SDI appeal denied because can't collect unemployment and disability at same time — now what?
Filing my appeal felt like the right move after EDD denied my disability claim, but I just got the decision back and they upheld the denial. The reason on the notice is that I was collecting unemployment benefits during the same weeks I was claiming disability. I honestly didn't realize you couldn't do both at the same time. I had filed for unemployment first because I didn't know what else to do after my employer let me go, and then my doctor told me I needed to stay out longer because of my back. I thought I was doing the right thing by switching to SDI mid-claim. The appeal decision says the overlapping weeks are the problem. Is there any path forward from here, or is this just done? Can I appeal again, or is there a second level? I'm really stressed about the money because I still can't work.
73 comments

GalaxyGuardian
Medical certification timing on my own claim was a mess, so I ended up phoning EDD directly after weeks of watching SDI Online sit there. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get through, and the agent pulled up my file and said the certification had come in but hadn't been matched to my claim yet because the receipt number my provider used was off by a digit. Got that corrected on the call. Video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. For your situation specifically, the agent told me that overlapping unemployment and disability weeks get flagged automatically, and the only real fix is to make sure the two claims don't cover the same days. If your disability started on a date after your last unemployment week ended, that's the argument to make in any further appeal.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Receipt number mismatch is exactly what happened to me too. My provider put the wrong one in and my claim sat there forever. Tried Claimyr as well and talked to an agent who confirmed the number on file didn't match what I'd filed with. Once I gave my provider the right receipt number and they resubmitted, things moved. Getting through to an actual person made all the difference because SDI Online just kept showing the same screen with no explanation.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
Four mornings in a row I tried that line. Busy signal, automated message, then it just hangs up. How did anyone actually get through? I've given up trying to reach them by phone.
0 coins
GalaxyGuardian
The line does exactly what you described, every single morning I tried before I found another way. After I got through, the agent was actually helpful and straightforward, which I wasn't expecting.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
30 days from the date on the appeal decision is the window to file a second-level appeal with the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board. If you missed that you can still try, but you'd need to explain in writing why the appeal was late and an administrative law judge would decide whether to accept it. The appeal form is DE 1000A, or a detailed letter if you can't locate the form, mailed to the address on the decision notice.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorThe notice I got is dated about three weeks ago so I'm still inside that window. Is the second appeal to the same place or somewhere different?
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
The same DE 1000A goes to the return address printed on the denial notice itself, and they route it from there. Write clearly that the disability start date was after the last unemployment week you claimed, if that's the case, with dates to back it up.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Wait, so there's actually a second appeal? I thought once EDD said no twice that was it. I'm dealing with something similar and I didn't know there was another step.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
The overlap rule is strict. You can't be collecting unemployment and disability for the same days, full stop. If even one week overlapped, they'll deny those weeks. The question is whether there were any disability weeks that didn't overlap with unemployment. Those might still be payable.
0 coins
AstroAce
That's the key part. If there were clean weeks after the unemployment ended, those could still be separate. Worth going back through the dates carefully.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorLooking at my records now. There might be a gap of a few days between when my last unemployment week ended and when I started claiming disability. Would even a partial week matter?
0 coins
Andre Laurent
Partial weeks can count. EDD looks at specific days, not just full weeks. Put the exact dates in your appeal explanation.
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
Worth understanding why this happens: unemployment requires you to be able and available to work every week you claim it, and disability is for weeks when you can't work at all. The two programs are designed to be mutually exclusive because they're based on opposite conditions. That's why EDD and the appeals board treat the overlap as disqualifying, not just as an administrative error.
0 coins
Jamal Brown
August 14th through September 3rd is the overlap period on my own situation from last year. I had the same conflict when I switched programs mid-month. EDD was clear that the disability payment only covered the days after unemployment ended, not the whole week.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
so they basically penalize you for not knowing the rules when youre already sick and stressed. makes no sense
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
The rule itself makes logical sense even if the situation is awful. The harder part is that EDD rarely explains it clearly before someone runs into the problem.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
Waiting period on my claim had me confused for weeks, couldn't figure out why the first seven days weren't showing any payment. Finally got through to an EDD agent and sorted it out. Used Claimyr to reach the disability line, and once I was talking to someone she walked me through exactly which days counted as my waiting period and which were my first payable days. Worth knowing your disability start date cold before any appeal, because that date is what everything else gets measured from.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Seven days with no payment honestly sounded wrong to me when I first read it. I tried calling every day for two weeks and never got through, so I genuinely thought my claim had a problem. How did you actually end up talking to someone? I've tried that line more mornings than I can count.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
The hold time was brutal every time I tried on my own. Claimyr handled the wait and rang me once an agent was on the line. Agent confirmed right away that my waiting period ran from my claim start date and that the first payable day was day eight. Knowing that settled a lot of anxiety about whether something was broken on my claim.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount was lower than I expected. Seeing the waiting period laid out helped me understand the full picture of what my claim would actually pay out over the whole period.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorKeeping my start date and all the overlapping week dates written out now. The timeline is what the second appeal is really going to come down to.
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
For your specific situation: gather the last unemployment payment record showing which week it covered, your SDI claim confirmation with the disability start date, and any doctor's notes showing when you became unable to work. Put those dates in a table in your appeal letter so the judge can see at a glance whether the periods overlap or not.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorPulling those records together this week. My SDI Online claim shows the start date and so does the original claim confirmation email. For the unemployment side, do I look in the UI Online account for the last week I certified?
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
UI Online will show each week you certified and was paid. Download or screenshot the last few weeks so you have the specific dates in hand.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
EDD's appeals information on edd.ca.gov describes the evidence standard. Contemporaneous records like a doctor's written restriction and your payment histories carry more weight than a summary you write after the fact.
0 coins
Ethan Wilson
MY CLAIM SAT IN LIMBO FOR A MONTH because nobody could explain why both my unemployment and disability weeks were showing denied. No one picks up, the automated line doesn't give real answers, and messages in SDI Online just bounce back generic responses. The system is not built for people who made an honest mistake about which program to file under first.
0 coins
AstroAce
Same frustration. EDD expects you to know all the rules upfront, but doesn't explain them when you file. You find out the hard way.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Maktoum
Sending you patience. The wait while everything is in limbo is genuinely exhausting.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
Something my coworker pointed out when I was going through a similar appeal situation: EDD can't fix overlapping weeks retroactively even if you explain the mistake. The only thing the appeal can do is get the non-overlapping weeks approved or get the disqualification lifted if the dates actually don't overlap once you look closely. Keep your expectations realistic going in, lol, but it's still worth filing.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorThat's honest and I appreciate it. If even a few weeks come through it helps a lot right now.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
Realistic is right. The appeals board isn't going to approve weeks where you were also collecting unemployment. The dates either overlap or they don't.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
Base period question on my claim turned into a whole thing. The quarter they used wasn't the one I expected, and the weekly amount on my Notice of Computation was lower than I calculated. Phoned EDD about it and used Claimyr to get a live agent. She told me which four quarters made up my base period and confirmed which one was my highest-paid quarter. Turned out a quarter I thought would count fell outside the lookback window.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Maktoum
What's Claimyr? Haven't heard of it before.
0 coins
Dmitry Petrov
You phone EDD through it, and when an agent at the disability office picks up, it rings you so you're on the line with them directly. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Fatima Al-Maktoum
The question I'd want answered is which weeks on my own claim are actually pending versus already decided. Might try it for that.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
49 days from the disability start date is when the medical certification deadline falls. That deadline is separate from the appeal window, which is 30 days from the notice date. People sometimes mix those up and miss the appeal window thinking they have more time.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
That 30-day clock on the notice date caught me completely off guard. I assumed it was 30 days from when I received it, not when it was issued. Those can be a few days apart.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
The date printed on the notice is what controls. If you're close to the edge, file first and add a detailed explanation after if needed.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Filing immediately with what you have and supplementing later is always safer than waiting to get everything perfect and missing the cutoff.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
cant believe nobody told you at the unemployment office that you cant also do sdi for the same weeks. like that should just be a warning they give you when you file for ui
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
UI and SDI are run by the same agency but different programs, and the intake process for each one doesn't cross-check the other at filing time. The conflict only surfaces when claims are reviewed.
0 coins
Mei Zhang
still feels like it shouldnt be the claimants job to know all that when theyre already dealing with being out of work and sick
0 coins
Jamal Brown
October 1st to October 8th was the exact gap I found when I audited my own claim dates. That one clean week was payable even after the overlap denial because it fell entirely after my last UI week. Getting specific about dates saved me from just accepting the whole denial.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorThis is exactly the kind of detail I need to look for. Going through my records day by day this weekend.
0 coins
Andre Laurent
That's the right move. A week-by-week review beats arguing the whole thing in general terms.
0 coins
Aisha Abdullah
Appeals stress me out so much. When I went through mine I kept second-guessing whether I'd included enough documentation. The judges do actually read what you submit, though. Mine came back with a very specific reference to a form I'd included, so it's not just disappearing into a void.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorGood to know the evidence actually gets looked at. I'll make sure the date documentation is as clear as possible.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
Putting a short cover note at the top that flags the key dates helps a reader see your argument quickly before they get into the attachments.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Patients switch programs when their condition changes and sometimes the timing creates overlap without anyone intending it. If your disability started on a date your doctor documented before you stopped claiming unemployment, that documentation is your strongest evidence.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorMy doctor wrote a work restriction letter around that time. Would that letter count as documentation of the start date even if it predates when I actually filed the SDI claim?
0 coins
StarSurfer
Yes. The date on the restriction note is what matters, not the filing date. Attach it.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Filing date and disability onset date are two separate things in EDD's system. The medical documentation date is what establishes onset.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
appeals take so long to come back. i know the 30-day window is strict but the waiting after you file is rough too
0 coins
Fatima Al-Maktoum
Filed mine and then just had to find a way to stop checking for the decision every day.
0 coins
Ava Martinez
yeah eventually you just have to let it sit there
0 coins
AstroAce
DE 1000A is the form you want. If you can't find it, a detailed letter with your name, claim number, and a clear statement that you're appealing mailed to the address on the denial notice works too.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorFound the DE 1000A on EDD's site. Printing it now and writing out the timeline of dates on a separate sheet to attach.
0 coins
AstroAce
Attach everything. Don't assume the judge has the original claim file in front of them.
0 coins
Amara Oluwaseyi
Knowing the specific weeks in dispute really does sharpen the whole appeal. Generic appeals that just say the denial was wrong tend to go nowhere. The ones that say 'these specific days did not overlap and here is why' have a real argument behind them.
0 coins
Zoe Kyriakidou
The burden in an administrative appeal is basically to show the record doesn't support the determination. Date evidence that contradicts the overlap finding is exactly the kind of record evidence that moves things.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorWriting the appeal around specific dates and attaching the documentation for each one. That's the direction I'm going.
0 coins
Sofia Gutierrez
EDD mail dates on notices are sometimes days before the notice actually arrives. If you're at 25 days since you got it in the mail, check the printed date on the notice immediately.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorChecked the printed date as soon as I read this. I have eight days left. Filing this week.
0 coins
Giovanni Rossi
Eight days is tight but workable. Getting the DE 1000A submitted first with even a brief explanation protects the deadline, then follow with the full documentation.
0 coins
Dylan Mitchell
EDD's SDI Online message center is slow for appeal-related questions but it creates a written record of what you asked and when. Worth sending a note there in addition to the mailed appeal, just to have the timestamp.
0 coins
CosmicCaptain
Keeping a parallel paper trail is smart. Mail the appeal, send a message in SDI Online, keep copies of everything with the dates you sent them.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorDoing both. And keeping copies of every single thing before it goes out.
0 coins
Carmen Diaz
Not sure if this is the right place to ask but does the fact that she was fired while on disability affect the appeal at all? My situation has that extra piece and I don't know if it changes what programs are available.
0 coins
StarSurfer
Disability covers days you can't work regardless of employment status. Unemployment is for when you're able and available to work again. Those two programs handle the job loss piece and the medical piece separately, and EDD decides each claim on its own facts. Asking EDD directly how your specific situation counts is the safest move.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
For the job protection side of things, the Civil Rights Department's CFRA information is the right starting point, not EDD. EDD handles the benefit side only.
0 coins
Liam McConnell
Routing your appeal correctly matters a lot. The return address on the denial notice is specific to the office that issued it, and mailing it to a general EDD address can delay things significantly.
0 coins
Mateo Rodriguez
AuthorDouble-checking the address on the actual denial notice, not the general EDD mailing address I had saved from before.
0 coins
Yuki Tanaka
Every notice has its own return address. Never use a previous one.
0 coins