Back to California Paid Family Leave

Aria Washington

PFL out of state doctor, can't complete physician's certificate online — care claim stuck

My mom had a health crisis earlier this fall and I flew out to be with her for a few weeks. I filed a PFL care claim through SDI Online before I left, got my receipt number, and everything seemed fine. Then the whole Part D situation became a nightmare. Her doctor is out of state and when I explained that the physician's certification needed to go to California EDD, he looked at me like I had three heads. His office said they can't submit anything through SDI Online because they don't have a California provider login or whatever the system needs. I've been trying to figure out if there's a paper option but I'm worried about the 41-day deadline from when my leave started. Can an out-of-state doctor even mail in Part D on paper? Does the doctor have to be licensed in California for EDD to accept it? I cannot find this spelled out anywhere on EDD's site and I am genuinely panicking that my claim is going to get denied over a technicality that isn't my fault.

Your doctor's office can absolutely mail in the Part D on paper, they don't have to use SDI Online. The physician/practitioner certification form gets mailed directly to the address printed on the form itself, with your receipt number written on it so EDD can match it to your claim. Being out of state doesn't disqualify your mom's doctor from completing the certification. What matters most right now is that 41-day window you mentioned, so I'd hand-deliver the blank Part D form to that office and ask them to priority-mail it back to EDD as soon as it's signed.

0 coins

The form itself has a mailing address on it? I was looking for somewhere to upload it on SDI Online and couldn't find it, which is why I panicked. I'll grab the DE 2501F packet and pull the Part D section.

0 coins

Just to add what's written on EDD's care claim page: it specifically says Part D can be mailed by the doctor or submitted in SDI Online with your receipt number. Uploading it yourself through the documents section in SDI Online isn't the right move, it can delay things. The form has the address.

0 coins

Uploading it myself would have made things worse? I was about to do exactly that. Thank you for stopping me.

0 coins

Exactly, don't upload it. Give the receipt number to the doctor's office so they can either mail the paper form or have someone log into SDI Online on their end. Either way works as long as it lands at EDD before that 41-day clock runs out.

0 coins

Out-of-state doctor mailing the form is fine. Done it twice, never had an issue. Just make sure the form is fully filled out and signed before it goes in the envelope.

0 coins

Twice with no issues is reassuring, thank you. Did EDD ever push back on the out-of-state license?

0 coins

Not once. EDD cares that the form is complete and that it shows up on time. License state never came up.

0 coins

Intermittent days I worked while on leave got all tangled up on my claim, the DE 2580GF kept not matching what SDI Online showed, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to an actual EDD PFL agent after the phone line ate my morning three days running. The agent pulled up my claim and walked me through which weeks were marked paid versus pending and confirmed my payment method was set to direct deposit not the debit card, which explained a weird hold I had. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Payment method on mine was also set wrong, debit card instead of direct deposit, and I had the same confusion. Tried Claimyr too and the EDD agent confirmed the payment method on file and switched it right there. Asked me which routing number I wanted on record.

0 coins

Wait, the agent actually updated your payment method during the call? I didn't know they could do that over the phone.

0 coins

They confirmed what was on file and said to update it in SDI Online to make sure it saved correctly. So not entirely over the phone but they flagged exactly what needed fixing.

0 coins

I didn't even think about the payment method side of this. I need to double check mine too.

0 coins

The 41-day thing is NOT flexible, they will deny benefits for days outside that window and no amount of explaining fixes it after the fact. Get that form to the doctor today.

0 coins

Today as in literally today. Got it. Dropping off the printed form this afternoon.

0 coins

To add to what's said above: the 41 days runs from the first day your leave actually started, not the day you filed. So if you started caring for your mom before you filed the claim, the clock started earlier than you might think.

0 coins

Oh that is a really important distinction. My leave started four days before I filed. So I need to subtract those four days from whatever I thought I had left.

0 coins

Part D doesn't require a California license. The practitioner just has to be your mom's treating provider. Seen plenty of out-of-state certifications go through fine.

0 coins

I keep reading conflicting things in Facebook groups about this. Some people say EDD rejects out-of-state doctors. Is there anything on EDD's site that says one way or the other?

0 coins

EDD's published guidance says physician or practitioner, it doesn't say California-licensed. The form itself says the same thing. The Facebook rumor is probably someone who had a different problem with their form, like it being incomplete, and blamed the state of licensure.

0 coins

That makes sense. Incomplete form blamed on wrong reason. I'll stop worrying about that part and focus on getting the form there in time.

0 coins

Mailed Part D for a care claim with an out-of-state specialist. EDD accepted it. Took about ten days from mailing to the status updating in SDI Online.

0 coins

Ten days from mailing to status update. That's helpful to have as a rough frame even if mine might vary.

0 coins

My care claim updated faster than that, maybe six days. But I was watching SDI Online every couple of hours which probably didn't help my stress levels.

0 coins

my dads doctor in nevada did the paper form and edd took it no problem. just make sure they sign every line the form asks for bc his first submission came back because one signature box was empty

0 coins

Every signature line. I will tell the office explicitly when I drop it off. Thank you.

0 coins

This is such a real thing. The form rejection for a missing signature is brutal when you're already stressed about the deadline. Worth calling the office and going through the form with whoever fills it out.

0 coins

Tried the EDD PFL line nineteen times over two weeks on my own denial situation and kept hitting the recorded message that ends the call. Finally got through and the agent pulled up the DE 2514, confirmed the appeal deadline from when it was mailed, and read me the specific reason code on the determination. Used Claimyr for that call, spent way too long thinking the phone situation was just something everyone accepted.

0 coins

Nineteen tries and you still used something that sounds like an ad somebody posted. I've seen these kinds of comments before and I'm not buying it.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I first saw Claimyr mentioned somewhere, figured it was just noise. Tried it anyway because I had burned two full weeks on that line and my receipt number situation needed sorting. Agent confirmed EDD had received my receipt and that the claim was linked correctly. Honestly just glad to have talked to a real person.

0 coins

Okay. If I hit week three with no answer I'll try it. Not there yet but noted.

0 coins

Nineteen times is not an exaggeration, I've had stretches like that. Good to know there are options when it gets that bad.

0 coins

Part C is on the claimant side right? Just want to make sure I have this straight. So your mom would complete Part C and mail it in, and the doctor does Part D separately?

0 coins

You have it right. Part C is the care recipient's statement, your mom would fill that out and mail it. Part D is the physician's certification, which the doctor completes and either mails or submits in SDI Online. They go in separately and EDD matches them to the claim with the receipt number.

0 coins

Got it! And both have to be in within 41 days of when leave started? Or is Part C on a different timeline?

0 coins

The 41-day deadline covers Part D, that's the one EDD is firmest about. EDD's materials specify Part D must reach them within 41 days of the leave start date. Part C should still go in promptly but Part D is the one that determines whether the claim can be processed at all.

0 coins

My mom already mailed Part C the week I filed. It's the Part D that turned into this whole ordeal.

0 coins

The claim's start date, the filing date and the Part D receipt date all show up differently in SDI Online and it's worth checking all three to understand where you are on the 41 days. Pulling those dates took me about fifteen minutes of clicking around but it saved me from missing my own deadline.

0 coins

Finding those dates in SDI Online is not as obvious as it should be. The claim detail view has a lot of information and not all of it is labeled clearly.

0 coins

Agreed. The claim start date was the one I had wrong. I assumed it was my file date and it wasn't, it was set to the first day I listed as my leave start in the application.

0 coins

What happens if the 41 days expires before the doctor gets the form in? Can you appeal?

0 coins

EDD would likely issue a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination denying those days outside the window, and yes, you can appeal within 30 days of that notice using the Appeal Form that comes with it, the DE 1000A. Whether EDD grants benefits for days after a late filing is their call, not something anyone here can promise.

0 coins

So appeal is an option but not guaranteed. Better to just get the form in on time.

0 coins

Exactly. Getting the form in on time is the only sure thing. Appeal is what you do if that fails, not a plan A.

0 coins

Can the doctor's office fax it at all? I know fax sounds ancient but medical offices still use them and I wonder if that's faster than mail.

0 coins

EDD's instructions for Part D say mail it or submit it in SDI Online. Fax isn't listed as an option EDD accepts for Part D, so I wouldn't go that route and risk EDD not matching it to the claim.

0 coins

Good to know, would have suggested fax first otherwise. Sticking to mail or SDI Online.

0 coins

Doctor's offices are faster at mailing than you'd think when you explain it's a government deadline. Tell them the date it has to arrive, not the date they should send it.

0 coins

Proof of relationship came back as not received on my bonding claim two weeks after I uploaded the birth certificate, and I had no idea why. Used Claimyr to reach an agent who confirmed EDD had the document but it was sitting unmatched because the name on the certificate had a hyphen and my claim didn't. Agent told me to send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining the name discrepancy.

0 coins

Did the agent say how long it would take to clear once you sent the Request Claim Update?

0 coins

No timeline given, just that the update would flag it for review. Sent it that afternoon and the status changed about a week later.

0 coins

Three weeks trying that line myself and I haven't had a morning where it didn't drop before getting to anyone. Starting to think I need a different approach.

0 coins

If EDD denies the claim because the doctor submitted late but I can prove the delay was because the office didn't understand the SDI Online system, does that help in an appeal?

0 coins

You can include any documentation that shows what happened and when in an appeal. What EDD weighs is their call, but having records of when you gave the receipt number to the office and when they attempted to submit would be useful to include with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

So I should start keeping records now of every communication with the doctor's office just in case. Email confirmations, the date I dropped off the form, all of that.

0 coins

Yes, and ask the office to write down the date they received the form from you. A short note with their signature and date is worth more than a memory later.

0 coins

Waiting to hear how this plays out for the original poster. My own care claim had a Part D delay and EDD processed it without any issues once the form arrived, so fingers crossed the same happens here.

0 coins

Doctor's office has the form as of this afternoon. They said they'd mail it tomorrow with their standard postage. I'm going to ask them to send it priority so it has tracking.

0 coins

Priority mail with tracking is smart. That way you have proof of when it left and when it arrived if you ever need to reference it.

0 coins

Two weeks ago my payment showed as issued in SDI Online but the amount looked off compared to my Notice of Computation. Called and couldn't get through, then tried Claimyr and the agent confirmed the exact date the payment was released and which weeks it covered. Turned out one week had a partial because I'd reported a day back at work. Agent read me the per-day amount from my claim.

0 coins

The partial week thing is exactly what I want to understand on my own claim. I went back part time last month and I'm not sure how EDD calculated those days. Trying Claimyr for that question, sounds like you actually got clear numbers from the agent. What should I have ready when I go in?

0 coins

Have your claim ID and the specific weeks you're asking about written down. The agent pulled up my record by claim ID and went week by week.

0 coins

I didn't know EDD's agent could go through the payment breakdown week by week like that. That's genuinely useful to know for when my claim actually processes.

0 coins

Does the PFL waiting period affect the Part D deadline at all? Like does the clock start after the waiting period or from day one of leave?

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period, so that's not a factor. The 41-day clock runs from the actual first day of your leave, full stop.

0 coins

Wait, no waiting period? I thought there was a seven-day thing. Maybe I'm mixing it up with disability.

0 coins

You're mixing it up with Disability Insurance, which has a seven-day unpaid period before benefits start. PFL has no such waiting period. Different programs.

0 coins

Good catch. I definitely had those confused.

0 coins

Just want to flag one more thing for anyone reading this later: the receipt number you got when you filed is the number the doctor's office needs to submit Part D through SDI Online. Without it they can't attach the certification to the right claim. Print the confirmation page if you still have it, or log into myEDD and find it in your claim details.

0 coins

Printed the confirmation page months ago and it's been sitting in a folder. That folder has never been more important than it was today when I handed it to the doctor's office.

0 coins

That folder is doing real work right now. Hope the form gets there with days to spare.

0 coins

The receipt number being the link between the doctor's submission and the claimant's file is something I didn't understand at all when I filed my own care claim. Wish this thread had existed then!

0 coins

also make sure your mom signs part c before she mails it. my uncle forgot his signature on part c and edd sent the whole thing back

0 coins

Part C already in the mail with her signature on it, that one I handled before I left. It's just the Part D that became this whole situation.

0 coins

ok good at least one half is done. seriously though those forms are picky about signatures

0 coins

Track the mailing once it goes out and screenshot the delivery confirmation. If EDD ever says Part D wasn't received, you have something concrete to reference when you submit a Request Claim Update.

0 coins

Doing exactly that. The tracking number is already saved in my notes app.

0 coins

Tracking number plus the date you gave the form to the office. Both timestamps together tell the whole story if you ever need to explain the timeline.

0 coins

Agreed. And if the online status in SDI Online doesn't update within about two weeks of confirmed delivery, send a Request Claim Update right away rather than waiting longer.

0 coins

any update on whether the form made it in time? been following this one

0 coins

Doctor's office confirmed they mailed it priority two days ago. Tracking shows it delivered to EDD this morning. SDI Online still says pending but I'll give it a week or so before I send a Request Claim Update if the status doesn't move.

0 coins

Delivered with days inside the window is exactly the best case outcome here. Status will catch up.

0 coins

Once it shows delivered and you're within the 41 days, the hard part is over. Keep an eye on SDI Online and if it doesn't move in about two weeks, the Request Claim Update is the right next step.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure