Back to California Paid Family Leave

AstroAce

PFL bonding appeal no response after months — what to do next?

I filed a bonding claim back in the spring for my daughter and got denied. I appealed right away using the DE 1000A and sent it in by mail. That was over three months ago and I haven't heard a single thing. No letter, nothing in SDI Online, just silence. I'm not sure if I did something wrong or if this is just how long it takes. I didn't get any reason for the denial beyond the Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination I received — it just said ineligible. I think I uploaded the birth certificate fine but maybe the proof of relationship wasn't accepted? I really don't know. Is three months without a response normal for a PFL appeal or should I be doing something to follow up?

Appeals through EDD honestly just take forever and nobody warns you about that. Three months isn't unusual unfortunately, the appeals office has a big backlog. But you should have gotten at least an acknowledgment letter when they received it. Did you send it certified mail so you have proof they got it?

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

I didn't send it certified, I just dropped it in the mailbox. That was probably dumb of me. I have no idea if they even got it.

0 coins

If you're not sure it arrived, filing again online through the appeals portal won't hurt — but check the instructions on that DE 2514 denial notice first, it should say where to send it and your options.

0 coins

The 30-day window to appeal is on the DE 2514 itself. As long as you filed within 30 days of that notice date you're in the system. The California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board handles these once EDD passes them along, which is a separate agency — that's partly why it can feel like a black hole for a while.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

I did file within 30 days, the denial notice came in June and I got the appeal in before the end of the month. So at least I did that part right.

0 coins

Worth noting the DE 1000A also says you can file by mail or online — if the original was mailed and you're not sure it arrived, filing online now as a backup might be the move. Did your denial say anything specific about why the proof of relationship was rejected?

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

It really didn't go into much detail. Just said ineligible. I genuinely don't know if the birth certificate was the issue or something else entirely.

0 coins

Payment method on my bonding claim was showing a weird status so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). The line had cut me off four mornings in a row before that. Agent pulled up my account and confirmed the payment method was set to debit card, so the hold wasn't coming from there — turned out the proof of relationship document still hadn't been matched to my claim. That alone would've taken me another week to figure out without getting someone on the phone. If your appeal is in and you're just hearing nothing, calling in to verify they even received the DE 1000A seems worth doing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

My payment method situation led me somewhere similar — tried Claimyr after the agent found on my claim that the DE 2514 had a note I hadn't seen about a document gap. Once I knew that, I filed a corrected appeal the same day. Good outcome eventually.

0 coins

Three months waiting and you found out in one call. That's the whole problem with EDD right there.

0 coins

Pretty much. The online status tells you nothing useful when an appeal is pending.

0 coins

I've called that PFL line so many times I know the hold music better than my own ringtone and I still haven't reached anyone. Three months of silence on an appeal is infuriating. EDD just makes you wait and wait and assumes you'll give up.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

That's kind of what I'm afraid of honestly. I really can't afford to give up, the denial affected weeks I genuinely needed.

0 coins

Don't give up. File a Request Claim Update in SDI Online too if you haven't. It's not the appeals office but it at least creates a paper trail.

0 coins

Wait, so when you appeal, does EDD handle it or is it a totally separate office? And does the SDI Online status ever change to show the appeal is pending or does it just stay the same as before?

0 coins

The appeals go to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, which is separate from EDD's day-to-day claims unit. SDI Online typically won't reflect appeal status changes the way it does for a regular claim — it usually just shows the last EDD determination, not the appeal outcome.

0 coins

Oh I had no idea it was a different board. That explains why there's no update showing anywhere. So basically you just wait for a letter?

0 coins

That's been my understanding, yes. You receive a hearing notice by mail once your case is scheduled. The timeline varies but three to four months before a hearing notice is not unusual from what I've seen.

0 coins

You can also contact your state Assembly member's office. Their constituent services staff can sometimes get EDD moving on a stalled appeal faster than waiting around. It's not glamorous but it works.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

I hadn't thought of that at all. That's actually a really useful idea.

0 coins

My coworker did this for a totally different EDD issue and said the response time got noticeably shorter after the office made contact. Worth trying while you wait.

0 coins

edd appeals take so long its like they forget you exist just keep checking your mail every day thats all you can really do

0 coins

Checking mail is about the only thing you can do short of getting someone on the phone.

0 coins

Before the hearing date even arrives, make sure you have your documentation organized — the original denial notice, your birth certificate or other proof of relationship, and any correspondence you sent. At the hearing you can present all of that. The appeals board looks at whether EDD's determination was correct based on the full record.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

So the hearing is where I actually get to explain what happened? I wasn't sure if it was just paperwork or if I'd actually talk to someone.

0 coins

You present your side, yes. It's typically a phone hearing and you can bring documentation to reference. The notice will explain the format when it arrives.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Okay, that's reassuring. I feel like I could make a decent case if I actually get to explain the birth certificate situation.

0 coins

The receipt number from when I originally filed got disconnected from my claim somehow and I ended up speaking to an EDD agent using Claimyr to sort it out. The agent found the receipt number in the system and confirmed it was matched correctly, so my claim could move forward. Such a relief to finally get a real answer about where things stood instead of guessing!

0 coins

I'll be honest, I'm not sure how calling an outside service would get you through to EDD any faster. I've tried first thing Monday mornings, mid-week afternoons, all of it, and either get the busy signal or the line just drops. What exactly happened when you used it?

0 coins

The service waits on hold with EDD while you go about your day, and your phone rings when an actual EDD agent picks up. That's genuinely all it was. I wasn't stuck listening to hold music for two hours.

0 coins

My bonding claim had the proof of relationship sitting unmatched for over a week. Got on with an agent and they confirmed the birth certificate had been received but hadn't been linked yet. That got resolved the same day.

0 coins

Alright, that is at least more useful than what I've been doing. I might try it to ask about my own pending payment.

0 coins

Three months with no response means either they haven't scheduled your hearing yet or the appeal wasn't received. Those are really the only two possibilities. Contact the appeals board directly — their number is separate from EDD's main line.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Do you know the number for the appeals board specifically or is it just the same EDD number?

0 coins

Different office. Look up the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board — they have their own contact line. EDD's PFL number is 1-877-238-4373 and that's just for the claims side, not appeals.

0 coins

we went through a bonding denial last year and the appeal took about five months total before the hearing, it felt endless with a newborn anyway. the key thing is just making sure they have everything — the DE 1000A received, proof of relationship attached, all of it, good luck

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Five months. Okay that makes three months feel slightly less alarming I guess.

0 coins

it does eventually happen, just hang in there, we got a favorable decision so it was worth the wait anyway

0 coins

One thing that tripped me up with my own claim — I thought uploading the birth certificate in SDI Online was the same as it being "received" and matched to my bonding claim. Those are two different steps. EDD has to match the uploaded document to the claim record, and that can take time. Worth clarifying with an agent whether the document actually got linked.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

That could be exactly what happened to me. It showed as uploaded but maybe it never got matched.

0 coins

Same thing happened on my claim. Uploaded fine, still showed pending for days after.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my bonding claim had a weekly benefit amount that looked wrong to me, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent using Claimyr about it. Agent confirmed the amount on the DE 429DF and walked me through which base period quarter was used — the number came out different from what the online calculator estimated, but the agent said the notice figure was what EDD had on file. Cleared up a lot of confusion about whether I'd been underpaid on the weeks before my appeal question even came up.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? First time hearing the name.

0 coins

It holds the line with EDD's paid family leave number until an agent answers, then you pick up. That's the whole thing. No tricks.

0 coins

Alright. I'd want to ask EDD whether my own DE 2514 denial was actually mailed to the right address because I never got the original — moved last year and updated myEDD but not sure if it took. Might try it for that.

0 coins

At the hearing itself, you do not need a lawyer, though you can bring one. Many people represent themselves and do fine. Bring every document you submitted with the original claim and a copy of your denial notice. If the issue was the proof of relationship, have the birth certificate right in front of you to reference.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

That's really helpful. I was wondering if I needed to get legal help and was worried about the cost.

0 coins

For a straightforward proof of relationship issue, most people handle it themselves. The appeals board is used to unrepresented claimants.

0 coins

The appeals process really does feel like shouting into a void until suddenly you get a hearing notice in the mail. Three months is frustrating but it doesn't mean your appeal was lost. Just keep the original denial notice safe and don't throw away anything EDD sends you.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

I've been keeping everything in a folder thankfully. Good reminder to not let any of it get buried.

0 coins

Same thing I did when mine was pending. The notice when it finally came had a date and time for the phone hearing only about two weeks out so having everything ready mattered.

0 coins

The SDI Online message system — Request Claim Update — does actually get read eventually even if the auto-reply is useless. I sent one about my appeal and got a written response about two weeks later clarifying which documents were on file. Not fast but better than nothing.

0 coins

You can send messages directly through SDI Online? I thought that was just for checking payment status.

0 coins

In myEDD go into SDI Online, find your claim, and there's an option called Request Claim Update. Pick the type and write your question. It's slow but it at least gives you something in writing back.

0 coins

Okay I need to do that for my own claim, I've been waiting on a Part D update and had no idea that existed.

0 coins

appeals take way longer than they say. i waited four months. hearing notice came on a random tuesday. just wait for the mail

0 coins

Random Tuesday is exactly how it shows up. No warning.

0 coins

Something to double-check before the hearing — make sure your address in myEDD is current. The hearing notice goes by mail and if EDD has an old address you'll miss the date. Had a coworker miss a hearing for exactly that reason on a different claim.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Already updated it but I'm going to log in and verify it again after reading this. Not taking chances.

0 coins

Good call. Five minutes now saves a huge headache later lol.

0 coins

If a lot of time has passed and you're genuinely worried the DE 1000A wasn't received, the appeals board allows you to file a late appeal in some cases if you can show good cause for why it was late. That's a harder path but worth knowing exists. The main thing is to contact them directly and ask whether your appeal is in their system.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

I'm going to try to reach someone this week, either through the appeals board line or by sending a Request Claim Update in SDI Online. I really just need to know if the DE 1000A made it.

0 coins

That's the right move. Knowing whether it's in the system or not is the whole question right now — everything else is secondary.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

Agreed. I'll come back and update this once I know what's actually happening with it.

0 coins

Don't sit on it another month. Phone the appeals board, send the SDI Online message, contact your Assembly rep — do all three this week. Waiting quietly doesn't help you here.

0 coins

AstroAce

Author

You're right. I've been in a kind of paralysis about it because I didn't know what to do. Now I have actual steps to take.

0 coins

EDD doesn't reward patience. You have to push.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure