Back to California Paid Family Leave

Emma Morales

PFL eligibility for business owner paying SDI on own payroll — does it actually work?

So I run a small landscaping business and put myself on payroll a few years back, so I've been paying into SDI through my own paychecks ever since. My wife is expecting in February and I want to take a few weeks off to bond with the baby. I keep reading that PFL is for employees but I'm technically my own employer. Does the SDI withholding on my paychecks actually count toward PFL eligibility or am I just throwing that money away? I have over $300 in CASDI withheld across the base period for sure. Really just need to know if I'm going to be able to file a bonding claim or if there's some owner exception that knocks me out. Anyone dealt with this?

The base period wages with SDI withheld is the key thing here, and from what EDD's own site says, the requirement is that you had at least $300 in wages with SDI deducted during your base period, and that you were employed or actively looking for work when the leave starts. It doesn't carve out business owners specifically. If you're on your own payroll with CASDI withheld from your checks, that withholding is what counts. The calculator on EDD's site can give you a weekly benefit estimate based on your wages.

0 coins

ok that's actually reassuring. I kept second guessing myself because every example I see is like a regular W-2 employee at some company, not someone who owns the company

0 coins

Same position here a couple years ago, I put myself on payroll at my shop and filed PFL for my second kid no problem. The CASDI line on your pay stub is the thing.

0 coins

Wait so as long as the CASDI deduction shows on the pay stub it counts? Even if you're the one writing your own paycheck? I'm in a similar situation and I've been terrified I'd be told I don't qualify.

0 coins

You file just like any other worker. SDI Online through myEDD, apply for PFL bonding, give them the receipt number off the confirmation page. You'll need a proof of relationship doc once the baby's born, birth certificate works. Don't overthink it.

0 coins

Is the proof of relationship something I upload in SDI Online or mail in?

0 coins

SDI Online lets you upload it. Birth certificate, declaration of paternity, that kind of thing. Get it in after the birth.

0 coins

We uploaded ours the same night we got home from the hospital. Had the receipt number saved from when we filed so it matched up fine.

0 coins

Weeks paid and upcoming payment schedule were the things I needed clarity on after my own bonding claim started. I tried that EDD phone line four mornings in a row and either got a busy signal or the recording cut out before I reached anyone. Eventually I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get a live person on the PFL line. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been issued and when the next payment was scheduled to go out. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

Four mornings and nothing, I believe it, I've had exactly that experience. But a third-party service that gets you through to EDD, how does that actually work? I've tried everything short of driving to an SDI office.

0 coins

Basically you let it sit with EDD's hold line for you, and when an actual EDD agent picks up, your phone rings and you're on. That's the whole thing. No tricks, just someone handling the hold so you don't have to.

0 coins

Used it myself when I needed to know how many of my eight weeks were still available after a care claim earlier in the year. Agent told me I had three weeks remaining in the 12-month window, which matched what I'd calculated. Good to have it confirmed though.

0 coins

Three weeks left after a care claim, that's something I didn't even think about. So bonding and care share the same eight weeks total?

0 coins

To answer the question at the end of the last comment, yes, the eight weeks is one pool for bonding, care, and military assist combined inside any 12-month stretch. It's not eight weeks per claim type. If you use five weeks bonding with the baby, you have three left for anything else in those 12 months.

0 coins

I had no idea about that. I was planning like I had a fresh eight for each situation. Good to know before I file.

0 coins

I assumed bonding and care each had their own eight weeks, that changes my whole plan.

0 coins

Pretty much everyone assumes that. They're wrong. One pool, 12 months.

0 coins

Filing date is one thing that tripped me up, so just flagging it. You can't file before your first actual day of leave, but you also can't wait more than 41 days from when the leave started or you lose some benefits. I filed the night I got home from the hospital and that felt like the right call.

0 coins

So I could file the day the baby's born if that's also my first day off work?

0 coins

Yep, that's what I did. First day of leave, file that evening. Gets the clock started.

0 coins

I didn't realize the 41-day thing was a hard limit. I thought you had a few months. That would've really hurt me.

0 coins

PFL doesn't have a waiting period before payments start, just to head off that confusion. Some people mix it up with disability's seven unpaid days. Bonding through PFL, no waiting period.

0 coins

I thought there was a one-week wait for PFL too. That's genuinely good to know before I file.

0 coins

Someone told me the same wrong thing about the waiting week. Spent like two hours trying to figure out if it applied to me.

0 coins

Disability has the seven-day waiting period, not PFL. Different programs. Easy to mix up.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is essentially decorative. I've called at every hour they're supposed to be staffed and gotten either a busy tone or a hang-up. If you have a question that needs a human, build in extra time because that line is not reliable.

0 coins

I already dread having to call them if something goes sideways with my claim.

0 coins

Just log everything in SDI Online where you can. Request Claim Update if something's off. At least there's a record.

0 coins

request claim update is my last resort too. takes forever but at least it doesnt hang up on you

0 coins

DE 2500E showing up in SDI Online was what I needed to see before I believed my payment was actually coming. I'd been watching the claim status every day and seeing nothing move. Tried calling and gave up after the hold dropped twice. Used Claimyr to get through, and the agent confirmed the DE 2500E had been issued and told me the payment date and amount from my Notice of Computation.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I've seen it mentioned and I don't know what it is.

0 coins

It's a service that handles the hold with EDD's line so you don't have to sit there waiting. When an agent picks up, you get the call. That's pretty much it.

0 coins

Oh that's actually simple. I'd use it to ask about my proof of relationship, been uploaded for nine days and I can't tell if they've matched it to my claim yet.

0 coins

I'll probably need that at some point too. Good to know the DE 2500E is what to look for once you're approved.

0 coins

Payment method for a bonding claim filed in SDI Online can be set to direct deposit, which is faster than waiting for a debit card in the mail. Set it up during the application. Debit card is also an option if that's easier, but direct deposit hits quicker in my experience.

0 coins

Direct deposit sounds better. Can you change it after filing or does it have to be during the application?

0 coins

You can update it in SDI Online after filing. It's under the claim options. Do it before the first payment goes out.

0 coins

Changed mine after the fact, took a few days to show but it worked fine.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation came in the mail like a week into my claim and I panicked thinking it meant I was approved. It just shows your potential weekly benefit amount based on your wages, it's not an approval letter. Actual approval shows up differently, through the DE 2500E.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation is not the same as getting approved, it's just the number. Got it.

0 coins

I would have made that exact same mistake, calling everyone I know to say I got approved.

0 coins

Literally what I did lol. Then I read it again and realized it said potential. Still waiting for the real confirmation at that point.

0 coins

PFL doesn't protect your job. That's CFRA or FMLA. If your job security question is really about whether the leave is covered, you're asking about two different things. PFL pays you, those laws protect the job.

0 coins

In my case I'm the owner so job protection is less of an issue, but good to flag for anyone else reading this.

0 coins

Worth adding that whether CFRA or FMLA actually covers someone depends on the employer and the person's situation, not EDD. HR is the right call for that one.

0 coins

I didn't know CFRA and PFL were separate at all. I thought applying for PFL meant my job was automatically protected. Glad I know now.

0 coins

Tried eight times in one week to reach EDD about an intermittent schedule I'd set up after going back part-time. Never got a live person. Used Claimyr and reached an agent who looked at the DE 2580GF on my claim, confirmed EDD had received it and that the days I'd reported were processed. Huge relief after a week of silence from that phone line!

0 coins

The DE 2580GF is what they send when you go intermittent right? I've been going back two days a week and didn't realize I needed to return anything.

0 coins

Yes, EDD mails it and you have to return it or the payments stop. The agent told me mine had been received and the reported days were logged, so I knew I was fine. Send it back as soon as you get it.

0 coins

Used Claimyr myself actually, I had a question about my claim's start date and whether I was still inside the 41-day window. Agent confirmed the date EDD had on file and said I was within the window, so I was good to file without losing anything.

0 coins

wait so if you dont send that form back payments just stop with no warning

0 coins

Pretty much, yeah. That form is how you tell EDD what days you worked and what wages you earned. Miss it and the money stops.

0 coins

Wages in the base period matter more than most people think going in. It's not just the current pay period, it's the highest quarter across a 12-month window that's roughly five to 18 months before you start the leave. If your business had a slower year before things picked up, that could affect your weekly benefit amount. The calculator on EDD's site gives you an estimate to work from.

0 coins

That's a good point. I had a rough patch two years back so I'll need to actually check which quarter was my highest.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation spells out exactly which quarter they used and what your weekly amount comes to. You'll see it once EDD processes the claim.

0 coins

And if you think they pulled the wrong quarter or the amount looks off, that's when you read it carefully and check whether an appeal makes sense within 30 days of getting it.

0 coins

Got a denial notice, the DE 2514, right before I figured this out. If that happens, the appeal form DE 1000A comes with it, and you have 30 days to appeal. Just wanted to flag it because I almost missed the window.

0 coins

30 days to appeal and it comes right in the denial notice, ok noted.

0 coins

I didn't know the appeal form came with the denial. I thought you had to find it somewhere else.

0 coins

It's attached to the DE 2514. 30 days from the date on the notice.

0 coins

DE 2514 landed in my mail two weeks after filing. I'd done everything right as far as I knew, so I appealed using the DE 1000A included with it. Filed the appeal online. Still pending but at least I knew what to do because of threads like this. Also, I noticed a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination question on my own situation so I used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent who pulled up my claim and confirmed that the DE 2514 had been issued because EDD had a question about my payment method selection, not my eligibility itself. Agent said to watch for a follow-up notice in the mail.

0 coins

EDD sends a denial over a payment method question? That sounds like overkill. How is that a denial of the claim and not just a form asking you to pick something.

0 coins

I thought the same thing when I read that. Ended up trying Claimyr myself after I convinced myself it was just advertising. Agent found my payment method had flagged something on my claim and told me what notice to watch for. Decided what I'd assumed about not needing to verify was wrong.

0 coins

ok, if it got you an actual answer I can see the point. might try it if my own situation gets stuck.

0 coins

Watching for the follow-up notice is exactly the kind of thing I'd miss if I wasn't paying attention. Saving that detail.

0 coins

my boss told me business owners cant get pfl at all i think he was just wrong based on everything here

0 coins

He was wrong. Eligibility is about CASDI withheld from wages in the base period. Business owner, sole prop on payroll, doesn't matter as long as the withholding is there.

0 coins

yeah makes sense now. he probably never put himself on payroll so he never paid in

0 coins

Exactly, if you never ran your wages through payroll with SDI withheld, you never built up the base period that qualifies you. That's the distinction.

0 coins

Intermittent is a whole thing people don't think about before it comes up. If you plan to ease back into the business part-time after the baby arrives, you can do that and still collect PFL for the days you're not working. Just make sure you report the days and wages to EDD when you go back, any wages even if they haven't hit your bank yet.

0 coins

This might actually be how I do it. Take the first three or four weeks solid and then come back part-time for a bit.

0 coins

That works, you've got up to 12 months from the birth to use the eight weeks, doesn't have to be all at once.

0 coins

didnt know the 12 months thing. i thought you had to use it right away or lose it

0 coins

Not reporting wages when you go back part-time creates an overpayment. EDD finds out. You pay it back. Report everything.

0 coins

Even if the wages haven't been paid out yet you report them right away?

0 coins

Yes. When you earn them, not when you get the check. EDD's rule.

0 coins

That's the one that catches people off guard. They wait until payday and EDD already counted those days as leave days.

0 coins

Can two parents both file PFL bonding for the same baby? Like my husband and I, could we both take weeks from that same eight-week pool or do we each get our own?

0 coins

Each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim. You each have your own eligibility and your own pool of up to eight weeks within 12 months. His claim doesn't pull from your weeks and yours doesn't pull from his.

0 coins

Oh that's completely different from what I thought. I figured there was one pool for the household.

0 coins

Same, I thought my wife's pregnancy disability would somehow eat into my PFL bonding. Turns out they're totally separate.

0 coins

If EDD asks for more information on your bonding claim and you need to send a document, do it in SDI Online. Do not use some random address. The online system keeps a record and ties it to your claim ID. Paper gets lost.

0 coins

Is there any document for a bonding claim that can't go through SDI Online and has to be mailed?

0 coins

Bonding is simpler than a care claim. No Part C or Part D for bonding. Main thing is the proof of relationship, and that you can upload in SDI Online.

0 coins

Care claims are the ones where Part C and Part D have to be mailed or the doctor submits Part D in SDI Online. Bonding claimants don't deal with either of those.

0 coins

Overpayments scare me more than anything. If EDD decides something was wrong with the claim after paying, do they just take it all back at once or is there a process?

0 coins

You get a notice about the overpayment and the same 30-day appeal window applies. You can appeal the overpayment notice just like a denial. No one can promise a waiver, but the process exists and you don't just lose the money with no recourse.

0 coins

I didn't know you could appeal an overpayment notice. I figured once EDD said you owe it, that's it.

0 coins

30 days from the date on the notice. Same DE 1000A form.

0 coins

Last thing I'll add for the original poster: file through SDI Online via myEDD, save the receipt number on the confirmation page before you close out of it, and after the birth get the birth certificate or declaration of paternity uploaded as the proof of relationship. That's the main sequence.

0 coins

Got it. File in SDI Online, save receipt number, upload proof of relationship after birth. That's the plan.

0 coins

And don't file before the first actual day of leave. That tripped up a friend of mine who pre-filed thinking it would speed things up.

0 coins

Pre-filing sounds like something I'd do honestly. Good warning.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure