Back to California Paid Family Leave

Lucy Taylor

Can I take FMLA and PFL separately or do they always run at the same time?

Okay so I've been trying to figure this out for weeks and I keep getting different answers from different people. My wife is due in February and I want to take time off to bond with the baby. HR told me I'd be using FMLA and California PFL at the same time, but my brother-in-law said he took them separately somehow and got way more time off total. Now I'm completely confused about how this actually works. Is it possible to take FMLA and PFL at the same time, or can you separate them? My HR department keeps saying they run concurrently, but then why did my brother-in-law seem to get more time? I work in logistics and my employer offers no additional paid leave beyond what the state provides, so I'm trying to figure out the maximum time I can actually be home with the baby. I filed my PFL claim on SDI Online and got a receipt number, but I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet and I'm not sure if I even set it up right for a bonding claim. Any experience with this would be really helpful.

My claim's start date was something I had to get straight with EDD before anything else fell into place, and that actually pushed me to try Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the hold times were brutal. Ended up speaking with an EDD agent who confirmed my bonding claim's start date, told me the 41-day window I had from that date, and flagged that my proof of relationship document had already been received on their end. That cleared up a lot of my confusion about timing. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

The 41-day thing is real and people sleep on it. EDD's clock starts the first day you're actually on leave, not the due date, not the day you filed. If you go past that window you lose those early days.

0 coins

That's exactly the kind of timing detail I was worried about getting wrong. Did the agent say anything about how the FMLA piece interacts with the PFL start date at all?

0 coins

The agent stuck to what was on my claim — the start date and what EDD had received. The FMLA question they said is really between me and my employer, since that's a federal law EDD doesn't administer.

0 coins

HR is correct that FMLA and California PFL usually run at the same time for most people — your employer is allowed to designate FMLA leave to run alongside any other leave you take, including state PFL, if you qualify for both. So the job protection from CFRA or FMLA and the wage replacement from PFL cover the same weeks. What your brother-in-law may have done is a different scenario, like his employer didn't qualify for FMLA or he wasn't eligible, so his PFL weeks stood alone. How the two programs stack for your specific job is really an HR and employment law question, not an EDD question. EDD handles the PFL payment side only.

0 coins

So EDD just pays the PFL benefit and my employer controls the FMLA designation? That makes more sense now. HR said the same thing but I thought they were trying to cut my time short.

0 coins

Yep, EDD has nothing to do with FMLA. PFL provides the money, FMLA or CFRA provides the job protection, and your employer decides how to stack them. Worth asking HR specifically what their written policy says.

0 coins

Exactly. And just to be clear for anyone reading — PFL by itself does not protect your job. EDD says that outright. The job protection piece lives with CFRA and FMLA, so if you lose the job protection piece, you still have the PFL pay but no guaranteed return.

0 coins

went through this same rabbit hole last year when my daughter was born. EDD paid my PFL bonding claim and my job used FMLA on their end for the same stretch. I had 8 weeks of PFL pay from EDD and my FMLA ran alongside it. I did not get extra weeks by separating them — my employer stacked them from day one.

0 coins

Same here. My employer's HR ran them together and nobody told me I could do it differently. I still have no idea if I could have gotten more time.

0 coins

How did you file the PFL side? Did you go through SDI Online or use the paper form?

0 coins

SDI Online through myEDD. The bonding claim for a new child — I uploaded the birth certificate as the proof of relationship and that was pretty much it on EDD's side. HR handled the FMLA paperwork separately.

0 coins

something that tripped me up — PFL does not have a waiting period before the first payment. I was sitting there thinking I'd lose the first week like with disability, but bonding PFL kicks in from day one. If anyone told you there's a one week wait on PFL that's wrong, it was disability insurance that had the waiting period.

0 coins

This confused me too. My pregnancy disability claim had days before pay kicked in and I assumed PFL bonding would be the same. It's not, they're different programs.

0 coins

Nobody had told me about a waiting period so I didn't have that specific fear, but good to know in case someone at HR mentions it.

0 coins

The no-waiting-period thing is specific to PFL. Disability Insurance (DI) has unpaid days at the start of a claim. They are not the same and EDD is pretty clear about that on their site.

