Back to California Disability

Ruby Garcia

Can they garnish all of my SDI benefits for overpayment during pregnancy leave?

So I got an overpayment notice from EDD last week and I'm honestly freaking out a little. I was on pregnancy disability leave earlier this year and apparently they're saying I was overpaid for some of the weeks I claimed. The notice has an amount on it and says I need to respond but I don't totally understand what my options are. What I really need to know is whether they can garnish all of my SDI benefits for overpayment during pregnancy leave or if there's some limit to how much they can take. I'm still dealing with postpartum recovery stuff and the last thing I need is to lose my entire payment. Has anyone dealt with an overpayment notice from a pregnancy disability claim? Did you appeal it or just pay it back? I don't even know where to start.

Payment method on my claim got tangled up after an overpayment notice arrived, so I ended up phoning EDD through Claimyr (claimyr.com) because the disability line just rang until it dropped. The agent pulled up my account and confirmed the Money Network card was still the active payment method and that the overpayment offset would show on future payments, not wipe them out entirely. Video on reaching a live person at EDD disability: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ

0 coins

Reads a bit like a sponsored thing to me, not going to lie. The disability line being impossible is real, but I'd want to know this actually got someone a person at EDD before passing it along.

0 coins

Felt the same way at first, honestly. Tried it myself after my Notice of Determination came and I had maybe two days to figure out my next step. Ended up speaking with an agent who told me the appeal window on my notice was 30 days from the date printed on it, not the date I received it, and that I'd want to mail the DE 1000A to the return address on the notice itself. That cleared up the whole thing for me.

0 coins

Okay, that's useful context. I'll give it a look, especially because I've redialed that line probably twenty times on different mornings and gotten nowhere.

0 coins

Overpayment notices during a pregnancy claim are genuinely scary, I had one too. The appeal form is the DE 1000A and it's attached to your Notice of Determination. You have 30 days from the date on the notice, so check that date right now because mailing time doesn't extend your window.

0 coins

Wait, so the 30 days runs from when they dated the notice, not when I got it in the mail? That changes my math completely.

0 coins

Yes, the date printed on the notice itself is what counts. So if it sat in transit for a few days you've already used those days.

0 coins

Is that the same form whether the overpayment is from a pregnancy disability claim or any other kind of SDI claim? I'm not sure if pregnancy leave is handled differently for appeals.

0 coins

Same appeal process regardless of whether it was a pregnancy claim or any other disability claim. The DE 1000A is the form either way.

0 coins

The notice you received is a Notice of Determination, the DE 2517. EDD's own information says you can appeal it within 30 days of the date it was issued, using the DE 1000A that comes with it. If you've misplaced the form, a detailed letter explaining why you disagree works too, mailed to the return address on the notice. Missing the 30 days doesn't end it, but a late appeal needs a reason for the delay and an administrative law judge reviews whether to allow it.

0 coins

Mine is definitely a DE 2517, yes. I still have the form. I didn't realize a letter works if the form is gone though, that's good to know just in case.

0 coins

What do you gather up before you send that appeal in? Pay stubs, the certification dates, something else?

0 coins

Pull together anything that shows what you actually reported during those weeks, your pay stubs if you worked any hours, records of when your medical certification covered, and the notice itself with its date. The more specific your explanation, the better.

0 coins

They can't just zero out your whole payment. An overpayment offset takes a portion of future benefits, not everything. But the exact amount depends on what EDD decides, and your Notice of Determination should spell out what they say you owe.

0 coins

That's actually the first reassuring thing I've heard. I was imagining them stopping payments entirely.

0 coins

Yeah it doesn't work that way. Appeal it if you think the amount is wrong though. Don't just sit on it.

0 coins

EDD's disability line on a weekday morning is a joke, three different times I've tried calling about my claim and gotten either a busy signal or a recording that just ends. No person, nothing. If you need an answer fast on that overpayment notice, the Request Claim Update tool inside SDI Online is at least something you can do without being put on hold forever.

0 coins

yeah the request claim update thing is real, i used it when my certification wasnt matching and got a message back in a few days. not fast but at least it goes somewhere

0 coins

Exactly. Better than redialing for the fifth morning in a row and hearing the same recording.

0 coins

Didn't know that option was in SDI Online. Going to try that.

0 coins

Medical certification timing was the thing that got me flagged for an overpayment on my own pregnancy claim. My provider submitted late and EDD said some weeks weren't covered. Ended up talking to an agent through Claimyr about it, and she confirmed EDD had received the certification but that it came in after the 49-day window for those particular weeks, which was why they'd been marked as overpaid.

0 coins

Can I ask whether the agent was able to tell you the exact date the certification was received on their end? I'm trying to figure out if there's a gap between when my provider submitted and when EDD actually logged it.

0 coins

She gave me the date it was recorded on the claim, yes. It was a few days after my provider said they sent it, so there was a gap. That's what I brought to my appeal, the submission confirmation from my provider's office versus the date EDD had.

0 coins

I've been trying to reach someone at EDD about a similar certification question for going on two weeks now, anyway. Good to know there's a way to actually get through.

0 coins

My pregnancy disability claim had a week flagged as overpaid because I went back to work part time and reported it, but EDD's calculation came out differently than I expected. The notice explained how they counted that partial week. If yours is a similar situation, your pay stubs from those weeks are the most important thing to have when you write your appeal explanation.

0 coins

Mine might be something like that actually. I did reduce my hours before my leave officially started. I'll dig out those stubs.

0 coins

Does EDD spell out the partial week calculation on the notice itself, or do you have to phone them to understand the numbers?

0 coins

The Notice of Determination explains what weeks are at issue and what amount they say you owe. The exact calculation breakdown sometimes requires asking EDD directly if the notice isn't clear enough.

0 coins

yeah i had a partial week thing too on my claim and the notice was honestly not super clear lol, ended up sending a Request Claim Update through SDI Online to ask for clarification

0 coins

Not sure if this is obvious but I want to ask, does filing the appeal stop them from collecting while the appeal is pending? Or does the offset on future payments keep going the whole time?

0 coins

That's worth asking EDD directly about your specific claim. The notice and EDD's own information doesn't spell out a suspension of collection during an appeal in what I've read, so I'd go to the source rather than guess.

0 coins

Okay. I'll send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online and ask that specifically.

0 coins

my provider submitted my part b late on my pregnancy claim and that was the whole problem. edd flagged weeks as overpaid because the certification didnt come in before the 49 day window. i thought my provider had it handled but they didnt submit until way after

0 coins

49 days from the disability start date is the cutoff for the medical certification? I didn't realize there was a hard deadline on that.

0 coins

Correct. The provider has to submit the medical certification within 49 days of when the disability began. If it comes in after that, those weeks can get flagged.

0 coins

yeah and mine came in like two weeks late. the office said they sent it but edd never got it in time. still dealing with that overpayment now

0 coins

Waiting period question was the reason I phoned EDD, and I ended up doing it through Claimyr because I'd spent three mornings trying the disability line before I got anything other than a recording. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the first seven days are always non-payable on a new DI claim, that it's not processing time, and that my first payable day was day eight. She also confirmed which weeks were actually pending versus already paid.

0 coins

I want to know if EDD counted my waiting period correctly given that my injury happened mid-pay-period. Going to try Claimyr for that. What should I have ready when I get on with the agent?

0 coins

Have your claim ID, the date your disability started, and your Notice of Computation in front of you. The agent can pull up the specific weeks on your claim and tell you exactly how they counted the period.

0 coins

seven days no matter what, no exceptions? even if the doctor certified right away?

0 coins

The waiting period is the first seven calendar days of every new disability claim. It doesn't change based on how quickly the certification comes in. The eighth day is the first day that can be paid.

0 coins

Pregnancy disability claims and overpayments can get complicated when PFL is in the picture too. Just making sure, the original question is about the SDI pregnancy disability part, not the bonding leave after, right? They're two separate claims and two separate programs.

0 coins

Yes, mine is the pregnancy disability side. I haven't even started a PFL bonding claim yet.

0 coins

Good to keep them separate in your head because the rules and claim numbers are different. Your overpayment is on the DI side only.

0 coins

This is a really common mix-up. PFL is a separate program and has its own claim process entirely.

0 coins

Which quarter of the base period EDD used to calculate my benefit amount was something I had to verify because my wages in one quarter were significantly higher and I wasn't sure if it was included. Ended up getting on the phone with EDD through Claimyr after two weeks of the line not connecting. The agent told me exactly which quarter showed as the highest-paid one on my claim and what the weekly benefit amount came out to on my Notice of Computation.

0 coins

The quarter question matches what I'm dealing with. I went through a similar check on my own claim using Claimyr, and once the agent confirmed which quarter EDD was using, I went back and checked my Notice of Computation against my actual pay records. The start date on my claim turned out to be one day off from what I'd entered, so I had to request a correction.

0 coins

Two weeks of trying the line and nothing. I believe that completely.

0 coins

The disability line is rough. I tried it across several mornings before I found another way to get through.

0 coins

The appeal window really is 30 days and it goes fast. My sister got an overpayment notice and waited thinking she had more time, and by the time she actually read the date on the notice she had like four days left. File the DE 1000A as soon as you can.

0 coins

Mine is dated about ten days ago so I still have time but not a lot. Sending the appeal this week.

0 coins

Good. Certified mail or at least some way to show it was sent on that date is worth doing.

0 coins

Your appeal explanation should be specific. Write out each week you're disputing, what you reported to EDD during that week, and why you believe the overpayment determination is wrong. Vague appeals are harder to win than ones that address each week directly.

0 coins

Should I attach copies of everything or just reference them in the letter?

0 coins

Attach copies. Don't make EDD go find them. Everything that supports your position goes with the DE 1000A.

0 coins

Agreed. I included copies of the medical certification dates and my pay stubs and referenced each one in the body of the appeal. Made it much easier to follow.

0 coins

EDD takes a portion of future benefits for an overpayment offset, they don't cut you off entirely. That said, if you don't respond to the notice at all they can escalate it. The notice tells you your options, so read the whole thing even the fine print on the back.

0 coins

I read the front but I hadn't flipped it over. Going to do that now.

0 coins

Always the back. EDD puts half the important stuff on the back of those notices.

0 coins

Pregnancy disability claims seem to get flagged more often for overpayments when the return-to-work date is fuzzy. If your claim covers the period right before your due date and EDD has a different date in their system than your provider certified, that mismatch is usually where the problem starts.

0 coins

My provider's certification ended a few days before I actually went back and I reported my return date, but I'm not totally sure EDD has the right end date in their system. That could be what's happening.

0 coins

That would do it. Pull up SDI Online and see what dates are showing on your claim, then compare to what your provider certified. If there's a gap there, that's your appeal argument.

0 coins

How do you see the specific dates on your claim in SDI Online? I can find the status but not the certification dates.

0 coins

Overpayment appeals take time but they do get reviewed. Document everything and send your DE 1000A with as much backup as you can. I've seen coworkers get overpayments reversed when they had solid records.

0 coins

What kind of turnaround are we talking for a decision? Weeks, months?

0 coins

I honestly don't know the timeline. EDD decides when it decides. The important thing is getting the appeal in on time.

0 coins

late to this but can they garnish future sdi payments if you're still on a pregnancy disability claim, or only after the claim closes

0 coins

The offset on future SDI payments can apply while a claim is still active. The notice will tell you how EDD intends to recover the amount. Appealing within 30 days is the way to dispute it before anything is withheld.

0 coins

ok so appeal first, understand what comes next after that

0 coins

Worth double-checking whether the weeks EDD flagged were actually within your certified period. Sometimes the overpayment is a data entry mismatch between what the provider submitted and what EDD entered, not an actual overpayment. Your provider's submission confirmation and the dates on your Notice of Computation are both worth pulling before you write the appeal.

0 coins

I didn't even think about a data entry error. My provider's office gave me a confirmation when they submitted. I'll compare it to what's in SDI Online.

0 coins

That kind of discrepancy between submission dates and what EDD shows on the claim is exactly what I found when I looked closely at my own notice. It was the basis of my whole appeal.

0 coins

The 49-day window for the medical certification is strict, that tripped up my wife's claim too. If the certification came in late for any of those flagged weeks that might be the whole answer right there, anyway.

0 coins

yeah 49 days sounds like a lot until you realize you're just out of surgery or just had a baby and have no idea what's happening with paperwork

0 coins

Exactly, nobody tells you about that deadline when you're in the hospital, anyway.

0 coins

Nobody told me either. I assumed the doctor's office handled everything automatically.

0 coins

For what it's worth, EDD does consider late appeals when you give a reason. If you end up missing the 30 days for some reason, write a detailed explanation of why. It goes to an administrative law judge who decides whether to let it through. Not ideal but it's not necessarily a dead end.

0 coins

I really hope I don't need that but it's good to know the door isn't completely closed if I miss it.

0 coins

Don't bank on it. File the appeal on time if at all possible.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure