Back to California Paid Family Leave

Keisha Brown

Appeal SDI denied because paid family leave was filed first — what are my options?

So I'm in a mess and trying to figure out how to untangle it. My wife gave birth in August and her pregnancy disability claim was going fine, then she wrapped up and I figured it was my turn to take bonding leave. Filed my PFL bonding claim no problem. But here's where it got complicated — I also ended up with a minor surgery thing of my own in September and filed a disability claim after the PFL was already running. Got a denial notice saying basically that I can't get DI benefits for the same period because PFL was already in place for those days. I know they're two separate programs but apparently you can't collect both at the same time. Now I'm looking at this denial and wondering whether to appeal. Anyone dealt with this situation where SDI got denied because PFL came first? Do I have any grounds to appeal or is it basically a done deal?

Filing the appeal is still worth considering even so, and here is why I would not let the 30 days pass without at least submitting the form. The denial notice itself should have come with an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A. You have 30 days from that notice date to get it in, online or by mail. As for whether you have grounds, that really depends on whether the two claims overlapped on the same calendar days. EDD's own rule is that PFL and DI don't pay for the same days, so if your surgery recovery period was entirely separate from the bonding weeks, you may have an argument worth making. The claim's start date and how the 41-day window was recorded mattered a lot on mine. I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through to someone at EDD's PFL line and ask about the exact dates recorded for my bonding claim's start. The agent pulled up my file and read me the start date and confirmed which 41-day window EDD had on record, which was different from what I'd assumed. Claimyr's video on reaching a live person at EDD Paid Family Leave: https://youtu.be/DOLxZQb92wM

0 coins

The start date piece is exactly what I need to sort out on my own claim. My situation is a care claim, not bonding, and I'm not sure EDD recorded the right leave start date either. I'd try that service to ask an agent about the 41-day window and whether my start date is what they have on file. What should I have ready when I make that call?

0 coins

Have your receipt number and your Social Security number. Know the date you say your leave actually started and have any paperwork that backs that up, like your first absence from work. The agent will read you what the system shows and you can go from there.

0 coins

The overlapping days angle is exactly what I wasn't sure about. The surgery recovery was mid-September and I'd already been on bonding leave since late August, so they did overlap. That changes things I think.

0 coins

Yeah if the days genuinely overlapped then EDD's position is going to be hard to fight on appeal. But it's still worth submitting the DE 1000A before the 30 days are up just to preserve your options while you figure it out.

0 coins

EDD's rule on this is pretty clear and pretty brutal when you're on the wrong side of it. You get one at a time, PFL or DI, never both for the same day. If your surgery recovery days were the same days as your bonding claim days, the denial is going to hold. The appeal would only have a shot if there's a date dispute, like if EDD got the start or end date of one of the claims wrong.

0 coins

So my only real shot is if there's a date error on one of the claims. That's what I need to dig into then.

0 coins

Correct. Date errors happen more than people think. Worth pulling both claim records before you decide anything.

0 coins

Wait, I didn't know you couldn't have both running at the same time. I thought they were totally separate. So if someone is on PFL bonding and they get hurt, they just get nothing for the injury days? That seems really unfair honestly. Does it matter which one was filed first?

0 coins

The one filed first doesn't determine who wins. The rule is just that EDD won't pay both for the same calendar day, whichever it is. So if the PFL bonding claim covers day X, a DI claim for that same day X will be denied.

0 coins

Okay so the timing of filing doesn't fix it. The only way out would be if the claims covered different days entirely?

0 coins

That's right. EDD's FAQ page says explicitly that PFL is not paid for the same days as DI or unemployment. The only scenario where both could ever coexist in a 12-month period is if they cover completely non-overlapping calendar dates.

0 coins

Have you pulled up SDI Online to actually look at the date ranges EDD has recorded for both claims? Sometimes what EDD has on file doesn't match what you submitted, and that discrepancy could actually support an appeal.

0 coins

I can see my PFL claim in SDI Online but the DI denial notice doesn't show the exact date range they used. The appeal form seems like it's asking me to explain my grounds and I'm not sure what to write.

0 coins

For the appeal, describe the dates factually. If you believe the claims covered different periods, lay that out clearly. If you're not sure what dates EDD has on file for the DI claim, that's actually a reason to contact them before you submit.

0 coins

They wont pick up tho. ive tried that line so many times. just rings forever.

0 coins

Submit the DE 1000A before anything else. Even if you end up not pursuing the appeal, you want that door open. Missing the 30-day window shuts you out completely.

0 coins

Already printed it. Just trying to figure out what to actually write in the grounds section before I send it.

0 coins

Write that you dispute the determination that the claims covered the same dates. Keep it short. You don't have to win the argument on the form, you just have to get it in.

0 coins

My PFL claim was set to direct deposit, and I wasn't sure if the payment method would cause issues with how EDD tracked which claim was active on which day. I kept trying to get someone on the phone about it. Eventually I went through Claimyr to reach a live person at EDD's PFL line, and the agent told me the payment method on file was direct deposit and confirmed that setting didn't affect the claim dates at all. That part at least I could stop worrying about.

0 coins

Payment method is something I checked on my own claim too. I'd used Claimyr for that exact thing when my DE 2580GF didn't seem to be updating my intermittent days correctly. The agent confirmed which days EDD had recorded as reported and which were still pending. After that I re-submitted the form for the days that hadn't posted.

0 coins

ive been trying that line since monday and cant get through at all. what days did you two try?

0 coins

I tried a few different mornings. After a while I stopped trying to guess the right time and just used the service to handle the wait.

0 coins

Good to know the payment method is a separate thing from claim dates. That's one fewer thing to worry about while I sort the appeal out.

0 coins

My coworker went through something similar last year and she said the EDD hearing process for a PFL appeal is actually less intense than she expected. You submit the form, they schedule a review, and you can present your dates and documents. She didn't need a lawyer or anything.

0 coins

Is the appeal hearing done over the phone or do you have to go somewhere in person?

0 coins

The DE 1000A lets you request a phone hearing. EDD mails you the hearing date and instructions. You can present whatever records you have about your claim dates during that hearing.

0 coins

Yeah she did hers over the phone, had all her paperwork in front of her. Said being organized was the main thing that helped.

0 coins

You're not going to win if the days overlapped. The rule is the rule. Appeal if there's a genuine date dispute, but go in clear-eyed about what the actual facts are.

0 coins

I know. I'm not trying to argue that two claims should pay at once, I just genuinely don't know if EDD's dates on the DI claim are right. That's the actual question.

0 coins

Then the appeal is the right move. Dispute the specific dates. If EDD got it wrong, the hearing is where you correct it.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation on my PFL claim confused me so much at first because I thought it meant I was approved! Took me forever to figure out it was just showing my potential weekly amount, not an actual payment confirmation. Ended up calling EDD through Claimyr to ask an agent about it because I wasn't sure what to do next. The agent looked at my DE 429DF and told me the weekly benefit amount on the notice and explained that I'd still get the Electronic Benefit Payment Notification once a payment actually processed. Super helpful to have someone actually read me the numbers on my own file!

0 coins

What is Claimyr exactly? First time hearing that name.

0 coins

You give it your info and it handles waiting on EDD's line for you, so when a live agent picks up your phone rings and you're talking to them directly. That's basically it. The agent I spoke with was an actual EDD employee.

0 coins

Oh interesting. I need to ask EDD about my denial notice, the DE 2514, because it doesn't match the dates I have. I'd use that for that question.

0 coins

The Notice of Computation confusion is so real. I thought the same thing on my first claim. It's not an approval, just the calculation of what you'd get if approved.

0 coins

For what it's worth on the appeal form itself, attach anything that documents the actual start and end dates of your bonding leave separately from your surgery recovery. Work records, the date your wife's pregnancy disability claim ended, the date you formally started your bonding leave. The more concrete the better.

0 coins

I have emails from HR about my start date and end date for each leave. I didn't know if those would be useful but sounds like they're exactly what I need.

0 coins

HR emails are good. Anything that pins down a specific date with a paper trail. EDD can't argue with a dated email from your own employer confirming when your leave began.

0 coins

yeah keep everything. i lost an argument with EDD once because i had no documentation for dates. had to just take the loss.

0 coins

Did you get the DE 2514 for the DI denial? That notice should have the specific reason and the dates EDD used. Worth reading it line by line before you fill out the DE 1000A. When I had a question about my own receipt number after filing, I ended up talking to EDD through Claimyr and the agent confirmed the receipt number matched what was in the system and what dates were attached to it.

0 coins

I've tried calling EDD's PFL line I don't know how many times. Mornings, afternoons, tried different days of the week. Never once got a person. I'm pretty doubtful anything actually gets through that line anymore.

0 coins

I had the same experience for a while. Kept getting cut off after waiting. Trying through Claimyr was the difference. The agent was an actual EDD employee and answered the question about my receipt number right then.

0 coins

An agent also confirmed a Notice of Paid Family Leave Determination, the DE 2514, for a patient I was helping navigate a care claim. The agent read off what it said and that the appeal window was 30 days from the notice date. Clear and fast.

0 coins

Alright. Maybe I'll give it a try if I keep hitting a wall the regular way.

0 coins

if you filed pfl first and then tried to get disability for the same weeks thats just not how it works right. you cant get paid twice for being out at the same time

0 coins

That's the rule, yes. One program at a time. The appeal only matters if the dates are actually different and EDD got it wrong.

0 coins

ok so its not like pfl automatically kills a disability claim forever just for the same days

0 coins

The 30-day appeal window goes fast. I'd submit the DE 1000A first, even a simple one, then gather your documentation. You can add more detail once the hearing is scheduled.

0 coins

Filing it today actually. Decided to just get it in and argue the date issue at the hearing.

0 coins

Good call. Getting it in is the most important step right now.

0 coins

Just to put a finer point on the date question since it matters so much here: EDD records the leave start date based on what you entered when you filed. If you entered a start date on your DI claim that overlapped with your existing PFL bonding claim, that's what EDD goes on. If you believe the actual first day of your surgery recovery was before your PFL bonding leave started or after it ended, that's the specific argument to make in writing on the DE 1000A.

0 coins

My bonding leave started August 28th. Surgery was September 10th. I was still on bonding leave on September 10th, so they did overlap. I think I see the problem now.

0 coins

If that's accurate, the denial is going to be difficult to overturn. But the date you returned to work from bonding leave matters too. If bonding ended before September 10th, you'd have a different situation.

0 coins

Bonding ran through September 20th. So yeah, September 10th was inside it. I think the denial was correct and I just didn't understand the rule when I filed the DI claim.

0 coins

So if someone understood this rule ahead of time, would the smart move have been to pause or end the PFL bonding claim before filing the DI claim? Or is that even possible?

0 coins

Ending bonding leave early to start a DI claim is technically possible since the eight weeks don't have to be used all at once. But you'd want to contact EDD before making any changes to either claim, not after.

0 coins

So in theory you could have used some bonding weeks, stopped, gone on DI for the surgery, then restarted bonding after recovery, as long as all the bonding weeks get used within 12 months of the birth?

0 coins

That's consistent with how the rules read. PFL bonding can be broken up and must be used within 12 months of the birth. Whether EDD would have set that up cleanly in practice is worth asking them directly.

0 coins

EDD really should make this clearer when you file. nothing in the PFL application says hey by the way if you get sick you cant also file disability for those same days.

0 coins

EDD assumes you read the guide. The DE 2530 does actually say this, buried in there. But nobody reads the whole thing when they're sleep-deprived with a newborn.

0 coins

fair point. i definitely did not read the guide.

0 coins

Can you still use the remaining bonding weeks after your surgery is over? Like if the surgery recovery is done and you're physically able to bond again, do those weeks just pick up?

0 coins

Bonding weeks can be broken up and used in pieces, but they all have to fall within 12 months of the birth. If your child was born in August and you have weeks left, you'd need to use them before next August.

0 coins

And you'd just contact EDD to restart it? Or file a new claim?

0 coins

Someone who had eight weeks originally and took some, then stopped, would contact EDD to resume. Someone who went back to full-time work and wants the remaining weeks later would file a new DE 2501F.

0 coins

The whole thing is a good reminder to think carefully before filing multiple EDD claims in the same general time period. I know it's hard when life is happening all at once, but calling EDD before you file a second claim would have flagged this.

0 coins

easier said than done when you cant get anyone on that phone line

0 coins

So true. That line has never been easy.

0 coins

Appeal is in. Date dispute is settled. Next thing to decide is whether to withdraw the appeal or let it go to a hearing knowing the outcome is probably what it is.

0 coins

Yeah I'm leaning toward withdrawing it since I've now confirmed the dates genuinely overlapped. I appreciate everyone helping me work through this.

0 coins

Probably the right read. No sense in a hearing you've already answered.

0 coins

Withdrawing makes sense. And at least you know the rule now for any future claims.

0 coins

The one thing still worth checking before you close the book on this: confirm how many PFL bonding weeks you've actually used so far and how many remain in your 12-month window. If surgery recovery is over and you're eligible to bond again, those remaining weeks still have value.

0 coins

Good point. I think I have about two and a half weeks left before the 12-month window closes. Worth checking SDI Online to see exactly what's there.

0 coins

SDI Online shows your payment history and how much has been paid out. That'll give you the clearest picture of what's left.

0 coins

California Paid Family Leave AI

Expert Assistant
Secure