Back to California Paid Family Leave

Malik Davis

Paid family leave claim denied after using PTO to supplement — what did I do wrong?

So I'm completely lost and honestly a little panicked. I took time off in October to bond with my daughter and my job lets us use PTO on top of PFL, so I did both at the same time figuring that was totally fine. EDD just sent me a denial notice and I don't even know where to start. I reported my wages like I was supposed to, so why would the claim get denied? Is it because I was earning too much with the PTO stacked on top? Has anyone dealt with a paid family leave claim denied after using PTO to supplement their PFL? I don't want to lose the whole eight weeks, I just thought I was doing the right thing.

Payment weeks on my bonding claim went weird after I added PTO too, so I called EDD to find out which weeks were paid and when the next payment would come. Getting anyone on that line is brutal, I tried for four mornings in a row and the recording just ended the call every time. Eventually I tried Claimyr (claimyr.com) and actually got through to someone at EDD. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and said two weeks were marked paid and the third was pending because the wages I reported from PTO pushed that week over my normal earnings. She said PFL plus the wages I get from paid time off can't be more than what I normally make, excluding overtime. That was the piece I was missing.

0 coins

Spent three weeks trying that line myself. Never once got a person. Hard to believe you got through on some service.

0 coins

Got the same dead-end recordings the first few days. What the agent told me was specific to my claim, she named the week and the amount. That was not a bot.

0 coins

Used it too for my own bonding claim! The agent told me I had six weeks left in my 12-month window, which I had completely lost track of. Good to know before I try to use them later!

0 coins

Wait, so your PTO wages plus the PFL payment together can't go over your regular pay? I had no idea there was a cap on that. Does EDD calculate it automatically or do I have to tell them somehow?

0 coins

You report your wages to EDD, including PTO pay. If the total for a week is more than your normal earnings, EDD adjusts the PFL amount for that week or may not pay it at all.

0 coins

Normal earnings meaning my regular weekly paycheck, not including overtime?

0 coins

Right, overtime is excluded from that comparison. It is your base wages they look at.

0 coins

That is exactly what tripped me up. I never thought the PTO would count as wages I had to report because my employer said it was fine to use them together.

0 coins

October 14th my PFL claim showed pending for a week I took vacation pay on top of it. The wages I reported for that week came to more than my usual Friday deposit. EDD held that week entirely. Ended up getting paid for five of the seven days once I sent in the corrected wage amounts on the certification.

0 coins

Five of seven days is an interesting way to put it. Does EDD really break it down by individual days?

0 coins

Each day pays one-seventh of the weekly benefit amount, so yes, if part of a week is over the wage limit they can pay some days and not others.

0 coins

That is actually a helpful way to think about it. So a week where your PTO pushes you over your normal pay for three days would still get you PFL for the other four?

0 coins

In theory yes, though the actual calculation is on EDD's side. Report everything accurately and let them figure the days.

0 coins

You need to appeal. The denial notice came with an appeal form, the DE 1000A. Thirty days from the date on the notice. Don't miss it.

0 coins

There was a form in the envelope. I didn't even look at it closely, I was just upset. I'll find it tonight.

0 coins

Read the reason on the denial too. If it says wages exceeded normal pay for specific weeks, you at least know what they're disputing.

0 coins

The DE 2500E on my own bonding claim never showed up in SDI Online and I couldn't figure out if a payment had actually been issued. Tried the EDD line myself a few times with nothing but a busy signal. Ended up using Claimyr and reached an agent who looked at the claim and told me the payment had been issued that same morning to my direct deposit, the DE 2500E just hadn't refreshed on the portal yet. Really glad I didn't assume it was lost.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's line for you, then your phone rings when an agent picks up. That is the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh, okay. I've been trying to ask EDD whether the proof of relationship I uploaded matched to my son's claim. That is exactly the kind of thing I would use it for.

0 coins

EDD denying a claim because of PTO is honestly the most frustrating thing. You did what your employer told you to do and now you're being penalized for it.

0 coins

EDD isn't really penalizing her. The rule says PFL plus wages can't top normal pay. Employer's policy and EDD's rule are two different things.

0 coins

Yeah I know the rule. Still frustrating when nobody tells you that upfront.

0 coins

My employer definitely did not explain the wage limit piece. I just assumed 'allowed to use together' meant there were no consequences.

0 coins

pto wages absolutely count as earnings you have to report, found that out the hard way last year. if you dont report and they find out later thats an overpayment and thats way worse

0 coins

I did report everything, that's the part that's confusing me. I reported all the PTO wages and they still denied it.

0 coins

oh then its probably just that the amount went over your normal pay. the denial notice should say the specific weeks

0 coins

Report everything, every time. Never try to guess what matters. That part you got right.

0 coins

The denial might be for specific weeks rather than the whole claim. The notice should break down which weeks EDD found your combined wages exceeded normal pay. If the denial is only for those weeks, you might still get paid for weeks where the PTO didn't push you over.

0 coins

I really hope that is how it works. I only used PTO for the first two weeks of leave, the rest I had no employer pay at all.

0 coins

Then weeks three through eight, if you took all eight, should not be affected by the PTO issue at all. That is a separate analysis for each week.

0 coins

That is good to know, I was worried that one problem week could tank the whole claim.

0 coins

Appealing within 30 days is the most important step right now. The Appeal Form is the DE 1000A and it comes with the denial notice, which is the DE 2514. You can submit it online or by mail, whichever is easier, but that 30-day window runs from the date printed on the notice, not the date you received it.

0 coins

Counted from the date on the notice, not when it arrived. That changes my timeline, I need to look at that date tonight.

0 coins

Same thing happened to me. I almost waited too long thinking the clock started when I got it.

0 coins

Did you get a Notice of Computation before this happened? Just want to make sure they even processed the claim at all before denying, anyway

0 coins

Yes, I got the Notice of Computation a few days after I filed. It showed a weekly benefit amount. Then a few weeks later this denial came.

0 coins

Okay so they processed it, computed it, then denied weeks because of the wages. That at least means the base claim is not in question, anyway.

0 coins

Notice of Computation is not an approval, it just shows the potential weekly amount. The denial is what addressed the actual eligibility for those specific weeks.

0 coins

Intermittent days were the tricky part for me when I went back part time. Missed returning the DE 2580GF one week and my payments stopped entirely until I sorted it out with EDD. Took forever to reach anyone until I went through Claimyr to get an agent on the phone. She pulled up the claim and confirmed the DE 2580GF for that week had not been received, and that once it came in EDD would process the days. Mailed it priority that afternoon.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself when my claim start date looked wrong and I was worried about the 41-day window. Agent confirmed the date EDD had on file matched what I submitted, so I was inside the deadline. Relieved doesn't even cover it.

0 coins

Can I ask, did the agent say anything about whether the late DE 2580GF would affect any of your other weeks, or just that one?

0 coins

The agent told me only the week tied to that specific form was held. The other weeks were separate and unaffected.

0 coins

been trying that line for two weeks myself. glad there's something that actually works.

0 coins

For the appeal, write down the specific weeks that were denied and what your normal weekly wages were for that period. If your PTO plus PFL came to exactly your normal pay or less, make that case clearly on the form.

0 coins

My pay stubs will show the weekly amounts. I can pull those for the two weeks I used PTO and lay it out clearly.

0 coins

Exactly. If the math shows you did not exceed normal pay, that is your whole argument.

0 coins

Sick leave, vacation, any paid time off, all of it counts as wages. First time I saw that in my own claim I thought EDD made a mistake. They didn't.

0 coins

I genuinely thought PTO was separate from wages in EDD's eyes because my company called it a supplement. Live and learn.

0 coins

What your company calls it doesn't change what EDD counts. Wages are wages.

0 coins

Does the denial affect CFRA protection at all? Or is that totally separate from whether EDD pays out?

0 coins

PFL pays the wage benefit but doesn't protect the job. CFRA is what handles job protection, and that's between you and your employer, not EDD.

0 coins

Okay so fighting the PFL denial doesn't touch whatever CFRA rights she has. Got it.

0 coins

For the job protection piece, HR is the right place to ask about how CFRA applies to your specific situation.

0 coins

Is there a waiting period for PFL? Like seven days before they start paying? I thought I read something like that somewhere.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period at all. You may be thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have an unpaid waiting period at the start of a claim. PFL is different.

0 coins

Oh I had those mixed up. That makes more sense now, thank you.

0 coins

A lot of people mix those two up. Disability is a separate claim, usually for a birth mother before bonding starts.

0 coins

The appeal form is easier to fill out than it looks. Just describe what happened and attach your pay stubs showing what you actually earned each week.

0 coins

That is reassuring. I was afraid it would require some kind of legal argument.

0 coins

You're just explaining your side of the numbers. Keep it factual.

0 coins

The reason the wage limit excludes overtime is specifically so a worker doesn't end up penalized for working extra hours before leave. The rule is about your base normal earnings. If your PTO weeks still came under that number including the PFL payment, say so in the appeal with documentation.

0 coins

My overtime was already excluded because I never worked it. But knowing the base pay comparison is what matters makes the math straightforward.

0 coins

Bring the pay stubs for the same weeks from the prior year too if you have them. Shows what your normal pay looked like.

0 coins

did you file online through sdi online or paper form because online makes it way easier to see which weeks are showing what status

0 coins

I filed through SDI Online. The status just shows the denial, it doesn't break down which weeks specifically on the screen I can see.

0 coins

check the payment history section, sometimes the week breakdown is there even if the main screen just says denied

0 coins

The DE 2514 denial notice is the document that starts the 30-day clock, not anything in SDI Online. Date on that paper is what matters.

0 coins

Found the envelope. The notice is dated November 3rd. I have more time than I thought, but I'm going to get the appeal in this week.

0 coins

Good. Don't cut it close.

0 coins

Hoping the appeal goes well for you! The math in your favor for weeks three through eight sounds solid.

0 coins

Those weeks I should have solid ground on. It's really just the first two I'm worried about, and even then I want EDD to show me their calculation.

0 coins

Asking EDD to show the week-by-week breakdown in your appeal is a reasonable thing to put in writing.

0 coins

filing the appeal this week is the right call. dont wait on that one

0 coins

Appeal is going out Thursday. I've got all my pay stubs pulled and I found the DE 1000A in the envelope.

0 coins

good luck thursday

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure