


Ask the community...
It sounds like there's some confusion about your work schedule in your PFL claim. The denial reason suggests EDD thinks you're not regularly employed during the weekends you're trying to claim benefits for, despite you working full-time Monday-Friday and being on-call every other weekend. This is likely a misunderstanding about your employment situation. PFL benefits are designed for people who need to take time off from work they would otherwise be performing. Since you're regularly on-call every other weekend as part of your normal work schedule, you should be eligible to claim PFL for those periods. You definitely have grounds for appeal. For your appeal, gather documentation that clearly shows: - Your full work schedule including the on-call weekend rotation - Proof that being on-call is part of your regular employment (like your employment contract) - Documentation showing you're regularly paid for these on-call weekends When filing the appeal, specifically address the misunderstanding about your "normal contractual employment period" by explaining that your regular work includes these on-call weekends, and you're seeking PFL only for time you would otherwise be working. The EDD likely misinterpreted your work schedule, thinking you were trying to claim benefits for days you wouldn't normally be working. This is a relatively common misunderstanding with non-traditional schedules.
@Natasha Elloway This situation highlights a really important distinction that trips up a lot of people with PFL claims. I went through something similar when my son was born and I had a non-traditional work schedule. The bottom line is that PFL is wage replacement, not additional income. So you can only claim it for times when you re'actually losing wages that you would have otherwise earned. If your off "weekends" don t'involve any compensation no (on-call pay, no standby pay, nothing ,)then you re'not losing any wages during those periods - hence no PFL eligibility. However, if you do receive ANY form of compensation for your on-call weekends even (something small like $50 for being available ,)then those weekends could potentially qualify since you d'be giving up that income to care for your daughter. My advice would be to carefully review your pay stubs to see if there s'any compensation for your on-call periods, then potentially file a new claim specifically for those weekends rather than appealing the current denial. Make sure you have documentation from your employer clearly outlining your schedule and any associated pay. The EDD denial actually makes sense if you were claiming your truly off "weekends" - they were right that those fall outside your normal employment period.
@Natasha Elloway I think everyone here has given you excellent advice about the wage loss requirement. Just wanted to add that you might also want to check if your employer offers any kind of differential pay or compensation for weekend availability, even if you re'not actively called in. Some employers have policies where they pay a small amount just for being available during your scheduled on-call periods, which many employees don t'even realize they re'entitled to. It might be worth having a conversation with HR or payroll to clarify exactly what compensation if (any you) receive for your on-call weekends. If there is compensation you re'not aware of, that could open up eligibility for those specific weekends. But if your off weekends truly have zero compensation attached, then the others are right - there s'no wage loss to replace with PFL benefits. Either way, getting clear documentation from your employer about your schedule and any associated pay will be crucial for any future claims or appeals. Good luck navigating this - the system can be confusing especially with non-standard work schedules!
Hey Ana! I just wanted to chime in as another sleep-deprived mom who's been through the EDD maze. I'm so glad you found your remaining 3 weeks - that's such a relief! I had a similar situation last year where I thought I'd used all my PFL time but discovered I had 2 weeks left hiding in my claim history. One thing that really helped me was setting up text alerts through my EDD account so I'd get notifications about any claim updates or payment processing. It saved me from constantly checking the website wondering if my paperwork went through. Also, since you mentioned your husband's work stress, I'd definitely encourage you to look into whether he's eligible for his own PFL time - California allows both parents to take bonding leave, and even if his employer isn't super supportive, they legally can't deny him the right to use it. The coordination between both of your leaves could really help during this tough period. You're doing an amazing job juggling everything - new parenthood is no joke, especially when you're dealing with bureaucratic nightmares on top of it all!
Thank you so much Andre! Setting up text alerts is such a smart idea - I had no idea that was even an option in the EDD account. That would definitely save me from obsessively checking the website every day wondering about status updates. And you're absolutely right about my husband potentially being eligible for his own PFL time - I really need to have him look into that with his HR department. Even if his company isn't thrilled about it, knowing they can't legally deny him the right to use it gives me some confidence to encourage him to apply. With everything going on with his work stress and our childcare situation, having both of us able to take some strategic time off could make such a huge difference. Thank you for the encouragement about juggling everything - some days I really do feel like I'm drowning in all the logistics while trying to be a good mom, so hearing from other parents who've made it through this chaos successfully really helps keep me going!
Ana, congratulations on your little one and I'm so glad you were able to find your remaining PFL balance! As someone who also navigated the EDD system as a new parent, I completely understand the frustration with their phone system - it's absolutely terrible. Since you discovered you still have 3 weeks available, I wanted to share a tip that really helped me: consider keeping a simple calendar or planner specifically for tracking your PFL usage and deadlines. I marked down when I took each week, when I submitted forms, and set reminders for important dates like the one-year deadline. It helped me stay organized when my brain was total mush from sleep deprivation! Also, since you mentioned struggling with childcare and your husband's work stress, you might want to look into local parent groups or mom groups in your area - they're often great resources for childcare recommendations, emergency babysitting swaps, and just general support during those overwhelming early months. The fact that you can use those remaining weeks flexibly throughout the year is such a blessing - you'll figure out the perfect timing for your family's needs. You're doing great mama, even when it doesn't feel like it!
Update: We finally got through to EDD this morning! Turns out there was a document missing that they never notified us about. They needed my husband's ID verification even though he submitted all the other documents correctly. The rep was able to push it through and said payment should process within 48 hours. Thanks everyone for your help and suggestions!
Glad to hear you got it resolved! This is unfortunately common - the system doesn't always generate notifications for missing documents. For anyone else reading this thread in the future, it's always worth calling if your claim sits in pending status for more than 2-3 weeks with no explanation.
Congratulations on getting it resolved! This is such a perfect example of why the EDD system is so frustrating - they required additional ID verification but never sent any notification about it. I'm dealing with a similar situation right now with my own PFL claim (different reason though) and this gives me hope that calling persistently will eventually work. Did you try calling right at 8am like others suggested, or did you get through at a different time? Always trying to figure out the best strategy for actually reaching a human there!
I'm really sorry you're going through this - the 41-day deadline is one of those things that catches so many people off guard, especially when you're dealing with the chaos of a new baby and recovery. From reading through all the great advice here, it definitely sounds like you shouldn't give up yet! The "good cause" exception seems to be a real lifeline for situations exactly like yours. I'm pretty new to this whole PFL world myself, but it's clear from everyone's experiences that persistence really pays off. One thing that stood out to me from the responses is how important it seems to be to document absolutely everything - even things that might seem minor could end up being helpful for your appeal. And the fact that multiple people have mentioned success with medical recovery reasons gives me hope that there are legitimate paths forward even after missing that initial deadline. The calling strategy of trying right when they open seems to be the consistent advice from folks who've actually gotten through. It's frustrating that it has to be such a battle just to access benefits you've paid into, but at least there are people here who've navigated it successfully. Keep fighting for what you deserve - you've got a whole community rooting for you! 💪
@Taylor Chen Thank you so much for the encouragement! You re'absolutely right about documenting everything - I m'starting to realize that even things I thought were insignificant like (confusing emails from HR or unclear paperwork might) actually help my case. It s'really comforting to know that this community has people who ve'successfully navigated this nightmare system. I m'definitely going to try the early morning calling strategy tomorrow and start putting together all my documentation for the appeal. The support from everyone here is honestly keeping me sane during what feels like an impossible situation! 🙏
I'm new to this community but wanted to chime in because I'm currently going through something similar with my PFL claim. It's really encouraging to see so many people sharing their experiences and practical advice! What really stands out to me from reading all these responses is how common this 41-day deadline issue seems to be. It makes me wonder if there's something fundamentally broken about how this information gets communicated to new parents in the first place. I've been taking notes on everyone's suggestions - the early morning calling strategy, the DE 1000M appeal form, documenting everything for "good cause" - and it's giving me a roadmap for my own situation. The fact that medical recovery and employer miscommunication can potentially qualify as good cause is really helpful to know. @Yara Khoury, I hope you're able to get through to them and that your appeal goes well. Please keep us posted on what happens - I think your experience could help a lot of other people who find themselves in this same frustrating situation. The support in this thread is exactly what makes communities like this so valuable! 🤞
Brielle Johnson
One more thing - make sure your husband's employer didn't report him as having returned to work "permanently" after his first bonding period. Some HR departments make this mistake, and it can cause EDD to question the second claim. If possible, have him check with HR about how his first leave period was classified in their records.
0 coins
Jake Sinclair
•That's a great point I hadn't considered! I'll have him talk to HR tomorrow. Thank you!
0 coins
NeonNova
I just went through this exact situation in December! My husband took his second PFL bonding period after using only part of his 8 weeks initially. Here's what worked for us: 1) We applied exactly 30 days before his leave start date, 2) In the "additional information" section, I wrote "CONTINUATION OF BONDING LEAVE FOR SAME CHILD - PREVIOUS CLAIM #[his claim number]", 3) We kept all documentation from the first claim handy, and 4) He called EDD within 48 hours of submitting to confirm they could see it was a continuation claim. The whole process went smoothly and he got approved within 2 weeks. The key is being very explicit that it's a continuation and having the previous claim details ready!
0 coins
Amara Okafor
•This is incredibly helpful, thank you! I love how specific your steps are. Quick question - when you say he called within 48 hours to confirm, did he just ask them to verify the claim was in the system correctly? And did you have any issues with the online system recognizing it as a continuation versus trying to create a completely new claim?
0 coins
Dana Doyle
•This is so reassuring to hear about a recent success story! I'm definitely going to follow your exact steps. One thing I'm wondering - did your husband's employer need any special paperwork for the second leave period, or was the EDD approval sufficient? I want to make sure we don't run into any issues with his job protection during the second bonding period.
0 coins