Back to California Paid Family Leave

Miguel Diaz

Does employer opting into SDI require upfront payment and one year wait for California PFL?

So I've been going back and forth on this and I'm confusing myself. I work for a small nonprofit that doesn't currently withhold CASDI from paychecks, and HR told me they're 'considering opting in' to SDI. I want to take paid family leave next spring when my husband and I finalize our adoption, and I'm panicking a bit because I don't know if there's some kind of waiting period after the employer joins, or if employees have to pay something upfront before they can file. Does anyone know how the employer opting into SDI thing actually works for PFL eligibility? Do I need a full year of contributions before I can even file a bonding claim? I keep finding conflicting info and I genuinely don't know what to believe.

To figure out where you stand, I'd check your most recent pay stubs first and look for 'CASDI' in the deductions. That withholding is what tells EDD you're contributing to SDI. The eligibility rule is that you need at least $300 in base period wages with SDI withheld. The base period looks back five to eighteen months before your claim starts, so the timing of when your employer actually begins withholding does matter quite a bit.

0 coins

My stubs right now show nothing for CASDI, which is what I expected since HR said we're not in yet. So basically if they don't start withholding soon I might not have $300 in SDI wages by the time our placement happens?

0 coins

Exactly right. The base period is a twelve-month window made of four quarters, and EDD uses the highest quarter to calculate your benefit. If withholding only starts a month or two before your leave, you likely won't have enough in the base period to qualify.

0 coins

This is the part that trips people up. The employer has to actually be enrolled and withholding before those wages count toward PFL eligibility. Worth pressing HR on a firm start date.

0 coins

Two Fridays ago the Notice of Computation arrived for my bonding claim, and the weekly amount was lower than I expected, so I wanted to understand which quarter EDD had used. EDD's phone line defeated me for three days straight, every attempt ending with a busy signal or a recording. Claimyr (claimyr.com) changed that: I ended up talking to an actual PFL agent. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. The agent pulled up my claim and told me exactly which base period quarter had the highest wages and what that produced as my weekly benefit amount. That matched the Notice of Computation once I read it more carefully. For your situation, the key thing is that it's the CASDI withholding that has to show in those base period wages, not just the employment itself.

0 coins

What did you have ready when the agent answered? I never know what to gather beforehand.

0 coins

My Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the Notice of Computation itself, since I had a specific question about the numbers on it. That was enough for the agent to pull everything up right away.

0 coins

been trying that line myself for a week now. mornings, afternoons, doesnt matter. never gets past the recording.

0 coins

No upfront payment from the employee side. CASDI comes out of your paycheck once your employer is enrolled, same as any other payroll deduction. You don't write a check to EDD yourself.

0 coins

That's a relief. I was picturing having to pay some lump sum to 'buy in' or something. So it's purely payroll withholding from the first check after they enroll?

0 coins

Yep. First check with CASDI showing, those wages start counting. Nothing from you directly.

0 coins

Same as how it worked at my last place when they switched over. Just showed up on the stub one week. No paperwork I had to sign.

0 coins

The one-year wait idea probably comes from people confusing this with certain employer leave policies, but EDD doesn't have a one-year waiting period for PFL. EDD's rule is the base period wages with CASDI withheld. If your employer starts withholding tomorrow and you rack up $300 in SDI wages before your base period closes, you can file.

0 coins

So there is no waiting period at all from EDD's side, it's just about whether the contributions are there in the base period?

0 coins

Right. PFL doesn't even have a benefit waiting period within a claim. That's a common mix-up with disability, which has an unpaid week at the start. PFL doesn't have that.

0 coins

Wait, I thought PFL had a seven-day waiting period too. So that's only disability insurance and not PFL at all?

0 coins

Only disability. PFL has zero waiting period. First eligible day, you can be paid.

0 coins

Worth noting that citizenship and immigration status don't affect PFL eligibility either, in case that's a concern for anyone reading. The two things EDD looks at are the employment and the CASDI withholding in the base period.

0 coins

Good to know. My husband is on a work visa and I wasn't sure if that affected our situation at all from EDD's end.

0 coins

For PFL it doesn't. Eligibility turns on those wages with SDI withheld, nothing else about status.

0 coins

My coworker went through almost this exact thing last year. Her employer wasn't in SDI when she was hired, they opted in mid-year, and she filed a PFL bonding claim about eight months after they started withholding. She got benefits because she had enough CASDI wages in her base period by then. It really is just about the timing of when withholding starts.

0 coins

Eight months was enough for her? That's actually encouraging. I'm hoping our placement is at least that far out from whatever date HR gets this rolling.

0 coins

She had been there a while and her pay is decent, so she hit that $300 threshold easily once the deductions started. Yours might look different depending on your wages, but the calculator on EDD's site can give you an estimate.

0 coins

yeah the calculator is actually useful, rare for a government site lol. plug in your wages and it shows you roughly what your weekly amount would be.

0 coins

HR saying they're 'considering' it is the part I'd push on. Considering and enrolled are very different things.

0 coins

You're right and that's exactly what worries me. 'Considering' could mean next month or could mean never.

0 coins

Get a date in writing if you can.

0 coins

From an employer side, opting into SDI does involve registration with EDD and setting up the payroll deduction going forward. There's no bulk payment for past wages that weren't withheld. The effective enrollment date is what matters, and from that date forward the deductions begin and those wages start building toward an employee's base period.

0 coins

Is there any cost to the employer itself to enroll? I'm wondering if that's why they're dragging their feet.

0 coins

There can be employer contributions depending on how the plan is structured, but that's separate from the employee's CASDI deduction. The employee side is just the withholding from wages.

0 coins

For anything specific about what your employer owes or pays, that would be a question for EDD's employer services side rather than the PFL line. The PFL line handles the employee claim side.

0 coins

About six weeks into intermittent leave for my mom's care, I realized the payment for my second week hadn't come through, and SDI Online showed two weeks still marked pending. I used Claimyr and spoke with a PFL agent directly after too many early mornings on hold. The agent went through my claim week by week and confirmed which weeks had been paid and which were still pending, and told me the next payment was due after my Continued Claim Certification came back. That form, the DE 2580GF, is the one that keeps intermittent payments moving, and EDD stops them if it doesn't come back.

0 coins

How does an agent know which weeks are confirmed paid versus just pending? I've got a week sitting there and I can't tell if it's just slow or actually stuck.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and Social Security number ready, and also know the specific week dates you're asking about. The agent can see the status on each individual week right on the claim.

0 coins

The DE 2580GF trips people up! EDD sends it and if it doesn't come back the payments just stop, no warning. So glad you caught it.

0 coins

your hr people need to give you a real answer not just 'considering'. adoption placements dont wait for hr to get organized

0 coins

Exactly how I feel. I have zero control over when the placement happens and a lot of control over whether I have income during it.

0 coins

push them. get it in an email. something in writing beats a conversation every time

0 coins

PFL for a bonding claim after an adoption placement works the same as after a birth in terms of eligibility. You'll need a proof of relationship document, which for an adoption would be the Adoptive Placement Agreement, the AD-907. That's separate from the eligibility question but worth knowing early.

0 coins

AD-907, writing that down. We're early in the process but it's good to know what I'll need to upload.

0 coins

You submit that through SDI Online with your bonding claim. Keep a copy of the placement agreement from your agency.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online is the recommended route. Under myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ you apply for PFL bonding. Save the receipt number on the confirmation page.

0 coins

Can I ask something that might be dumb, is there a difference between the employer opting into SDI and the employer having a voluntary plan? I saw something about voluntary plans online and now I'm not sure if those are the same thing or totally different.

0 coins

Voluntary plans are employer-approved substitutes for the state SDI plan, so separate from just opting in. If an employer has a voluntary plan it covers the same benefits but through a private insurer. For PFL eligibility purposes, what matters is that SDI or an approved plan is withholding from your wages.

0 coins

So either way the CASDI deduction on the stub is the sign that you're covered?

0 coins

For the state plan, yes, CASDI on the stub. A voluntary plan may show differently. If you're unsure which you have, ask HR specifically.

0 coins

The second payment on my bonding claim was delayed and I could not get a human on EDD's PFL line for anything. I tried Claimyr after about five days of dead ends, and reached a PFL agent who pulled up my Electronic Benefit Payment Notification, the DE 2500E, and confirmed the payment date and the method on file. Turned out my direct deposit information from myEDD hadn't synced correctly.

0 coins

Direct deposit not syncing is my actual nightmare scenario right now, two kids, mortgage, the works. I had the same thing happen with the DE 2500E showing one thing and my bank showing nothing. Used Claimyr myself actually, agent told me the exact date my first payment was issued and what day it hit the payment method on file. After that I went into myEDD and double-checked everything anyway.

0 coins

How long had you been at the busy signal before that?

0 coins

Honestly more mornings than I want to count. six, maybe seven. the line just cuts you off.

0 coins

I'll believe the 'at least $300 threshold is all it takes' line when I see it. EDD finds ways to complicate things.

0 coins

Fair, but the base period wage requirement is the actual written rule. Whether EDD processes it cleanly is a separate question.

0 coins

That's the part I'm skeptical of. Rule on paper, chaos in practice.

0 coins

Eight weeks of PFL for a bonding claim, that's so important to know about! And you can break them up too, you don't have to take all eight straight.

0 coins

Breaking them up is something I hadn't thought about but that's really useful. If the placement is bumpy and I need to go back to work for a bit, I could still use the remaining weeks?

0 coins

Yes, the eight weeks just have to be used within twelve months of the placement date. They don't have to run consecutively.

0 coins

That flexibility makes such a difference for adoptive parents especially, placements can be unpredictable!

0 coins

Intermittent days I'd taken every other Friday for the first couple months of my daughter's care claim, and the third payment never appeared even though I'd sent the Continued Claim Certification back. I tried Claimyr and the agent walked through the DE 2580GF on file, then confirmed that EDD had received it but that reporting for a specific week was still showing as incomplete. The agent said to watch for a follow-up notice by mail and to appeal within 30 days if I disagreed with any determination.

0 coins

Every time I've dialed that PFL line I get the same recorded message and then nothing. So you're saying you actually reached a person? I've tried before the phones even get busy.

0 coins

Yeah, I know how that sounds, I didn't expect it to work either. But I did end up talking to a real EDD agent. The DE 2580GF being received but incomplete was something I never would have known without that call.

0 coins

I used Claimyr for my own care claim a while back and the agent told me I had three weeks left in my twelve-month window, which I hadn't tracked carefully at all. Really saved me from losing them.

0 coins

To loop back to the original question, there's no magic one-year rule from EDD. The employer enrollment date is the starting gun for withholding, and it's those withheld wages in your base period that determine eligibility.

0 coins

Okay this whole thread has been genuinely clarifying. So my to-do is push HR for a firm enrollment date, track when CASDI starts showing on stubs, and use EDD's calculator to estimate my benefit once I have a couple of months of wages in.

0 coins

That's the right list. And save your receipt number after you file the bonding claim, you'll need it.

0 coins

Also keep the adoption agency documentation organized from the start. The AD-907 or whatever placement agreement they give you is what you'll upload as proof of relationship.

0 coins

Is PFL eight weeks total across all claims in a year or eight weeks per claim? Like if I already used some weeks for a care claim earlier this year, do I have a full eight weeks left for bonding?

0 coins

That's one pool, not separate pools. Bonding, care and military assist all draw from the same eight weeks within any twelve-month period. So weeks used on a care claim earlier do count against what's left for bonding.

0 coins

Good to know before I assume I have the full eight weeks.

0 coins

Yep, one limit for all three claim types. Someone upthread assumed each type was its own eight weeks, but that's not how EDD's rule reads.

0 coins

wait does anyone know if you can collect PFL and unemployment at the same time? asking for a friend who lost their job during their bonding leave

0 coins

You can't receive both for the same days. They're separate programs and EDD doesn't pay them for the same period.

0 coins

ah that makes sense, figured it was too good to be true lol. ill pass that along

0 coins

The friend should ask EDD which one fits their situation better given the timing.

0 coins

my employer was already in sdi when i was hired so i never had to think about this but reading through i realize i took it for granted. if that casdi line hadnt been on my stub from day one i could have been in real trouble when the baby came

0 coins

This is exactly my fear. Everyone else I know had it automatic and never thought twice about it.

0 coins

push hr hard. dont let it slide

0 coins

What happens if the placement falls through after you've already filed a PFL bonding claim?

0 coins

If a placement doesn't go through, there's no eligible bonding event, so benefits wouldn't be paid for days when no child was placed. You'd want to contact EDD and let them know the situation changed.

0 coins

I hadn't even thought about that scenario. Adoption is unpredictable. Good thing to keep in mind.

0 coins

the pfl line being impossible to reach is not new. been that way for years. i gave up once and just sent a request through sdi online instead. took longer but at least it went somewhere

0 coins

Is the Request Claim Update in SDI Online actually useful for eligibility questions, or is it more for things like missing documents?

0 coins

mostly for specific claim questions, like if something is pending or a document hasnt been matched. for general eligibility stuff it can be hit or miss

0 coins

For a question about whether you qualify before even filing, the Ask EDD contact form or calling the PFL line at 1-877-238-4373 are probably more direct. Request Claim Update works best once a claim is in the system.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure