Back to California Paid Family Leave

Sophie Hernandez

PFL eligibility after layoff while covered by voluntary plan — does the SDI withholding still count?

So I'm in kind of a weird spot and I can't find a clear answer anywhere. I was laid off from my job back in September, and while I was employed there, my company used a Voluntary Plan instead of the state SDI program. I do see CASDI withheld on some older paystubs from a previous job, but my most recent employer never withheld the standard state SDI — it was all through their VP. Now here's the thing: my partner and I are expecting in February, and I want to file for PFL bonding after the baby arrives. I'm not sure if the wages from my VP-covered job even count toward the base period for a PFL claim, or if I'm just out of luck because I got laid off and wasn't under the state SDI plan at the end. I know you need at least $300 in wages with SDI withheld during the base period to qualify. But what counts — the state SDI withholding, the VP withholding, or both? And does being laid off now matter at all for eligibility since I'm not currently working? I'm really worried I'm going to miss out on bonding time because of the plan my employer happened to use. Anyone navigate something like this?

DE 2514 came in the mail for my bonding claim last month, a denial because EDD said I wasn't eligible, and I was pretty sure they had it wrong. Spent three mornings trying the PFL line before I actually got someone. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and when the agent pulled up my claim she walked me through exactly what base period wages they had on file. Turns out they hadn't matched the wages from my previous job correctly. Here's the video if you're trying to reach a live person on EDD's Paid Family Leave line: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. Anyway, to your question — the agent confirmed EDD looks at wages with SDI withheld, and that includes Voluntary Plan withholding if the VP has been approved. So those wages can count. I'd appeal the denial with the DE 1000A if you get one, you have 30 days.

0 coins

Reads like a sponsored post to me. You just happen to get through, they fix everything right away. How does that actually work.

0 coins

I thought the same thing honestly, sounded too neat. But I tried it after two weeks of calling and hanging up. When I got an agent she told me my receipt number was showing in the system but nothing had been matched to it yet, and she flagged it to look again. That's not a sales pitch, that's just what happened.

0 coins

ok fair. ill give it a shot and see what actually happens.

0 coins

The piece about the Voluntary Plan matters a lot here. EDD's own guidance says wages earned under an approved employer Voluntary Plan can count toward your base period for PFL, because VPs are part of the SDI program — they're just administered by the employer instead of the state. The withholding on those paystubs should still have been labeled as SDI-equivalent. What I'd do is pull every paystub from both jobs and check what the deduction was actually called.

0 coins

The paystubs from the VP job show a different label, not CASDI. Would that automatically disqualify those wages or is it something EDD can verify on their end?

0 coins

EDD can verify whether your employer's VP was state-approved. If it was, those wages count regardless of the label on the stub. The employer should have records too.

0 coins

Does that mean I need to contact my old employer to get some kind of letter, or does EDD pull that info themselves when you file?

0 coins

EDD pulls wage data from employers, but if there's a discrepancy you may need to provide paystubs. When you file, attach what you have and let EDD sort the matching.

0 coins

Filing while actively looking for work is actually allowed under PFL eligibility rules — you don't have to be currently employed when the leave starts, as long as you were employed or actively seeking work when the family leave begins. So being laid off right now doesn't necessarily end things, provided you meet the base period wage requirement.

0 coins

That part about still being eligible while job searching — does the job searching have to be documented somehow, or is it more of a self-reported thing when you file?

0 coins

The PFL application asks about your work status at the time of leave. You'd answer that you were unemployed but seeking work. EDD may verify, so keep records of any applications you've sent.

0 coins

didn't know you could file PFL while unemployed. good to know.

0 coins

You can't collect PFL and unemployment at the same time for the same days. Keep that in mind if you're on UI right now. One at a time.

0 coins

Are you sure about that? I was thinking maybe I could stack them since I'm not working.

0 coins

EDD doesn't pay both for the same day. You pick one. PFL for bonding, UI for job searching. Not both.

0 coins

That tracks with what EDD says — PFL isn't paid for the same days as unemployment. So once the baby comes and you start the bonding claim, you'd stop certifying for UI during those weeks.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I'll stop UI when I start PFL bonding. Didn't realize you had to actively switch.

0 coins

edd line is a nightmare. called at 8am sharp four different mornings and got the 'we cannot take your call' recording every single time. don't know how anyone actually gets through to ask a simple eligibility question.

0 coins

same exact thing happened to me man, three weeks of mornings and nothing

0 coins

the line being impossible isn't news to anyone here. have you tried the Request Claim Update in SDI Online? sometimes that gets a faster response than calling.

0 coins

i've sent two of those already. nothing back yet.

0 coins

Worth clarifying one thing that tripped me up: PFL doesn't have a waiting period the way DI does. When I first filed I thought there were seven unpaid days at the start, like disability insurance, but that's only for Disability Insurance, not PFL. PFL starts paying from day one of your leave once approved.

0 coins

Wait, so PFL has no waiting period at all? My HR told me there were seven days before benefits started.

0 coins

HR might be thinking of Disability Insurance, which does have that seven-day period. PFL bonding has no waiting period. EDD's own materials say so pretty clearly.

0 coins

My HR said the same thing as hers. Glad that got cleared up here because I had already mentally written off the first week.

0 coins

Part D and the proof of relationship were both things I worried about on my care claim. When I filed for my dad, the status in SDI Online stayed quiet for almost two weeks. Used Claimyr to reach someone and the agent told me EDD had received Part D from the doctor's office but it hadn't been matched to my claim yet — she gave me the date it arrived and said to give it a few more business days. Proof of relationship for a bonding claim works similarly: you upload the birth certificate or the paternity declaration through SDI Online and EDD matches it to the claim.

0 coins

When the agent told you Part D was received but not matched, did she say what you should do if it still didn't update after a few days?

0 coins

She said to send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online if nothing changed in a week. That way there's a record of my inquiry.

0 coins

been trying to get through on that line since Tuesday. four attempts, four recordings. glad there's a way to actually reach someone.

0 coins

The base period is the year of wages before you filed. EDD looks at the highest earning quarter in there. Your Notice of Computation will show what they came up with. File first and see what the notice says.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation shows up before or after they decide if I'm eligible?

0 coins

You'll get it. It doesn't mean you're approved, just what the potential benefit amount would be if you are.

0 coins

Exactly right. The Notice of Computation shows the potential weekly benefit amount only. Eligibility decision is separate and comes later.

0 coins

if you do get a denial after all this, you have 30 days to appeal with the DE 1000A. had a coworker who got denied on a bonding claim, appealed, and it got sorted. not a dead end.

0 coins

Good to know there's still a path after a denial. I was thinking denial meant game over.

0 coins

nope, 30 days to appeal. use the form they send with the denial, the DE 1000A. file it and explain what you think they got wrong.

0 coins

My bonding claim was filed while I was between jobs too — I'd left my old position and the new one hadn't started yet. As long as I was actively looking, EDD counted me as eligible. I got my Notice of Computation pretty quickly, within the first week after filing.

0 coins

Between jobs as in you hadn't started the new one yet — did you have to prove you were looking for work or did EDD just take your word on the application?

0 coins

They didn't ask me for documentation during the claim, but I'd kept a little spreadsheet of applications just in case. Never needed to submit it, but I was glad I had it.

0 coins

The spreadsheet idea is smart. I'll start doing that now so I have a record going back to when I was laid off.

0 coins

voluntary plans are confusing and EDD doesn't make it obvious. had to call twice just to get a straight answer about whether my employer's VP counted.

0 coins

Did EDD end up confirming your VP wages counted, or did they need you to send something in first?

0 coins

they confirmed verbally but then sent me a letter asking for paystubs. just bring everything you've got.

0 coins

Eight weeks total for PFL in any 12-month window, bonding or care or both together. Not eight for each. Mention it because a few people here seem to be counting on more.

0 coins

wait its not 8 weeks each? i thought bonding was 8 and care was separate 8

0 coins

Nope. Eight weeks combined, all PFL types together, within 12 months. Use five for bonding, three left if you need a care claim that same year.

0 coins

That's really important and I had no idea. I was planning like I had 8 weeks bonding plus more if something happened to a family member.

0 coins

Payment timing got me anxious on my care claim for my mom — the status sat quiet after I filed and I had no idea if the first check was coming. Claimyr got me to an EDD agent who pulled up the claim and told me the first payment had been issued three days before and was on its way to my debit card. I hadn't received it yet, that's all. Total relief.

0 coins

My own question is about the weekly benefit amount on my Notice of Computation — I want to confirm EDD used the right quarter of wages before my leave started. Would Claimyr be useful for that?

0 coins

Absolutely worth trying for that. Have your Notice of Computation with you and the dates of your base period quarters, so the agent has something to compare on the spot.

0 coins

I've been dreading the payment timing thing too, honestly. The idea of filing and then having no idea when money arrives is stressful.

0 coins

For the base period question, EDD uses wages from about 5 to 18 months before the claim start date. If your layoff was in September and the baby comes in February, run the numbers on what quarters that covers. The benefit calculator on EDD's site gives an estimate before you file.

0 coins

So my VP wages from before the layoff could still fall in that window, depending on when I officially start the leave?

0 coins

Correct. The claim start date is what anchors the base period. If those VP wages land in the right quarters, they'd count, assuming the VP was approved.

0 coins

The EDD benefits calculator at edd.ca.gov lets you plug in quarterly wages and get an estimate. Use it before you file to see what you're working with.

0 coins

still trying to track down how many of my eight weeks I've got left after the bonding leave I took earlier this year. I used Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line, she looked at my claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid and that I had three weeks remaining in my 12-month window. I'd had no way to tell from SDI Online alone.

0 coins

Three weeks remaining matches my situation almost exactly — my bonding leave used up five weeks earlier this year and I've been trying to figure out if the remaining three are still good. Used Claimyr too after the agent confirmed my Notice of Computation figures, and once she answered that I went ahead and filed the new leave request.

0 coins

been hitting the EDD line most mornings this week. haven't gotten through once.

0 coins

Knowing how many weeks are left and when the window closes — that's exactly the kind of thing I'm going to need to track once I file.

0 coins

To the original question about the VP and the layoff: file when the baby arrives, don't wait. The 41-day window from the first day of leave is the deadline, and if you miss it you can lose benefits. File in SDI Online through myEDD, attach your birth certificate when it's available, and let EDD sort out the VP wage question once the claim is in.

0 coins

The 41 days runs from the actual first day I take leave, not from the birth date itself, right?

0 coins

From the first day of your leave. If the birth is February 10 and you start leave that same day, the clock starts February 10.

0 coins

Don't overthink it. File the day after the baby comes. That's the safest move.

0 coins

Is there a scenario where the VP wages just don't count at all? Like what if the employer's VP wasn't state-approved or they had some kind of gap in coverage?

0 coins

If the VP wasn't approved or there was a coverage gap, those wages may not count toward PFL eligibility. That's a situation where you'd want to contact EDD directly with documentation before you file, so you're not surprised by a denial.

0 coins

The employer is supposed to inform employees whether they're covered under the state SDI plan or a Voluntary Plan. If your employer never clarified, HR records or your onboarding paperwork might show it.

0 coins

So I should ask HR at the old job whether their VP was state-approved before the baby arrives, just to have that info ready.

0 coins

my employer switched from vp to state sdi mid year and nobody told anyone. had to figure out from my paystub that the deduction changed. edd said both halves of that year counted because both were approved plans

0 coins

That mid-year switch situation sounds messy — did EDD need any paperwork from your employer or did they already have that info?

0 coins

edd had it. they said the employer reports it. i just needed my paystubs to show both deductions

0 coins

If you end up getting that DE 2514 denial, read it carefully. It'll say exactly why EDD denied you. Sometimes it's a wage matching issue, sometimes it's the coverage question. The reason tells you what to put in the appeal.

0 coins

Good point, I should read the actual reason rather than just panicking at the word 'denied'.

0 coins

lol seriously, the denial letter is actually useful. they're pretty specific about what's missing.

0 coins

Exactly. The DE 1000A appeal goes back with whatever documentation addresses the stated reason.

0 coins

PFL doesn't protect the job. EDD pays the benefit but your employer isn't required by PFL to hold your position. CFRA may apply depending on your employer, but that's separate from EDD. Worth checking with HR before the leave starts.

0 coins

Since I'm already laid off, the job protection piece doesn't apply to me anymore anyway. But good reminder for anyone else reading.

0 coins

For anyone still employed, that distinction matters a lot. PFL money comes from EDD, job rights under CFRA are your employer's obligation. Two completely different things.

0 coins

The debit card or direct deposit question comes up when you file in SDI Online. If you file online you can set up direct deposit. Paper filing gets you a card. Payments for a claim taken all at once come every two weeks through the leave.

0 coins

Is the debit card the Bank of America one? I keep seeing that mentioned.

0 coins

No, that changed. EDD's card now comes from Money Network, not Bank of America.

0 coins

Good to know before I go looking for the wrong card in the mail.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure