Back to California Paid Family Leave

Yara Campbell

Applied for PFL before SDI after birth, can I still apply for SDI?

So I made a mistake and I'm not sure if it's fixable. I had my daughter six weeks ago and was so focused on getting the bonding claim going that I filed PFL first without realizing I should have filed for SDI disability for my own recovery from the birth first. My OB said I needed at least six weeks off for recovery and I never even thought about the pregnancy disability claim. Now I've been getting PFL payments and I'm wondering if I missed my chance to file the SDI disability claim for the pregnancy part, or if I can go back and do that even though the PFL is already running. Has anyone done this out of order and figured it out?

Two payments had already posted when I realized my own bonding weeks were ticking down faster than I expected, so I used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to phone EDD and ask an agent where my payment history stood. She pulled up my claim and read off the exact date each payment was issued. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM. She also confirmed the week the most recent payment covered, which was what I actually needed to know before making any decisions about going back part time.

0 coins

Oh I want to try that for my own situation. My bonding claim just hit day nine and I haven't gotten a Notice of Computation yet and I want to ask EDD what's holding it up. What do you have ready when you get through?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number and your receipt number from when you filed. The agent I spoke with asked for both right away and had everything pulled up in about a minute after that.

0 coins

Got it, I'll grab the receipt number from my confirmation email before I try. Thanks for the tip on what to have ready.

0 coins

You really do want to ask EDD directly about amending the order of your claims, because the rules around a birth mother's disability claim versus the bonding claim are specific. The standard path is to file a disability claim for the pregnancy recovery first, then move to PFL bonding after. If you filed them in the wrong order EDD may need to sort out how the weeks are counted, and that's worth a phone call rather than guessing.

0 coins

Is there still a chance to fix it at this point though? Six weeks have already gone by on PFL.

0 coins

Honestly I'm not certain what EDD can do after payments have already gone out. That's exactly why I'd phone them rather than try to work it out on your own. The SDI line for PFL is 1-877-238-4373.

0 coins

I'm not sure but I think there might be a deadline issue here too, like the 41 days thing applies to disability claims as well? I could be wrong though.

0 coins

Worth pinning down what program covers what, because they're separate. Your own physical recovery from childbirth falls under Disability Insurance, which is a different EDD program from PFL. PFL is specifically for bonding with the new baby. The standard sequence EDD describes is DI first for the pregnancy disability period, then PFL bonding after DI ends.

0 coins

So they really are two completely separate claims with separate payment amounts?

0 coins

Yes, completely separate. DI is for your own medical condition, PFL is for bonding. Your weekly amounts might even differ between the two since they're calculated the same way but are independent claims.

0 coins

This is the part that tripped me up when my wife had our son. I kept thinking PFL was just the umbrella for everything after birth but the disability piece for the birth parent is its own thing entirely.

0 coins

You're not the first person to do this backward. Call EDD. Explain what happened. They've seen it before.

0 coins

This. Don't overthink it, just call.

0 coins

Sure, just call, except you'll spend two hours on hold and get disconnected. Easy advice to give.

0 coins

The 41-day filing window is the piece I'd focus on. For a disability claim tied to your pregnancy recovery, that clock started when your leave began, which sounds like it was right around the birth six weeks ago. Six weeks is 42 days, so you may already be right at or past that window for the disability claim. EDD is the one to tell you whether anything can be done.

0 coins

42 days. That's what I was afraid of. So I might have already missed it completely?

0 coins

You might be at the edge or just past it. EDD has the actual date your leave started on file. Only they can say whether the disability claim is still possible.

0 coins

The 41-day thing really stresses me out for my own claim. I keep checking SDI Online to make sure everything went through.

0 coins

The 41 days is counted from the first day of leave, not from when you filed the other claim. So the question is exactly when your recovery leave started relative to today's date.

0 coins

Weeks left on my bonding claim were the thing I had to get straight, so I called EDD through Claimyr to ask an agent how many of the eight weeks I still had available in my 12-month window. She told me I had used five weeks so far and had three remaining, which was more than I thought because I'd taken a few days intermittently here and there.

0 coins

The intermittent days piece matches exactly what confused me on my own claim. After the agent confirmed which weeks had been paid and when the next payment was due, I went back into SDI Online and printed my payment history so I had a paper record of it. Keeping that helped a lot when I went back part time.

0 coins

How many times did you try the EDD line before that?

0 coins

More mornings than I want to admit. The line would just cut me off after the menu. Having a record from the agent made all the difference though.

0 coins

The intermittent reporting piece was what I asked about next once she answered the weeks question. She walked me through what I needed to report and when.

0 coins

my sister did this same thing after her second kid, filed pfl first by accident. she just called edd and explained it and they figured it out. dont remember exactly what happened but she wasnt left with nothing

0 coins

That's actually reassuring. Did she end up getting both or just one?

0 coins

i honestly dont know the details she just said it worked out. you should definitely still call though

0 coins

EDD has a specific form for birth mothers moving from disability to bonding. It's called the DE 2501FP. If you can still file the disability claim, you'd eventually get that form. If not, well, you're already on PFL so at least something is running.

0 coins

To add to that, the DE 2501FP is what EDD sends a birth mother at the end of her disability period so she can transition to PFL bonding without needing extra documents. If the DI claim isn't filed first, that path doesn't happen automatically.

0 coins

So the DE 2501FP only comes if I had a disability claim first? I didn't get that form at all, which I guess makes sense now.

0 coins

Right. You went straight to PFL so there was no disability claim to transition from.

0 coins

Wait so PFL doesn't cover the mom's recovery at all? I thought that was what it was for. Learning something new here, anyway.

0 coins

PFL is purely for bonding with the baby, not the birth parent's physical recovery. The recovery from childbirth is what DI covers as a pregnancy disability. They're two different programs that often run back to back for a birth mother.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense now. We just had our second and I think my wife handled both but I honestly let her deal with EDD and just signed whatever she handed me.

0 coins

A lot of partners don't realize the two exist separately. It only becomes obvious when something goes wrong with the order.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute mess. I've tried before 8, right at 8, midday, nothing works. You either get the busy signal loop or it hangs up on you after five minutes of menus. Good luck getting anyone on the line to sort this out.

0 coins

This is the real issue. The answer might be simple but getting to someone to tell you is a whole other battle.

0 coins

Mornings I've tried that line myself have gone the same way. That's part of why I looked for another option when my own payments question came up.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying in the morning and nothing. I get the message saying they can't take my call and then it ends. It's beyond frustrating.

0 coins

Ask EDD whether your recovery period still qualifies and what documentation your doctor needs to provide. Your OB likely documented the medical necessity for your six weeks off, which is what a disability claim requires.

0 coins

My OB definitely has records of everything, that part I'm not worried about. It's more the timing and whether EDD will even look at a disability claim at this point.

0 coins

That's exactly the question for EDD, not something anyone here can answer for your specific dates. Worth asking.

0 coins

PFL is not disability. People mix these up constantly and then end up in this exact situation.

0 coins

In fairness EDD could make it a lot clearer when you're filing. The SDI Online flow doesn't exactly wave a flag saying hey birth mom, you need to file DI first.

0 coins

True. But the information is on EDD's site if you look.

0 coins

It is on the site but you have to know to look for it. If you just google PFL for new moms you can easily miss the DI step.

0 coins

Has anyone actually gotten EDD to allow a disability claim after PFL payments already went out? I want to know if there's a real path here or if it's just hopeful thinking.

0 coins

It's not something I've seen a clear answer to in EDD's published materials. The standard guidance says to file DI first. What happens when it's reversed and payments have already issued is something only EDD can determine on a case by case basis.

0 coins

This is my exact fear. That it's just not possible at this point.

0 coins

An EDD agent told me on my own call that the claim history is all there and visible to them. Whatever happened before is on file. Whether they can adjust anything from there is their call, not ours.

0 coins

Days after my bonding start date mattered a lot on my own claim, so I ended up reaching an agent through Claimyr to ask whether my start date was recorded correctly and whether I was still inside the 41-day window. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the start date EDD had on file, which matched what I'd entered, and said I was well within the window still.

0 coins

I've tried that EDD line a bunch of times over the past few weeks and it's always the same, either busy or it just ends the call. How do you even get through? I'm honestly skeptical anything gets through that line.

0 coins

I get the skepticism, I really do, because I tried on my own for days and got nowhere. With Claimyr I ended up talking to an actual EDD agent. That's all I know, it happened.

0 coins

EDD confirmed the DE 2500E on my claim through that same thing. Agent told me it had been issued and what date, so I knew to watch for it. Really cleared up the confusion I had about timing.

0 coins

Okay if the agent actually worked for EDD that's what I needed to hear. I'd want to ask about my own claim's start date and whether my proof of relationship got matched up.

0 coins

The waiting period piece confused me when I first filed because someone told me PFL has a seven-day wait just like disability. I lost a few days worrying about that before I found out it's not true for PFL.

0 coins

No waiting period on PFL at all. EDD is clear about that. The seven unpaid days is a DI thing only, not PFL.

0 coins

Wish I had known that before I convinced myself I was losing a week of payments.

0 coins

Wait, so PFL doesn't have the seven-day waiting period? I didn't even know DI had one, this whole thing is so confusing.

0 coins

Correct. PFL has no benefit waiting period. If you do eventually get the DI claim sorted out, the seven unpaid days at the start would apply to that claim, not to your PFL.

0 coins

Payment method on my bonding claim took a moment to figure out, so I reached an EDD agent through Claimyr to ask how the payment would come through. She confirmed it was set up for the debit card since I'd filed on paper, and told me where to watch for it.

0 coins

What even is Claimyr?

0 coins

It waits on hold with EDD so you don't have to, and your phone rings once a live agent picks up. That's really the whole thing.

0 coins

Huh okay. I'd want to ask about the debit card situation on my own claim too because I'm not sure if I set up direct deposit right when I filed online.

0 coins

Bottom line here is nobody on a forum can tell you if EDD will accept the disability claim now. You have to contact EDD. Everything else is just guessing.

0 coins

You're right. I think I've been posting here because I'm scared of what EDD will say. But I need to just contact them.

0 coins

That's the right call. Get on the phone or send a message through SDI Online. Either way you need an actual answer from EDD, not from a forum.

0 coins

been reading all this and honestly filing both claims right seems really hard if nobody tells you the order upfront

0 coins

That's the thing, you usually find out the right order after you've already done it wrong. EDD's website has it but it's not exactly front and center when you're a new parent just trying to file something.

0 coins

yeah makes sense. hope op gets it sorted

0 coins

Update from me: I sent a Request Claim Update through SDI Online explaining what happened, and I also left a message through Ask EDD. I'll try the phone line too. I don't know yet what EDD will say about whether a disability claim is still possible but at least I'm actually asking instead of just worrying. Thank you all.

0 coins

Good move reaching out through multiple channels. Whatever EDD tells you, make sure you read any notices they mail you carefully, because if they issue any determination you disagree with you'd want to appeal within 30 days.

0 coins

Glad you're reaching out. Getting the actual answer from EDD is the only way to know for sure.

0 coins

Ask EDD in writing is smart. You'll have a record of when you asked.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure