Can I find a new doctor to certify my SDI claim mid-claim?
So my situation is a little complicated and I'm hoping someone here has dealt with this. I had a knee procedure done and my orthopedic surgeon filed the initial medical certification for my SDI claim. But I had a falling out with that office, honestly it was a billing dispute that turned ugly, and they're basically refusing to do any further paperwork for me. I found a new orthopedic who took me on as a patient and has been handling my follow-up care, but I'm not sure whether EDD will accept a certification from someone who didn't do the original surgery. Can I find a new doctor to certify my SDI claim going forward, or am I stuck trying to work things out with the first office? I already looked through EDD's site but couldn't find anything that directly answers this. The new doctor has my full records from the first office so they know exactly what's going on with my recovery.
81 comments

Evelyn Martinez
Switching providers mid-claim is something I had to figure out myself once, so this question caught my eye. EDD's rule is about whether the person certifying falls within the list of licensed health care professionals authorized to certify, not whether they were the original treating provider. A licensed physician who is currently treating you and can attest to your condition and your inability to do your regular work is exactly what EDD needs. Your new orthopedic should be able to submit the certification through SDI Online just as the first office did.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorThat's a relief to read. So the new office just needs my claim's receipt number to find it in SDI Online, same as the first doctor did?
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
Exactly right. Give them the receipt number you got when you filed your Part A. They enter it on the provider side of SDI Online and submit from there.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
Does the new doctor have to certify from the very beginning of the claim or just from when they took over care? I'm in a similar spot and that's what I keep wondering.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
EDD's guidance says the certification covers the period the provider can attest to. A new provider who took over your care certifies the period they've been treating you, not the entire prior period already covered.
0 coins
Isaac Wright
DE 2525XX had been sitting with my new provider's office for almost two weeks before I realized the submission never went through on their end. Getting anyone at EDD on the phone to confirm whether they'd received it felt impossible, every morning that line just rang until it cut off. Claimyr (claimyr.com) is what finally got me talking to an agent. The agent pulled up my claim and confirmed the extension hadn't come in yet, so I was able to go back to the provider and have them resubmit. Here's a short video on reaching a live person at EDD's disability line: https://youtu.be/1X-mEsLtbmQ
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
wait what even is Claimyr, like how does it work? asking bc my claim has been sitting and i cant get through either lol
0 coins
Isaac Wright
You hand it your EDD phone number and it stays on that line in your place. When an agent picks up, your phone rings and you're the one who talks to them. That's the whole thing.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
oh ok that actually makes sense. i'd want to ask about whether my doctor's office sent the medical certification in because SDI Online hasn't changed from pending in like 12 days
0 coins
Connor Murphy
Tried that line maybe eight or nine times across three different mornings last month. Got the recording every single time, never an actual person. Still trying to figure out the extension situation on my own claim.
0 coins
KhalilStar
New doctor is fine as long as they're licensed and treating you now. I switched providers after my back injury and EDD never said a word about it. The certification is about your condition, not about which office did your procedure.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorGood to know it happened without any issues for you. Did your new provider need anything besides the receipt number from you?
0 coins
KhalilStar
Just the receipt number and my Social Security number so they could look up the claim. That was it.
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Same here. No questions asked from EDD's side.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
you should be fine switching docs, the certification is just about who can verify youre actually unable to work, doesnt have to be whoever did the surgery
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
i thought only the doctor who performed the procedure could certify it, like it had to be the same person. guess i had that wrong?
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
That's a pretty common misread. The requirement is that the certifier is a licensed health care professional authorized under EDD's list and that they're actually treating you. The operating surgeon isn't required.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
ok that makes me feel better, my GP has been handling my follow-up and i wasnt sure if that counted
0 coins
Noah Irving
My first certification covered my surgery date through week six. When I changed providers at week seven, the new doctor submitted a fresh certification from the date she took over my care, and EDD processed it without any gap in my payments. The two certifications together covered the full period.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorThis is exactly what I needed to hear. So there's no gap in coverage as long as the new doctor certifies from when they took you on?
0 coins
Noah Irving
That's how it worked for my claim. The new provider's start date matched the date of my first appointment with her, and EDD matched it up fine.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
Did you have to do anything on your end in SDI Online to link the two certifications, or did EDD connect them automatically?
0 coins
Noah Irving
Nothing on my end. I just gave the new office my receipt number and they handled the submission. EDD connected it on their side.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Claim start date on my paperwork looked wrong and I spent a week trying to figure out if it would affect my payments. Ended up reaching an EDD agent through Claimyr after getting nowhere with the phone line myself. The agent looked at my claim and confirmed the start date was recorded as the day I stopped working, which is what I had on my DE 2501.
0 coins
Madison King
I have used Claimyr too and honestly getting that agent was such a relief. The payment method on my claim had defaulted to a debit card even though I wanted direct deposit, and the agent was able to confirm direct deposit had been set up correctly on my end and that the first payment would go there.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Oh that's good to know! Did the agent say whether direct deposit takes longer than the card for the first payment?
0 coins
Madison King
She said the payment would go out the same way either way, that the timing is the same. What matters is that you set it up in SDI Online before the payment issues.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Useful to know the start date thing can be checked. I had a question about which week mine was set to and never got a clear answer from EDD.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Your new doctor just needs to be on EDD's authorized provider list, which covers licensed physicians, nurse practitioners, PAs and a few others. Your orthopedic definitely qualifies. Give them your receipt number and ask them to log into SDI Online on the provider side and submit for the period they've treated you.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorMy new orthopedic is a fully licensed MD so that part's covered. I'll bring the receipt number to my next appointment.
0 coins
William Schwarz
That should get it moving. If EDD doesn't update within about 14 days after the certification goes in, you can send a Request Claim Update through SDI Online to ask what's holding.
0 coins
Connor Murphy
What nobody mentions is that the billing dispute situation you described could matter if the first office tries to retract anything they already submitted. I'd get everything they submitted in writing before you fully cut ties.
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
That's a fair practical point, though EDD's certification process doesn't allow retroactive retractions in the way you might be imagining. Once a certification is processed, it stands. Still, keeping your own records is smart.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorI do have copies of the original certification paperwork. Good point about keeping documentation while this is in dispute.
0 coins
Maya Lewis
EDD's system records what was submitted and when. If you ever need to reference the original certification period, it'll be in your claim history in SDI Online.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
physical therapist at my place tried to certify for someone and edd rejected it. make sure your new doc is actually on the authorized list
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
That's correct. A physical therapist isn't on EDD's authorized list of health care professionals. The list includes licensed physicians, osteopaths, chiropractors, podiatrists, optometrists, dentists, psychologists, nurse practitioners, physician assistants, licensed midwives, nurse-midwives, and authorized medical officers of US government facilities.
0 coins
Lauren Johnson
yeah found that out the hard way. cost a few weeks before they got the right person to certify
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorDefinitely not an issue here, my new provider is an orthopedic MD. But good warning for anyone who might assume any provider can do it.
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Notice of Computation on my claim showed a weekly amount that didn't match what I expected at all, so I tried the EDD line about fifteen mornings and kept getting cut off before anyone answered. Used Claimyr to get a live agent, and she went through the base period quarters with me and explained which quarter had been used for the calculation. Made a lot more sense once I could see which wages they pulled.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
that sounds like marketing to me, like why would some service just get you through when nobody else can
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Thought the same thing the first time I saw it. Tried it anyway after my Notice of Determination came and I had no idea what it meant. The agent walked me through what the notice said and confirmed I had 30 days from the issue date to file an appeal if I disagreed. It's real, the agent was EDD.
0 coins
Katherine Ziminski
ok if someone who was skeptical tried it and got an actual edd agent i might just do it. i have a question about whether my wages in the base period are even enough to qualify
0 coins
Jade Santiago
Have your Notice of Computation and your pay stubs from the past couple years ready when you get on. The agent can see the base period quarters they used.
0 coins
William Schwarz
base period question is a real one. EDD's site has a calculator that can give you an estimate before you even file, worth checking first
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
Can I ask something that's been bugging me since reading this thread? If the original doctor already certified the first few weeks and the new doctor certifies the rest, does EDD ever question whether it's really the same disability or do they treat it as one continuous claim?
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
They treat it as one claim. The claim number stays the same. EDD is looking at whether each certification period is covered by a qualified provider who confirms you're still unable to work, not at whether the same provider covers the whole duration.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
That makes sense, I guess it's similar to how a patient can transfer care to a different specialist and it's still the same injury.
0 coins
Noah Irving
Exactly that. My two-provider situation never raised any flags. The claim number tied everything together.
0 coins
Madison King
your situation honestly sounds less complicated than mine was and mine worked out fine. the new doc just submits through SDI Online like any other provider, EDD doesnt care who performed the surgery
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorThat's reassuring. I think I've been overthinking this whole thing.
0 coins
Madison King
you really have lol, give the receipt number to the new office and let them handle it
0 coins
Ella Knight
Assuming your new doctor is willing to certify you as unable to work, there's no procedure in EDD's rules requiring the certifier to have performed the original treatment. That's a distinction a lot of people miss.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorYeah that was exactly my confusion. I assumed there was some continuity requirement that tied the certification to the surgery itself.
0 coins
Ella Knight
Reasonable assumption but EDD's list is about licensure and treating relationship, not about which doctor performed a specific procedure.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Went through almost this exact situation after switching OBs partway through a pregnancy claim! My new midwife was able to certify the remaining weeks no problem. EDD processed it without any issue and my payments kept coming.
0 coins
Benjamin Carter
Oh that's so good to hear, especially for pregnancy claims where timing really matters.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
The key was giving the new provider the receipt number right at the first appointment. Got it all set up before my next certification period was due and there was no gap.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorThis confirms it works across different claim types, not just orthopedic. Really helpful to see.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
wait does the original doctor have to like officially hand off or notify EDD that youre switching, or can the new doc just submit without any kind of transfer paperwork
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
No handoff paperwork is involved on EDD's end. The new provider submits a certification through SDI Online for the period they're treating you, and EDD matches it to the claim by the receipt number. The first provider's submission stays on the claim for the period it covered.
0 coins
Lucy Taylor
oh that's way simpler than i thought, the billing dispute situation the original poster is in sounds stressful enough without extra bureaucracy on top
0 coins
Maya Lewis
EDD's process here is actually one of the more straightforward parts of the system. Provider changes don't require any special notification from either provider.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Fourteen months of SDI claims across two separate injuries. Never once had EDD question a provider change. The certification is what it is.
0 coins
Vanessa Chang
Two separate claims is a lot of experience with this system. Good to hear the provider thing never caused problems either time.
0 coins
Caleb Stone
Biggest lesson both times was keep the receipt number safe and get it to the new provider fast. Everything else sorted itself out.
0 coins
KhalilStar
Tell your new orthopedic to look up the provider guide on EDD's site if they haven't done this before. Some offices are new to SDI Online and need a minute to figure out the portal.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorMy new office said they'd done SDI certifications before so hopefully they're already set up. I'll mention the provider guide just in case.
0 coins
KhalilStar
Good. The main holdup in these situations is usually the provider's office not knowing their own login, not anything on EDD's end.
0 coins
William Schwarz
true, if the office is unfamiliar with SDI Online it can take a few extra days just for them to get their provider account sorted
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
Had the same question before my claim. New doctor was fine. EDD never asked anything about it.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorShort and to the point, appreciate it. How far into your claim did you switch?
0 coins
Amelia Dietrich
About three weeks in. No gap, no questions.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
just make sure the new doc certifies you for the right dates, like from when they started treating you, not trying to go back and re-cover dates the old doc already did
0 coins
Noah Irving
The dates thing is worth double-checking with the new office before they submit. My provider accidentally put an overlap of two days on the first try and we had to have them resubmit with corrected dates.
0 coins
Kaiya Rivera
yeah an overlap sounds like it could cause a flag on the claim
0 coins
Evelyn Martinez
An overlap in certification dates can slow things down. Worth confirming the new provider starts their certification period the day after the last day the first provider's certification covered.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
Came back to update: gave my new orthopedic the receipt number at today's appointment and they said they'd submit through SDI Online by end of week. The office has done SDI certifications before so they knew exactly what to do. Really glad I asked here before panicking and trying to contact the first office again.
0 coins
William Schwarz
Glad it worked out. Check SDI Online in about a week to see if the certification shows up, and if nothing changes in 14 days, send a Request Claim Update through the portal.
0 coins
Alexander Evans
AuthorWill do. The receipt number was the key piece I wasn't sure about sharing with a new provider. Now I know that's exactly what they need.
0 coins
Julian Paolo
Great update! Smooth from here hopefully.
0 coins