0 coins

Are you sure you saved your receipt number from SDI Online when you filed? Because if the bonding claim is in and you haven't gotten the Notice of Computation yet, the receipt number is how EDD and your doctor's office (if you needed any certification) can link documents back to your file. For a bonding claim you don't need Part C or Part D — that's only for care claims — but the receipt number still matters for any follow up.

0 coins

I did screenshot the confirmation page so I have the receipt number saved. The bonding claim just needs the proof of relationship, right? No forms going to a doctor?

0 coins

Correct — bonding has no Part C or Part D. Those only exist for care claims where a family member is ill. For a bonding claim you need the proof of relationship document, which for a birth is typically the birth certificate. Since the baby isn't born yet you'd upload it once you have it, within that 41-day window from when your leave starts.

0 coins

Just double-check that you answered the relationship question correctly in SDI Online too. I filed a bonding claim and had to confirm I was the father and that it was a birth not an adoption, those are different proofs of relationship.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you do the math on how EDD pays it. Each day you're on leave pays out at one-seventh of your weekly benefit amount, so it's not one lump sum. EDD sends payments every two weeks while you're on leave. The actual dollar amount per week is on the Notice of Computation when it comes — EDD calculates it from your earnings in a base period of about 5 to 18 months before your claim, and it's somewhere around 70 to 90 percent of what you made, depending on your income level. Use the calculator on EDD's site for an estimate before the notice arrives.

0 coins

The calculator estimate was lower than I expected but I haven't gotten the Notice of Computation yet so I'm hoping the actual amount is a bit higher. How long after filing does that notice usually show up?

0 coins

In my experience it came pretty fast, within a week of EDD processing the claim. But it doesn't mean you're approved — it just shows the potential weekly amount. The actual eligibility decision is separate.

0 coins

The notice coming does not mean you're approved. I made that mistake and told my wife we were good to go. The eligibility decision came later and it's what actually started the payments.

0 coins

The payment method on a bonding claim caught me off guard a bit. EDD's debit card now comes through Money Network, not Bank of America like it used to. I had set up direct deposit in SDI Online so it went there instead, but I want to double-check on the status. Used Claimyr to reach an EDD agent about the payment method on my claim, and the agent confirmed my direct deposit was on file and told me which week my first payment had been issued. Helped a lot to hear it straight.

0 coins

The debit card change got me too. I was sitting there waiting for a card from a bank I didn't recognize in the mail and almost threw it out. Direct deposit through SDI Online is smoother if you have that option set up.

0 coins

I did choose direct deposit when I filed, good to know that's the cleaner option. How long from when EDD issues the payment to when it actually hits your account?

0 coins

It was quick for me, like a regular ACH transfer, a couple of business days after EDD issued it. The SDI Online payment history shows the issue date so you can track it.

0 coins

the FMLA vs CFRA vs PFL question always turns into a whole thing in these threads. quick reminder that CFRA is California's version of FMLA basically, and they mostly run together too. the job protection in california for new parents is usually CFRA and or FMLA, the money comes from EDD's PFL. it's three separate things doing three separate jobs and HR manages two of them.

0 coins

CFRA and FMLA do not cover everyone the same way though. Smaller employers may only be under CFRA or only FMLA or neither. Whether you're protected depends on your employer's size and your own eligibility, so it's not safe to assume both apply. That's why HR is the right starting point for the job protection piece.

0 coins

fair point, I was oversimplifying. the main thing is EDD only controls PFL. the rest is on your employer and those leave laws.

0 coins

My bonding claim sat pending for about ten days before anything moved. The 14-day window EDD has for making an eligibility decision had me checking SDI Online every morning. If yours goes past two weeks with no Notice of Computation and no payment activity, the Request Claim Update tool inside SDI Online is there to send EDD a message about your specific claim.

0 coins

Good to know there's an in-platform way to reach them without picking up the phone right away. I'm only a few days in so I'll give it more time.

0 coins

Yeah the pending stage is just the worst for anxiety. Once the notice comes it moves faster.

0 coins

EDD's target is 14 days to decide. If you hit day 15 with nothing, the Request Claim Update or just calling 1-877-238-4373 are both options.

0 coins

Something I want to flag for anyone who's a new mom reading this thread — the PFL bonding process is a bit different if you're coming off a pregnancy disability claim. EDD mails you a specific form, the DE 2501FP, and you just fill that out within 41 days of when your bonding leave starts. You don't need to file a whole new claim in SDI Online and you don't need extra documents with it like a birth certificate.

0 coins

DE 2501FP is only for birth mothers transitioning from their own disability claim. For dads and adoptive parents it's the regular SDI Online bonding claim with the proof of relationship.

0 coins

Right, I should have said that more clearly. The DE 2501FP is the new mother form that comes in the mail, not for anyone who didn't have a pregnancy disability claim first.

0 coins

I'm the dad in this case so the SDI Online filing I already did is the right move, good confirmation.

0 coins

I know the original question is about FMLA and PFL but can I ask — does the 8 weeks have to be used all at once? My situation is I want to take some weeks now when the baby comes and then maybe some days here and there later when my wife goes back to work part time. Is that allowed?

0 coins

PFL can absolutely be taken in pieces. The eight weeks don't have to be consecutive, they just all need to be used within 12 months of the birth or placement. If you go back to work and want to take intermittent days later, you'd report your work and wages and EDD sends you a Continued Claim Certification form to keep things moving.

0 coins

Oh that's a relief. My HR told me I had to decide upfront whether it was going to be all at once or intermittent and I wasn't sure if EDD required the same thing.

0 coins

EDD and your employer are two separate decisions. EDD allows the flexibility, but whether your employer will approve an intermittent schedule is their call under CFRA or FMLA or their own policy. Those are different approvals.

0 coins

Eight weeks total is the ceiling for PFL in any 12-month window, and that's shared across bonding, care and military assist. So if you used five weeks bonding with the baby and then a parent gets seriously ill later in the same 12 months, you'd only have three PFL weeks left for that care claim. I've seen people in this forum surprised by that.

0 coins

I did not know it was one shared pool. I thought each reason for leave had its own eight weeks.

0 coins

That's a common mistake. The 8 weeks is one limit for all PFL purposes in a 12-month period. EDD tracks how many you've used.

0 coins

This is accurate and worth knowing before you plan anything. If you have a reason you might need a care claim down the road, don't treat the eight bonding weeks as a 'use it or lose it' situation where you should max out.

0 coins

For your original question about the receipt number and not having the Notice of Computation yet — that's pretty normal if you just filed. The notice can take up to two weeks after EDD processes the claim. The receipt number you saved is the key link between your claim and anything EDD needs from you going forward, so keep it handy. If you uploaded the birth certificate already, great; if not, once the baby arrives you'd upload it in SDI Online (not email, not fax, right in the portal) within the 41-day window.

0 coins

The baby's not here yet so I can't upload the birth certificate right now. So basically the claim sits with EDD until I add the proof of relationship after the birth?

0 coins

Yep, the claim is in and the receipt number is yours. Upload the birth certificate once it's issued and that ties it to your bonding claim. EDD processes from there.

0 coins

The Declaration of Paternity (CS-909) also works as proof of relationship if for some reason the birth certificate is delayed. Good to know that option exists.

0 coins

Filing in SDI Online through myEDD (https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/) is the right move if you want direct deposit, which the paper DE 2501F doesn't support. Sounds like you already did it that way which is good. Getting a receipt number and keeping it confirms the claim is in EDD's system. Used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent on my own bonding claim when I wasn't sure my receipt number had matched to my document upload, and the agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the proof of relationship had been received on their end. The receipt number was the first thing they asked for.

0 coins

Good to know the agent just needs the receipt number right away. I've got mine saved so I'd be ready if I need to call.

0 coins

Direct deposit is definitely the way to go. Processing times are faster than waiting for a card or check in the mail.

0 coins

The paper form is fine if someone doesn't have a computer or can't access myEDD, but you lose the direct deposit option and can't track as easily through SDI Online.

0 coins

FMLA and California PFL doing different things is the core of your confusion and honestly it's confusing for everyone. FMLA is a federal law that tells your employer they have to hold your job. PFL is a California state program run by EDD that replaces some of your pay. They often cover the same weeks but they come from two totally different places and your employer controls one of them, EDD controls the other. Neither your brother-in-law's experience nor HR's explanation is necessarily wrong — it depends on the specifics of his employer, yours, and both of your situations.

0 coins

Okay so it's entirely possible his employer was smaller and not covered by FMLA and he used CFRA alone with PFL, and the timing just lined up differently? That would explain why he seemed to get more total time.

0 coins

Exactly that kind of scenario is possible. CFRA and FMLA have their own employer size and eligibility rules — your HR knows whether both apply to your workplace. EDD just pays the PFL side regardless.

0 coins

This is probably what happened with your brother-in-law. These programs interact differently at different employers. HR and an employment lawyer if it really matters are the right places to map it out.

0 coins

If your employer runs FMLA and CFRA at the same time as your PFL, your 12 weeks of FMLA or CFRA job protection and 8 weeks of PFL pay still cover different things and have different end points. After your 8 weeks of PFL pay runs out you might still have FMLA or CFRA job protection left, but EDD stops paying. So the overlap isn't necessarily a loss — the pay period just ends before the protection period.

0 coins

I hadn't thought of it that way — so I could potentially have job protection for a few more weeks after PFL pay ends. That changes the math on planning.

0 coins

Correct, and that extra protected time beyond PFL is unpaid from EDD's side. Some employers offer supplemental paid leave or let you use vacation or sick time for those remaining weeks, so worth asking HR what you can stack on top.

0 coins

Sick leave or vacation used at the same time as PFL can be combined, but EDD's rule is that your regular wages plus the PFL amount can't exceed your normal weekly pay. How your employer structures that is their policy though.

0 coins

my claim took 11 days to get the Notice of Computation and then another 4 or 5 days before the first payment showed up. so from filing to first dollar in the account was about two and a half weeks. that was last spring so I can't say if it's faster or slower now but that's what happened for me.

0 coins

Two and a half weeks total is actually better than I was mentally prepared for. I was thinking a month.

0 coins

It moved faster than I expected too. I think the SDI Online claims process faster than paper because EDD already has all the info digitally.

0 coins

Not sure if anyone mentioned this but if you want to split the leave between both parents — like you take some weeks and your wife takes some — each parent files their own separate PFL bonding claim with their own 8-week limit. The mom's 8 weeks and your 8 weeks are independent because they're on separate claims tied to separate SDI accounts. EDD doesn't link them or reduce one because the other is being used.

0 coins

So the 8-week cap per person is per claim, not per family per year? That's really useful to know.

0 coins

Per claimant. Each person who files a PFL bonding claim for the same child gets their own 8-week allotment. How that interacts with FMLA for each of your jobs is a separate employer question but EDD's side of it is independent.

0 coins

The only shared pool is within your own 12-month PFL period across all your own claims. Your wife's PFL weeks are hers; yours are yours.

0 coins

For the proof of relationship on a bonding claim — birth certificate is the most common, but EDD also accepts a Declaration of Paternity (the CS-909 form) or if it was an adoption there's the Adoptive Placement Agreement (AD-907), or a foster care agency letter. As a dad filing before the birth certificate is ready, the CS-909 might be an option if it comes through faster and you're worried about the 41-day clock.

0 coins

The 41-day clock starts when I actually start leave, not when the baby is born, right? So if I take a few days before the due date I need to count from there.

0 coins

The 41 days runs from the first day of your family leave. If you start leave the day before the birth you count from there, not the birth date. Most people's first day of leave is the birth date or day after so it's usually not an issue, but worth knowing.

0 coins

And the 41-day window is generous enough that you'll almost certainly have the birth certificate in time, unless there are complications. Just don't file the claim, then do nothing for six weeks and suddenly scramble — stay on it.

0 coins

For the question about whether you can take FMLA and PFL separately — the short answer is that it depends on your employer and what they designate. EDD doesn't decide FMLA and your employer doesn't decide PFL. They operate in parallel. Whether your employer is required to stack them, can stack them, or has to honor a request to separate them is an HR and employment law question. The civil rights department in California has CFRA information if you want to look into the state side, and the federal Department of Labor has FMLA info. EDD's PFL is totally separate from both.

0 coins

So if I really wanted to maximize the total time off, I'd need to negotiate with my employer on the FMLA side and separately manage the PFL side with EDD. They're essentially two parallel tracks.

0 coins

Exactly. EDD controls the pay. Your employer and the leave laws control the job protection. Getting the most out of both means knowing your rights under CFRA or FMLA for your specific employer and separately filing a timely PFL claim with EDD. Some employers are flexible on scheduling, some aren't — that part is a conversation with HR.

0 coins

And if EDD denies the PFL or you get a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination that you disagree with, you have 30 days to appeal using the Appeal Form (DE 1000A). That piece is EDD's process entirely, separate from any FMLA or CFRA dispute.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure