through by phone. In myEDD, go to your claim and send a Request Claim Update. It's not instant but it creates a written record and EDD has to respond to it.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online this morning before I found this thread. If that gets a response before my thirty days are up I might not need to phone at all.

0 coins

Good move. Keep the appeal timeline going in parallel though. Don't wait on the message response to decide whether to appeal.

0 coins

The written record from SDI Online is useful too if you end up at an appeal hearing. Everything documented.

0 coins

The benefit calculation when wage continuation is involved is something EDD explains on the determination notice, but it's dense. Your weekly PFL benefit plus whatever your employer pays cannot go over what you normally earn in a week. If the two together would exceed your usual wages, EDD adjusts the PFL down or finds you ineligible for that period.

0 coins

That's the clearest explanation I've seen of how those two things interact. The original poster said their employer pays sixty percent, so PFL should still cover part of the difference unless EDD calculated something differently.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

My normal weekly wages would not be exceeded even with both combined. If EDD thinks they would be, their numbers are off and that's exactly what I need to show in the appeal.

0 coins

Document your normal weekly wage, what your employer paid during leave, and what PFL would have added. If the total is under your normal wage, lay that out clearly on the appeal form.

0 coins

Appeals take time and EDD doesn't rush them. File it, then be patient. At least once it's in you've protected your right to dispute the finding.

0 coins

Right. Filing it is what matters. You can keep gathering documents while it's pending.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Mailed the DE 1000A this afternoon with a copy of my employer's leave policy attached. Receipt from the post office in hand. Now I wait.

0 coins

Filing it with documentation the same day is the right move. Good luck with the outcome.

0 coins

The thirty days to appeal is in the same section of the determination notice that explains the finding. EDD prints it plainly but most people skip to the conclusion and miss it. The Appeal Form (DE 1000A) can also be submitted through SDI Online under the claim, not just by mail.

0 coins

Didn't know you could submit the DE 1000A through SDI Online. That feels safer than hoping it arrives in the mail on time.

0 coins

SDI Online creates a timestamp. If you're close to the thirty days, online is the safer route. If you mail it, send it with tracking.

0 coins

Good tip on the tracking. Easy to do and proves it was sent on time.

0 coins

been dealing with a determination on a bonding claim and nobody told me wage continuation from my job would affect it. feel like this should be explained somewhere obvious before you file, not after

0 coins

EDD's site does mention it, but it's buried. Most people learn it the hard way.

0 coins

yeah thats where i am now. learning the hard way.

0 coins

Same honestly. The claim process feels smooth and then the determination notice shows up and you realize there was a whole layer of stuff nobody flagged upfront.

0 coins

EDD phone line being unreachable is not new information. Has been like this for years. Send the appeal in writing and stop trying to phone.

0 coins

wish someone had told me that two weeks ago when i was spending my mornings redialing

0 coins

Now you know. Mail plus SDI Online message. That's the actual path.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure