


Ask the community...
Pro tip: call right when they open in the morning. That's usually when you have the best chance of getting through. Good luck!
I had this exact same issue a few months ago! The wrong return-to-work date was causing delays with my benefits. What worked for me was documenting everything first - take screenshots of what's showing incorrectly, then try the online method that Andre mentioned above. If that doesn't work within a week, definitely try calling first thing in the morning like Mei suggested. The key is being persistent but polite when you finally get through to someone. They were able to fix mine during the call once I explained the situation clearly. Don't give up!
I've been following this thread and wanted to add something that helped me tremendously during my EDD appeal last year. Beyond all the great advice here about documentation and evidence, I'd strongly recommend practicing your testimony out loud beforehand. I actually recorded myself explaining my situation multiple times and listened back to identify where I was rambling, getting emotional, or unclear. During the actual hearing, I was much more composed and articulate because I'd rehearsed the key points. Also, if your former employer shows up to the hearing, don't get rattled if they say things that aren't true. Stay calm, stick to your facts, and address any lies in your rebuttal time. The ALJ will notice inconsistencies. One last tip - when you submit your evidence packet, include a brief cover letter summarizing your case and referencing each piece of evidence by number. It makes it easier for the judge to follow your argument. You've got this! The fact that you're being so thorough in preparing shows you're taking it seriously, which will come across during the hearing.
This is such helpful advice - I never thought about practicing my testimony out loud! I tend to get nervous and ramble when I'm anxious, so rehearsing beforehand is a brilliant idea. I'm going to start recording myself this week to work on being more concise and factual. The cover letter tip is also great - I was wondering how to organize all my evidence so the judge could easily follow my timeline. Having everything numbered and referenced will definitely make my case clearer. Thank you for the encouragement! Reading everyone's responses here has given me so much more confidence that I can actually win this appeal if I prepare properly.
I'm so sorry you're going through this - the stress of being wrongfully terminated AND having benefits denied is overwhelming. I went through a similar situation with a medical office that created a hostile work environment, then fired me when I raised concerns. Here's what I learned from my successful appeal: **Documentation is everything** - Your evidence sounds strong! Make sure to organize it chronologically and create a clear timeline showing: - Your positive work history before raising concerns - Specific incidents of hostile behavior - When you reported issues - The timing of your termination (retaliation pattern) **Key points for your hearing:** - Emphasize that you were fired for raising legitimate workplace concerns, not performance issues - If they can't provide documented warnings or specific misconduct incidents, that strengthens your case - The burden is on them to prove you committed "misconduct" (not just poor performance) **Practical tips:** - Submit ALL evidence before the hearing deadline - Practice explaining your situation clearly and factually - Don't get emotional during testimony - stick to documented facts - If your supportive coworker can testify live rather than just provide a written statement, that carries more weight The 28% statistic includes people who don't prepare well. With your documentation and preparation, your odds are much better. Keep certifying for benefits while appealing - you'll get backpay if you win! Stay strong - employers who create hostile environments and then lie to deny your benefits deserve to be challenged!
Hey Mila! First off, congrats on your new little one! 🎉 I totally get the stress about waiting for PFL approval - been there myself. My claim took about 8 days last year, which felt like forever when you're watching every penny. One thing that helped me stay sane was setting up a daily reminder to check the portal at the same time each day instead of obsessively refreshing it. Also, if you haven't already, make sure your husband saved all his confirmation numbers and screenshots from when he submitted everything - just in case you need them later. The good news is that once it's approved, the payments usually start pretty quickly and they backdate to when his leave started. Hang in there - you're doing great! 💪
Thank you so much for the congrats and the reassurance! 🥰 That's such a good tip about checking at the same time each day - I've definitely been guilty of refreshing the portal way too much lol. He did save all the confirmation numbers so we're good there. It's just so nerve-wracking being first-time parents and not knowing what to expect! Really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience.
I'm going through the exact same thing right now! My wife just had our baby 4 days ago and I filed my PFL claim the same day. Still showing "pending review" and I keep refreshing the portal like crazy. Reading everyone's experiences here is actually really reassuring - sounds like 1-2 weeks is totally normal even though it feels like an eternity when you're stressing about money. Thanks for posting this question, it's helping me feel less alone in the waiting game! Hope you get good news soon 🤞
Oh wow, we're literally in the same boat! It's so comforting to know someone else is going through the exact same timing and stress right now. Congrats on your new baby too! 🎉 This thread has definitely made me feel way less anxious about the wait - seems like everyone goes through this nail-biting period but it works out in the end. Fingers crossed we both get approved soon! Keep me posted on how yours goes!
Hey Joshua! Great questions - I went through something similar last year. Here's what I learned: 1. Your employer cannot deny your PFL benefits request since those go directly through EDD, not your employer. However, since you don't have FMLA protection yet, they're not required to hold your job or provide unpaid leave time. 2. If you're fired mid-leave, you should still receive your PFL benefits as long as you were eligible when you applied and continue to meet the ongoing requirements. The benefits are tied to your previous work history and contributions to SDI, not your current employment status. Just be prepared that without FMLA protection, there's no guarantee your job will be there when you're ready to return. You might want to have a frank conversation with your employer first - some are more flexible than legally required, especially in today's job market. Good luck with everything and congrats on the new baby! 🍼
hi @Isabella Silva thank you for the info. From my understanding PFL is a “wage loss” program and from a previous discussion with a representative I wouldn’t be able to receive benefits if I were to quit as they only replace hours that I’ve lost from work. Would this be the same case if they were to fire me mid-leave? Hope that makes sense.
That's a really important distinction @Joshua Villaruel! You're absolutely right to clarify this. From what I understand, if you're fired while on approved PFL, it could potentially affect your benefits since PFL is indeed designed to replace wages you're losing due to taking leave from work. If there's no job to return to, the logic is that you're not actually losing wages from leave anymore - you're unemployed for a different reason. However, this can get complicated depending on the timing and circumstances of the termination. I'd strongly recommend calling EDD directly to discuss this specific scenario before making any decisions. They can give you the most accurate information about how termination during PFL would affect your specific case. @Isabella Silva might have more insight on this too since she mentioned going through something similar!
James Maki
Update: I FINALLY got through this morning! Used a combination of the tips here - called at 8:01am exactly, used the Spanish option trick, and kept redialing after getting the busy message. Got through on my 12th try and spoke to a very helpful rep who found the issue. Apparently there was a mismatch between my baby's birthdate on two different forms which triggered a manual review. She fixed it right away and said my claim should be processed within 48 hours! Thank you all for the helpful suggestions!
0 coins
Scarlett Forster
•That's great news! Glad you got through and the rep was able to help. That birthdate mismatch is a common issue that can definitely cause delays. Congrats on getting it resolved!
0 coins
Jasmine Hancock
•Thanks for updating! Gives me hope lol. Gonna try your exact method tomorrow morning!
0 coins
Zainab Ismail
Wow, reading through all these experiences makes me realize I'm not alone in this struggle! I've been trying to reach EDD about my PFL claim for my newborn for over a week now. My claim has been stuck in "pending" status for almost 3 weeks and I'm getting really worried about when I'll receive my first payment. The tips about calling at 8:01am sharp and using the Spanish option sound promising - definitely going to try those tomorrow. It's honestly ridiculous that new parents have to become expert phone warriors just to get the benefits we're entitled to. Has anyone had success with the callback feature on the EDD website, or is that just as useless as everything else? Thanks to everyone sharing their strategies - it gives me hope that I'll eventually get through!
0 coins