Back to California Paid Family Leave

Daniela Rossi

Can EDD deny second child PFL claim because of first child PFL claim?

So we just had our second kid, born in October, and I'm trying to file my PFL bonding claim. But here's the thing, I took PFL when our first was born back in late 2025 and used all eight weeks then. My wife is saying EDD can deny second child PFL claim because of first child PFL claim, like the eight weeks is a lifetime thing or something. That can't be right, can it? I'm losing sleep over this. Filed in SDI Online last week and uploaded the new birth certificate. Claim is sitting pending and I don't know if that's because of the old claim or just normal processing time.

Notice of Computation on this second claim showed a weekly amount right around what I expected, so the system wasn't treating my earlier bonding claim as some kind of block. Months between claims is what matters, not whether you've filed before. I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the pending status was dragging and I wanted to know if the notice meant anything about eligibility. Agent pulled up the claim and said the computation was issued and the 14-day review window was still open. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

The computation matching what you expected is exactly what I was watching for on mine. Used Claimyr too after my payment date came and went with nothing hitting my account. Agent looked it up and said the first payment issued on a specific date and to watch for it in the next day or two, which is exactly what happened.

0 coins

How many mornings did you spend redialing before you tried that? I've hit the busy signal so many times before 9am that I stopped counting.

0 coins

Four days straight before that. Each time the line would just drop me after a couple minutes of hold music.

0 coins

The 12-month window is the piece your wife might be thinking of. EDD says you get up to eight weeks within any 12-month period, so if your first claim's 12 months already closed before October, a whole new eight weeks is available for this baby.

0 coins

So it restarts? Like every 12 months from the start of whatever claim I filed?

0 coins

The 12 months runs from each child's birth date, not from some rolling calendar. The new child gives you a fresh 12-month window to use those eight weeks for bonding with that child.

0 coins

Wait, so my husband and I could both file for this baby separately? Each our own eight weeks? Sorry if that's obvious but we didn't know.

0 coins

Each parent does file their own claim, yes. EDD treats them as separate claims tied to the same child's birth, each with its own eight-week allowance within the 12 months from the birth date.

0 coins

My neighbor went through this same panic last year with her second. She was convinced EDD would reject it because she'd used PFL with her first. Got approved fine. The old claim just doesn't follow you around like that.

0 coins

EDD's not tracking lifetime uses. Each kid, new claim.

0 coins

That is genuinely relieving to hear.

0 coins

I'm in a similar spot and I'm not sure I understand the 12 months thing fully. Like, if I took three weeks bonding with my first in early 2025 and the 12 months from that birth are definitely over, those three weeks are just gone right? I can't add them to this new baby's eight weeks, I think?

0 coins

Correct. Those three weeks belonged to the first child's 12-month window. The new baby gets its own fresh eight weeks. You don't carry anything over.

0 coins

Ok that's actually better than I feared. I thought somehow the leftover weeks would complicate things.

0 coins

edd doesnt care how many kids you have had just care about the 12 month window for each one, filed for my second in august no issues at all

0 coins

August and no issues, good to know. Mine is from October so fingers crossed.

0 coins

should be fine mine processed in like 11 days

0 coins

The birth certificate you uploaded with the SDI Online claim should be enough proof of relationship for a dad. Just make sure the name on it matches your EDD account exactly, that tripped a friend of mine up and delayed things by a week.

0 coins

Name matches, I checked three times after reading that happened to someone else on here.

0 coins

Is the birth certificate always enough or does it have to be the official one from the county? I have a hospital copy.

0 coins

EDD accepts a certified copy from the county registrar. The hospital copy that gets handed out in the room may or may not be accepted, so if you have any doubt, ordering the official certified one through the county is worth the small fee.

0 coins

Thank you, I'll go get the certified one to be safe.

0 coins

Pending for a week is pretty standard. EDD has up to 14 days to decide. Clock's not broken.

0 coins

Day 10 now. Trying to be patient.

0 coins

Day 14 and still pending, then send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online.

0 coins

Two payments into my second bonding claim and I had no idea how many weeks I had left after taking a few weeks intermittent, so I tried Claimyr to get a straight answer. Agent looked at the claim and told me exactly which weeks had been paid out and that my next payment was set to issue the following Friday. That cleared up a lot of confusion on my end.

0 coins

Every time I've tried that line I either get a busy signal or it disconnects me after the menu. How is anyone actually getting through to a person?

0 coins

Claimyr is the only way I've managed it twice now. It handles the hold time and your phone rings when an EDD agent is on. Both times I got a real person who could actually see my claim.

0 coins

I've used Claimyr for a care claim I had earlier this year and the agent told me I had three of my eight weeks remaining in the 12-month period, which helped me plan the rest of my leave. Good to know it works for bonding claims too.

0 coins

Huh. I've been redialing since last Tuesday. Might be worth a try if the line keeps doing that to me.

0 coins

October birth, filed within a week, proof of relationship uploaded. Everything looks right on your end. The only thing I'd double-check is that the name on the birth certificate matches the account, and that SDI Online shows the document as received, not just uploaded.

0 coins

How do I confirm it shows received vs just uploaded? Is there a status somewhere?

0 coins

In SDI Online under your claim there should be a documents section showing what's been submitted. If it lists the file, EDD has it. If that section is blank or unclear, sending a Request Claim Update asking them to confirm receipt is the cleaner move.

0 coins

Worked five years with a guy who filed PFL for three different kids. Never got denied for any of them. EDD's not keeping score on how many children you bond with.

0 coins

Three kids, three claims. That's the answer right there.

0 coins

Five years of data points, I'll take it.

0 coins

your wife's thinking of the 12 months within the same child's window, not some global limit. happens a lot.

0 coins

Yeah I think she read something online that wasn't specific to California and panicked us both.

0 coins

While we're on this, does PFL protect your job while you're out? I keep seeing CFRA mentioned and I don't know if that's the same thing or separate.

0 coins

They are separate. PFL from EDD pays the benefit but EDD itself says it does not protect the job. CFRA is a California leave law that can run at the same time and may protect the position, but whether it covers someone depends on their employer and situation. Worth checking with HR about CFRA specifically.

0 coins

So I could get paid through PFL but still not have job protection if CFRA doesn't apply to me?

0 coins

That's the right read. PFL is the pay, CFRA is the job protection, and they're not automatic together. HR is the right place to ask about whether CFRA applies.

0 coins

Ask HR. They'll know your situation.

0 coins

Eight weeks sounds like a lot until you realize it resets per child and that two parents each get their own eight. We staggered ours and it stretched things out nicely.

0 coins

Staggering is smart. We're trying to do the same, my wife finishing her weeks first and then me picking up after.

0 coins

That's a solid plan. Just make sure each of you files your own separate claim in SDI Online, they don't link automatically.

0 coins

PFL has no waiting period either, unlike disability. First eligible day pays.

0 coins

Wait I thought there were seven unpaid days at the start, like a waiting period?

0 coins

That's disability insurance, not PFL. PFL starts paying from day one of the leave.

0 coins

I would have sat there waiting out seven days for nothing. Thank you.

0 coins

DE 2500E came up on my second bonding claim and I had no idea what it was. Used Claimyr to reach EDD and ask. Agent explained that the DE 2500E is the notification that the first payment has been issued and told me the amount and date so I knew what to watch for.

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? I keep seeing it mentioned here.

0 coins

It's a service that waits on hold with EDD's line in your place, and once a live agent picks up, your phone rings. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

My second bonding claim just went to approved and I'm waiting on that first payment confirmation. That might be exactly what I need to ask about.

0 coins

Two hours trying that 877 number this morning and not once did a human pick up. At some point you have to wonder if anyone actually works there.

0 coins

Mondays are brutal. Try midweek.

0 coins

Tried Wednesday too. Same result.

0 coins

I had luck mid-morning on a Thursday but honestly it's pretty hit or miss no matter when you go.

0 coins

My second claim processed faster than my first, which surprised me. First one took 13 days, second one was done in nine. No rhyme or reason I can figure out.

0 coins

Day 10 and counting over here. Really hoping for nine.

0 coins

The birth certificate being clean and already in the system from before might have helped. Hard to know.

0 coins

Intermittent days on this second claim were confusing until the EDD agent sorted it out for me. I tried Claimyr after getting nowhere on the phone line myself, and the agent found the DE 2580GF on the account and told me exactly which intermittent days had been reported and which ones were still showing unconfirmed.

0 coins

Used Claimyr earlier this year for my first claim and it worked. Agent checked the start date on the claim and confirmed the 41-day filing window, which I had almost missed by waiting too long. Really glad I called when I did.

0 coins

The 41 days, did the agent say when it started from? The birth date or the first day you actually took leave?

0 coins

First day of leave, that's what the agent said. For me that was two days after the birth, so the clock started there, not the day she was born.

0 coins

For anyone reading who's confused about the 12-month window: EDD's rule is that the eight weeks must be used within 12 months of the child's birth or placement. A previous claim for an older child doesn't shrink that window at all. Each child, each placement, starts its own 12-month clock.

0 coins

This is the clearest explanation I've seen. Saving this.

0 coins

wish someone had just said this to me when i filed for my second, would have saved a lot of back and forth

0 coins

Your claim will process. The pending status doing nothing for ten days is uncomfortable but it's normal. When the Notice of Computation shows up in SDI Online, that's the system starting to move.

0 coins

Notice of Computation appeared this morning actually. So things are moving?

0 coins

Yes. The Notice of Computation shows your potential weekly benefit amount. It doesn't confirm you're approved yet, but it means EDD has processed enough of the claim to calculate what you'd receive.

0 coins

Got it. So I still wait for the actual eligibility decision. At least something happened.

0 coins

approved. congrats. second kids always make you worry twice as much about paperwork.

0 coins

Just got the approval notice this afternoon. Week two of wondering for nothing. Thanks everyone, this thread saved me a lot of anxiety.

0 coins

Congrats on the new baby and the approval.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure