Back to California Disability

Alexander Evans

Does reduce paid family leave benefit if employer pays wages during leave?

So I'm about to go on bonding leave after my maternity disability ends and my HR said the company will keep paying me partial wages during that time. I thought that was great news but then someone in a Facebook group said that employer payments might reduce your PFL benefit dollar for dollar and now I'm panicking. I already filed for Paid Family Leave through SDI Online and the claim is pending. Does anyone know if getting paid by your employer at the same time actually cuts into what EDD pays you? I don't want to end up getting less than I expected and not be able to cover my bills. I've never gone through any of this before and I'm totally lost on how the two interact.

Many people assume employer wage payments automatically cancel out the PFL benefit, and I held that belief myself until I actually read through EDD's materials when I took bonding leave a couple of years ago. EDD says to report any wages you receive, and from what I've read the benefit may be reduced if your combined wages and PFL would exceed your normal weekly pay. The honest answer is that EDD makes the calculation on each individual claim, so the best thing to do is report what your employer pays accurately and let EDD do the math.

0 coins

Thank you, that's actually reassuring to hear. So I just report the wages honestly and EDD figures out the reduction, if any? I was afraid I'd have to do the math myself and get it wrong.

0 coins

Report everything accurately and on time. Overpayment notices are a headache you don't want later.

0 coins

HR told me the same thing before my leave and I spent way too long trying to get a straight answer out of EDD. The phone line is an absolute wall, I tried for three days straight and either got a busy signal or ended up at a recording that dropped the call. Eventually I sent a message through the Ask EDD form and got a reply in about five days. Not ideal but it worked.

0 coins

Three days on that line sounds about right. I gave up after the second morning.

0 coins

Did the Ask EDD reply actually answer your specific question or was it just a form response? I'm not sure I trust a generic reply for something this important.

0 coins

It was pretty specific, they confirmed I needed to report the wages each certification period. It wasn't a canned answer.

0 coins

DE 2593 landed in my mailbox right in the middle of my bonding leave and I had no idea what to do with it. I tried the disability line a few times but couldn't get through, so I ended up using Claimyr (claimyr.com) to reach an actual EDD agent. Video on getting a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my claim and told me my DE 2593 had been received and my automatic payment was continuing. Huge relief because I was afraid missing that form would stop everything.

0 coins

Wait what is Claimyr exactly? I've been on that phone line forever and nothing gets through, I need to sort out my own claim and anyway.

0 coins

You hand it your situation and it stays on the line with EDD until a live person picks up, then your phone rings and you're talking to the agent. That's the whole thing.

0 coins

Oh that's actually simple. I'd want to ask EDD whether my employer wage payments get reported on the PFL side or the DI side since my transition was a little confusing.

0 coins

The rule as EDD writes it is that PFL doesn't have a waiting period, which catches a lot of people off guard if they went through the seven-day wait on their DI pregnancy claim right before this. PFL starts from day one of bonding, so there's no gap to worry about there.

0 coins

I thought the waiting period carried over somehow from my disability claim. Good to know PFL has its own start and there's no extra wait.

0 coins

Does the PFL claim have to be filed separately even if the DI pregnancy claim is still open or just ending? I assumed EDD transitioned it automatically.

0 coins

Separate filing. You file the PFL bonding claim yourself in SDI Online. EDD doesn't do it for you when the DI claim closes.

0 coins

Filing it now. I didn't realize I had to do that myself at all.

0 coins

Report what your employer pays every period without fail. I've seen guys at my site get overpayment letters because they forgot to report a week of supplemental pay. That notice is not fun to deal with.

0 coins

Overpayment notices are brutal. What did they end up doing?

0 coins

Appealed it. Took a while but they got most of it sorted. Keep every pay stub from your employer during the leave period, that's the main thing.

0 coins

my employer paid me full wages for two weeks after my baby and i never reported it and nothing happened but i really dont know if i got lucky or if it just wasnt counted somehow

0 coins

Reporting is required regardless of what happened on any individual claim. EDD can catch discrepancies later and issue an overpayment notice, so I wouldn't count on it staying quiet.

0 coins

yeah fair enough i probably just got lucky dont do what i did

0 coins

Paycheck from my employer kept coming for the first three weeks of my PFL claim and I reported every dollar. EDD reduced my benefit for those weeks and paid the difference to bring me up to my normal weekly amount. So it worked out fine, I just got it in two pieces.

0 coins

That's really helpful to see how it played out. So the total income stayed roughly the same, just split between EDD and your employer?

0 coins

Exactly, it wasn't a penalty, just a coordination thing. Total came out close to my usual weekly pay.

0 coins

That matches how I understood it. EDD calculates the benefit to avoid a windfall over your normal wages.

0 coins

What happens if my employer pays me and I report it but the amount fluctuates week to week? I'm on a variable schedule and the supplemental pay isn't the same every week.

0 coins

Report the actual amount for each week accurately. EDD accounts for each period separately, so fluctuating wages just mean the reduction varies week to week.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense, I was afraid one weird week would mess up the whole claim.

0 coins

Keep a log of each week's employer payment so you have records if any question comes up later.

0 coins

Spent two weeks trying to reach the disability line before I ever got a person. Finally got through, confirmed my payment history. The hold times are what they are.

0 coins

Two weeks is about right for a streak of bad luck on that line. Did you try different times of day?

0 coins

Tried mornings, tried after lunch. No pattern that helped. Eventually one morning it connected.

0 coins

Notice of Determination showed up saying my PFL claim was denied and I had no idea why. Spent a week hitting redial and getting nowhere, so I tried Claimyr and got an EDD agent on the line. The agent told me the denial was because EDD showed my base period wages weren't sufficient, which I hadn't expected at all.

0 coins

Claimyr worked well for me too on a different question. Agent told me the DE 2525XX for my extension had been received and what date it was logged. Saved me from sending a duplicate.

0 coins

Can I ask what you did after the agent confirmed the extension was received? Did you have to do anything else while waiting?

0 coins

Just waited for EDD's decision. The agent said to watch for a notice in the mail.

0 coins

Couldn't have figured out the base period issue without actually talking to someone. The denial notice just said to appeal within 30 days with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

My HR told me to just take the full employer pay and not bother filing for PFL because the EDD process was complicated. I'm glad I didn't listen because filing was straightforward through SDI Online and EDD does handle the coordination!

0 coins

HR said the same thing to a coworker of mine, lol. EDD's process is actually pretty manageable if you read the instructions step by step.

0 coins

Exactly! HR meant well but it's worth going through the process because every dollar of your PFL benefit is there for you.

0 coins

For what it's worth, I tracked every payment side by side during my leave. Week of October 6th: employer paid me partial wages, EDD issued a PFL payment that covered the gap. Week of October 13th: employer paid the same partial amount, EDD did the same calculation. No surprises once I understood what was happening.

0 coins

Seeing it broken down by week is so helpful. I'm going to do the same kind of tracking.

0 coins

Keeping that kind of record also protects you if EDD later questions any week.

0 coins

Does any of this change if the employer pays you as a salary continuation rather than calling it wages?

0 coins

Report it accurately and let EDD classify it. The name the employer gives it matters less than the amount you actually received.

0 coins

Makes sense. I'll just report the dollar amount and not overthink the category.

0 coins

Clinically speaking from the leave side, the number of patients I've seen get overpayment notices because they assumed employer pay didn't need to be reported is not small. Report it every period, keep the stub. EDD sorts the math.

0 coins

yeah got a notice once and it was rough. report everything.

0 coins

The overpayment notice is so stressful when you're barely back on your feet. Accurate reporting from day one avoids all that.

0 coins

My PFL claim showed pending for about two weeks after I filed even though my DI pregnancy claim had already closed. Is that typical or should I be following up?

0 coins

Two weeks pending isn't unusual. EDD says to expect contact about the claim's status usually within 14 days after a completed claim is in. If it's past that point, using Request Claim Update in SDI Online is the right move.

0 coins

Haven't tried the Request Claim Update option yet. I'll do that today.

0 coins

In SDI Online you pick the claim ID, then Request Claim Update, choose the type and write your question. It's under the claim you filed, not the old DI one.

0 coins

HR at my job said any employer top-up over a certain percentage would completely eliminate the EDD benefit, like it goes to zero. Is that actually how it works or is she wrong?

0 coins

If your combined employer wages and PFL benefit would add up to more than your normal weekly wages, EDD adjusts the benefit down. But EDD makes that calculation per period. It doesn't just disappear outright unless your employer is paying you your full normal wages.

0 coins

Okay so HR had part of it right but oversimplified it. I was afraid it meant no EDD payment at all.

0 coins

HR gets this wrong surprisingly often. Trust the actual EDD calculation over what HR tells you.

0 coins

What if I forget to report one week and the next week I include the missed wages in that report? Does that cause a problem?

0 coins

Report each week's wages in the period they were paid. Combining missed weeks into a later period creates a discrepancy that can trigger a review.

0 coins

Got it, I need to be accurate per period, not play catch-up.

0 coins

Receipt number on my PFL claim wasn't matching what my provider had on file and I couldn't get anyone at EDD on the phone for days. Tried Claimyr and spoke to an agent who pulled the claim and confirmed the receipt number EDD had on record for me, so I was able to give the right one to the office. Got sorted from there.

0 coins

Sounds like a marketing thing to me. Free receipt number lookups aren't usually how these services work.

0 coins

Had the same suspicion when I first heard of it. Used it anyway when my payment method was showing incorrect and the agent confirmed which account EDD had on file for my direct deposit. It's just the phone wait handled for you.

0 coins

Fair enough. If the payment method thing can be fixed that way I might try it, my deposit information has been wrong for two weeks.

0 coins

Have your claim ID and your EDD account info ready when you go in. The agent needs to pull the claim.

0 coins

been on this thread ten minutes and learned more than i have in two weeks of googling. the waiting period thing confused me most, good its cleared up here.

0 coins

Same, I was mixing up PFL and DI rules constantly. This thread sorted a lot out for me.

0 coins

PFL having no waiting period is the one thing I wish I'd known before I filed.

0 coins

Payment on my PFL bonding claim hit almost two weeks after EDD issued it and I had no idea where it was. Used Claimyr and talked to an EDD agent who told me the payment was issued on the 14th to my Money Network card and gave me the specific date to look up the transaction.

0 coins

Can I ask, did the agent give you a transaction reference or just the date? I'm trying to figure out how to trace a payment that also seems delayed.

0 coins

Just the issue date. Told me to check the Money Network card balance directly because it can take a couple of days to post after EDD releases it.

0 coins

I have been trying that disability number off and on for about three weeks and have not gotten a person once. Good to know there's a way.

0 coins

does the employer have to know you filed for pfl or can you keep that private

0 coins

Whether your employer knows is a separate question from EDD's side. EDD processes the claim but your employer is involved if you're using a leave policy they offer. For job protection questions like CFRA, that goes to HR or the Civil Rights Department, not EDD.

0 coins

ok fair enough i was mixing up the payment side with the job protection side

0 coins

For anyone still confused about the PFL versus DI split, the clearest way I've heard it said is that DI covers you while you physically can't work, then PFL starts for bonding once you can. They're two separate claims and you file each one yourself in SDI Online.

0 coins

That framing finally made it click for me. DI for recovery, PFL for bonding, two separate filings.

0 coins

And the medical certification for the DI part comes from your doctor. The PFL bonding claim doesn't require the same medical piece, which is another thing people mix up.

0 coins

Yes! The bonding claim is much simpler to certify than the DI pregnancy side.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure