Back to California Disability

ApolloJackson

Can employer paid parental leave cause SDI overpayment in California?

So I'm kind of panicking right now and hoping someone has been through this. I had my baby in September and filed my SDI claim for the pregnancy disability part. EDD approved it and I've been getting payments. But my HR just told me that my company's paid parental leave kicked in at the same time and that I was getting full pay from them on top of my SDI checks. Nobody told me this was going to overlap. Now HR is saying it might create a problem with EDD and I could owe money back. Has anyone dealt with this? I don't even know if employer paid parental leave can cause SDI overpayment or if HR is just being overly cautious. I haven't gotten any notice from EDD yet but I'm scared one is coming.

Your HR isn't wrong to flag it, though I'd want to understand your company's specific plan before worrying too much. Some employers coordinate their parental leave so it supplements SDI rather than stacking on top of it. The key question is whether your employer's plan was set up to pay you only the difference between your SDI benefit and your full salary. If they paid the full amount without offsetting SDI, that's where the overlap issue can come up. Check the plan documents HR gave you when you enrolled.

0 coins

I honestly don't remember getting any documents about how it coordinates with SDI. I'll ask HR to send me whatever they have in writing.

0 coins

The plan document is the right place to look. Some policies explicitly say they integrate with state disability and reduce their payment by whatever SDI sends. Others don't, and that's where people end up with more coming in than their regular salary.

0 coins

Wait, so if my employer just pays me my full salary and EDD also pays me, that could be a problem? I'm pregnant and about to file and nobody told me any of this.

0 coins

HR told you, so at least you know now. Don't wait around for a notice. Call EDD and tell them what happened. Better to get ahead of it than to get a bill and have fewer options.

0 coins

This. Don't sit on it. The sooner you let EDD know the better.

0 coins

You're right. I've been avoiding it because I'm scared but waiting is probably making it worse.

0 coins

DE 2593 came in the mail during my parental leave overlap situation and I wasn't sure if I should answer it the way I'd been doing. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) after getting nowhere on my own for days. Video on getting a live person on the disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ. The agent pulled up my account, confirmed the DE 2593 was there waiting for a response, and told me I had 20 days from the date on it to return it or benefits would stop. Got it in the mail that same afternoon.

0 coins

The 20-day part is what I always miss. Did they say anything about what happens if you're right at that edge?

0 coins

She said the 20 days run from the date printed on the form, not the date it arrives. So if it sat in the mailbox a few days, that time is already gone.

0 coins

been trying that disability line most mornings for two weeks now, anyway thanks for the heads up on the form date

0 coins

From what I understand, SDI is meant to replace a portion of your wages when you can't work. If your employer is also paying you, there's a reasonable question about whether you've actually lost wages at all. That said, EDD's rules and your employer's plan rules are two separate things. EDD doesn't automatically know what your employer is paying you unless it's reported.

0 coins

EDD has no idea what's coming from your employer unless you tell them or they find out some other way. That's kind of the whole problem people run into.

0 coins

To be clear though, that doesn't mean you don't have to report it. The obligation to report income during a claim is real. Saying EDD won't find out isn't the same as saying you don't owe it.

0 coins

Agreed, wasn't suggesting anyone hide it. Just explaining why it doesn't happen automatically.

0 coins

I'm so confused about the difference between SDI and paid parental leave from my job. Are they the same thing? My HR keeps calling it parental leave and EDD calls it disability. I don't want to file for the wrong one.

0 coins

They are completely different programs. SDI from EDD covers your disability before and after birth, the actual medical recovery time. Your employer's paid parental leave is a company benefit they offer separately. You file for SDI through myEDD at https://myedd.edd.ca.gov/ and your employer's leave through HR. They can run at the same time, which is exactly what this thread is about.

0 coins

That's what caught me off guard too. I thought my employer's leave was just a name for the EDD thing. Turns out they're completely separate.

0 coins

Yep, two totally different buckets. EDD doesn't even know about your employer's plan unless it comes up somehow.

0 coins

My coworker went through something similar last year. Her employer paid her full salary the whole time and she also got SDI. She only found out there was an issue when EDD sent an overpayment notice months later. It was a stressful few weeks dealing with that.

0 coins

What happened? Did she have to pay it all back?

0 coins

She appealed and explained the situation. I don't know exactly what happened after that but I think it got sorted out, she said she had to send in some documentation.

0 coins

This is what I'm afraid of getting. Did she file anything proactively or just wait for EDD to contact her?

0 coins

She waited. Looking back she wishes she'd called EDD first instead of letting it come to her as a notice.

0 coins

Not sure if this is relevant but I think there's a difference between your employer just paying you and your employer having an approved Voluntary Plan through EDD. I might be wrong about this but I think if your employer has one of those, it works differently. Someone please correct me if I'm off.

0 coins

You're pointing at something real. Voluntary Plans are employer-run plans that have to be approved by EDD and provide at least equal benefits. That's a whole separate setup from a company just having a parental leave policy. For this thread's situation, the question is about a standard employer parental leave benefit, not a Voluntary Plan. Worth asking HR which one applies.

0 coins

Okay that makes sense. I didn't want to confuse things but it seemed related.

0 coins

Good instinct to flag it. Best to ask HR directly whether the plan is a state-approved Voluntary Plan or just an employer benefit.

0 coins

EDD's phone line is an absolute nightmare. I've called at 8am, 11am, 2pm and every time it's either a busy signal or the recording just cuts off. If you need an answer on this overlap situation, good luck actually getting a human on the line.

0 coins

Same. I gave up after three mornings in a row.

0 coins

It's genuinely terrible. I had a simple question about my claim and it took forever to get anyone.

0 coins

my employer did the same thing to me, paid me the whole time and i had sdi going too. nobody from hr mentioned it and i didnt know i was supposed to report it. ended up getting a notice. not fun

0 coins

Did you have to pay the whole thing back? That's what I'm most scared of.

0 coins

most of it yeah. i appealed but didnt win. just paid it off in chunks

0 coins

Ouch. That's the risk of not sorting it out up front.

0 coins

Notice of Determination came in and mine had a denial in it, all over the overlap between my parental leave pay and SDI. I had no idea what to do. I ended up getting through to an EDD agent through Claimyr (claimyr.com) and asking about it. The agent told me my Notice of Determination included an Appeal Form, the DE 1000A, and that I had 30 days from the date on the notice to file it if I disagreed with EDD's decision. That deadline piece was the main thing I needed to know.

0 coins

The 30-day clock on the notice is the thing I always tell people about. I've been trying to get through on the disability line myself to ask about my own extension situation, so I'm going to try Claimyr for it. What should I have ready when I try?

0 coins

Have your Social Security number, the claim ID from SDI Online, and the date on the notice. The agent will pull up the claim from those.

0 coins

30 days goes fast when you're recovering with a newborn. Good to know to look for that form right away.

0 coins

If you get an overpayment notice, the Appeal Form is included with it. Send it to the return address on the notice, not EDD's general address. Write a detailed explanation of why you think the amount is wrong or why you believe you weren't overpaid.

0 coins

I haven't gotten a notice yet but saving this. So the form comes with the notice itself, I don't have to find it separately?

0 coins

Correct, it comes attached. The notice itself explains the deadline, which is 30 days from the date on the notice.

0 coins

Is there any chance they waive it rather than making you pay it all back?

0 coins

EDD handles that on a case-by-case basis. The notice will tell you your options. Appeal if you think there's an error, and if the amount is correct, ask EDD what options exist for your situation.

0 coins

Report to EDD what your employer paid you during the same weeks you received SDI. Do that before a notice arrives if you can. It's much cleaner than dealing with an overpayment after the fact.

0 coins

Is there a form for that or do I do it through SDI Online?

0 coins

Use the Request Claim Update option in SDI Online or contact EDD directly by phone. Either way, have the dates and amounts ready.

0 coins

Agree with this approach. Getting out ahead of it is always better than reacting to a notice.

0 coins

just went through this. it took forever to sort out. had no idea my company parental leave would matter to edd at all

0 coins

Did EDD send you something or did your employer flag it?

0 coins

edd sent a notice. months after the claim closed. surprised me completely

0 coins

HR knowing about this and telling you is actually a decent outcome. A lot of people find out from EDD, not from their employer.

0 coins

You're right, I guess I should be grateful HR said something. Even if it's stressful now.

0 coins

Yeah HR usually just processes the leave and doesn't think about whether SDI is involved at all. Lucky they caught it.

0 coins

the SDI claim and the employer leave can run at the same time, right? it's not automatically wrong, it's just about the amounts and how they coordinate, anyway that's what i got from reading all this

0 coins

Whether it's a problem depends entirely on how your employer's plan is structured. Some plans are built to supplement SDI, paying only the difference. Others pay full salary regardless. The second kind is what creates the overlap question.

0 coins

got it, so the plan design is the thing. makes sense

0 coins

receipt number issue is what held up my claim. The number my doctor's office used didn't match what SDI Online had, and the medical certification just sat there unmatched. I ended up talking to an EDD agent after getting through with Claimyr (claimyr.com). She confirmed the receipt number on file and told me exactly which one the provider needed to use to file the certification correctly.

0 coins

Receipt number mismatch is the same thing that happened on my claim. Got through to EDD once and they said the same thing about giving the right number to the provider. I'd already done that and the agent looked at the DE 2525XX extension and confirmed EDD had received it and it was attached to the right claim.

0 coins

i have been trying to get through on that line for two and a half weeks now

0 coins

Was the fix as simple as giving the doctor's office the right number?

0 coins

In my case yes. Provider re-submitted with the correct receipt number and it matched up within a few days.

0 coins

Worth noting that the SDI benefit is calculated from your wages in the base period, not from what your employer is paying during your leave. So your EDD benefit amount doesn't change based on your employer's leave pay. The issue is about whether receiving both at once creates an overpayment under EDD's rules, which is a separate question from the benefit calculation itself.

0 coins

That's a useful distinction. The Notice of Computation reflects what you're entitled to from EDD based on past wages, not current employer pay.

0 coins

So the Notice of Computation isn't what changes, it's whether I owe some of it back because of what my employer paid?

0 coins

That's the right way to think about it. The notice just shows your potential weekly amount. What you actually keep depends on the reporting and how EDD treats the employer pay.

0 coins

Nobody at EDD is going to call you and ask about your employer leave. The only way this comes up is if you report it, your employer reports it, or EDD catches it some other way. That doesn't mean you should ignore it, it means you need to take action yourself.

0 coins

I know. I'm going to call EDD this week and try to explain what happened before anything else arrives.

0 coins

Good. Keep a record of when you called and what they told you. Dates matter if anything is disputed later.

0 coins

payment date on one of my checks didn't match the week it was supposed to cover and I wasn't sure if it was an error or just how the cycle works. Used Claimyr (claimyr.com) to get to an agent. She looked at the payment history and told me that specific payment was issued on the date I expected but had posted a couple days later and covered the right benefit week.

0 coins

Two weeks of calls to that line and not once did I get a human. Got a busy signal most tries and a recording that just ended the call a couple times. Something about that just doesn't add up to me, honestly I'm not convinced anything on that line actually works right now.

0 coins

I get the doubt. I tried that line probably a dozen times over several days before I did it differently. The agent who answered was an EDD employee. She had my claim on her screen and read me the dates.

0 coins

I had a similar payment timing question on my claim. The agent confirmed the payment method on file and that the deposit had cleared on their end, which is what I needed to know to stop worrying about it.

0 coins

I really need to get through to EDD before anything escalates on my end. Good to know there are ways to actually reach someone.

0 coins

I just want to triple check something. The waiting period for SDI, is that the first week where you don't get paid at all? Because if my employer is paying me that week anyway, does that change how it counts?

0 coins

The first seven days of your SDI claim are non-payable no matter what. That's EDD's waiting period and it's a fixed rule, not processing time. Your employer paying you during those seven days doesn't change the waiting period or extend it. Your first payable SDI day is the eighth day of disability.

0 coins

Okay that helps a lot. So the waiting period is just the first seven days and that's it, employer pay or not.

0 coins

Wait I was completely confused about this too. I thought the waiting period was how long EDD takes to process things. So it's actually just the first seven days where SDI won't pay you regardless?

0 coins

Exactly. It's not processing time. EDD may also take time to process the claim, but those are two separate things. The waiting period is just the first seven days of every new claim being non-payable by design.

0 coins

Has anyone actually had EDD proactively sort out an overlap situation in their favor without the person filing an appeal or doing something? Asking because I'm curious if EDD ever just figures it out and moves on or if it always becomes a whole thing.

0 coins

In my experience EDD doesn't sort anything out in your favor without you pushing for it.

0 coins

Pretty much. EDD sends notices. What you do with the notice determines what happens next.

0 coins

Never seen it resolve itself. You have to take some kind of action.

0 coins

Update for anyone following: I talked to HR and they sent me the plan document. Looks like our parental leave is supposed to coordinate with SDI, meaning they pay the difference between my SDI amount and my full salary. HR thinks the overlap might be smaller than they first said because of how the plan was designed. I'm still going to contact EDD to report what happened and have the documentation ready. Thanks everyone, this thread helped me figure out what questions to actually ask.

0 coins

That coordination language in the plan document is exactly what you needed to find. If the plan was designed to supplement SDI rather than stack on top of it, your situation may be more straightforward than it first appeared. Good move getting it in writing from HR.

0 coins

Glad you got some clarity. Having the plan document when you talk to EDD will make that conversation a lot cleaner.

0 coins

Report the dates, the amounts from each source, and have the plan document summary ready. That's all you need to get started.

0 coins

California Disability AI

Expert Assistant
Secure