Back to California Disability

Isabella Santos

EDD says not enough wages SDI but W-2 shows box 14 CASDI withholding

I'm kind of panicking right now and not sure if I'm reading something wrong. Filed my SDI claim about three weeks ago after my doctor cleared me to take medical leave for a back issue, and EDD came back saying I don't have enough wages to qualify. But I'm looking at my W-2 right now and box 14 shows CASDI withholding from my employer for the whole year. How can they say I didn't pay into it if the withholding is right there? I've been at this job for two years. Is there something I'm missing about how they calculate eligibility? I don't want to appeal if I'm actually wrong but I don't understand how the withholding and the wages could point in opposite directions like this.

The payment method on my own claim flagged something unexpected, so I ended up talking to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com). Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the direct deposit info had not been saved correctly in SDI Online, which is why my first payment went to the default card instead. That said, the base period question you're raising is worth understanding before you do anything else. EDD doesn't look at your most recent year of wages. They look at a specific 12-month window that ended several months before your claim started, so wages from the last several months before you filed often don't count at all. Your W-2 showing CASDI withheld just means you paid the SDI tax. The eligibility question is whether enough of those wages fall inside EDD's base period.

0 coins

Pardon my asking, but what exactly is Claimyr? I've been trying to reach someone at EDD about my own claim for days and I haven't gotten through once.

0 coins

The service waits on EDD's line in your place, and your phone rings once a live EDD agent picks up. That's the whole of it. What is it you need to ask them about?

0 coins

My Notice of Computation came in and the weekly amount looks lower than I expected given my salary. That's what I'd want to get answered.

0 coins

The base period thing completely threw me too when I went through this. I kept thinking my most recent paystubs would be what they used, but that's not how it works at all. EDD looks at a specific set of earlier quarters, not your current job or your most recent months. Can I ask, do you know roughly when your disability start date was and how long you'd been at this job before that?

0 coins

My disability start date was about five weeks ago and I've been at this job for just over two years. So I'm guessing the wages should be there, right?

0 coins

Two years should be plenty of history for the base period to cover. I'd really look into which quarters EDD is actually using before assuming the denial is correct.

0 coins

The base period pulls from four quarters, the five to eighteen months before the claim start date. EDD's site has a benefits calculator that can show you roughly which quarters they'd look at.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute joke. Spent four mornings this week hitting redial and got the busy signal every single time. The W-2 box 14 thing is a real issue though. That withholding proves you paid into SDI, it does not automatically prove your wages in the right quarter crossed the threshold they need.

0 coins

What's the threshold?

0 coins

You need at least 300 bucks in SDI-taxed wages in the base period. But the bigger issue is usually which months they count. Some people have big earnings right before filing and EDD doesn't even see those.

0 coins

The $300 figure is correct per EDD. But the more common issue is wages falling outside the base period window, not being below $300. Worth figuring out which situation applies here before filing an appeal.

0 coins

My cousin went through almost this exact thing last year, her W-2 had CASDI in box 14 and EDD still said not enough wages. Turned out she'd switched jobs mid-year and the first few months at the new job were light on hours, so the base period quarters they pulled were the low-earning ones, not her full paychecks. She appealed and won but it took forever.

0 coins

This is making me feel a little better actually. I did have a stretch of reduced hours about a year and a half ago so maybe that's what they're seeing.

0 coins

That could definitely be it. The Notice of Computation should spell out which quarters they used. Have you gotten that form yet?

0 coins

I haven't gotten anything except the denial notice. Not sure if the Notice of Computation comes separately or at the same time.

0 coins

They are separate documents. The Notice of Computation shows your potential benefit amount based on wages. The denial notice, if that's what you received, should be a Notice of Determination, and it has an appeal form attached.

0 coins

Box 14 on a W-2 is your receipt for paying the SDI tax. EDD's eligibility check is a different question entirely. You could pay into SDI for years and still land in the wrong quarter window when you file.

0 coins

Exactly. Paying in doesn't equal qualifying. People mix these up constantly.

0 coins

I genuinely did not know they were two separate things. The denial letter didn't explain it this clearly.

0 coins

The medical certification on my injury claim hadn't been matched to my file when I checked SDI Online, so I used Claimyr to get through to an EDD agent. The agent confirmed they had received my doctor's Part B but it was sitting unmatched because the receipt number my provider used was off by one digit. They flagged it for correction. On your situation, the Notice of Determination you got should list the specific base period quarters EDD evaluated. That's the starting point before deciding whether to appeal.

0 coins

I've used Claimyr on my own claim too, good way to actually reach someone. The agent I spoke to told me my Notice of Determination had been issued and mailed out the day before I called. I didn't even know it had gone out yet. Got it in the mail two days later and then had the full 30 days to decide whether to appeal.

0 coins

What did you do after that? Did you end up appealing?

0 coins

Didn't have to. The notice said approved, so I just waited for the payment.

0 coins

Important point for the original poster: the appeal window is 30 days from the date on that notice, not from when you receive it. So don't sit on it once it arrives.

0 coins

Paystubs from the base period quarters might actually matter here more than the W-2. If your employer pulled SDI deductions from every paycheck, you'd see that in the paystub records, and the quarterly amounts would tell you whether you hit the wage floor in the quarters EDD evaluated. Worth pulling those if you can.

0 coins

Pulling old paystubs now. I save them in a folder so this should be manageable.

0 coins

Compare the CASDI deduction quarters to the ones listed on your Notice of Determination, if you have it. If you don't yet, EDD's site has a table that shows how base period quarters are assigned based on claim start date.

0 coins

my employer for a minute wasnt taking out casdi correctly and i didnt even notice til i tried to file, the deduction line just wasnt there on some checks. worth double checking that all your paystubs actually show the withholding

0 coins

That's a scary thought. All my paystubs do show it but I'll verify the specific quarters.

0 coins

yeah if even one quarter was missed youre kind of stuck, the tax getting pulled is what ties the wages to sdi eligibility

0 coins

The quarter they picked for my own claim caught me off guard, so I called through Claimyr to get a straight answer from an EDD agent. The agent told me they'd used my second quarter wages, which was my lowest quarter of the four, because that ended up being my highest-earning quarter once they ran the base period calculation. It didn't make sense to me until they walked me through which four quarters the base period actually covered. The highest quarter of wages inside that window is what sets the weekly benefit, not your overall earnings.

0 coins

Wait, did you have to tell them which quarter to look at, or did they just pull that up from the account?

0 coins

They pulled it right up. I just gave them my claim ID and they went through the base period quarters with me one by one.

0 coins

been trying that line since tuesday morning, haven't gotten through once.

0 coins

Three days on that line is a lot. Hope you get through soon.

0 coins

Sorry to jump in here, I'm dealing with something similar. My W-2 shows CASDI and EDD flagged my claim as potentially ineligible. I haven't gotten a formal denial yet, just a letter saying they're reviewing it. Do I wait or do I do something now? Anyway.

0 coins

Waiting is usually the right move while they review, but make sure you haven't received any forms that need a response. If they send you something asking for information, there's typically a deadline on it.

0 coins

Nothing in the mail yet besides that letter. I'll keep watching for it.

0 coins

Worth clarifying one thing that tripped me up early on: the waiting period at the start of a claim is seven days that simply don't get paid, no matter what. So I called EDD through Claimyr about whether my claim's waiting period had already been counted, because my payment seemed short. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the first seven days were the waiting period, that they're never paid, and that my first benefit week was day eight. The waiting period is not processing time, it's just the front end of every new claim that EDD doesn't pay.

0 coins

I'm going to be honest, I saw Claimyr mentioned in this thread and assumed it was a sponsored post or something a marketer dropped in.

0 coins

Ha, I thought the same thing at first! Then my own claim sat pending for two weeks and I tried everything. I ended up getting to an EDD agent and they confirmed my claim's start date was recorded correctly, which I'd been unsure about since I filed nine days after symptoms started. The agent said the start date I put on the form was what they had on file.

0 coins

Okay, that actually helps. I'll give it a shot. My denial letter came in and I need to understand whether the base period they used was even the right one before the 30-day appeal window runs out.

0 coins

The W-2 shows you paid into SDI. What EDD needs for eligibility is wages in the right time window. Those are two different checks. Pull the Notice of Determination, find the base period quarters listed, and compare them to your actual pay periods.

0 coins

Got the denial letter out again and I see it does mention the base period. I didn't read that section carefully enough the first time.

0 coins

Read that section carefully and check whether the quarters they listed actually match your highest-earning period. If they don't, that's your appeal argument.

0 coins

The appeal form should be attached to the denial notice. It's the DE 1000A. If that form got separated from the letter or you can't find it, you can write a detailed letter instead and mail it to the return address on the notice. Either way, 30 days from the date on the notice is the window.

0 coins

Found the form. It was on the back page and I'd set it aside without looking at it.

0 coins

So glad you found it. Write out exactly which wages you think they should have counted and in which quarters.

0 coins

Don't overthink the appeal. Write down what you think they got wrong, attach your paystubs showing the CASDI deductions, and send it in. They review it.

0 coins

That's actually a helpful way to think about it. I keep imagining it has to be this complicated legal document.

0 coins

It doesn't. Just be specific about the dates and the quarters.

0 coins

My sister went through an SDI denial appeal and she said being really specific about dates on the DE 1000A made a difference. Like which pay periods, which quarters, the exact amounts. Vague appeals apparently don't go as well.

0 coins

Specific dates and amounts are the right approach. Attach anything that shows the CASDI deduction per paycheck in the quarters at issue.

0 coins

She kept all her paystubs in a folder, which really helped when she had to put the appeal together quickly.

0 coins

Good luck with the appeal. The base period confusion trips a lot of people up.

0 coins

Thank you. Starting to feel like I actually have a path forward with this.

0 coins

Can you still appeal if you're not sure the denial was actually wrong? Like if you want to appeal just to have EDD explain the calculation better?

0 coins

You can appeal and ask EDD to clarify the base period calculation as part of the process. The appeal is also a chance to submit additional wage documentation if any was missing from the initial review.

0 coins

Using SDI Online's Request Claim Update option is another way to ask for clarification without filing a formal appeal. Both paths are open.

0 coins

Didn't know about the Request Claim Update option. That might be the first step honestly, before going full appeal.

0 coins

if you file the appeal and then get more info that changes your mind can you withdraw it or does it just keep going

0 coins

You can withdraw an appeal. Contact EDD in writing if you decide not to proceed.

0 coins

ok good to know, was worried youd be locked in once you filed

0 coins

CASDI on the W-2 is consistent, no gaps. The question is strictly about the base period quarters. If the wages in those four quarters add up to enough and EDD didn't count them right, that's appealable.

0 coins

Checked my paystubs against the quarters on the denial. The quarters they listed are definitely lower-earning than the ones I had hoped they'd use. Not sure yet if I had a choice over that or if it's just locked in by when I filed.

0 coins

The base period is determined by the claim's start date. EDD assigns the quarters based on that date, not based on which quarters would be most favorable to you. If those are your wages in those quarters, that's what the appeal would work with.

0 coins

File the appeal if the wages they listed are wrong or incomplete. If the wages are right but just low, the math is the math.

0 coins

This thread helped me understand the base period so much better. I'd been confusing the CASDI withholding with actual wage eligibility this whole time. Filing my own claim next week and now I know what to actually look for on the Notice of Computation.

0 coins

Before you file, the benefits calculator on EDD's site can give you a rough idea of which quarters will be in your base period and what your weekly amount might look like.

0 coins

Going to look that up tonight, thank you.

0 coins

Update from the original poster: I went through my paystubs carefully and the quarters EDD used are correct, but two of those quarters had reduced hours because I was covering a part-time schedule. My wages in those quarters were genuinely lower. I'm going to file the appeal anyway and submit the full paystub records to make sure nothing was missed in their calculation. The form is straightforward once you actually read it.

0 coins

Submit everything. Even if the math holds, let them see the full picture.

0 coins

Reduced hours in the base period is actually a recognized situation. The appeal gives you a chance to make sure all wages in those quarters were counted, in case any paychecks were missed.

0 coins

Good approach. Document what you're submitting and keep copies.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure